This article presents an integrated quantitative analysis of the functional, formal
and content-related aspects of German political party websites during the 2002
National Elections. The analysis is guided by the normalization hypothesis of
cyberspace, which infers a transfer of ‘real-world’ features of
politics to the Internet. Results provide empirical evidence of a limited
normalization in German e-campaigning: indeed, German party websites primarily serve
information functions while neglecting interactive features. Yet, no overall gap in
professionalism is found between major and minor parties analysed. Finally, online
campaigning is dominated by a high level of self-referentiality but lacks both the
expected degree of personalization and characteristic differences in communication
styles between incumbents and challengers.
Baldauf, Manuela
(2002) Wahlkampf im Web. Eine Untersuchung der offiziellen
Webseiten von George W. Bush und Al Gore im
US-Präsidentschaftswahlkampf 2000 [Election Campaigns on the Web: An
Analysis of the Official Websites of George W. Bush and Al Gore in the US
Presidential Election Campaign 2000].
Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitäts-Verlag
.
2.
Beck, Klaus
(1999) ‘Computer-Mediated
Communication’, pp. 127-157 in
H.-B. Brosius
and
C. Holtz-Bacha
(eds) German Communication Yearbook.
Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press
.
3.
Benoit, William L.
and
Pamela J. Benoit
(2002)
‘The Virtual Campaign: Presidential Primary Websites in Campaign 2000’
, American Communication Journal3(3); at:
acjournal.org/holdings/vol3/Iss3/rogue4/benoit.html (accessed 18 June 2002).
4.
Bentivegna, Sara
(2002a)
‘E-Campaigning in the 2001’s Italy Election’
, paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political
Science Association, Boston, MA,
August; at:
apsaproceedings.cup.org/Site/papers/038/038011Bentivegna.pdf (accessed 17
January 2004).
5.
Bentivegna, Sara
(2002b) ‘Politics and the New
Media’, pp. 50-61 in
L.A. Lievrouw
and
S. Livingstone
(eds) Handbook of New Media: Social Shaping and Consequences of
ICTs.
London: Sage
.
6.
Bimber, Bruce
and
Richard Davis
(2003) Campaigning Online. The Internet in US
Elections.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
7.
Boelter, Dietrich
(2002) ‘Online-Campaigning im Härtetest:
Die Online-Kampagnenstrategie der SPD im Bundestagswahlkampf 2002’
[Online Campaigning Put to the Test: The SPD’s Online Campaign
Strategy in the National Election 2002]. PR Guide, October; at:
www.dprg.de/onlineb/p021002a.htm (accessed 6 October 2002).
8.
Carlson, Tom
and
Göran Djupsund
(2001)
‘Old Wine in New Bottles? The 1999 Finish Election Campaign on
the Internet’
, The Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics6:
68-87
.
9.
Challen, Colin
(2001)
‘Think Global, Talk Local: Getting the Party Political Message
Across in the Age of the Internet’
, Journal of Public Affairs1:
254-265
.
10.
Clemens, Dietrich
(1999) ‘Netz-Kampagnen - Parteien und politische
Informationslotsen in den Internet-Wahlkämpfen 1998 in Deutschland und
den USA’ [Net Campaigns - Parties and Political Information Pilots in
the 1998 Internet Election Campaigns in Germany and the United States],
pp. 153-174 in
K. Kamps
(ed.) Elektronische Demokratie? Perspektiven politischer
Partizipation.
Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag
.
11.
Coleman, Stephen
(2001)
‘Online Campaigning’
, Parliamentary Affairs54:
679-688
.
12.
Cunha, Carlos
,
Irene Martin
,
James Newell
and
Luis Ramiro
(2003) ‘Southern European Parties and Party
Systems, and the New ICTs’, pp. 70-97
in
R. Gibsonet al.
(eds) Political Parties and the Internet. Net Gain?London: Routledge
.
13.
D’Alessio, David
(2000)
‘Adoption of the World Wide Web by American Political Candidates, 1996-1998’
, Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media44:
556-568
.
14.
Davis, Richard
(1999) The Web of Politics: The Internet’s Impact
on the American Political System.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
15.
