What is Small Business Policy in the UK for? Evaluation and Assessing Small Business Policies

Abstract

PROFESSORJAMES CURRAN IS EMERITUS professor at Kingston University, England, and was formerly director of its Small Business Research Centre. Since 1980 the United Kingdom small business population has increased greatly. Small businesses have also acquired a key role in UK economic policies paralleled by a huge development in support structures to promote them. Despite broad rhetorical claims that policies and support help develop a strong enterprise culture and promote UK economic prosperity, the precise outcomes of these policies have been difficult to pin down. As policies developed over the twenty years, the evaluation of their achievements has also proved difficult because of methodological problems. This paper examines the problems of evaluating small business policies and support and draws out some key implications for their future in the UK It concludes that even allowing for the problems of evaluation, one of the best and clearest supported findings is of poor take-up of the support offered. In other words, although small businesses have become much more important in the UK economy, it is unlikely that this has been due to state intervention. Because of the well-entrenched unanimity on the value of small business support in the UK, little attention has been given to whether the support represents good value for public money. Small and medium-sized businesses now account for well over half of business turnover and jobs in the UK. Not only can there be doubts about whether the policies and support are cost effective but more importantly, the question can be asked whether such policies are needed at all any more.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Audit Commission (1989), Urban Regeneration and Economic Development: The Government Dimension, London, HMSO .

Barclays Bank (1998), Recent Trends in the UK Business Stock, Barclays Bank Economics Department , May.

Beesley, M., and Wilson, P. (1981), 'Government Aid to Small Firms in Britain', in Gorb, P. et al, (eds.), Small Business Perspectives, London, Armstrong Publishing .

Bennett, R.J. (1997), 'SMEs and Public Policy: Present Dilemmas, Future Priorities and the Case of Business Links' , paper presented to the Small Firms Policy and Research Conference, Belfast, November.

Birch, D. L. (1979), TheJob Generation Process, MIT Study on Neighbourhood and Regional Change, Boston, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Boston .

Bryson, J. R., and Daniels, P. W. (1998), 'The Secrets of Industry are in the Air or 'On the Jungle Drums in the Village': Traded and Untraded Knowledge and Expertise Interdependencies Between SMEs' , paper at the SmallFirms Policy and Research Conference, Durham, November.

Commission on Public Policy and British Business (1997), PromotingProsperity A Business Agenda for Britain, Institute for Public Policy Research, London, Vintage Books .

Curran, J. (1986), Bolton Fifteen Years On: A Review and Analysis of Small Business Research in Britain, 1971-1986, London, Small Business Research Trust .

Curran, J. (1991), 'Employment and Employment Relations in the Small Enterprise', in Stanworth, J., and Gray, C. (eds.), Bolton 20 Years On: The Small Firm in the 1990s, London, Paul Chapman .

10.

Curran, J. (1993), 'TECs and Small Firms: Can TECs Reach the Small Firms Other Strategies Have Failed to Reach' . Paper presented to a meeting of the All Party Social Science and Policy Group, House of Commons, April.

11.

Curran, J. (1999), The Role of the Smal Firm in the UKEconomy: Hot Stereotypes and Cool Assessments, Milton Keynes, Small Business Research Trust and the Open University .

12.

Curran, J., Berney, R., and Kuusisto, J. (1999), A Critical Evaluation of Industry SM;E Support Policies in the United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland: Stage One Report An Introduction to SME Support Policies and theirEvaluation, Helsinki, Ministry of Trade and Industry, Finland .

13.

Curran, J., and Blackburn, R. A. (1994), Small Firms and Local Economc Networks, The Death of the Local Economy?, London, Paul Chapman .

14.

Curran, J., Blackburn, R A., Kitching, J., and North, J. (1996), EstablishingSmall Firms' Training Practices, Needs, Difficulties and the Use of Industry Training Organisations, Departnent of Education and Employment Research Study RS17, London, HMSO .

15.

DTI (1983), Summary of Government Measures to Assist Small Firms, Department of Trade and Industry , February.

16.

