Different effects of attachment anxiety and attachment avoidance on depressive symptoms: A meta-analysis

Abstract

Although insecure adult attachment is thought to be associated with depressive symptoms, results of research on the link between attachment dimensions (attachment anxiety and attachment avoidance) and depressive symptoms have been inconsistent. The aim of this study was to use meta-analysis to examine the strength of the correlations between the two attachment dimensions and depressive symptoms. A total of 64 papers and 78 independent samples were included in this meta-analysis. Results showed significant associations between both attachment dimensions and depressive symptoms. Additional analyses indicated that attachment anxiety was more strongly related to depressive symptoms, whereas attachment avoidance was weakly related to depressive symptoms. Cultural orientation and sex were found to moderate the relationship between attachment anxiety and depressive symptoms. Age was a significant moderator of the relationships between both attachment anxiety and avoidance and depressive symptoms. Results of the meta-analysis and the implications were discussed.

Keywords

Attachment anxiety attachment avoidance depressive symptoms meta-analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

*Aarts

Hinnen

Gerdes

V. E. A.

Acherman

Brandjes

D. P. M.

(2014). Psychologists’ evaluation of bariatric surgery candidates influenced by patients’ attachment representations and symptoms of depression and anxiety. Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings, 21(1), 116–123.

Abu-Kaf

Priel

(2008). Dependent and self-critical vulnerabilities to depression in two different cultural contexts. Personality and Individual Differences, 44(3), 689–700.

Ainsworth

M. D. S.

Blehar

M. C.

Waters

Wall

S. N.

(1978). Patterns of attachment: A study of the strange situation (p. 23). Lawrence Erlbaum.

Albert

P. R.

(2015). Why is depression more prevalent in women? Journal of Psychiatry & Neuroscience, 40(4), 219.

Aldao

Nolen-Hoeksema

Schweizer

(2010). Emotion-regulation strategies across psychopathology: A meta-analytic review. Clinical Psychology Review, 30(2), 217–237.

Allen

T. D.

French

K. A.

Dumani

Shockley

K. M.

(2015). Meta-analysis of work–family conflict mean differences: Does national context matter? Journal of Vocational Behavior, 90, 90–100.

Ames

M. E.

Leadbeater

B. J.

(2018). Depressive symptom trajectories and physical health: Persistence of problems from adolescence to young adulthood. Journal of Affective Disorders, 240, 121–129.

Bartholomew

Horowitz

L. M.

(1991). Attachment styles among young adults: A test of a four-category model. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 61(2), 226–244.

Begg

C. B.

Mazumdar

(1994). Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Biometrics, 50, 1088–1101.

10.

*Berlin

L. J.

Whiteside-Mansell

Roggman

L. A.

Green

B. L.

Robinson

Spieker

(2011). Testing maternal depression and attachment style as moderators of early head start’s effects on parenting. Attachment & Human Development, 13(1), 49–67.

11.

*Bernstein

Keltner

Laurent

(2012). Parental divorce and romantic attachment in young adulthood: Important role of problematic beliefs. Marriage & Family Review, 48(8), 711–731.

12.

*Bishop

J. L.

Norona

J. C.

Roberson

P. N.

Welsh

D. P.

McCurry

S. K.

(2018). Adult attachment, role balance, and depressive symptoms in emerging adulthood. Journal of Adult Development, 26(1), 31–40.

13.

Blazer

D. G.

Hybels

C. F.

(2005). Origins of depression in later life. Psychological medicine, 35(9), 1241–1252.

14.

Borenstein

Hedges

L. V.

Higgins

J. P.

Rothstein

H. R.

(2011). Introduction to meta-analysis. John Wiley.

15.

Bowlby

(1973). Attachment and loss: Vol. 2. Separation, anxiety and anger. Basic Books.

16.

Brennan

K. A.

Clark

C. L.

Shaver

P. R.

(1998). Self-report measurement of adult attachment: An integrative overview. In Simpson

J. A.

Rholes

W. S.

(Eds.), Attachment theory and close relationships (pp. 46–76). The Guilford Press.

17.

*Brown

C. C.

(2017). Chronic disease, depression, and adult attachment within romantic relationships: A longitudinal analysis of trajectories of physical health (Doctoral dissertation). Kansas State University.

18.

*Burnette

J. L.

Davis

D. E.

Green

J. D.

Worthington

E. L.

Jr Bradfield

(2009). Insecure attachment and depressive symptoms: The mediating role of rumination, empathy, and forgiveness. Personality and Individual Differences, 46(3), 276–280.

