Cardioplegic arrest can be induced by various methods, fueling a long-standing controversy about their comparative merit. We aim to compare cardioplegic methods in coronary artery disease.
Methods
PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane databases were interrogated for randomized trials that compared various cardioplegic methods in adult patients undergoing elective isolated coronary artery bypass grafting. Differences in cardioplegic composition – crystalloid or blood, route of delivery – antegrade or retrograde, and temperature, were evaluated in a network meta-analysis. The endpoints were mortality, myocardial infarction, insertion of intra-aortic balloon pump, low cardiac output syndrome, increased inotropic support, as well as cardiopulmonary bypass time, aortic cross-clamp time, intensive care stay, hospital stay, new onset atrial fibrillation, reperfusion ventricular fibrillation, and neurologic event. Confidence In Network Meta-Analysis web application was employed.
Results
75 studies were included, with 6131 patients receiving one of 13 cardioplegic methods. Warm ante/retrograde blood cardioplegia was associated with fewer deaths (P-score 0.81), fewer intra-aortic balloon pumps (P-score 0.77), and shorter intensive care (P-score 0.69) and hospital stay (P-score 0.81). Cross clamp time was shorter with crystalloid cardioplegias, while reperfusion ventricular fibrillation was less frequent with warm blood cardioplegias. Cold cardioplegias were associated with lower rates of new onset atrial fibrillation and stroke. Confidence varied greatly across the endpoints.
Conclusion
The outcomes of this network study indicate presumable advantages of warm ante/retrograde blood cardioplegia in elective isolated coronary artery bypass grafting. Under the light of certain biases and mixed confidence, the results should be cautiously interpreted. More studies are needed.
FrancicaATonelliFRossettiC, et al.Cardioplegia between evolution and revolution: from depolarized to polarized cardiac arrest in adult cardiac surgery. J Clin Med2021; 10: 4485.
2.
SáMPRuedaFGFerrazPE, et al.Is there any difference between blood and crystalloid cardioplegia for myocardial protection during cardiac surgery? A meta-analysis of 5576 patients from 36 randomized trials. Perfusion2012; 27: 535–546.
3.
GuruVOmuraJAlghamdiAA, et al.Is blood superior to crystalloid cardioplegia? A meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. Circulation2006; 114: I331–1338.
4.
ZengJHeWQuZ, et al.Cold blood versus crystalloid cardioplegia for myocardial protection in adult cardiac surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth2014; 28: 674–681.
5.
AbahUGarfjeld RobertsPIshaqM, et al.Is cold or warm blood cardioplegia superior for myocardial protection?Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg2012; 14: 848–855.
6.
HuttonBSalantiGCaldwellDM, et al.The PRISMA extension statement for reporting of systematic reviews incorporating network meta-analyses of health care interventions: checklist and explanations. Ann Intern Med2015; 162: 777–784.
7.
SanetraKPawlakICisowskiM. Del Nido cardioplegia - what is the current evidence?Kardiochir Torakochirurgia Pol2018; 15: 114–118.
8.
MisraSSrinivasanAJenaSS, et al.Myocardial Protection in Adult Cardiac Surgery With del Nido Versus Blood Cardioplegia: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Heart Lung Circ2021; 30: 642–655.
9.
AlmeidaASCeronROAnschauF, et al.Comparison between Custodiol, del Nido and modified del Nido in the myocardial protection - Cardioplegia Trial: a study protocol for a randomised, double-blind clinical trial. BMJ Open2021; 11: e047942.
10.
RückerGSchwarzerG. Ranking treatments in frequentist network meta-analysis works without resampling methods. BMC Med Res Methodol2015; 15: 58.
11.
ChaimaniASalantiG. Using network meta-analysis to evaluate the existence of small-study effects in a network of interventions. Res Synth Methods2012; 3: 161–176.
12.
EfthimiouORückerGSchwarzerG, et al.Network meta-analysis of rare events using the Mantel-Haenszel method. Stat Med2019; 38: 2992–3012.
13.
KrahnUBinderHKönigJ. A graphical tool for locating inconsistency in network meta-analyses. BMC Med Res Methodol2013; 13: 35.
14.
