This article develops the analytics of counter-mapping as counter-archiving in order to account for the continuum of violence that migrants experience during their journeys: building on administrative traces produced by states – such as expulsion orders, refusal of entry, identification papers – and combining these with migrants’ testimonies, it investigates how migrants’ geographies are affected, disrupted and rerouted by heterogenous paper trails. Focusing on migrants’ passages at the French-Italian Alpine border, both in the present and in the past, the article proceeds in three sections. It starts by introducing the analytics of counter-mapping as counter-archiving, and it takes into account migrants’ maps, showing how these rely on sort of counter-archiving processes. The second section draws on archival material and provides a historical insight into migration paper trails at the French-Italian border during the timeframe 1945–1966. The paper moves on dealing with the present context, retracing bio-geographies, drawing on heterogenous administrative traces. The article concludes by pointing to the need of re-articulating a critique of the border regime that centers on the continuum of violence experienced by migrants, which includes the impact of paper trails.
AppaduraiA (2003) Archive and Aspiration. In: Brouwer J, Mulder A and Charlton S (eds) Information is Alive.
Rotterdam: NAi Publishers, pp. 14–25.
2.
AradauCPerretS (2022)
The politics of (non-) knowledge at Europe's borders: Errors, fakes, and subjectivity. Review of International Studies48(3): 405–424.
BachellerieS (2020)
Chasing down foreigners at the French-Italian border (Hautes-alpes) as a matter of social and racial policing. Revue de Géographie Alpine108(2): 1–18. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/rga/7248
5.
BeneduceR (2008)
Undocumented bodies, burned identities: refugees, sans papiers, harraga – When things fall apart. Social Science Information47(4): 505–527.
6.
Bibler CoutinS (2020) Opportunities and double binds: Legal craft in an era of uncertainty. In: HortonSBHeymanJ (eds) Paper Trails. Migrants, Documents and Legal Insecurity.
Durham:
Duke University Press, pp. 130–152.
CanzuttiLTazzioliM (2023)
Digital–nondigital assemblages: Data, paper trails, and migrants’ scattered subjectivities at the border. International Political Sociology17(3): olad014.
9.
Casas-CortésMCSHellerCPezzaniL (2017)
Clashing cartographies, migrating maps: The politics of mobility at the external borders of EU rope. ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies16(1): 1–33.
10.
Casella-ColombeauS (2017)
Policing the internal Schengen borders – Managing the double bind between free movement and migration control. Policing and Society27(5): 480–493.
11.
ChakrabartyD (1988) Conditions of knowledge of working class conditions: Employers, government and the jute workers of Calcutta, 1890–1940. In: RanajitGGayatriCS (eds) Selected Subaltern Studies.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press, pp. 179–232.
12.
CobarrubiasS (2019)
Mapping illegality: The i‐Map and the cartopolitics of “migration management” at a distance. Antipode51(3): 770–794.
13.
Cobarrubias S and Pickles J (2008) Spacing movements: The turn to cartographies and mapping practices in contemporary social movements. In: Warf B and Arias S (eds) The Spatial Turn. Interdisciplinary Perspective. New York: Routledge, pp. 52–74.
14.
CulbertJL (2016) A counter-archival sensibility: Picking up Hannah Arendt's. In: MothaSvan RijswijkH (eds) Law, Memory, Violence: Uncovering the Counter-Archive.
London:
Routledge, pp. 16–32.
15.
DelaneyD (2016)
Legal geography II: Discerning injustice. Progress in Human Geography40(2): 267–274.
16.
De GenovaN (2010)
The queer politics of migration: Reflections on “illegality” and incorrigibility. Studies in Social Justice4(2): 101–126.
17.
El-ShaarawiNRazsaM (2019)
Movements upon movements: Refugee and activist struggles to open the Balkan route to Europe. History and Anthropology30(1): 91–112.
18.
EmersonRG (2023)
Counter-maps of body-territory: Gender-based violence in Mexico. Political Geography106: 102956.
GordonAF (2008) Ghostly Matters: Haunting and the Sociological Imagination.
Minnesota:
U of Minnesota Press.
21.
HameršakMHessSSpeerM, et al. (2020)
The forging of the Balkan route. Contextualizing the border regime in the EU periphery. Movements. Journal for Critical Migration and Border Regime Studies5(1): 9–32.
22.
HanusP (2020)
Along footpaths over snow-covered mountains. Historical perspectives on migration journeys across the France–Italy border (1945–1960). Journal ofRevue de Géographie Alpine108(2): 1–19. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/rga/7121
23.
HessSKasparekB (2021) Historicising the Balkan Route. In: WaltersWHellerCPezzaniL (eds) Viapolitics. Migration, Borders and the Power of Locomotion.
Durham:
Duke University Press, pp.183–210.
24.
HortonS (2020) Introduction. Paper trails. Migrants, bureaucratic inscription, and legal recognition. In: HortonSBHeymanJ (eds) Paper Trails: Migrants, Documents, and Legal Insecurity.
Durham:
Duke University Press, pp. 1–20.
25.
HortonSBHeymanJ (eds) (2020) Paper Trails: Migrants, Documents, and Legal Insecurity.
Durham:
Duke University Press.
26.
HullMS (2012) Government of Paper: The Materiality of Bureaucracy in Urban Pakistan.
California:
Univ of California Press.
27.