19.

Butler

E. A.

Lee

T. L.

Gross

J. J.

(2009). Does expressing your emotions raise or lower your blood pressure? The answer depends on cultural context. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 40(3), 510–517.

20.

*Cai

(2018). The relationship between insecure attachment and depressive symptoms among college students: The mediating role of self-forgiveness and forgiveness of others (Master’s thesis). China Master’s Theses Full-text Database. Jilin University.

21.

*Caldwell

J. G.

Shaver

P. R.

C. S.

Minzenberg

M. J.

(2011). Childhood maltreatment, adult attachment, and depression as predictors of parental self-efficacy in at-risk mothers. Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment & Trauma, 20(6), 595–616.

22.

Card

N. A.

(2011). Applied meta-analysis for social science research. Guilford Press.

23.

*Chen

Jin

Lou

(2018). Relationship among adult attachment, social support and depression in caregivers of inpatients with gastrointestinal cancer. Chinese Evidence-based Nursing, 4(09), 769–775.

24.

Chentsova-Dutton

E. Y.

Tsai

L. J.

Gotlib

H. I.

(2010). Further evidence for the cultural norm hypothesis: Positive emotion in depressed and control European American and Asian American women. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 16, 284–295.

25.

Chopik

W. J.

Edelstein

R. S.

Fraley

R. C.

(2013). From the cradle to the grave: Age differences in attachment from early adulthood to old age. Journal of Personality, 81(2), 171–183.

26.

*Chow

C. M.

Ruhl

(2014). Friendship and romantic stressors and depression in emerging adulthood: Mediating and moderating roles of attachment representations. Journal of Adult Development, 21(2), 106–115.

27.

Cohen

(1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. Routledge.

28.

Cui

(2013). Inner Mongolia region of the relationship between college students adult attachment and mental health (Master’s thesis). China Master’s Theses full-text Database. Inner Mongolia, China: Inner Mongolia Agricultural University.

29.

*Dodd

Driver

Warren

Riggs

Clark

(2015). Effects of adult romantic attachment and social support on resilience and depression in individuals with spinal cord injuries. Topics in Spinal Cord Injury Rehabilitation, 21(2), 156–165.

30.

Donaldson

Lam

(2004). Rumination, mood and social problem-solving in major depression. Psychological Medicine, 34(7), 1309–1318.

31.

Dozier

Lee

S. W.

(1995). Discrepancies between self-and other-report of psychiatric symptomatology: Effects of dismissing attachment strategies. Development and Psychopathology, 7(1), 217–226.

32.

(2015). The relationship between adult attachment and adaption among freshman: The mediator roles of depression and loneliness (Master’s thesis). China Master’s Theses full-text Database. Henan University.

33.

Duval

Tweedie

(2000). Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics, 56, 455–463.

34.

Egger

Smith

G. D.

Schneider

Minder

(1997). Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. British Medical Journal, 315, 629–634.

35.

Estrada-Martínez

L. M.

Caldwell

C. H.

Bauermeister

J. A.

Zimmerman

M. A.

(2012). Stressors in multiple life-domains and the risk for externalizing and internalizing behaviors among African Americans during emerging adulthood. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 41(12), 1600–1612.

36.

*Feng

(2017). The study on the relationship of adult attachment, social support and mental health among the college students (Master’s thesis). China Master’s Theses full-text Database. Qinghai Normal University.

37.

Flint

Kendler

K. S.

(2014). The genetics of major depression. Neuron, 81(3), 484–503.

38.

Fraley

R. C.

Garner

J. P.

Shaver

P. R.

(2000). Adult attachment and the defensive regulation of attention and memory: Examining the role of preemptive and postemptive defensive processes. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79(5), 816–826.

39.

*Franz

C. E.

York

T. P.

Eaves

L. J.

Prom-wormley

Jacobson

K. C.

Lyons

M. J.

Jimenez

Panizzon

Xian

Grant

M. D.

Kremen

W. S.

(2011). Adult romantic attachment, negative emotionality, and depressive symptoms in middle aged men: A multivariate genetic analysis. Behavior Genetics, 41(4), 488–498.

40.

Freeman

Tyrovolas

Koyanagi

Chatterji

Leonardi

Ayuso-Mateos

J. L.

Rummel-Kluge

Koskinen

Tobiasz-Adamczyk

Haro

J. M.

(2016). The role of socio-economic status in depression: Results from the COURAGE (aging survey in Europe). BMC Public Health, 16(1), 1098.

