The growing body of research on the subject of women and the media has only recently begun to consider the treatment of female criminality. The present study examines the `chivalry hypothesis' as related to media portrayals of female criminality. The data were obtained from a systematic content analysis of 724 press reports of crimes which appeared in Israel's leading dailies. The attribution-of-responsibility statements in these reports were classified by type of offence, offender's sex and other variables. A multivariate analysis, applying the log-linear procedure, reveals the effect of the interaction between the offender's sex and the type of crime on the tendency of the press to present the offender as a `pawn' or as an `origin' type criminal. In spite of the overall tendency to treat female criminality as a consequence of social or psychological factors (i.e. a `pawn'), the attribution of responsibility varies significantly across categories of crime, suggesting that sex-based bias in press reports of crime is highly dependent in the offence involved.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adler, F.
(1975) Sisters in Crime. New York: McGraw-Hill.
2.
Anderson, E.
(1979) `The Chivalrous Treatment of the Female Offender in the Arms of the Criminal Justice System', Social Problems23, 50-57.
3.
Atkin, C.
and Miller, M. (1975) `The Effects of Television Advertising on Children'. Paper presented at the meeting of the International Communication Association, Chicago.
4.
Baunch, P.J.
(1977) `Women Offenders: A Commentary on Current Conceptions on Women in Crime', Quarterly Journal of Corrections1, 4-17.
5.
Beasley, M.
and Silver, S. (1977) Women in the Media. Washington, DC: Women's Institute for Freedom of the Press.
6.
Beuf, A.
(1974) `Doctor, Lawyer, Household Drudge', Journal of Communication24(2), 142-145.
7.
Bernstein, I.
, Cardascia, J. and Ross, C.E. (1979) `Defendent's Sex and Court Decision', pp. 329-354 in R. Alvarez and K. Lutterman (eds), Discrimination in Organization. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
8.
Bowman, W. (1974) `Distaff Journalists: Women as a Minority Group in the News Media'. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Illinois, Chicago.
9.
Busby, L.J.
(1975) `Sex-Role Research on the Mass Media', Journal of Communication25(4), 107-131.
10.
Butler, M.
and Paisley, W. (1980) Women and the Mass Media. New York: Human Sciences Press.
11.
Chesney-Lind, M.
(1977) `Judical Paternalism and the Female Status Offender', Crime and Delinquency23, 121-130.
12.
Davis, F.J.
(1952) `Crime News in Colorado Newspapers', American Journal of Sociology57, 325-330.
13.
De Charms, R.(1968) Personal Causation. New York: Academic Press.
14.
Domenick, J.R.
(1978) `Crime and Law Enforcement in the Mass Media', pp. 105-128 in C. Winick (ed.) Deviance and Mass Media. Beverly Hills: Sage.
15.
Dussuyer, I.
(1979) Crime News: A Study of 40 Ontario Papers. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
16.
Eaton, M.
(1986) Justice for Women?London: Open University Press.
17.
Edwards, S.
(1984) Women on Trial. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
18.
Farrington, D.
and Morris, A. (1983) `Sex, Sentencing and Reconviction', British Journal of Criminology23(3), 229-248.
19.
Ferguson, M.
(1983) Forever Feminine. London: Heinemann.
20.
Fishman, G.
and Weimann, G. (1985) `Presenting the Victim: Sex-Based Bias in Press Reports on Crime', Justice Quarterly2, 491-504.
21.
Giallombardo, R.
(1966) Society of Women: A Study of a Women's Prison. New York; John Wiley.
22.
Glueck, S.
and Glueck, E. (1934) Five Hundred Delinquent Women. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
23.
Goodman, L.
(1970) `The Multivariate Analysis of Qualitative Data: Interaction Among Multiple Classification', Journal of the American Statistical Association63, 1091-1131.
24.
Goodman, L.
(1972) `A General Model for the Analysis of Surveys', American Journal of Sociology77, 1035-1086.
25.
Goodman, L.
(1978) Analysing Quantitative/Categorical Data. Cambridge: Abt Books.
26.
Graber, D.
(1980) Crime News and the Public. New York: Praeger.
27.
Halloran, J.D.
