An examination of the pattern of preschool referrals to speech and language therapy

Abstract

This evaluation was undertaken as part of a UK-wide multidisciplinary audit of services to preschool children with speech and language difficulties. Information was collected via questionnaire from parents, health visitors and general practitioners from six districts in Britain. The results showed a discrepancy between the average age at which parents first noticed speech and language problems in their children (2;3) and the average age at which health visitors referred children to speech and language therapy (3;3). This is interesting in the light of new research on early communication that suggests that it should be possible to screen for communication difficulties as early as 12 months and that many language difficulties will be apparent by 2 years. The study also found that health visitor training by speech and language therapists was provided on an ad hoc basis. The paper recommends that more training should be available and it should support professionals in providing good practice based on current evidence.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Awcock, C. and Hapgood, N. 1998: Early intervention project: evaluation of Wilstaar, Hanen and specialist playgroup . International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders, 33, supplement, 500-505 .

Butler, J. (1989). Child health surveillance in primary care. London: HMSO .

Bowers, R. and Oakenfull, S. 1996: The role of health visitors in speech and language therapy . Health Visitor 69, 319-321 .

Department of Health 1998: A first class service: quality in the new NHS. London: HMSO .

Dixon, J. , Kot, A. and Law, J. 1988: Early language screening in City and Hackney - work in progress . Child: Care, Health and Development 14, 213-229 .

Gale, M. , Holloway, K. and Roulstone, S. 1994: Early identification of communication problems . Health Visitor 67, 348-349 .

Gibbard, D. 1994: Parent-based intervention with pre-school language children . European Journal of Disorders of Communication 29, 131-150 .

Hall, D. 1989: Health for all children. Oxford: Oxford University Press .

Hall, D. 1996. Health for all children, 3rd edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press .

10.

Harkness, A. 1998: Report of a literature search on child health surveillance in relation to speech and language therapy, child health and audit . Paper available from the Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists, 2 White Hart Yard, London SE1 1NX, UK.

11.

Home Office 1998: Supporting families: a consultation document. London: Home Office .

12.

Iancono, T. , Chan, B. and Waring, R. 1998: Efficacy of a parent-implemented early language intervention based on collaborative consultation . International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 33, 281-303 .

13.

Law, J. (1994). Early language screening in City and Hackney: the concurrent validity of a measure designed for use with 21/2 year-olds . Child: Care, Health and Development 20, 295-308 .

14.

Law, J. , Boyle, J. , Harris, F. , Harkness, A. , Nye, C. 1998: Screening for speech and language delay; as systematic review of the literature . Health Technology Assessment 2, No. 9.

15.

Pollard, C. 1992: The health visitor’s perspective. In Law, J. , editor, The early identification of language impairment in children. London: Chapman & Hall .

16.

Rescorla, L. 1989: The language development survey: a screening tool for delayed language in toddlers . Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders 54, 587-599 .

17.

Smith, L. 1998: Predicting communicative competence at 2 and 3 years from pragmatic skills at 10 months . International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 33, 127-148 .

18.

Stokes, S. 1997: Secondary prevention of paediatric language disability: a comparison of parents and nurses as screening agents . European Journal of Disorders of Communication 32, 139-158 .

19.

van der Gaag, A. , Reid, D. , McCartan, P. and McDade, A. 1999a: The development of an audit tool for speech and language therapists and members of the primary healthcare team. Report to the Department of Health.

20.

van der Gaag, A. , McCartan, P. , McDade, A. and Reid., D. 1999b: The early communication audit manual. London: RCSLT .

21.

Ward, S. 1992: The predictive validity and accuracy of a screening test for language delay and auditory perceptual disorder . European Journal of Disorders of Communication 27, 55-72 .

22.

Ward, S. 1999: An investigation into the effectiveness of an early intervention method for delayed language development in young children . International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders, 34, 243-264 .

23.

Werner, P. 1969: Mothers’ reactions to delayed language development in their children . Exceptional Children 36, 277-279 .