HigginsJPJacksonDBarrettJK, et al.Consistency and inconsistency in network meta-analysis: concepts and models for multi-arm studies. Res Synth Methods2012; 3: 98–110.
15.
DiasSWeltonNJCaldwellDM, et al.Checking consistency in mixed treatment comparison meta‐analysis. Stat Med2010; 29: 932–944.
16.
MavridisDSalantiG. How to assess publication bias: funnel plot, trim-and-fill method and selection models. Evid Base Ment Health2014; 17: 30.
17.
PapakonstantinouTNikolakopoulouAHigginsJPT, et al.CINeMA: software for semiautomated assessment of the confidence in the results of network meta-analysis. Campbell Syst Rev2020; 16: e1080.
18.
FalcozPEKailiDChocronS, et al.Warm and tepid cardioplegia: do they provide equal myocardial protection?Ann Thorac Surg2002; 74: 2156–2160.
19.
BadakMIGurcunUDiscigilB, et al.Myocardium utilizes more oxygen and glucose during tepid blood cardioplegic infusion in arrested heart. Int Heart J2005; 46: 219–229.
20.
AzizTAAAl KhajaNAliMA, et al.Antegrade-retrograde cardioplegia for myocardial protection during coronary artery bypass graft surgery. Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann1998; 6: 188–194.
21.
AstorriEFiorinaPGrattaglianoC, et al.Cardiac Troponin T to evaluate myocardial protection via intermittent cold blood or continuous warm blood cardioplegia in coronary artery bypass grafting. J Cardiovasc Surg1998; 39: 797–802.
22.
BarassiAMerliniGFinazziS, et al.Comparison of three strategies for myocardial protection during coronary artery bypass graft surgery based on markers of cardiac damage. Clin Biochem2005; 38: 504–508.
23.
BaronORousselJCDelarocheO, et al.Prospective clinical and biological comparison of three blood cardioplegia techniques in low-risk CABG patients: better is worse than good enough. Cardiovasc Surg2003; 11: 489–495.
24.
BeyersdorfFKrauseESaraiK, et al.Clinical evaluation of hypothermic ventricular fibrillation, multi-dose blood cardioplegia, and single-dose Bretschneider cardioplegia in coronary surgery. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1990; 38: 20–29.
25.
BiagioliBGiomarelliPGnudiG, et al.Myocardial function in early hours after coronary artery bypass grafting: comparison of two cardioplegic methods. Ann Thorac Surg1993; 56: 1315–1323.
26.
BiagioliBBorrelliEMaccheriniM, et al.Reduction of oxidative stress does not affect recovery of myocardial function: warm continuous versus cold intermittent blood cardioplegia. Heart1997; 77: 465–473.
27.
BicalOMFromesYPaumierD, et al.Does warm antegrade intermittent blood cardioplegia really protect the heart during coronary surgery?Cardiovasc Surg2001; 9: 188–193.
28.
BjerrumJTPerkoMJBeckB. Myocardial oxygen tension during surgical revascularization. A clinical comparison between blood cardioplegia and crystalloid cardioplegia. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg2006; 29: 181–185.
29.
BratRTosovskyJJanuskaJ. Myocardial function in early hours after coronary artery bypass grafting in patients with left ventricular dysfunction: comparison of blood and crystalloid cardioplegia. J Cardiovasc Surg2004; 45: 265–269.
30.
ButtnerEEKarpRBRevesJG, et al.A randomized comparison of crystalloid and blood-containing cardioplegic solutions in 60 patients. Circulation1984; 69: 973–982.
31.
CaputoMDihmisWBirdiI, et al.Cardiac troponin T and troponin I release during coronary artery surgery using cold crystalloid and cold blood cardioplegia. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg1997; 12: 254–260.
CarpenterAJFolletteDMSheppardB, et al.Simultaneous antegrade and retrograde reperfusion after cardioplegic arrest for coronary artery bypass. J Card Surg1999; 14: 354–358.
34.
CarrierMPelletierLCSearleNR. Does retrograde administration of blood cardioplegia improve myocardial protection during first operation for coronary artery bypass grafting?Ann Thorac Surg1997; 64: 1256–1261.
35.