December, John
(1996)
‘Units of Analysis for Internet Communication’
, Journal of Communication46:
14-38
.
16.
Djupsund, Göran
and
Tom Carlson
(2001)
‘Catching the “Wired Voter”: Theoretical
Considerations and an Empirical Analysis’
, paper presented at the XV Nordic Conference on Media and
Communication Research, Iceland,
August; at:
www.nordmediakonferens.hi.is/papers/eight/GDjupsund.doc (accessed 30 June 2002).
17.
Dulio, David A.
,
Don L. Goff
and
James A. Thurber
(1999)
‘Untangled Web: Internet Use During the 1998 Election’
, PSOnlineMarch:
53-59
.
18.
Facheux, Ron
(1998)
‘How Campaigns are Using the Internet: An Exclusive Nationwide Survey’
, Campaigns and ElectionsSeptember:
22-25
.
19.
Foerster, Uly
(1998)
‘Neandertaler im Cyberspace’ [Neanderthals in Cyberspace]
, Spiegel Online 28 September; at:
www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/politik/0,1518,13683,00.html (accessed 17
November 2002).
20.
Gellner, Winand
and
Gerd Strohmeier
(2002a) ‘Cyber-Kampagnen’ [Cyber
Campaigns], pp. 164-186 in
A. Dörner
and
L. Vogt
(eds) Wahl-Kämpfe: Betrachtungen über ein
demokratisches Ritual.
Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp
.
21.
Gellner, Winand
and
Gerd Strohmeier
(2002b) ‘Parteien in
Internet-Wahkämpfen’ [Parties in Internet Election
Campaigns], pp. 189-209 in
U. von Alemann
and
S. Marschall
(eds) Parteien in der Mediendemokratie.
Wiesbaden: Westdeutscher Verlag
.
22.
Gibson, Rachel K.
and
Stephen Ward
(1998)
‘UK Political Parties and the Internet: “Politics as
Usual” in the New Media?’
, The Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics3:
14-38
.
23.
Gibson, Rachel K.
and
Stephen Ward
(2000)
‘A Proposed Methodology for Studying the Function and
Effectiveness of Party and Candidate Web Sites’
, Social Science Computer Review18:
301-319
.
24.
Gibson, Rachel K.
and
Stephen Ward
(2003) ‘Letting the Daylight in? Australian
Parties’ Use of the World Wide Web at the State and Territory
Level’, pp. 139-160 in
Rachel Gibson
,
Paul Nixon
and
Stephen Ward
(eds) Political Parties and the Internet. Net Gain?London: Routledge
.
25.
Gibson, Rachel K.
,
James Newell
and
Stephen Ward
(2000)
‘New Parties, New Media: Italian Party Politics and the Internet’
, South European Society and Politics5:
123-144
.
26.
Gibson, Rachel K.
,
Michael Margolis
,
David Resnick
and
Stephen Ward
(2001)
‘Election Campaigning on the WWW in the US and UK: A Comparative Analysis’
, paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political
Science Association, San Francisco, CA,
August; at:
pro.harvard.edu/papers/038/038007GibsonRach.pdf (accessed 21 May 2002).
27.
Greer, Jennifer
and
Mark LaPointe
(2001)
‘Cyber-Campaigning Grows up: A Comparative Content Analysis of
Senatorial and Gubernatorial Candidates’ Web Sites, 1998-2000’
, paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political
Science Association, San Francisco, CA,
August; at: pro.harvard.edu/papers/038/038007GreerJenni.pdf
(accessed 21 May 2002).
28.
Holtz-Bacha, Christina
(1999) ‘Mass Media and Elections: An Impressive
Body of Research’, pp. 39-68 in
H.-B. Brosius
and
C. Holtz-Bacha
(eds) German Communication Yearbook.
Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press
.
29.
Holtz-Bacha, Christina
(2004) ‘Germany: The “German
Model” and its Intricacies’, pp.
9-27 in
J. Roper
,
C. Holtz-Bacha
and
G. Mazzoleni
(eds) The Politics of Representation: Election Campaigning and
Proportional Representation.
New York: Peter Lang
.
30.