(1978) `Studying Violence and the Media', pp. 278-305 in C. Winnick (ed.) Deviance and Mass Media. Beverly Hills: Sage.
28.
Heidensohn, F.
(1985) Women in Crime. London: Macmillan.
29.
Heider, F.
(1944) `Social Perception and Phenomenal Causality', Psychological Review51, 358-374.
30.
Heider, F.
(1958) The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York: Wiley.
31.
Hodges, K.K.
and Brandt, D.A. (1978a) `Attribution of Causality in Counselling', JSAS Catalog of Selected Documents in Psychology8, 9.
32.
Hodges, K.K.
and Brandt, D.A. (1978b) `Measurement of Attribution of Causality in Counsellor Behaviour', Journal of Counselling Psychology, 25, 343-348.
33.
Hodges, K.K.
, Brandt, D.A. and Kline, J. (1981) `Competence, Guilt and Victimization: Sex Differences in Attribution of Causality in Television Dramas', Sex Roles7, 537-546.
34.
Howitt, D.
and Cumberbatch, G. (1975) Mass Media Violence and Society. London: Elek Science.
35.
Jones, E.T.
(1976) `The Press as a Metropolitan Monitor: The Case of Crime', Public Opinion Quarterly40, 239-244.
36.
Katz, E.
(1981) `On Conceptualizing Media Effects', Studies in Broadcasting1, 119-141.
37.
Knoke, D.
and Burke, P.J. (1980) Log Linear Models. Los Angeles: Sage.
38.
Löchel, E.
(1983) `Sex Differences in Achievement Motivation', pp. 193-220 in J. Jaspars, F. Fincham and M. Hewstone (eds) Attribution Theory and Research: Conceptual, Developmental and Social Dimensions. London: Academic Press.
39.
Lublin, J.S.
(1972) `Discrimination against women in the Newsroom: Fact or Fantasy?', Journalism Quarterly49, 357-361.
40.
Marzoff, M.
(1977) Up from the Footnote: A History of Women Journalists. New York: Hastings House.
41.
McArthur, L.Z.
and Eisen, S.V. (1976) `Television and Sex Role Stereotyping', Journal of Applied Social Psychology6, 329-351.
42.
Miller, M.M.
and Reeves, B. (1975) `Children's Occupational Sex Role Stereotypes'. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Communication Association, Chicago.
43.
Morgan, M.
(1982) `Television and Adolescents' Sex Role Stereotypes: A Longitudinal Study', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology43, 947-955.
44.
Moulds, E.J.
(1980) `Chivalry and Paternalism: Disparity of Treatment in the Criminal Justice System', pp. 277-299 in S.K. Datesman and F.R. Scarpitti (eds) Women, Crime and Justice. New York: Oxford University Press.
45.
Pandiani, J.A.
(1978) `Crime Time TV: If All We Know Is What We Saw', Contemporary Crises2, 437-458.
46.
Quinney, R.
(1975) `Public Conceptions of Crime', pp. 175-184 in R.L. Hersel and R.A. Silverman (eds) Perception in Criminology. New York: Columbia University Press.
47.
Root, J.
(1984) Pictures of Women. London: Pandora Press.
48.
Shaver, K.G.
(1985) The Attribution of Blame. New York: Springer-Verlag.
49.
Sherizan, S.
(1978) `Social Creation of Crime News', pp. 203-224 in C. Winnick (ed.) Deviance and Mass Media. Beverly Hills: Sage.
50.
Tuchman, G.
(1978) `The Symbolic Annihilation of Women by the Mass Media', pp. 3-38 in G. Tuchman, A.K. Daniels and J. Benet (eds) Hearth and Home: Images of Women in the Mass Media. New York: Oxford University Press.
51.
Tuchman, G.
(1979) `Women's Depiction by the Mass Media', Signs4(3), 528-542.
52.
Tuchman, G.
, Daniels, A.K. and Benet, J. (eds.) (1978) Hearth and Home: Images of Women in the Mass MediaNew York: Oxford University Press.
53.
Upton, G.
(1978) The Analysis of Cross Tabulated Data. Chichester: Wiley.
54.
Voumvakis, S.
and Ericson, R. (1984) New Accounts of Attacks on Women: A Comparison of Three Toronto NewspapersToronto: University of Toronto Press.
