A comparison of gaseous emboli release in five membrane oxygenators

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to compare the air handling capability of five currently used membrane oxygenators: the Avecor Affinity™, the Bentley® SpiralGold™, the Medtronic Maxima Plus™, the Sarns Turbo™ and the Sorin Monolyth™ M. A circuit was constructed to include a hardshell venous reservoir and roller pump. Pressure monitoring sites and ultrasonic microbubble detection probes were located proximal and distal to the oxygenator. An air injection/infusion site was provided proximal to the roller pump inlet. Each circuit was primed with fresh anticoagulated bovine blood, adjusted to a haematocrit of 25% and maintained at 38 ± 1°C. Three different bolus amounts of air (10, 20 and 40 cm³) were injected at three blood flow rates (3, 4.5 and 6 l/min). A 1-min infusion of air delivered at 1 ml/s was also administered at three blood flow rates (3, 4.5 and 6 l/min). The hardshell reservoir was also completely emptied at each flow rate to simulate a massive air infusion.

At any given blood flow, outlet microbubble counts were usually higher with greater bolus amounts of air. When indexed to the inlet bubble counts, the following average percent microbubbles were released from the outlet: Turbo™ 25%, Affinity™ 7%, Monolyth™ 5%, Maxima™ 3% and SpiralGold™ 1%. With a constant air infusion of 1 ml/s, greater outlet microbubble counts were associated with higher blood flow rates. Again, when indexed to the inlet bubble counts, the following average percent microbubbles were released from the outlet: Turbo™ 44%, Affinity™ 25%, Maxima™ 19%, Monolyth™ 16% and SpiralGold™ 0%. All oxygenators deprimed when the hardshell reservoir was emptied and all shed microbubbles into the outlet blood except the SpiralGold™.

The results of this study indicate that air handling is not a simple function of blood flow pattern (i.e. top to bottom versus bottom to top), but also includes dynamics associated with oxygenator design, fibre arrangement and flow resistance.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Tovar EA , DelCampo C , Borsari A , Webb RP , Dell JR , Weinstein PB. Postoperative management of cerebral air embolism: gas physiology for surgeons . Ann Thorac Surg 1995; 60: 1138-1142 .

Stoney WS , Alford Jr WC , Burrus GR , Glassford Jr DM , Thomas Jr CS. Air embolism and other accidents using pump oxygenators . Ann Thorac Surg 1980; 29: 336-340 .

Mills NL , Ochsner JL. Massive air embolism during cardiopulmonary bypass: causes, prevention, and management . J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1980; 80: 708-717 .

Kurusz M , Conti VR , Arens JF , Brown JP , Faulkner SC , Manning Jr JV. Perfusion accident survey . Proc Am Acad Cardiovasc Perf 1986; 7: 57-65 .

Temple AP , Katz J. Air embolism: a potentially lethal surgical complication . AORN J 1987; 45: 387-389 .

Mills SA. Cerebral injury and cardiac operations . Ann Thorac Surg 1993; 56(5 suppl): S86-S91 .

Kurusz M. Gaseous microemboli: sources, causes, and clinical considerations . Med Instr 1985; 19: 73-76 .

van Oeveren W , Dankert J , Wildevuur CR. Bubble oxygenation and cardiotomy suction impair the host defense during cardiopulmonary bypass: a study in dogs . Ann Thorac Surg 1987; 44: 523-528 .

Gourlay T. The role of arterial line filters in perfusion safety . Perfusion 1988; 3: 195-204 .

10.

Campbell DE , Raskin SA. Cerebral dysfunction after cardiopulmonary bypass: aetiology, manifestations and interventions . Perfusion 1990; 5: 251-260 .

11.

Griffin S , Pugsley W , Treasure T. Microembolism during cardiopulmonary bypass: a comparison of bubble oxygenator with arterial line filter and membrane oxygenator alone . Perfusion 1991; 6: 99-103 .

12.

Kurusz M , Butler BD , Katz J , Conti VR. Air embolism during cardiopulmonary bypass . Perfusion 1995; 10: 361-391 .

13.

Hill AG , Groom RC , Vinansky RP , Speir AM , Macmanus Q , Lefrak EA. Gaseous microemboli and extracorporeal circulation . Proc Am Acad Cardiovasc Perf 1986; 7: 131-137 .

14.

Schabel RK , Berryessa RG , Justison GA , Tyndal CM , Schumann J. Ten common perfusion problems: prevention and treatment protocols . J Extra Corpor Technol 1987; 19: 392-398 .

15.