41.

(2017). Study on the relationship among adult attachment, sense of life meaning and depression of college students (Master’s thesis). China Master’s Theses full-text Database. Harbin Engineering University.

42.

*Gao

Wang

Chen

Zhou

Jin

Zhou

(2016). Study on the relationship between attachment style, relationship satisfaction and depression. Chinese General Medicine, 19(31), 3850–3854.

43.

*Gao

Lin

(2018). Impact of adult attachment and mindfulness on mental health of college students in a university of Huzhou city. Medicine and Society, 31(10), 79–81.

44.

*Garrison

A. M.

(2014). Testing a model of maladaptive perfectionism and depression symptoms: The roles of emotional disclosure, emotion regulation strategies, adult attachment, and shame (Doctoral dissertation). Western Michigan University.

45.

Garrison

A. M.

Kahn

J. H.

Miller

S. A.

Sauer

E. M.

(2014). Emotional avoidance and rumination as mediators of the relation between adult attachment and emotional disclosure. Personality and Individual Differences, 70, 239–245.

46.

*Garrison

A. M.

Kahn

J. H.

Sauer

E. M.

Florczak

M. A.

(2012). Disentangling the effects of depression symptoms and adult attachment on emotional disclosure. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 59(2), 230.

47.

*Gillath

Johnson

D. K.

Selcuk

Teel

(2011). Comparing old and young adults as they cope with life transitions: The links between social network management skills and attachment style to depression. Clinical Gerontologist, 34(3), 251–265.

48.

*Givertz

Safford

(2011). Longitudinal impact of communication patterns on romantic attachment and symptoms of depression. Current Psychology, 30(2), 148.

49.

*Gnilka

P. B.

Ashby

J. S.

Noble

C. M.

(2013). Adaptive and maladaptive perfectionism as mediators of adult attachment styles and depression, hopelessness, and life satisfaction. Journal of Counseling & Development, 91(1), 78–86.

50.

*Gu

Guo

Wang

(2015). Relationship between depression and adult attachment in college students: The mediating role of self-esteem. Chinese Journal of Special Education, 9, 64–70.

51.

Hankin

B. L.

Abramson

L. Y.

(2001). Development of gender differences in depression: An elaborated cognitive vulnerability-transactional stress theory. Psychological Bulletin, 127(6), 773–796.

52.

*Harwood

E. A.

(2008). Attachment, personality, and conflict behaviors in romantic couples: Examining vulnerability to depression (Doctoral dissertation). University of Montana.

53.

Hazan

Shaver

(1987). Romantic love conceptualized as an attachment process. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52(3), 511–524.

54.

Herbster

(2016). Attachment styles and depressive symptoms in college students: Exploring the roles of interpersonal problems and coping (Doctoral dissertation). Marywood University.

55.

Higgins

J. P.

Thompson

S. G.

Deeks

J. J.

Altman

D. G.

(2003). Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ, 327(7414), 557–560.

56.

*Iles

Slade

Spiby

(2011). Posttraumatic stress symptoms and postpartum depression in couples after childbirth: The role of partner support and attachment. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 25(4), 520–530.

57.

Joan

Kaite

Christine

(2017). The gender difference in depression: are elderly women at greater risk for depression than elderly men? Geriatrics, 2(4), 35.

58.

Kessler

R. C.

Birnbaum

H. G.

Shahly

Bromet

Hwang

McLaughlin

K. A.

Sampson

Andrade

L. H.

de Girolamo

Demyttenaere

Haro

J. M.

Karam

A. N.

Kostyuchenko

Kovess

Lara

Levinson

Matschinger

Nakane

Browne

M. O.

… Stein

D. J.

(2010). Age differences in the prevalence and co-morbidity of DSM-IV major depressive episodes: Results from the WHO world mental health survey initiative. Depression and Anxiety, 27(4), 351–364.

59.

Kim

Kashy

D. A.

Evans

T. V.

(2007). Age and attachment style impact stress and depressive symptoms among caregivers: A prospective investigation. Journal of Cancer Survivorship: Research and Practice, 1(1), 35–43.

60.

*Kowal

Wilson

K. G.

McWilliams

L. A.

Péloquin

Duong

(2012). Self-perceived burden in chronic pain: Relevance, prevalence, and predictors. Pain, 153(8), 1735–1741.

