The Changing Face of Information System Issues in Small Firms

Abstract

CAROL E. POLLARD IS WITH THE FACULTY OF Management, University of Calgary, Alberta, Canada, and Stephen C. Hayne is with the School of Management, Arizona State University West, Phoenix, USA. This study provides insights into the information technology concerns of small firms and indicates ways in which small firms are managing technological challenges and opportunities. A national survey of small Canadian firms was conducted using a modified Delphi technique and follow-up telephone interviews. (ritical information systems issuies identified include 1) using IS for competitive advantages; 2) improving IS project management practices; 3) improving the effectiveness of software development. A comparison with recent sttudies to identify recent trends in IS issues reveals that the issues faced by small Caniadian firms have changed. Small firms are lagging large firms where the technology is concerned but are similar on conceptual issues. We believe that small firms will continue to desire more internal control over operations ancl consequently adopt more technology. Hardware and software qualitx and reliability will stay at the forefront of their worries. Furthermore, as conmmunications become more mission critical, i.e. electronic mail and electronic data interchanige, small firms will embrace network technologx. Managing communications max become a very critical problem for small business.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alpar, P. , and Ein-Dor, P. (1991), 'Major IS Concerns of Entrepreneurial Organisations', Information and Management, 20, pp1-11.

Ball, L. , and Harris, R. (1982), 'SMIS Members: A Membership Analysis', Management Information Systems Quarterly, March, 6 (1), pp19-38.

Blackler, F. , and Brown, C. (1985), 'Evaluation and the Importance of Information Technologies on People in Organisations', Human Relations, 36, pp213-231.

Brancheau, J. , and Wetherbe, J. (1987), 'Key Issues in Information Systems Management', Management Information Systems Quarterly, March, 11 (1), pp23-45.

Clark, A. (1987), Small Business Computer Systems, London: Hodder and Stoughton.

Comford, A. , and Whitley, E. (1991), 'A Review of Information Technology Strategies Within the UK SME Sector'. Internal Research Paper for the ESPRIT Project (No. 5639). London: The London School of Economics.

Computerworld (1995), 'Is the Cost of Networking Worth It?', 29 (44), pp45-48.

Delbecq, A. , Van de Ven, A. , and Gustafson, D. (1975), Group Techniques for Program Planning: A Guide to Nominal Group and Delphi Processes, Glenview, ILL: Scott-Foresman.

Dickson, G. , Leitheiser, J. , Wetherbe, J. , and Nechis, M. (1984), 'Key Information Systems Issues for the 1980s', Management Information Systems Quarterly, September, 8 (3), pp135-148.

10.

Dickson, G. , andjohn, D. (1989), 'Technology Issues Facing Corporate Management in the 1990s', Management Information Systems Quarterly, September, 13 (3), pp247-255.

11.

Doukidis, G. , Smithson, S. , and Lybereas, T. (1994), 'Trends in Information Technology in Small Business', Journal of End User Computing, 6 (4), pp15-25.

12.

Ein-Dor, P. , and Segev, E. (1978), 'Organisational Context and the Success of Management Information Systems', Management Science, 24 (6), pp1067-1077.

13.

Farhoomand, R. , and Hrycyk, G. (1985), 'The Feasibility of Computers in the Small Business Environment', American Journal of Small Business, 9 (4), pp15-22.

14.

Heikkila,J. , Saarinen, T. , and Saaksjarvi, M. (1991), 'Success of Software Packages in Small Business: An Exploratory Study', Journal of Information Systems, 1 (3), pp159-169.

15.

Kagen, P. , Lau, K. , and Nusgart, K. (1990), 'Information System Usage Within Small Business Firms', Entrepreneurship, Theory and Practice, Spring, pp25-37.

16.

Keen, P. (1991), Shaping the Future: Business Design Through Information 7echnology, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA.

17.

Lai, V. (1994), 'A Survey of Rural Small Business Computer Use: Success Factors and Decision Support', Journal of Injormation and Management, 26, pp297-304.

18.

Lin, B. , Vassar,J. , and Clark, L. (1993), 'Information Technology Strategies for Small Business', Journal of Applied Business Research, 9 (2), pp25-29.

19.

Longenecker,J. , and Moore, W. (1987), Small Business Management, 7th Edition, Cincinnati, OH: South-Western Publishing Co.

20.

Malone, S. (1985), 'Computerising Small Businiess Information Systems', Journal of Small Business Management, April, pp10-16.

21.

Meyer, N. , and Boone, M. (1987), The Injormation Edge, New York: McGraw Hill.

22.

Montazemi, A. (1988), 'Factors Affecting Information Satisfaction in the Context of the Small Business Environment', MVIS Quarterly, 12 (2), pp239-256.

23.

Niederman, F. , Brancheau,J. , and Wetherbe, J. (1991), 'Information Systems for the 1990s', Management InJormation Systems Quarterly, December, 15 (4), pp475-500.

24.

Nickell, G. , and Seado, P. (1986), 'The Impact of Attitudes and Experience on Small Btusiness Computer Use', American Journal of Small Business, 10 (1), pp37-48.

25.

Poutsma, E. , and Walravens, A. (eds.) (1989), TIechnology and Small Enterprises: 7echnology, Autonomy and Industrial Organisation, Delft University Press.

26.

Raymond, L. (1985), 'Organisational Characteristics and MIS Success in the Context of Small Business', Management Information s7 stems Quarterly, March, 9 (1), pp37-52.

27.

Rivard, S. , Boisvert, C. , and Talbot, J. (1988), 'Key Management Isstues in Information Systems: A Comparative Analysis', Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the ASAC 1988 Conference, pp32-42.

28.

Scholhammer, H. , and Kuriloff, A. (1979), Entrepreneurship and Small Business Mlanagement, News York, WAilev.

29.

Senn, J. , and Gibson, V. (1981), 'Risks of Investment in Microcomllputets for Small Business', Journal of Small Business Management, 19 (3), pp24-32.

30.

Small Business Adininisti-ationi (1990). 'Size Standards by SIC Induistry', Washington, DC, Government Prittinig Office.

31.

Watson, R. , and Brancheau,J. (1991). 'Key Issues in Information Svstenis Management: An Interniational Perspective', Injormation an(n Management, 20 (3), pp213-223.

32.

Weinstein, A. (1994), 'Market Definition in Technology-based Industry: A (omparative Study of Small Versuis Non-small Companies', Journal oJfSmall Business Managuement, 32 (4), pp28-36.

33.

Wright, B. (1995), Director Caniadlian Federation of Independent Business, in a personal communicationl.