Nuclear voices in the news: A comparison of source,news agency and newspaper content about nuclear energy over time

Abstract

While news media are frequently criticized for their alleged increasing reliance on ‘subsidized content’ provided by sources and news agencies, this claim is seldom empirically verified. Based on insights from computer science, this study proposes an approach to quantitatively compare source, news agency and newspaper content over time. Including press releases from two corporate actors and one nongovernmental actor as well as articles of news agencies and newspapers, the approach is applied to the debate about nuclear energy in the Netherlands (2003–2012). Results show no indication of an increased similarity of newspapers’ content with either source content or news agency content, thus providing no justification for the concerns about an increasing dependency of newspapers on subsidized content. Contradicting literature, we found that media content is most similar to the nongovernmental organization’s content, with the exception of one regional newspaper that strongly reflects the local corporation’s content.

Keywords

Content analysis journalism local/regional media news agencies sources

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

(1997) Media, Culture and the Environment. London: UCL Press.

Bakker

Scholten

(2011) Communicatiekaart Nederland: Overzicht van Media en Communicatie [Dutch Communication Map: Overview of Media and Communication]. Deventer: Kluwer.

Boumans

Vliegenthart

(2014) Safety first versus op de barricaden. Een inhoudsanalyse van het nucleaire debat in Nederland. [Safety first versus on the barriers. A content analysis of the nuclear debate in the Netherlands] Tijdschrift voor Communicatiewetenschap 42(4): 358–377.

Boyd-Barrett

Rantanen

(2000) European national news agencies the end of an era or a new beginning? Journalism 1(1): 86–105.

Boyer

(2011) News agency and news mediation in the digital era. Social Anthropology 19(1): 6–22.

Carlson

(2009) Dueling, dancing, or dominating? Journalists and their sources. Sociology Compass 3(4): 526–542.

Cottle

(2003) News, Public Relations and Power. London: SAGE.

Curtin

(1999) Reevaluating Public Relations Information Subsidies. Journal of Public Relations Research 11(1): 53–90.

Curtin

Rhodenbaugh

(2001) Building the news media agenda on the environment: A comparison of public relations and journalistic sources. Public Relations Review 27(2): 179–195.

10.

Davies

(2008) Flat Earth News: An Award-Winning Reporter Exposes Falsehood, Distortion and Propaganda in the Global Media. London: Chatto & Windus.

11.

Davis

(2000) Public relations, news production and changing patterns of source access in the British National Media. Media, Culture & Society 22(1): 39–59.

12.

Davis

Cottle

(2003) News, Public Relations and Power. London; Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

13.

Deacon

(2003) Non-governmental organizations and the media. In: Cottle

(ed.) News, Public Relations and Power. London: SAGE, pp. 99–115.

14.

Denham

(2010) Towards conceptual consistency in studies of agenda-building processes: A scholarly review. Review of Communication 10(4): 306–323.

15.

Diekerhof

Bakker

(2012) To check or not to check: An exploratory study on source checking by Dutch journalists. Journal of Applied Journalism & Media Studies 1(2): 241-253.

16.

Dimitrova

Stromback

(2009) Look who’s talking. Journalism Practice 3(1): 75–91.

17.

Dohmen

(2012, February 29) Nog Meer Banen Schrappen? Onmogelijk [Cutting even more jobs? Impossible]. Online news article. Retrieved from http://www.nrc.nl/handelsblad/2012/03/05/nog-meer-banen-schrappen-onmogelijk-12268903

18.

Forde

Johnston

(2013) The news triumvirate: Public relations, wire agencies and online copy. Journalism Studies 14(1): 113–129.

19.

Franklin

(2008) Pulling Newspapers Apart: Analysing Print Journalism. London: Routledge.

20.

Franklin

(2011) Sources, credibility and the continuing crisis of UK journalism. In: Franklin

Carlson

(eds) Journalists, Sources, and Credibility: New Perspectives. London: Routledge, pp. 90–107.

21.

Franklin

(2012) The Future of Journalism. Journalism Studies 13(5–6): 663–681.

22.

Freer

(2007) UK regional and local newspapers. In: Anderson

Ward

(eds) The Future of Journalism in the Advanced Democracies. Burlington, VT: Ashgate Publishing, pp. 89–103.

23.

Grimmer

Stewart

(2013) Text as data. The promise and pitfalls of automatic content analysis methods for political texts. Political Analysis 97: 1–31.

24.

Hall

Critcher

Jefferson

. (1978) Policing the Crisis: Mugging the State, Law, and Order. London: Macmillan.

25.

Hansen

(2011) Communication, media and environment: Towards reconnecting research on the production, content and social implications of environmental communication. International Communication Gazette 73(1): 7–25.