61.

Kwon

Yoon

K. L.

Joormann

Kwon

J. H.

(2013). Cultural and gender differences in emotion regulation: Relation to depression. Cognition & Emotion, 27(5), 769–782.

62.

Land

M. L.

(2012). Rumination as a mediator of attachment anxiety and symptoms of depression and anxiety among women (Doctoral dissertation). Pennsylvania State University.

63.

Lazarus

R. S.

Folkman

(1984). Stress, appraisal, and coping. Springer.

64.

Shu

Chen

(2019). Sex differences in romantic attachment among Chinese: A meta-analysis. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 36(9), 2652–2676.

65.

*Li

(2016). Research on the relationship on between adult attachment and regulatory emotional self-efficacy and depression in college students (Master’s thesis). China Master’s Theses full-text Database. Sichuan Normal University.

66.

*Li

Dai

(2008). Adult attachment, social support, and depression level of poststroke patients. Social Behavior and Personality: An International Journal, 36(10), 1341–1351.

67.

Qin

Guo

Wang

Liu

(2008). Adult attachment and mental health in Chinese college students. Chinese Mental Health Journal, 22(9), 631–635.

68.

*Li

Zhao

(2011). Adult attachment and depression level in pregnant women. Journal of International Reproductive Health/Family Planning, 30(6), 440–443.

69.

*Liu

Zhu

Deng

Yang

(2013). A study on mediating effect of perfectionism between attachment and depression. Chinese Journal of Clinical Psychology, 21(4), 658–661.

70.

*Lopez

F. G.

Fons-Scheyd

(2008). Role balance and depression among college students: The moderating influence of adult attachment orientations. Journal of College Counseling, 11(2), 133–146.

71.

Lopez

F. G.

Mauricio

A. M.

Gormley

Simko

Berger

(2014). Adult attachment orientations and college student distress: The mediating role of problem coping styles. Journal of Counseling & Development, 79(4), 459–464.

72.

*Madni

L. A.

(2016). The differences in attachment, depression, suicidality, and body image in alumni of all-girls versus coeducational high schools (Doctoral dissertation). Alliant International University.

73.

Mallinckrodt

Wei

(2005). Attachment, social competencies, social support, and psychological distress. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 52, 358–367.

74.

Mikulincer

Shaver

P. R.

(2003). The attachment behavioral system in adulthood: Activation, psychodynamics, and interpersonal processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 35, 56–152.

75.

Mikulincer

Shaver

P. R.

(2018). Attachment orientations and emotion regulation. Current Opinion in Psychology, 25, 6–10.

76.

*Monti

J. D.

Rudolph

K. D.

(2014). Emotional awareness as a pathway linking adult attachment to subsequent depression. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 61(3), 374.

77.

*Parker

M. L.

Tambling

R. B.

Campbell

(2013). Dyadic adjustment and depressive symptoms: The mediating role of attachment. The Family Journal, 21(1), 28–34.

78.

Pianta

R. C.

Egeland

Adam

E. K.

(1996). Adult attachment classification and self-reported psychiatric symptomatology as assessed by the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory—2. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 64(2), 273–281.

79.

*Qiao

Chen

Zhong

(2018). Parent-child support, defense mechanisms and depression in the elderly: Mediating role of elderly attachment. Chinese Journal of Gerontology, 38(18), 4531–4534.

80.

*Qin

Liu

Wan

(2009). Adult attachment and mental health of policemen. China Journal of Health Psychology, 17(5), 558–560.

81.

*Rholes

W. S.

Simpson

J. A.

Kohn

J. L.

Wilson

C. L.

Martin

III, A. M.

Tran

Kashy

D. A.

(2011). Attachment orientations and depression: A longitudinal study of new parents. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 100(4), 567–586.

82.

*Riggs

S. A.

Kaminski

(2010). Childhood emotional abuse, adult attachment, and depression as predictors of relational adjustment and psychological aggression. Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment & Trauma, 19(1), 75–104.

83.

*Shanmugam

Jowett

Meyer

(2012). Eating psychopathology amongst athletes: Links to current attachment styles. Eating Behaviors, 13(1), 5–12.

84.

Shaver

P. R.

Mikulincer

(2007). Adult attachment strategies and the regulation of emotion. Handbook of Emotion Regulation, 446, 465.

85.

*Shaver

P. R.

Schachner

D. A.

Mikulincer

(2005). Attachment style, excessive reassurance seeking, relationship processes, and depression. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 31(3), 343–359.