CasthelyPAShahCMekhjianH, et al.Left ventricular diastolic function after coronary artery bypass grafting: a correlative study with three different myocardial protection techniques. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1997; 114: 254–260.
36.
CernaianuACFlumDRMaurerM, et al.Comparison of antegrade with antegrade/retrograde cold blood cardioplegia for myocardial revascularization. Tex Heart Inst J1996; 23: 9–14.
37.
ChelloMMastrorobertoPDe AmicisV, et al.Intermittent warm blood cardioplegia preserves myocardial beta-adrenergic receptor function. Ann Thorac Surg1997; 63: 683–688.
38.
ChelloMMastrorobertoPPattiG, et al.Intermittent warm blood cardioplegia induces the expression of heat shock protein-72 by ischemic myocardial preconditioning. Cardiovasc Surg2003; 11: 367–374.
39.
ChocronSAlwanKYanY, et al.Warm reperfusion and myocardial protection. Ann Thorac Surg1998; 66: 2003–2007.
40.
ChocronSKailiDYanY, et al.Intermediate lukewarm (20 degrees c) antegrade intermittent blood cardioplegia compared with cold and warm blood cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2000; 119: 610–616.
41.
CoddJEBarnerHBPenningtonDG, et al.Intraoperative myocardial protection: a comparison of blood and asanguineous cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg1985; 39: 125–133.
42.
DarMI. Cold crystalloid versus warm blood cardioplegia for coronary artery bypass surgery. Ann Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2005; 11: 382–385.
43.
DiehlJTEichhornEJKonstamMA, et al.Efficacy of retrograde coronary sinus cardioplegia in patients undergoing myocardial revascularization: a prospective randomized trial. Ann Thorac Surg1988; 45: 595–602.
44.
EichhornEJDiehlJTKonstamMA, et al.Protective effects of retrograde compared with antegrade cardioplegia on right ventricular systolic and diastolic function during coronary bypass surgery. Circulation1989; 79: 1271–1281.
45.
FerreiraRFragaCCarrasquedoF, et al.Comparison between warm blood and crystalloid cardioplegia during open heart surgery. Int J Cardiol2003; 90: 253–260.
46.
FioreACNaunheimKSKaiserGC, et al.Coronary sinus versus aortic root perfusion with blood cardioplegia in elective myocardial revascularization. Ann Thorac Surg1989; 47: 684–688.
47.
FioreACNaunheimKSMoskoffME, et al.Right atrial versus aortic root perfusion with blood cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg1991; 52: 1014–1020.
48.
FioreACSwartzMTNevettR, et al.Intermittent antegrade tepid versus cold blood cardioplegia in elective myocardial revascularization. Ann Thorac Surg1998; 65: 1559–1564.
49.
FrankeUWahlersTCohnertTU, et al.Retrograde versus antegrade crystalloid cardioplegia in coronary surgery: value of troponin-I measurement. Ann Thorac Surg2001; 71: 249–253.
50.
FrankeUFKorschSWittwerT, et al.Intermittent antegrade warm myocardial protection compared to intermittent cold blood cardioplegia in elective coronary surgery--do we have to change?Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg2003; 23: 341–346.
51.
FremesSEChristakisGTWeiselRD, et al.A clinical trial of blood and crystalloid cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1984; 88: 726–741.
52.
GasiorZKrejcaMSzmagalaP, et al.Long term left ventricular systolic function assessment following CABG. A prospective, randomised study. Blood versus cristalloid cardioplegia. J Cardiovasc Surg2000; 41: 695–702.
53.
GozalYGlantzLLuriaMH, et al.Normothermic continuous blood cardioplegia improves electrophysiologic recovery after open heart surgery. Anesthesiology1996; 84: 1298–1306.
54.
GrechEDBainesMSteynR, et al.Evidence that continuous normothermic blood cardioplegia offers better myocardial protection than intermittent hypothermic cardioplegia. Br Heart J1995; 74: 517–521.
55.
GunaydinSGunertemOEBabarogluS, et al.Clinical outcomes of single-dose cardioplegia in high-risk coronary bypass. Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann2021; 29: 77–83.
56.
HendrikxMJiangHGutermannH, et al.Release of cardiac troponin I in antegrade crystalloid versus cold blood cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1999; 118: 452–459.