26.

Hijmans

Schafraad

Buijs

. (2011) Wie schrijft ons nieuws? een analyse van voorverpakt nieuws en brontransparantie in binnenlandse nieuwsonderwerpen in vier Nederlandse en Vlaamse kwaliteitskranten. [Who writes our news? An analysis of pre-produced news and source transparency in domestic news items in four Dutch and Flamish quality newspapers] Tijdschrift Voor Communicatiewetenschap 39(2): 77–91.

27.

Jackson

Moloney

(2015). Inside Churnalism: PR, journalism and power relationships in flux. Journalism Studies. Epub ahead of print 10 March. DOI: 10.1080/1461670X.2015.1017597.

28.

Johnston

Forde

(2011) The silent partner: News agencies and 21st century news. International Journal of Communication 5: 115–129.

29.

Jones

(1972) A statistical interpretation of term specificity and its application in retrieval. Journal of Documentation 28(1): 11-21.

30.

Kerrigan

Graham

(2010) Interaction of regional news-media production and consumption through the social space. Journal of Marketing Management 26(3–4): 302–320.

31.

Lewis

Williams

Franklin

(2008) A compromised fourth estate? UK news journalism, public relations and news sources. Journalism Studies 9(1): 1–20.

32.

Leydesdorff

Welbers

(2011) The semantic mapping of words and co-words in contexts. Journal of Informetrics 5: 469–475.

33.

McChesney

(2008) The Political Economy of Media: Enduring Issues, Emerging Dilemmas. New York: Monthly Review Press.

34.

McChesney

(2012) Farewell to journalism? Time for a rethinking. Journalism Practice (6)5–6: 614–626.

35.

Manning

(2001) News and News Sources: A Critical Introduction. London: SAGE.

36.

Manning

(2008) The press association and news agency sources. In: Franklin

(ed.) Pulling Newspapers Apart: Analysing Print Journalism. London: Routledge, pp. 247–255.

37.

O’Neill

O’Connor

(2008) The passive journalist: How sources dominate local news. Journalism Practice 2(3): 487–500.

38.

Phillips

(2010) Old sources: New bottles. In: Fenton (ed) New Media, Old News. London: SAGE, pp. 87–101.

39.

Prenger

van der Valk

Van Vree

. (2011) Gevaarlijk Spel: De Verhouding tussen PR & Voorlichting en Journalistiek [A Dangerous Game. The Relation between PR & Information and Journalism]. Diemen: AMB.

40.

Rafter

(2014) Voices in the crisis: The role of media elites in interpreting Ireland’s banking collapse. European Journal of Communication 29(5): 598–607.

41.

Reich

(2010) Measuring the impact of PR on published news in increasingly fragmented news environments. Journalism Studies 11(6): 799–816.

42.

Robertson

(2004) Understanding inverse document frequency: On theoretical arguments for IDF. Journal of Documentation 60(5): 503–520.

43.

Rutten

Slot

(2011) Zijn de persbureaus te verslaan. De positie van Nederlandse persbureaus in de nieuwsketen. [Can the press agencies be defeated? The position of Dutch press agencies in the news Chain]. Research Report TNO.

44.

Scholten

Ruigrok

(2009) Bronnen in het Nieuws: Een Onderzoek naar Brongebruik in Nederlandse Dagbladen 2006–2008 [Sources in the News: A Study of Source Usage in Dutch Newspapers 2006–2008]. Amsterdam: Nederlandse Nieuwsmonitor.

45.

Shehata

(2010) Marking Journalistic Independence. Official dominance and the rule of product substitution in Swedish press coverage. European Journal of Communication 25(2): 123-137.

46.

Sigal

(1986) Who? Sources make the news. In: Manoff

Schudson

(eds) Reading the News: A Pantheon Guide to Popular Culture. New York: Pantheon Books, pp. 24–43.

47.

Sissons

(2012) Journalism and public relations: A tale of two discourses. Discourse & Communication 6(3): 273–294.

48.

Tan

P-N

Steinbach

Kumar

(2006) Introduction to Data Mining. Boston, MA: Pearson Education.

49.

Tuchman

(1973) Making news by doing work: Routinizing the unexpected. American Journal of Sociology 79: 110–131.

50.

Van Dam

(2003) Kernthema’s (valedictory speech) [‘Core Themes’]. Delft: Technical University Delft.

51.

Van Hout

Jacobs

(2010) News production theory and practice: Fieldwork notes on power, interaction and agency. Pragmatics 18(1): 59–85.

52.

Waisbord

(2011) Can NGOs change the news. International Journal of Communication 5: 142–165.