This article examines the franchisor-franchisee relationship from two theoretical perspectives - agency theory and exchange theory. Taking the case of the fast-food industry in Israel, the research focuses on control and autonomy in a domestic hamburger chain - Burger Ranch - and two international chains - McDonald's and Burger King. The findings led to the design of a model that illustrates several aspects, such as the concept of franchising, the size and age of the chain, and the range of the contract, that relate to control and autonomy. The combination of agency theory and exchange theory enables us to focus on control and autonomy as multidimensional concepts, and to present various possibilities for judiciously balancing them. The case indicates that in some respects (e.g. master franchisee), the two global chains are more similar to each other than to the domestic chain. However, in other respects (e.g. size, growth rate), the domestic and one of the two global chains show more similarities than differences. The findings indicate different forms of integration of control and autonomy in the three chains.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agrawal, D. and Lal, R. (1995) `Contractual Arrangements in Franchising: An Empirical Investigation' , Journal of Marketing Research32(3): 213-221 .
2.
Anand, P. (1987) `Inducing Franchisees to Relinquish Control: An Attribution Analysis' , Journal of Marketing Research24(2): 215-221 .
3.
Bates, T. (1995) `Analysis of Survival Rates Among Franchise and Independent Small Business Startups' , Journal of Small Business Management33(2): 26-36 .
4.
Bates, T. (1998) `Survival Patterns Among Newcomers to Franchising' , Journal of Business Venturing13(2): 113-130 .
5.
Baucus, D. A., Baucus, M. S. and Human, S. E. (1996) `Consensus in Franchise Organizations: A Cooperative Arrangement Among Entrepreneurs' , Journal of Business Venturing11(5): 359-378 .
6.
Bills, D. B. (1998) `Community of Interests: Understanding the Relationships between Franchisees and Franchisors' , Research in Social Stratification and Mobility16: 351-369 .
7.
Birkeland, P. M. (1995) The Sociology of Franchising: Trust and Control in the Service Economy, PhD, Faculty of the Division of the Social Sciences, Department of Sociology, The University of Chicago.
8.
Blau, P. M. (1964) Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York: Wiley .
9.
Bradach, J. L. (1995) `Chains within Chains: The Role of Multi-Unit Franchisees', in P. J. Kaufmann and R. P. Dant (eds) Franchising: Contemporary Issues and Research, pp. 65-80. New York: Haworth .
10.
Brickley, J. A. and Dark, F. H. (1987) `The Choice of Organizational Form: The Case of Franchising' , Journal of Financial Economics18(2): 401-420 .
11.
Brickley, J. A., Dark, F. H. and Weisbach, M. S. (1991) `An Agency Perspective on Franchising' , Financial Management20(1): 27-35 .
12.
Bromiley, P. and Cummings, L. L. (1995) `Transaction Costs in Organizations with Trust', pp. 219-247 in R. J. Lewickiet al. (eds) Research on Negotiation in Organizations vol. 5. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press .
13.
Business Data Information (1997) Fast Food Chains in Israel. Israel: BDI .
14.
Carney, M. and Gedajlovic, E. (1991) `Vertical Integration in Franchise Systems: Agency Theory and Resource Explanations' , Strategic Management Journal12(8): 607-629 .
15.
Castrogiovanni, G. J. and Justis, R. T. (1998) `Franchising Configurations and Transitions' , Journal of Consumer Marketing15(2): 170-190 .
16.
Castrogiovanni, G. J. and Justis, R. T. (2000) `Strategic and Contextual Influences on Firm Growth: An Empirical Study of Franchisors' , paper presented at 14th Annual International Society of Franchising Conference, San Diego, CA, 20 February.
17.
Dandridge, T. C. and Falbe, C. M. (1994) `The Influence of Franchisees Beyond their Local Domain' , International Small Business Journal12(2): 39-49 .
18.
Dant, S. P. (1996) `Ownership Structure in Franchising: The Effect of Transaction Cost, Production Costs and Strategic Considerations' , The International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research6(1): 53-75 .
19.
Dant, R. P. and Gundlach, G. T. (1999) `The Challenge of Autonomy and Dependence in Franchised Channels of Distribution' , Journal of Business Venturing14(1): 35-68 .
20.
Dant, R. P. and Nasr, N. I. (1998) `Control Techniques and Upward Flow of Information in Franchising in Distant Markets: Conceptualization and Preliminary Evidence' , Journal of Business Venturing13(1): 3-28 .
21.
Davidson, J. O. (1994) `What Do Franchisors Do? Control and Commercialization in the Milk Distribution' , Work Employment and Society8(1): 23-44 .
22.
Dickey, M. H. (2002) `The Effect of Electronic Communication among Franchisees on Franchisee Compliance' , in J. Young (ed.) Franchise Systems at the Turning Point of Maturity, Proceedings of the 16th Conference of the International Society of Franchising. Orlando, FL, 8-10 February.