86.

*Shin

S. E.

Kim

N. S.

Jang

E. Y.

(2011). Comparison of problematic internet and alcohol use and attachment styles among industrial workers in Korea. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, 14(11), 665–672.

87.

*Simpson

J. A.

Rholes

W. S.

Campbell

Tran

Wilson

C. L.

(2003). Adult attachment, the transition to parenthood, and depressive symptoms. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84(6), 1172.

88.

Sudol

K. Y

. (2006). The relationship of attachment style, sex-role, and depressive symptomatology (Doctoral dissertation). La Salle University.

89.

Sun

Qin

(2016). Adult attachment, social support and mental health of medical college students in internship. China Journal of Health Psychology, 24(1), 80–84.

90.

*Sun

Guo

(2010). The Influence of college students’ attachment, attribution and collectivism on depression. Chinese Journal of School Health, 31(11), 1387–1389.

91.

*Sutin

A. R.

Gillath

(2009). Autobiographical memory phenomenology and content mediate attachment style and psychological distress. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 56(3), 351–364.

92.

*Tang

Zhang

Liu

(2009). Researches into the relationships among adult attachment, social support and depression in college students. Psychological Development and Education, 25(3), 95–100.

93.

*Tasca

G. A.

Szadkowski

Illing

Trinneer

Grenon

Demidenko

Krysanski

Balfour

Krysanski

Bissada

(2009). Adult attachment, depression, and eating disorder symptoms: The mediating role of affect regulation strategies. Personality and Individual Differences, 47(6), 662–667.

94.

Trives

J. J. R.

Bravo

B. N.

Postigo

J. M. L.

Segura

L. R.

Watkins

(2016). Age and gender differences in emotion regulation strategies: Autobiographical memory, rumination, problem solving and distraction. The Spanish Journal of Psychology, 19, 1–9.

95.

*Wang

Liu

(2010). Study on relationship among parental rearing patterns, attachment and depression of college students. China Journal of Health Psychology, 18(9), 1103–1105.

96.

*Wang

(2008). Study on the adult attachment status and the correlation of it with interpersonal relations and the level of mental health of college students (Master’s thesis). China Master’s Theses full-text Database. Liaoning Normal University.

97.

Waters

Merrick

Treboux

Crowell

Albersheim

(2000). Attachment security in infancy and early adulthood: A twenty-year longitudinal study. Child Development, 71(3), 684–689.

98.

*Watsky-Scileppi

(2012). Adult attachment and body dissatisfaction: The role of ethnicity (Doctoral dissertation). University of Miami.

99.

*Williams

N. L.

Riskind

J. H.

(2004). Adult romantic attachment and cognitive vulnerabilities to anxiety and depression: Examining the interpersonal basis of vulnerability models. Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy, 18(1), 7–24.

100.

*Wu

(2012). Romantic partner attachment and depression: The mediating role of social conflict. China Journal of Health Psychology, 20(1), 150–152.

101.

*Yang

Zhou

Tan

Liu

(2009). Mediation of alexithymia between adult attachment and depression. Chinese Journal of Clinical Psychology, 17(2), 161–163.

102.

*You

Huang

J. L.

M. Y.

Leung

Bond

M. H.

(2015). Perceived support and relational conflict as mediators linking attachment orientations with depressive symptoms: A comparison of dating individuals from Hong Kong and the United States. Personality and Individual Differences, 73, 50–55.

103.

*Yuan

Huo

Zhou

(2017). The mediation role of friendship quality between attachment style and mental health among female emerging adults: Love status as a moderator. Chinese Journal of Clinical Psychology, 25(5), 943–948.

104.

*Zakalik

R. A.

Wei

(2006). Adult attachment, perceived discrimination based on sexual orientation, and depression in gay males: Examining the mediation and moderation effects. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 53(3), 302–313.

105.

*Zhu

Chen

(2011). A Study on the relationship between adult attachment and depression in college students. Journal of Xinxiang University (Social Science Edition), 25(1), 30–31.

106.

*Zhu

Wang

C. D. C.

Chong

C. C.

(2016). Adult attachment, perceived social support, cultural orientation, and depressive symptoms: A moderated mediation model. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 63(6), 645–655.

107.

*Zhu

Wang

(2016). Adult attachment and anxiety, depression on pregnant women. China Journal of Health Psychology, 24(2), 199–202.