Core vocabulary therapy for the treatment of inconsistent phonological disorder: Variations in service delivery

Abstract

Approximately 10% of children with a speech sound disorder present with an inconsistent phonological disorder, characterized by inconsistent production of words across multiple trials. A number of studies have provided evidence of the efficacy of core vocabulary therapy for the remediation of this speech sound disorder with a dosage of two speech-language therapy sessions per week. The present study aimed to investigate if two variations of core vocabulary therapy under real world conditions were effective in improving consistency in the speech of children with inconsistent phonological disorder. Variation A was based on standard administration of core vocabulary therapy (with the addition of a third session per week) and Variation B involved one therapy session per week with a speech-language therapist and an imitation based home program delivered by caregivers. This effectiveness study involved five participants (four males, one female) with inconsistent phonological disorder. The ages of the participants ranged from 39 to 59 months at baseline. One child participated in Variation A and four children participated in Variation B. Changes in consistency of speech between baseline and post-therapy were analysed using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. Consistency of speech improved significantly between and pre- and post-test assessment for four out of five participants treated with either variation A or B. These results suggest that core vocabulary therapy delivered once per week with a speech language therapist and using imitation home practice may be an alternative therapy option for children with inconsistent phonological disorder, with implications for the cost and time required. These findings also challenge our theoretical understanding of the locus of impairment in inconsistent phonological disorder. Given the small number of participants in the study, there is a need for replication of these research findings using a larger number of participants.

Keywords

core vocabulary effectiveness inconsistent phonology service delivery therapy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (2007) Childhood apraxia of speech [technical report]. Available at: https://www.asha.org/policy/TR2007-00278/ (accessed June 2018).

Baker

(2012) Optimal intervention intensity. International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology 14: 401–09.

Caruso

Strand

(1999) Motor speech disorders in children: Definitions, background, and theoretical framework. In: Caruso

Strand

(eds) Clinical management of motor speech disorders in children. New York: Thieme.

Cohen

(1988) Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

Crosbie

Holm

Dodd

(2005) Intervention for children with severe speech disorder: A comparison of two approaches. International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 40: 467–91.

Dodd

(1995) Procedures for classification of subgroups of speech disorder. In: Dodd

(ed.) Differential diagnosis and treatment of children with speech disorder. London: Whurr, pp. 49–64.

Dodd

(2014) Differential diagnosis of pediatric speech sound disorder. Current Developmental Disorders Reports 1: 189–96.

Dodd

McCormack

(1995) A model of speech processing for the differential diagnosis of phonological disorders. In: Dodd

(ed.) Differential diagnosis of children with speech disorders. London: Whurr, pp. 65–89.

Dodd

Leahy

Hambly

(1989) Phonological disorders in children: underlying cognitive deficits. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 7: 55–71.

10.

Dodd

Hua

Crosbie

et al . (2002) Diagnostic evaluation of articulation and phonology. London: Pearson.

11.

Dodd

Holm

Crosbie

McIntosh (2006) A core vocabulary approach for management of inconsistent speech disorder. Advances in Speech Language Pathology 8: 220–30.

12.

Dodd

Holm

Crosbie

et al . (2010) Core Vocabulary intervention for inconsistent speech disorder. In: Williams

McLeod

McCauley

(eds) Interventions for speech sound disorders in children. New York: Brookes, pp. 117–36.

13.

Herman

Ford

Thomas

et al . (2015) Evaluation of core vocabulary therapy for deaf children: Four treatment case studies. Child Language Teaching and Therapy 31: 221–35.

14.

Iuzzini

Forrest

(2010) Evaluation of a combined treatment approach for childhood apraxia of speech. Clinical Linguistics and Phonetics 24: 335–45.

15.

McIntosh

Dodd

(2009) Evaluation of core vocabulary intervention for treatment of inconsistent phonological disorder: Three treatment case studies. Child Language Teaching and Therapy 25: 9–29.

16.

Ozanne

(1995) The search for developmental verbal dyspraxia. In: Dodd

(ed.) Differential diagnosis and treatment of children with speech disorder. London: Whurr, pp. 91–110.

17.

Robey

(2004) A five-phase model for clinical-outcome research. Journal of Communication Disorders 37: 401–411.

18.

Shriberg

(1993) Four new speech and prosody-voice measures for genetics research and other studies in developmental phonological disorders. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research 36: 105–40.

19.

Stackhouse

Wells

(1997) Children’s speech and literacy difficulties: A psycholinguistic framework. London: Whurr.

20.

Terband

Maassen

Guenther

et al . (2014) Auditory-motor interactions in pediatric motor speech disorders: Neurocomputational modeling of disordered development. Journal of Communication Disorders 47: 17–33.

21.

Wiig

Semel

Secord

et al . (2006) CELF Preschool 2: Australian and New Zealand clinical evaluation of language fundamentals, preschool. In: Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals: Preschool. 2nd edition, Australian and New Zealand standardized edition. Sydney: Pearson Clinical and Talent Assessment: PsychCorp.