DTI (1995), Small Firms in Britain Report 1995, London, HMSO .

17.

DTI (1996), Small Firms in Britain Report 1996, London, HMSO .

18.

DTI (1998a), Small Business Action Update, London, DTI , June.

19.

DTI (1998b), Our Competitive Future, Building the Knowledge Driven Economy, London, HMSO , Cm 4176, December.

20.

DTI (1998c), Small and Medium Enterprise (SME) Statistics for the United Kingdom 1997, Sheffield, SME Statistics Unit, Department of Trade and Industry , July.

21.

DTI (1998d), Business Link Stocktake 1998, London , October.

22.

Denzin, N., and Lincoln, Y S. (eds.) (1994), Handbook of Qualitative Research, Thousand Oaks, California, Sage .

23.

Edmonds, T. (1986), Background Paper 184: Small Firms, House of Commons Library, Research Division ,June.

24.

Employment Department (1992), Small Firms in Britain Report 1992, London, HMSO .

25.

Ernst and Young (1996), Evaluation of Business Links, A Report prepared by Ernst and Young for the Department of Trade and Industry , January.

26.

Fitchew, S., and Blackburn, R. A. (1998), Small Firms in Services the 1997 Survey, Kingston upon Thames, UK, Small Business Research Centre, Kingston University , March.

27.

Gavron, R., Cowling, M., Holtham, G., and Westall, A. (1998), The Entrepreneurial Society, London, Institute for Public Policy Research .

28.

Gibb, A. A. (1998), 'Academic Research and the Growth of Ignorance. SME Policy: Mythical Concepts, Myths, Rituals and Confusions' . Plenary paper presented at the National SmallFirms Policy and Research Conference, Durham, November.

29.

Gill, J., and Johnson, P. (1997), Research Methods for Managers, London, Paul Chapman , Second Edition.

30.

Goffee, R., and Scase, R. (1995), Corporate Realities, The Dynamics of Large and Small Organisations, London, Routledge .

31.

Goss, D. (1991), Small Business and Society, London, Routledge .

32.

Harrison, B. (1994), Lean and Mean, the Changing Landscape of Corporate Power in the Age of Corporate Flexibility, New York, Basic Books .

33.

Jarvis R., Kitching, J., Curran, J., and Lightfoot, G. (1996), TheFinancial Management of Small Firms: An Alternative Perspective, London, Chartered Association of Certified Accountants , Research Report 49.

34.

Keasey, K., and Watson, R. (1993), Small Firm Management, Ownership, Finance and Performance, Oxford, Blackwell .

35.

Kelm, M. (1996), Evolutionary and 'New' Institutional Economics: Some Implications for Industrial Policy, Cambridge, ESRC Centre for Business Research, Cambridge University .

36.

Lightfoot, G. (1998), Financial Management and SmallFirm Owner Managers, unpublished PhD thesis, Kingston University.

37.

Low Pay Commission (1998), The National Minimum Wage: First Report of the Low Pay Commission, London, HMSO , June.

38.

Martin, R., and Tyler, P. (1992), 'The Regional Legacy' in Mitchie, J. (ed.), The Economic Legacy 1979-1992, London, Academic Press .

39.

North, J., Blackburn, R. A., and Curran, J. (1998), The Quality Business, Quality Issues and SmallerFirms, London, Routledge .

40.

Oakey, R. (ed.) (1994), New Technology Based Firms in the 1990s, London, Paul Chapman .

41.

Storey, D. J. (1994), Understanding the Small Business Sector, London, Routledge .

42.

Storey, D. J. (1998), Six Steps to Heaven: Evaluating the Impact of Public Policies to Support Small Businesses in Developed Countries, Coventry, Centre for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises, Warwick University , Working Paper No. 59, September.

43.

Storey, D. J., and Westhead, P. (1994), Management Training and Small Firm Performance: A Critical Review, Coventry, Warwick University, Centre for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises , Working Paper No. 18.

44.

York Consulting (1997), Evaluation of Skills Challenge, London, Research Report RR 28, Department of Education and Employment .