Argumentative writing is a challenging communication task that calls upon sophisticated cognitive and linguistic abilities. Pre-adolescents (n = 80; mean age = 11;10; range = 10;6—13:5) were asked to write an argumentative essay on the controversial topic of training animals to perform in circuses. Additionally, they were asked to solve a set of verbal reasoning problems. Children whose essays reflected a more flexible attitude toward the controversy (Conditional subgroup) outperformed their peers whose attitude was more rigid (Absolute subgroup) on all key measures: Verbal Analogical Reasoning, Total Number of Reasons, and Mean Length of Utterance in Words. Implications for instruction and intervention with pre-adolescents are discussed.
Altoona List of Medical Analogies (2009) Available online at http://www.altoonafp.org/analogies.htm (January 2010).
2.
Boyd R. ( 1995) Teaching writing with logic. College Teaching43: 53-56.
3.
Cohen J. ( 1988) Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences . 2nd edition. Hillsdale, NJ : Erlbaum.
4.
Crowhurst M. ( 1980a) Syntactic complexity and teachers’ quality ratings of narrations and arguments. Research in the Teaching of English14(3): 223-31.
5.
Crowhurst M. ( 1980b) Syntactic complexity in narration and argument at three grade levels. Canadian Journal of Education5(1): 6-13.
6.
Knudson RE ( 1992) The development of written argumentation: An analysis and comparison of argumentative writing at four grade levels. Child Study Journal22(3): 167-84.
7.
Lorge I. and Thorndike RL ( 1957) Lorge-Thorndike Intelligence Tests. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.
8.
McCann TM ( 1989) Student argumentative writing knowledge and ability at three grade levels. Research in the Teaching of English23(1): 62-76.
9.
Miller JF and Chapman RS ( 2002) Systematic Analysis of Language Transcripts (SALT). Version 7.0 [Computer software]. Madison, WI: Language Analysis Laboratory, Waisman Center, University of Wisconsin .
10.
Montgomery JK and Hayes LL ( 2005) Literacy transition strategies for upper elementary students with language-learning disabilities. Communication Disorders Quarterly26(2): 85-93.
11.
Nippold MA ( 2007) Later language development: School-age children, adolescents, and young adults. 3rd edition. Austin, TX: Pro-Ed.
12.
Nippold MA and Sullivan MP ( 1987) Verbal and perceptual analogical reasoning and proportional metaphor comprehension in young children. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research30: 367-76.
13.
Nippold MA, Ward-Lonergan JM, and Fanning JL ( 2005) Persuasive writing in children, adolescents, and adults: A study of syntactic, semantic, and pragmatic development. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools36: 125-38.
14.
Oregon Department of Education (2009) Available online at http://www.ode.state.or.us (January 2010 ).
15.
Otis AS and Lennon RT ( 1967) Otis-Lennon Mental Ability Test. New York: Harcourt, Brace and World.
16.
Riley J. and Reedy D. ( 2005) Developing young children’s thinking through learning to write argument. Journal of Early Childhood Literacy5(1): 29-51.
17.
Sternberg RJ ( 1977) Intelligence, information processing, and analogical reasoning: The componential analysis of human abilities. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
18.
Sternberg RJ ( 1982) Reasoning, problem solving, and intelligence. In: Sternberg RJ (ed.) Handbook of human intelligence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 225-307.
19.
Sternberg RJ and Downing CJ ( 1982) The development of higher-order reasoning in adolescents . Child Development51: 27-38.
20.
Sternberg RJ and Nigro G. ( 1980) Developmental patterns in the solution of verbal analogies . Child Development51: 27-38.
21.
Sternberg RJ and Rifkin B. ( 1979) The development of analogical reasoning processes . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology27: 195-232.
22.
Taylor VL ( 1971) The art of argument. Metuchen, NJ: Scarecrow Press.
23.
Toulmin SE ( 1958) The uses of argument. London : Cambridge University Press.
24.
Wirefly Cell Phone Resources (2009) Available online at http://www.wirefly.com/resources/etiquette/kids.html (January 2010).
25.
Wong BYL, Butler DL, Ficzere SA, and Kuperis S. ( 1996) Teaching low achievers and students with learning disabilities to plan, write, and revise opinion essays. Journal of Learning Disabilities29: 197-212.