IraluE (2021)
Putting Indian country on the map: Indigenous practices of spatial justice. Antipode53(5): 1485–1502.
28.
KhosraviS (2019)
What do we see if we look at the border from the other side?Social Anthropology27(3): 409–424.
29.
KrosC (2015)
Rhodes must fall: Archives and counter-archives. Critical Arts29(suppl 1): 150–165.
30.
MaguireM (2012)
Biopower, racialization and new security technology. Social Identities18(5): 593–607.
31.
MengisteT (2018)
Refugee protections from below: Smuggling in the Eritrea-Ethiopia context. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science676(1): 57–76.
32.
Menjívar C (2006) Liminal legality: Salvadoran and Guatemalan immigrants’ lives in the United States. American Journal of Sociology 111(4): 999–1037.
33.
MezzadraS (2010) The gaze of autonomy: Capitalism, migration and social struggles. In: Squire V(ed.) The Contested Politics of Mobility.
London:
Routledge, pp. 141–162.
34.
MincaCCollinsJ (2021)
The game: Or, ‘the making of migration’ along the Balkan Route. Political Geography91: 102490.
35.
MincaCSanticDUmekD (2018)
Walking the Balkan Route: The archipelago of refugee camps in Serbia. In Katz I, Martín D and Minca C (eds) Camps Revisited: Multifaceted Spatialities of a Modern Political Technology. London/New York: Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 35–59.
36.
MitchellJCoutinSB (2019)
Living documents in transnational spaces of migration between El Salvador and the United States. Law & Social Inquiry44(4): 865–892.
37.
MothaSvan RijswijkH (2016) Introduction: A counter-archival sense. In: MothaSvan RijswijkH (eds) Law, Memory, Violence: Uncovering the Counter-Archive.
London:
Routledge, pp. 1–15.
38.
PelusoNL (1995)
Whose woods are these? Counter‐mapping forest territories in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Antipode27(4): 383–406.
39.
PicklesJ (2012) A History of Spaces: Cartographic Reason, Mapping and the Geo-Coded World.
London:
Routledge.
40.
La DerivaPA (2004)
Adrift through the circuits of feminized precarious work. Feminist Review77(1): 157–161.
41.
RamsayG (2020)
Time and the other in crisis: How anthropology makes its displaced object. Anthropological Theory20(4): 385–413.
42.
ReiterKCoutinSB (2017)
Crossing borders and criminalizing identity: The disintegrated subjects of administrative sanctions. Law & Society Review51(3): 567–601.
43.
RinauroS (2009) Il cammino della speranza: l’emigrazione clandestina degli italiani nel secondo dopoguerra.
Turin:
Einaudi.
44.
RolandiF (2015)
Heading towards the West. Yugoslav asylum seekers in Italy (1955–1968). Acta Histriae23(3): 555–574.
45.
RozakouK (2017)
Nonrecording the ‘European refugee crisis’ in Greece: Navigating through irregular bureaucracy. Focaal77: 36–49.
46.
SaidE (1994) Culture and Imperialism.
London:
Vintage.
47.
SalimeZ (2022)
A gendered counter‐archive: Mining and resistance in Morocco. Development and Change53(5): 1035–1058.
48.
SaltsmanA (2014)
Beyond the law: Power, discretion, and bureaucracy in the management of asylum space in Thailand. Journal of Refugee Studies27(3): 457–476.
49.
Scott JC (2020) Seeing like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition have Failed. New Haven: Yale University Press.
50.
SecorAJEhrkampPLoydJM (2022)
The problem of the future in the spacetime of resettlement: Iraqi refugees in the US. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space40(3): 508–527.
51.
StolerAL (2009) Along the Archival Grain: Epistemic Anxieties and Colonial Common Sense.
Princeton:
Princeton University Press.
52.
TazzioliM (2023) Border Abolitionism: Migrants’ Containment and the Genealogies of Struggles and Rescue.
Manchester:
Manchester University Press.
53.
TazzioliM (2020a)
Towards a history of mountain runaways “migrants” and the genealogies of mountain rescue and struggles. Journal of Revue de Géographie Alpine108(2): 1–18. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/rga/7272
54.
TazzioliM (2020b)
Disjointed knowledges, obfuscated visibility. Border controls at the French-Italian Alpine border. Political Geography79: 102155.
55.
TilleyL (2020)
“The impulse is cartographic”: Counter‐mapping Indonesia’s resource frontiers in the context of coloniality. Antipode52(5): 1434–1454.
56.
TombacciniS (1988) Storia Dei Fuorusciti Italiani in Francia.
Milan:
Mursi Editore.
57.
Van HoutumHBueno LacyR (2020)
The migration map trap. On the invasion arrows in the cartography of migration. Mobilities15(2): 196–219.
58.
WainwrightJBryanJ (2009)
Cartography, territory, property: Postcolonial reflections on indigenous counter-mapping in Nicaragua and Belize. Cultural Geographies16(2): 153–178.
59.
Weizman E and Herscher A (2011) Conversation: Architecture, violence, evidence. Future Anterior: Journal of Historic Preservation, History, Theory, and Criticism 8(1): 111–123.
60.
WoodD (2010) Rethinking the Power of Maps.
New York:
Guilford Press.
61.
YacobiHMisgavC (2019)
The geo-biographies of spatial knowledge: Regional planning from Israel to Sierra Leone and back. GeoJournal84: 1383–1401.