23.
Dun and Bradstreet Corporation (1997) Business Data Report. Israel: D & B .
24.
Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989) `Agency Theory: An Assessment and Review' , Academy of Management Review14(1): 57-74 .
25.
Elango, B. and Fried, V. H. (1997) `Franchising Research: A Literature Review and Synthesis' , Journal of Small Business Management35(3): 68-81 .
26.
English, W. and Hoy, F. (1995) `Are Franchisees Actually Entrepreneurs? Some Exploratory Survey Findings' , paper presented at 9th Annual International Society of Franchising Conference, San Juan, Puerto Rico, 20 January.
27.
Falbe, C. M. and Welsh, D. H. B. (1998) `NAFTA and Franchising: A Comparison of Franchisor Perceptions of Characteristics Associated with Franchisee Success and Failure in Canada, Mexico and the United States' , Journal of Business Venturing13(2): 151-171 .
28.
Fama, E. F. and Jensen, M. C. (1983) `Agency Problems and Residual Claims' , Journal of Law and Economics26(2): 327-350 .
29.
Felstead, A. (1991) `The Social Organization of the Franchise: A Case of Controlled Self Employment' , Work Employment and Society5(1): 37-57 .
30.
Felstead, A. (1993) `Shifting the Frontier of Control: Small Firm Autonomy within a Franchise' , International Journal of Small Business12(2): 50-62 .
31.
Fladmoe-Lindquist, K. (1996) `International Franchising: Capabilities and Development' , Journal of Business Venturing11(5): 419-438 .
32.
Fladmoe-Lindquist, K. and Jacque, L. L. (1995) `Control Modes in International Service Operation: The Propensity to Franchise' , Management Science41(7): 1238-1249 .
33.
Gamet-Pol, F. J. (1997) Franchise Agreements within the European Community. New York: Transnational .
34.
Ghoshal, S. and Moran, P. (1996) `Bad for Practice: A Critique of the Transaction Cost Theory' , Academy of Management Review21(1): 13-47 .
35.
Grunhagen, M. and Mittelstaedt, R. A. (2000) `Single-Unit vs. Multi-Unit Franchising: History, Typology and the Franchisee Perspective' , paper presented at 14th Annual International Society of Franchising Conference, San Diego, CA, 20 February.
36.
Hadfield, G. K. (1990) `Problematic Relations: Franchising and the Law of Incomplete Contracts' , Stanford Law Review42(4): 927-992 .
37.
Han, A. M. (2001) `Legal Aspects of Franchising in China', in I. Alon and D. H. B. Welsh (eds) International Franchising in Emerging Markets, pp. 83-104. Chicago, IL: CCH Publishing .
38.
Hoffman, R. C. and Preble, J. F. (1993) `Franchising into The Twenty-First Century' , Business Horizons36(4): 35-43 .
39.
Hopkins, D. M. (1996) `International Franchising: Standardization versus Adaptation to Cultural Differences' , Franchising Research: An International Journal1(1): 15-24 .
40.
Hoy, F. and Echegaray, M. H. (1994) `Double Your Trouble through International Franchising: Arby's Goes to Mexico', in W. D. Bygraveet al. (eds) Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research: 587-600. Babson Park, MA: Babson College .
41.
Israel America Chamber of Commerce and Industry (1997) Israel - Franchising: Market Research Reports. Israel: IACCI .
42.
Jambulingham, T. and Nevin, J. (1997) `Influence of Franchisee Selection Criteria on Franchisee Performance' , in M. Spriggs (ed.) Winning Strategies for Franchising: Current Research and Future Directions, Proceedings of the Eleventh Conference of the Society of Franchising. Orlando, FL, 1-2 March.
43.
Kahn, M. A. and Kahn, M. M. (2001) `Emerging Markets for Restaurant Franchising in Middle East Countries', in I. Alon and D. H. B. Welsh (eds) International Franchising in Emerging Markets, pp. 209-227. Chicago, IL: CCH .
44.
Kaufmann, P. J. (1996) `The State of Research in Franchising' , Franchising Research: An International Journal1(1): 4-7 .
45.
Kaufmann. P. J. and Dant, R. P. (1996) `Multi-Unit Franchising: Growth and Management Issues' , Journal of Business Venturing11(5): 343-358 .
46.
Kaufmann, P. J. and Eroglu, S. (1999) `Standardization and Adaptation in Business Format Franchising' , Journal of Business Venturing14(1): 69-86 .
47.
Kaufmann, P. J. and Kim, S. H. (1996) `Master Franchising and System Growth Rates', in P. J. Kaufmann and R. P. Dant (eds) Franchising: Contemporary Issues and Research. New York: Haworth .