57.
HonkonenELKaukinenLPehkonenEJ, et al.Myocardial cooling and right ventricular function in patients with right coronary artery disease: antegrade vs. retrograde cardioplegia. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand1997; 41: 287–296.
58.
HonorePMJacquetLMBealeRJ, et al.Effects of normothermia versus hypothermia on extravascular lung water and serum cytokines during cardiopulmonary bypass: a randomized, controlled trial. Crit Care Med2001; 29: 1903–1909.
59.
IbrahimMFVennGEYoungCP, et al.A clinical comparative study between crystalloid and blood-based St Thomas’ hospital cardioplegic solution. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg1999; 15: 75–83.
60.
IsomuraTHisatomiKSatoT, et al.Interrupted warm blood cardioplegia for coronary artery bypass grafting. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg1995; 9: 133–138.
61.
IversonLIYoungJNEnnixCLJr., et al.Myocardial protection: a comparison of cold blood and cold crystalloid cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1984; 87: 509–516.
62.
JacquetLMNoirhommePHVan DyckMJ, et al.Randomized trial of intermittent antegrade warm blood versus cold crystalloid cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg1999; 67: 471–477.
63.
JacquetLHonorePBealeR, et al.Cardiac function after intermittent antegrade warm blood cardioplegia: contribution of the double-indicator dilution technique. Intensive Care Med2000; 26: 686–692.
64.
JasinskiMKadziołaZBachowskiR, et al.Comparison of retrograde versus antegrade cold blood cardioplegia: randomized trial in elective coronary artery bypass patients. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg1997; 12: 620–626.
65.
JasinskiMJWosSKadziolaZ, et al.Does simultaneous antegrade and retrograde cardioplegia improve functional recovery and myocardial homeostasis?J Card Surg2000; 15: 354–361.
66.
JegadenOEkerAMontagnaP, et al.Antegrade/retrograde cardioplegia in arterial bypass grafting: metabolic randomized clinical trial. Ann Thorac Surg1995; 59: 456–461.
67.
KaracaPYurtsevenNEnçY, et al.Effects of different cardioplegic solutions on nitric oxide release from coronary vasculature in diabetic patients undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery. Anadolu Kardiyol Derg2006; 6: 347–351.
68.
KaukorantaPKLepojärviMVKiviluomaKT, et al.Myocardial protection during antegrade versus retrograde cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg1998; 66: 755–761.
69.
KuhnEWChoiYHPyunJM, et al.Endothelial injury associated with cold or warm blood cardioplegia during coronary artery bypass graft surgery. BioMed Res Int2015; 2015: 256905.
70.
LandymoreRMurphyJTHallR, et al.Randomized trial comparing intermittent antegrade warm blood cardioplegia with multidose cold blood cardioplegia for coronary artery bypass. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg1996; 10: 179–184.
71.
LapennaDMezzettiAde GioiaS, et al.Blood cardioplegia reduces oxidant burden in the ischemic and reperfused human myocardium. Ann Thorac Surg1994; 57: 1522–1525.
72.
LieboldALanghammerTBrüngerF, et al.Cardiac interleukin-6 release and myocardial recovery after aortic crossclamping. Crystalloid versus blood cardioplegia. J Cardiovasc Surg1999; 40: 633–636.
73.
MaccheriniMDavoliGSaniG, et al.Warm heart surgery eliminates diaphragmatic paralysis. J Card Surg1995; 10: 257–261.
74.
MartinTDCraverJMGottJP, et al.Prospective, randomized trial of retrograde warm blood cardioplegia: myocardial benefit and neurologic threat. Ann Thorac Surg1994; 57: 298–302.
75.
MercanIDereliYTopcuC, et al.Comparison between the effects of bretschneider's HTK solution and cold blood cardioplegia on systemic endothelial functions in patients who undergo coronary artery bypass surgery: a prospective randomized and controlled trial. Braz J Cardiovasc Surg2020; 35: 634–643.
76.
MullenJCFremesSEWeiselRD, et al.Right ventricular function: a comparison between blood and crystalloid cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg1987; 43: 17–24.
77.
NeumannFMohlWGriesmacherA, et al.Perioperative myocardial injury with different modes of antegrade and retrograde cardioplegic delivery. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg1996; 10: 185–193.