Cone JG , Hogan TM , Reed CC et al . Air embolism inhibition characteristics of arterial line filters: an in vitro study . Proc Am Acad Cardiovasc Perf 1987; 8: 170-172 .

16.

Padayachee TS , Parsons S , Theobold R , Gosling RG , Deverall PB. The effect of arterial filtration on reduction of gaseous microemboli in the middle cerebral artery during cardiopulmonary bypass . Ann Thorac Surg 1988; 45: 647-649 .

17.

Treasure T. Interventions to reduce cerebral injury during cardiac surgery - the effect of arterial line filtration . Perfusion 1989; 4: 147-152 .

18.

Deverall PB , Padayachee TS , Parsons S , Theobold R , Battistessa SA. Ultrasound detection of micro-emboli in the middle cerebral artery during cardiopulmonary bypass surgery . Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 1988; 2: 256-260 .

19.

Smith PLC. Interventions to reduce cerebral injury during cardiac surgery introduction and the effect of oxygenator type . Perfusion 1989; 4: 139-145 .

20.

Liu JF , Su ZK , Ding WX. Quantitation of particulate microemboli during cardiopulmonary bypass: experimental and clinical studies . Ann Thorac Surg 1992; 54: 1196-1202 .

21.

Johnston WE , Stump DA , DeWitt DS et al. Significance of gaseous microemboli in the cerebral circulation during cardiopulmonary bypass in dogs . Circulation 1993; 88(5 Pt 2): II319-II329 .

22.

Diesfeld T , Lajos TZ , Schimert G. Arterial venous bridge on cardiopulmonary bypass . J Cardiac Surg 1994; 9: 128-130 .

23.

Wheeldon DR , Bethune DW , Gill RD. Vortex pumping for routine cardiac surgery: a comparative study . Perfusion 1990; 5: 135-143 .

24.

Iatridis A , Chan T. Laboratory evaluations of vortex, centrifugal, and roller pump systems . Proc Am Acad Cardiovasc Perf 1992; 13: 64-69 .

25.

Pacheco DA , Ingram JM , Pacheco SL. A comparison of three centrifugal pumps’ ability to expel micro-air under conditions of cavitation or bolus air injection . Perfusion 1995; 10: 361-391 .

26.

Hatteland K , Pedersen T , Semb BKH. Comparison of bubble release from various types of oxygenators . Scand J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1985; 19: 125-130 .

27.

Sellman M , Ivert T , Stensved P , Hogberg M , Semb BKH. Doppler ultrasound estimation of microbubbles in the arterial line during extracorporeal circulation . Perfusion 1990; 5: 23-32 .

28.

Rhoades JR , French JS , Donaway J. Modification of a Terumo hollow fiber oxygenator to prevent massive air emboli . Proc Am Acad Cardiovasc Perf 1987; 8: 52-55 .

29.

Berryessa RG , Tyndal Jr CM , Osbourn D. An experimental evaluation of the Capiox 1.6 and 5.4M2 membrane oxygenators for air removal efficiency in the conventional and inverted positions . Proc Am Soc of Extra Corpor Technol 1988; 19-22 .

30.

Mehra AP , Akins A , Maisuria A , Glenville BE. Air handling characteristics of five membrane oxygenators . Perfusion 1994; 9: 357-362 .

31.

Fried DW , DeBenedetto BN , Zombolas TL , Leo JJ. Clinical evaluation of the Medtronic Maxima Plus membrane oxygenator . Perfusion 1994; 9: 363-372 .

32.

Vocelka CR , Thomas R , Kunzelman KS , Verrier E. An in vitro evaluation of Avecor’s Affinity hollow fiber membrane oxygenator . Proc Am Acad Cardiovasc Perf 1994; 15: 70-72 .

33.

Griffith KE , Vasquez MR , Beckley PD , LaLone BJ. Predicting oxygenator clinical performance from laboratory in-vitro testing . J Extra Corpor Technol 1994; 26: 114-120 .

34.

Adams D , Trpkosh T , Wooten D , Wright S. Evaluation of the Sorin Monolyth membrane oxygenator - our clinical experience . Proc Am Acad Cardiovasc Perf 1995; 16: 49-50 .

35.

Avecor cardiovascular Affinity hollow fiber oxygenator - instructions for use. Publication number 311.

36.

Medtronic cardiopulmonary Maxima Plus oxygenation system - instructions for use, 1993.

37.

Beckley PD , Morris SM , Smith JJ , McNamara JL , Novak JA. Comparison of the performance characteristics of three generations of membrane oxygenators: Univox, Univox Gold, and SpiralGold . Perfusion 1996; 11: 31-40 .