James, Karen
and
James D. Sadow
(1997)
‘Utilization of the World Wide Web as a Communicator of Campaign Information’
, paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political
Science Association, Washington, DC,
August; at:
www.people.uis.edu/jsado1/uis/cwsp/aspa97.htm (accessed 21 May 2002).
31.
Kamarck, Elaine Ciulla
(1999) ‘Campaigning on the Internet in the
Elections of 1998’, pp. 99-123 in
E.C. Kamarck
and
J.S. Nye Jr
(eds) Democracy.com? Governance in a Network World.
Hollis, NH: Hollis Publishing
.
32.
Kamarck, Elaine Ciulla
(2002) ‘Political Campaigning on the Internet:
Business as Usual?’, pp. 81-103 in
E.C. Kamarck
and
J.S. Nye Jr
(eds) Governance.com: Democracy in the Information Age.
Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press
.
33.
Katz, James E.
,
Ronald E. Rice
and
Philip Aspden
(2001)
‘The Internet, 1995-2000: Access, Civic Involvement, and Social Interaction’
, American Behavioral Scientist45:
405-419
.
34.
Klotz, Robert
(1998)
‘Virtual Criticism: Negative Advertising on the Internet in the
1996 Senate Races’
, Political Communication15:
347-365
.
35.
Leggewie, Claus
(2002) ‘Netzwerkparteien? Parteien in der
digitalen Öffentlichkeit’ [Network Parties? Parties in the
Digital Public Sphere], pp. 173-188 in
U. von Alemann
and
S. Marschall
(eds) Parteien in der Mediendemokratie.
Wiesbaden: Westdeutscher Verlag
.
36.
Löfgren, Karl
(2000) ‘Danish Political Parties and New
Technology. Interactive Parties or New Shop Windows?’, pp.
57-70 in
J. Hoffet al.
(eds) Democratic Governance and New Technology: Technologically Mediated
Innovations in Political Practice in Western Europe.
London: Routledge
.
37.
McMillan, Sally J.
(2000)
‘The Microscope and the Moving Target: The Challenge of Applying
Content Analysis to the World Wide Web’
, Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly77:
80-98
.
38.
Margolis, Michael
and
David Resnick
(2000) Politics as Usual: The Cyberspace
‘Revolution’.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
39.
Margolis, Michael
,
David Resnick
and
Chin-chang Tu
(1997)
‘Campaigning on the Internet: Parties and Candidates on the World
Wide Web in the 1996 Primary Season’
, The Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics2:
59-78
.
40.
Margolis, Michael
,
David Resnick
and
Joel D. Wolfe
(1999)
‘Party Competition on the Internet in the United States and Britain’
, The Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics4:
24-47
.
41.
Margolis, Michael
,
David Resnick
and
Jonathan Levy
(2003) ‘Major Parties Dominate, Minor Parties
Struggle: US Elections and the Internet’, pp.
53-69 in
Rachel Gibson
,
Paul Nixon
and
Stephen Ward
(eds) Political Parties and the Internet: Net Gain?London: Routledge
.
42.
Morris, Merrill
and
Christine Ogan
(1996)
‘The Internet as Mass Medium’
, Journal of Communication46:
39-50
.
43.
Newell, James L.
(2001)
‘Italian Political Parties on the Web’
, The Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics6:
60-87
.
44.
Norris, Pippa
(2001) ‘Preaching to the Converted? Pluralism,
Participation, and Party Websites’; at:
ksghome.harvard.edu/%7E.pnorris.shorenstein.ksg/ACROBAT/Preaching.pdf
(accessed 30 June 2002).
45.
Norris, Pippa
(2002) ‘Revolution, What Revolution? The
Internet and US Elections, 1992-2000’, pp.
59-80 in
E.C. Kamarck
and
John S. Nye Jr
(eds) Governance.com: Democracy in the Information Age.
Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press
.
46.
Poupolo, Sonia T.
(2001)
‘The Web and US Senate Campaigns 2000’
, American Behavioral Scientist44:
2030-2047
.
47.
Roper, Juliet
(1998) ‘New Zealand Political Parties Online:
The World Wide Web as Tool for Democratization or for Political
Marketing?’, pp. 69-83 in
C. Toulouse
and
T.W. Luke
(eds) The Politics of Cyberspace: A New Political Science.