78.
NoyezLvan SonJAvan der WerfT, et al.Retrograde versus antegrade delivery of cardioplegic solution in myocardial revascularization. A clinical trial in patients with three-vessel coronary artery disease who underwent myocardial revascularization with extensive use of the internal mammary artery. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1993; 105: 854–863.
79.
NoyezLVerhagenAFLacquetLK. Antegrade versus retrograde crystalloid cardioplegia: perioperative assessment of cardiac energy metabolism by means of myocardial lactate measurement. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1995; 43: 194–199.
80.
PehkonenEJMäkynenPJKatajaMJ, et al.Atrial fibrillation after blood and crystalloid cardioplegia in CABG patients. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1995; 43: 200–2003.
81.
PelletierLCCarrierMLeclercY, et al.Intermittent antegrade warm versus cold blood cardioplegia: a prospective, randomized study. Ann Thorac Surg1994; 58: 41–48.
82.
PichonHChocronSAlwanK, et al.Crystalloid versus cold blood cardioplegia and cardiac troponin I release. Circulation1997; 96: 316–320.
83.
PölingJReesWMantovaniV, et al.Evaluation of myocardial metabolism with microdialysis during bypass surgery with cold blood- or Calafiore cardioplegia. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg2006; 30: 597–603.
84.
RadmehrHSoleimaniATatariH, et al.Does combined antegrade-retrograde cardioplegia have any superiority over antegrade cardioplegia?Heart Lung Circ2008; 17: 475–477.
85.
RainioPSormunenRLepojärviM, et al.Ultrastructural changes during continuous retrograde warm and mild hypothermic blood cardioplegia for coronary bypass operations. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1995; 110: 81–88.
86.
RinneTPehkonenEKaukinenS, et al.Comparison of cardioprotection with crystalloid and blood cardioplegia in CABG patients. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth1993; 7: 679–683.
87.
SavunenTKuttilaKRajalinA, et al.Combined cardioplegia delivery offers no advantage over antegrade cardioplegia administration in coronary surgical patients with a preserved left ventricular function. Eur J Cardio Thorac Surg1994; 8: 640–644.
88.
ShapiraNKirshMJochimK, et al.Comparison of the effect of blood cardioplegia to crystalloid cardioplegia on myocardial contractility in man. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1980; 80: 647–655.
89.
SimeoneFBiagioliBDolciA, et al.The diagnostic and prognostic value of cardiac Troponin T in bypass surgery. J Cardiovasc Surg1999; 40: 211–216.
90.
SinghAKFarrugiaRTeplitzC, et al.Electrolyte versus blood cardioplegia: randomized clinical and myocardial ultrastructural study. Ann Thorac Surg1982; 33: 218–227.
91.
SirlakMEryilmazSYazicioğluL, et al.Conduction disturbances in coronary artery bypass surgery. Int J Cardiol2003; 92: 43–48.
92.
SirvinskasENasvytisLRalieneL, et al.Myocardial protective effect of warm blood, tepid blood, and cold crystalloid cardioplegia in coronary artery bypass grafting surgery. Croat Med J2005; 46: 879–888.
93.
TeohKHChristakisGTWeiselRD, et al.Accelerated myocardial metabolic recovery with terminal warm blood cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1986; 91: 888–895.
94.
YauTMIkonomidisJSWeiselRD, et al.Which techniques of cardioplegia prevent ischemia?Ann Thorac Surg1993; 56: 1020–1028.
95.
SauerbreiWRoystonP. Continuous variables: to categorize or to model. The 8th international conference on teaching statistics–data and context in statistics education. Voorburg: Towards an evidence based society international statistical institute, 2010.
96.
McErleanMSamwaysJGodolphinPJ, et al.The reporting standards of randomised controlled trials in leading medical journals between 2019 and 2020: a systematic review. Ir J Med Sci2023; 192: 73–80.
97.
SchoonenAvan KleiWAvan WolfswinkelL, et al.Definitions of low cardiac output syndrome after cardiac surgery and their effect on the incidence of intraoperative LCOS: a literature review and cohort study. Front Cardiovasc Med2022; 9: 926957.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
