Combining verbal information and a tactile guidance surface: the most efficient way to guide people with visual impairment in transport stations?

Abstract

This article reports on an experiment conducted in a complex underground station with 33 participants (13 blind and 20 partially sighted) who used an infrared verbal guidance system in combination with a tactile guidance surface system and 32 participants (14 blind and 18 partially sighted) who used an infrared verbal guidance system alone. Performance of the participants was assessed by the time taken to complete the trip and the number of pauses they made. Feedback from the participants was also recorded. The results showed that the use of the two guidance devices together led to a decrease in the time needed to complete the trip and reduced the difficulties of using the verbal guidance system. The participants reported their satisfaction when using the two devices and highlighted the necessity of avoiding cognitive overload in the design of orientation systems.

Keywords

metro station mobility orientation tactile surface verbal guidance visual impairment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bentzen, B.L. , Barlow, J.M. & Tabor, L.S. (2000) Detectable Warnings: Synthesis of US and International Practice. Berlin, MA 01503, USA: Accessible Design for the Blind.

Bentzen, B.L. , Crandall, W.F. & Myers, L. (1999) `Wayfinding System for Transportation Services — Remote Infrared Audible Signage for Transit Stations, Surface Transit, and Intersection', Journal of the Transportation Research Board 1671: 19—26.

Blades, M. , Lippa, Y. , Golledge, R.G. , Jacobson, D. & Kitchin, R.M. (2002) `The Effect of Spatial Tasks on Visually Impaired Peoples' Wayfinding Abilities', Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness 96: 407—19.

Crandall, W.F. , Brabyn, J. , Bentzen, B.L. & Myers, L. (1999) `Remoted Infrared Signage Evaluation for Transit Stations and Intersections', Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development 36(4): 341—55.

Espinoza, M.A. , Ungar, S. , Ochaita, E. , Blades, M. & Spencer, C. (1998) `Comparing Methods for Introducing Blind and Visually Impaired People to Unfamiliar Urban Environments', Journal of Environmental Psychology 18: 277—87.

Gallon, C. , Stephens, R. & Whitney, G. (1995) `The Wayfindings Requirements of Blind or Partially Sighted People in Metropolitan Underground Railways'. Paper presented at the Second TIDE (Technology Initiative for Elderly and Disabled) congress, Paris, April.

Gaunet, F. & Briffault, X. (2005) `Exploring the Functional Specifications of a Localized Wayfinding Verbal Aid for Blind Pedestrians: Simple and Structured Urban Areas ', Human Computer Interaction 20(3): 267—314.

Jones, T. & Jain, J. (2006) `Examining the Experiences of Sight-impaired Travellers: The Next Station Stop?', The British Journal of Visual Impairment 4(3): 141—4.

Koskinen, S. & Virtanen, A. (2004) `Public Transport Real Time Information in Personal Navigation Systems for Special User Groups'. Paper presented at the 11th world congress on ITS, Nagoya, Japan, October.

10.

Loomis, J.M. , Golledge, R.G. , Klatzky, R.L. , Speigle, J.M. & Tietz, J. (1994) `Personal Guidance System for the Visually Impaired '. Paper presented at the First Annual ACH/SIGGAPH. Conference on assistive technologies, Marina Del Ray, CA , USA, October—November.

11.

Loomis, J.M. , Klatzky, R.L. , Golledge, R.G. , Cicinelli, J.G. , Pellegrino, J.W. & Fry, P.A. (1993) `Nonvisual Navigation by Blind and Sighted: Assessment of Path Integration Ability', Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 122(1): 73—91.

12.

Marin-Lamellet, C. , Pachiaudi, G. & Breton-Gadegbeku, B. (2001) `Information and Orientation Needs of Blind and Partially Sighted People in Public Transportation: BIOVAM Project', Journal of the Transportation Research Board 1779: 203—8.

13.

Open (1997) User Trial Report (No. Deliverable D5.1): CEC TIDE Project TP 1182 OPEN.

14.

Schmidt, E. & Manser, J.A. (2000) Directives for the Pedestrian Ways Adapted to the Persons Who Are Disabled. Swiss Center of Building for the Handicapped.

15.

Shingledecker, C.A. & Foulke, E. (1978) `A Human Factors Approach to the Assessment of the Mobility of Blind Pedestrians', Human Factors 20(3): 273—86.

16.

Thinus-Blanc, C. & Gaunet, F. (1997) `Representation of Space in Blind Persons: Vision as Spatial Sense?', Psychological Bulletin 121(1): 20—42.

17.

Virtanen, A. & Koskinen, S. (2004) `Information Server Concept for Special User Groups '. Paper presented at the 11th world congress on ITS, Nagoya, Japan, October.

18.

Whitney, G. (1998) `The Use of Remotely Triggered Talking Sign Systems by Blind and Partially Sighted People'. Paper presented at the 3rd Technology for Inclusive Design and Equality (TIDE) conference , Helsinki, Finland, June.