Meshing Money with Mission: Purity Versus Pragmatism in Public Broadcasting

Abstract

This article asks whether the increasing recourse of European public broadcasters to commercial income sources endangers their public service commitments. As a benchmark, a distinctive mission for public television is outlined, concentrating on four communication tasks and four value commitments that private television tends to neglect. The implications for such a mission of three commercial revenue sources — advertising, sponsorship and foreign programme earnings — are examined. Other assimilating pressures, operative in a mixed system, which encourage public broadcasters to tailor their programming to private television are also identified. The various problems raised are explored in detail through a case study of the likely future of children's television in Britain. The author concludes that the claims of `purity' and `pragmatism' can be reconciled only through the adoption by public broadcasters of an integrity-safeguarding policy, the main elements of which are outlined.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

BBC (1992) Extending Choice: The BBC's Role in the New Broadcasting Age. London: BBC.

Birt, John (1993) `Extending Choice': Turning Promises into Realities. London: BBC.

Blumler, Jay G. (1990) `Television and Politics: The British Public Service Model'. Paper presented to an Aspen Institute Conference on Television Coverage and Campaigns, Wye Woods, Maryland.

Blumler, Jay G. (1991) `In Pursuit of Programme Range and Quality', Studies of Broadcasting 27: 191-206.

Blumler, Jay G. (1992) The Future of Children's Television in Britain. London: Broadcasting Standards Council.

Blumler, Jay G. , Malcolm Brynin and T.J. Nossiter (1986) `Broadcasting Finance and Programme Quality: An International Review', European Journal of Communication 1(3): 343-364.

Blumler, Jay G. and Wolfgang Hoffmann-Riem (1992) `New Roles for Public Service Television', in Jay G. Blumler (ed.), Television and the Public Interest: Vulnerable Values in West European Broadcasting. London: Sage.

Cave, Martin (1993) `The Role of the BBC: An Economic Evaluation', in Steven Barnett (ed.), Funding the BBC's Future. London: British Film Institute.

Congdon, Tim (1992) `Policy Questions in British Broadcasting', in Tim Congdon et al., Paying for Broadcasting: The Handbook. London: Routledge.

10.

de Bens, Elsa (1991) `Flanders in the Spell of Commercial Television', European Journal of Communication 6(2): 235-244.

11.

Ehrenberg, Andrew and Pam Mills (1993) `What is the BBC Worth to Viewers?', in Steven Barnett (ed.), Funding the BBC's Future. London: British Film Institute.

12.

Graham, Andrew and Gavyn Davies (1992) `The Public Funding of Broadcasting', in Tim Congdon et al., Paying for Broadcasting: The Handbook. London: Routledge.

13.

Gray, John (1993) `Cultural Diversity, National Identity and the Case for Public Service Broadcasting in Britain', in Wilf Stevenson (ed.), All Our Futures: The Changing Role and Purpose of the BBC. London: British Film Institute.

14.

Hall, Stuart (1993) `Which Public, Whose Service?', in Wilf Stevenson (ed.), All Our Futures: The Changing Role and Purpose of the BBC. London: British Film Institute.

15.

Henry, Georgina and Andy Mayer (1993) `Birthplace of the Fantastic 4', The Guardian, 17 May.

16.

Hoffmann-Riem, Wolfgang (1992) `Defending Vulnerable Values: Regulatory Measures and Enforcement Dilemmas', in Jay G. Blumler (ed.), Television and the Public Interest: Vulnerable Values in West European Broadcasting. London: Sage.

17.

Hultén, Olof and Kees Brants (1992) `Public Service Broadcasting: Reactions to Competition', in Karen Siune and Wolfgang Truetzschler (eds), Dynamics of Media Politics. London: Sage.

18.

McKinsey & Company (1993) Public Service Broadcasters Around the World. London: BBC.

19.

Newcomb, H.M. and P.M. Hirsch (1984) `Television as a Cultural Forum: Implications for Research', in W. Rowland and B. Watkin (eds), Interpreting Television: Current Research Perspectives. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

20.

Pragnell, Anthony (1985) Television in Europe: Quality and Values in a Time of Change. Manchester: European Institute for the Media.

21.

Peacock Committee (1986) Report of the Committee on Financing the BBC, Cmnd 9824. London: HMSO.

22.

Sanchez-Tabernero, Alfonso (1993) Media Concentration in Europe. Dusseldorf: European Institute for the Media.

23.

Santy, Herman (1992) `The Financial Survival of Public Broadcasters'. Paper presented to Second Annual Conference of Public Broadcasting International, Brussels.

24.

Sepstrup, Preben (1990) Transnationalization of Television in Western Europe. London: Libbey.

25.

Servaes, J. (1992) ` “Europe 1992”: The Audiovisual Challenge', Gazette 49(1-2): 75-97.

26.

van Cuilenburg, Jan and Paul Slaa (1993) `From Media Policy towards a National Communications Policy: Broadening the Scope', European Journal of Communication 8(2): 149-176.