Enterprise Competencies for Effective Information Systems and Information Management

Abstract

A study of small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) in Wales was undertaken to evaluate the effectiveness and competence of users of information technology (IT) and information systems (IS). A questionnaire survey, followed by selected follow-up interviews, was conducted: to determine levels of information technology (IT) and information systems (IS) use by small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in Wales; to identify key factors influencing SMEs’ ability to exploit opportunities that technology offers; to investigate whether IT/IS is managed in an active and strategic fashion; to assess the use and management of data within these enterprises; and to consider whether SMEs have opportunities to create strategic advantage from IT/IS. The results indicated that the utilization of IT is increasing but the majority of SMEs are under-exploiting the potential benefits due to a lack of management direction. Nevertheless, although few SMEs are being seen to achieve competitive advantage, those enterprises that are doing so tend to be focusing on acquiring knowledge, using their flexibility and ability to react speedily and generating innovative solutions. Th study identified areas where further research was needed to support the findings, particularly in terms of the regularly review of the level and exploitation of IT/ IS within the SME sector within Wales and the rest of the UK via quantitative surveys providing a base for a longitudinal comparison of data; the investigation of the factors that deter IT/IS development within SMEs; and the review of IS/IT within individual SME industries and sectors, utilizing case study methodology and allowing for the qualitative analysis of key factors underpinning usage. (Part 1 of this article was published in the previous issue of Business Information Review).

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

A Baldwin, A Lymer and R Johnson (2000) ‘Business Impacts of the Internet for SMEs’, in B Hunt and S Barnes (ed). E-Commerce and V-Business. London: Butterworth-Heinemann .

J Ballantine, M Levy and P Powell (1998). ‘Evaluating Information Systems in SMEs, Issue & Evidence’ . European Journal of Information Systems No 7, pp 241–251 .

M Bensaou and M Earl (1998) ‘The Right Mind Set for Managing Information Technology’ Harvard Business Review, Sep/Oct.

P Beynon-Davies, S Evans and I Owen (2000). ‘Electronic Commerce and Small and Medium Enterprises’ Information Technology Conference, Manchester 2000.

S Blili and L Raymond (1993). ‘Information Technology: Threats & Opportunities for SMEs.’ International Journal of Information Management 13, pp 439–448 .

Department of Trade & Industry (2000). DTI Small and Medium Enterprise (SME) Statistics, Definitions of SMEs. www.dti.gov.uk/SME4/define.htm. (Accessed on 21 February 2001.)

Department of Trade and Industry Small Business Service (1999). ‘Small and Medium Enterprise Statistics for the United Kingdom’ . Statistical Bulletin Sep 2000.

D Erasmus (1999) ‘A Common Language for Strategy.’ in Mastering Information Management. London: FT Publications .

D Feeny and L Willcocks (1999). ‘Transforming IT Based Innovation into Business Payoff ’ in Mastering Information Management. London: FT Publications .

10.

D Fink (1998). ‘Guidelines for the Successful Adoption of Information Technology in SMEs.’ International Journal of Information Management 18(4), pp 243–253 .

11.

G Jacobs and W Dowsland (2000). ‘The Dot-Com Economy in Wales: A Long Road Ahead’ . Information Systems: Research, Teaching and Practice. Proceedings of the 5th UKAIS Conference, University of Wales Institute, Cardiff 26–28 April 2000) pp 590–596 .

12.

M Levy and P Powell (1999). ‘Emerging Technologies: can the Internet add value for SMEs?’ in UKAIS. University of York: McGraw-Hill .

13.

M Levy and P Powell (2000). ‘Information Systems Strategy for SMEs: an Organizational Perspective.’ Journal of Strategic Information Systems 9, pp 39–62 .

14.

A Lymer, R Johnson and A Baldwin (1997). ‘The Internet and the Small Business.’ Proceedings of the 5th European Conference on Information Systems, Cork.

15.

National Economic Development Strategy (2001). In Search of Economic Growth: a consultation paper. Cardiff: National Assembly of Wales , Feb 2001.

16.

National Assembly for Wales Economic Development Committee (2001). Review of Business Support & Development Services. Cardiff: National Assembly for Wales , Feb 2001. Available at www.wales.gov.uk/index.htm. (Accessed on 26 March 2001.)

17.

Organization for Economic Co-operation & Development (2000) ‘Enhancing the Competitiveness of SMEs in Global Economy’ . The Bologna Charter on SME Policies, Bologna, Italy, 14–15 June, 2000. Paris: OECD.

18.

C E Pollard and S C Hayne (1998). ‘The Changing Face of Information System Issues in Small Firms.’ International Small Business Journal. 16(3) Apr/ Jun 1998 pp 70–77 .

19.

J Renton (2001). ‘Why Wales has to learn to mind its own business’ . Sunday Times 4 Feb 2001 p15.

20.

C K Riemenschneider and P P Mykytyn (2000). ‘What small business executives have learned about managing information technology’ Information & Management 37, pp 257–269 .