New York: Routledge
.
48.
Sadow, James D.
(2000)
‘A Uses and Gratifications Theory of Internet Campaigning’
, paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political
Science Association, Washington, DC,
August; at:
people.uis.edu/jsado1/uis/cwsp/aspa00.htm (accessed 21 May 2002).
49.
Sadow, James D.
and
Karen James
(1999)
‘Virtual Billboards? Candidate Web Sites and Campaigning in 1998’
, paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political
Science Association, Atlanta, GA,
September; at:
people.uis.edu/jsado1/uis/cwsp/apsa99.htm (accessed 21 May 2002).
50.
Sadow, James D.
and
Karen James
(2000)
‘A Theory of Internet Political Campaigning: A Revolution That
Isn’t, Yet’
, paper presented at the annual meeting of the Southwestern
Political Science Association, Galveston, TX,
March; at:
people.uis.edu/jsado1/uis/cwsp/swpsa00.htm (accessed 21 May 2002).
51.
Schulz, Winfried
(1997) Politische Kommunikation. Theoretische
Ansätze und Ergebnisse empirischer Forschung [Political Communication:
Theoretical Approaches and Results of Empirical Research].
Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag
.
52.
Stempel III
,
Guido H.
and
Robert K. Stewart
(2000)
‘The Internet Provides Both Opportunities and Challenges for Mass
Communication Researchers’
, Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly77:
541-548
.
53.
Swanson, David L.
and
Paolo Mancini
(1996) ‘Patterns of Modern Electoral Campaigning
and their Consequences’, pp. 247-276 in
D.L. Swanson
and
P. Mancini
(eds) Politics, Media, and Modern Democracy: An International Study of
Innovations in Electoral Campaigning and their Consequences.
Westport, CT: Praeger
.
54.
Tedesco, John C.
,
Jerry L. Miller
and
Julia A. Spiker
(1999) ‘Presidential Campaigning on the
Information Superhighway: An Exploration of Content and
Form’, pp. 51-63 in
L.L. Kaid
and
D.G. Bystrom
(eds) The Electronic Election: Perspectives on the 1996 Campaign
Communication.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
55.
Tomasello, Tami K.
(2001)
‘The Status of Internet-Based Research in Five Leading
Communication Journals, 1994-1999’
, Journal of Mass Communication Quarterly78:
659-674
.
56.
Tops, Pieter
,
Gerrit Voerman
and
Marcel Boogers
(2000) ‘Political Websites during the 1998
Parliamentary Elections in the Netherlands’, pp.
87-99 in
J. Hoff
,
I. Horrocks
and
P. Tops
(eds) Democratic Governance and New Technology: Technologically Mediated
Innovations in Political Practice in Western Europe.
London: Routledge
.
57.
Trent, Judith S.
and
Robert C. Friedenberg
(2000) Political Campaign Communication: Principles and
Practices, 4th edn.Westport, CT: Praeger
.
58.
Voerman, Gerrit
(1999)
‘Distributing Electronic Folders: The Digital Electoral Campaign
of 1998 in the Netherlands’
, paper presented at ‘Horizon 1999: Conference on
Communication’, Utrecht, Netherlands,
May; at:
www.archipol.nl/project/publications/folders.html (accessed 21 May 2002).
59.
Ward, Stephen K.
(2002)
‘Virtual Campaigning: Australian Parties and the Impact of the Internet’
, Australian Journal of Political Science37:
99-130
.
60.
Ward, Stephen
and
Rachel Gibson
(1998) ‘The First Internet Election: UK
Political Parties and Campaigning in Cyberspace’, pp.
93-112 in
I. Crewe
(ed.) Political Communication: Why Labour Won the General Election of
1997.
London: Frank Cass
.
61.
Weare, Christopher
and
Wang-Ying Lin
(2000)
‘Content Analysis of the World Wide Web: Opportunities and Challenges’
, Social Science Computer Review18:
272-292
.
62.
Wicks, Robert H.
and
Boubacar Souley
(2003)
‘Going Negative: Candidate Usage of Internet Web Sites during the
2000 Presidential Campaign’
, Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly80:
128-144
.