48.
Kedia, B. L., Ackerman, D. J. and Justis, R. T. (1995) `Changing Barriers to the Internationalization of Franchising Operations: Perceptions of Domestic and International Franchisors' , The International Executive37(4): 329-348 .
49.
Knight, R. N. (1984) `The Independence of the Franchise Entrepreneurs' , Journal of Small Business Management22(2): 53-61 .
50.
Knight, R. N. (1986) `Franchising from the Franchisor and Franchisee Points of View' , Journal of Small Business Management24(3): 8-15 .
51.
Krueger, A. B. (1991) `Ownership, Agency, and Wages: An Examination of Franchising in the Fast Food Industry' , Quarterly Journal of Economics106(1): 75-101 .
52.
Lafontaine, F. (1992) `Agency Theory and Franchising: Some Empirical Results' , Rand Journal of Economics23(2): 263-283 .
53.
Lafontaine, F. and Raynaud, E. (2002) `The Role of Residual Claims and Self-enforcement in Franchise Contracting' , in J. Young (ed.) Franchise Systems at the Turning Point of Maturity, Proceedings of the 16th Conference of the International Society of Franchising. Orlando, FL, 8-10 February.
54.
Lafontaine, F. and Show, K. L. (1998) `Franchising Growth and Franchisor Entry and Exit in the U.S. Market: Myth and Reality' , Journal of Business Venturing13(2): 95-112 .
55.
Larson, A. (1992) `Network Dyads in Entrepreneurial Settings: A Study of the Governance Exchange Processes' , Administrative Science Quarterly37(1): 76-104 .
56.
Leblebici, H. and Shalley, C. E. (1996) `The Organization of Relational Contracts: The Allocation of Rights in Franchising' , Journal of Business Venturing11(5): 403-418 .
57.
McCosker, C. F. and Walker, B. J. (1992) `International Expansion by Australian Franchisors', in N. C. Churchillet al. (eds) Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research, pp. 588-590. Babson Park, MA: Babson College .
58.
McGinty, R. L. (1998) `Free Advisory Services Create an Entrepreneurial Opportunity' , Journal of Consumer Marketing15(1): 55-63 .
59.
Macneil, I. (1978) `Contracts: Adjustment of Long-Term Economic Relations under Classical, Neo-Classical, and Relational Contract Law' , Northwestern University Law Review72(6): 854-906 .
60.
Mathewson, G. and Winter, R. (1985) `The Economics of Franchise Contracts' , Journal of Law and Economics28(3): 503-526 .
61.
Michael, S. C. (1996) `To Franchise or Not to Franchise: An Analysis of Decision Rights and Organizational Shares' , Journal of Business Venturing11(1): 57-71 .
62.
Mintzberg, H. (1990) `The Design School: Reconsidering the Basic Premises of Strategic Management' , Strategic Management Journal11: 171-196 .
63.
Monye, S. O. (1997) `The Theory and Practice of Franchising: An International Perspective' , Franchising Research2(4): 167-176 .
64.
Paswan, A. K., Young, J. A. and Kantamneni, S. P. (2001) `Public Opinions about Franchising in an Emerging Market: An Exploratory Investigation Involving Indian Consumers', in I. Alon and D. H. B. Welsh (eds) International Franchising in Emerging Markets, pp. 173-186. Chicago, IL: CCH Publishing .
65.
Perrow, C. (1986) Complex Organization: A Critical Essay, 3rd edn. New York: Random House .
66.
Pfeffer, J. and Salancik, G. (1978) The External Control of Organizations: A Resource Dependence Perspective. New York: Harper and Row .
67.
Powell, W. (1990) `Neither Market nor Hierarchy: Netforms of Organizations', in B. M. Staw and L. L. Cummings (eds) Research in Organizational Behavior, vol. 12, pp. 295-336. Greenwich, CT: JAI .
68.
Preble, J. F. (1992) `Global Expansion: The Case of U.S. Fast Food Franchisors' , Journal of Global Marketing6(1-2): 185-202 .
69.
Preble, J. F. and Hoffman, R. C. (1995) `Franchising Systems around the Globe: A Status Report' , Journal of Small Business Management33(2): 80-88 .
70.
Preble, J. F. and Hoffman, R. C. (1998) `Competitive Advantage through Specialty Franchising' , Journal of Consumer Marketing15(1): 64-77 .
71.
Putterman, L. (1984) `On Some Recent Explanations of Why Capital Hires Labor' , Economic Inquiry33: 171-187 .
72.
Ritzer, G. (1996) The McDonaldization of Society. London: Pine Forge Press .
73.
Ritzer, G. (1998) The McDonaldization Thesis. London: Sage .
74.
Rubin, P. H. (1978) `The Theory of the Firm and the Structure of the Franchise Contract' , Journal of Law and Economics21(1): 223-233 .
75.
Ryans, J. K., Lotz, S. L. and Maskulka, T. (1997) `US-Based Franchiser and European Franchisee Relationships: A Study in Conflict' , Franchising Research: An International Journal2(3): 115-122 .
76.
Shane, S. A. (1996a) `Hybrid Organizational Arrangements and their Implications for Firm Growth and Survival: A Study of New Franchisors' , Academy of Management Journal39(1): 216-234 .
77.
Shane, S. A. (1996b) `Why Franchise Companies Expand Overseas?' , Journal of Business Venturing11(2): 73-88 .
78.
Shane, S. A. (1996c) `Making New Franchise Systems Work', in P. D. Reynoldset al. (eds) Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research, pp. 301-315. Babson Park, MA: Babson College .
79.
Shane, S. A. and Spell, C. (1997) `Agency Costs, Search Costs, Transaction Costs, Managerial Limits to Firm Growth and New Franchisor Survival 1984-1994' , in M. Spriggs (ed.) Winning Strategies for Franchising: Current Research and Future Directions, Proceedings of the Eleventh Conference of the Society of Franchising. Orlando, FL, 1-2 March.
80.
Sharma, A. (1997) `Professional as Agent: Knowledge Asymmetry in Agency Exchange' , Academy of Management Review22(3): 758-798 .
81.
Sibley, S. D. and Michie, D. A. (1982) `An Explanatory Investigation of Cooperation in a Franchise Channel' , Journal of Retailing58(4): 23-45 .
82.
Spinelli, S. and Birley, S. (1996) `Toward a Theory of Conflict in the Franchise System' , Journal of Business Venturing11: 329-342 .
83.
Stanworth, J. (1993) `The Franchise Relationship-Entrepreneurship or Dependence?' , paper presented at Society of Franchising, 7th Annual Conference, San Francisco, CA, 7 February.
84.
Stanworth, J. (1996) `Dispelling the Myths Surrounding Franchise Failure Rates - Some Recent Evidence from Britain' , Franchising Research: An International Journal1(1): 25-28 .
85.
Stanworth, J. (1999) `Customer Service Franchising - a Trend on a Deviant Case' , International Small Business Journal27(3): 74-78 .
86.
Stanworth, J. and Curran, J. (1999) `Colas, Burgers, Shakes, and Shirkers: Towards a Sociological Model of Franchising in the Market Economy' , Journal of Business Venturing14(4): 323-344 .
87.
Stanworth, J., Price, S., Purdy, D., Zafiris, N. and Gandolfo, A. (1996) `Business Format Franchising: Innovation and Creativity or Replication and Conformity' , Franchising Research: An International Journal1(2): 29-39 .
88.
Stanworth, J. and Purdy, D. (2000) `Franchising and Enterprise', in S. Carter and D. Jones-Evans (eds) Enterprise and Small Business: Principles, Practice and Policy, pp. 198-219. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education Ltd (Financial Times Prentice Hall).
89.
Stanworth, J., Purdy, D. and Price, S. (1997) `Franchise Growth and Failure in the USA and the UK: A Troubled Dreamworld Revisited' , Franchising Research: An International Journal2(2): 75-94 .
90.
Terry, A. (2002) `A Comparison Analysis of Franchise Regulation in Asia' , in J. Young (ed.) Franchise Systems at the Turning Point of Maturity, Proceedings of the 16th Conference of the International Society of Franchising. Orlando, FL, 8-10 February.
91.
Tosi, H. L., Katz, J. P. and Gomez-Mejia, L. R. (1997) `Disaggregating the Agency Theory' , Academy of Management Journal40(3): 584-602 .
92.
Tuncalp, S. (1991) `The Problems and Prospects for Franchising in the Arabian Peninsula: The Case of Saudi Arabia' , International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management19(4): 28-37 .
93.
Vincent, W. S. (1998) `Encroachment: Legal Restrictions on Retail Franchise Expansion' , Journal of Business Venturing13(1): 29-41 .
94.
Welch, L. S. (1989) `Diffusion of Franchise System Use in International Operations' , International Marketing Review6(5): 7-19 .
95.
Williams, D. L. (1999) `Why Do Entrepreneurs become Franchisees? An Empirical Analysis of Organizational Choice' , Journal of Business Venturing14(1): 103-124 .
96.
Withane, S. (1991) `Franchising and Franchisee Behavior: An Examination of Opinions, Personal Characteristics and Motives of Canadian Franchisee Entrepreneurs' , Journal of Small Business Management29(1): 22-29 .
97.
Zaheer, A. and Venkataraman, N. (1995) `Relational Governance as an Interorganizational Strategy: An Empirical Test of the Role of Trust in Economic Exchange' , Strategic Management Journal16(5): 373-392 .
