Going for gold: A prospective assessment of the economic impacts of the Commonwealth Games 2014 on the East End of Glasgow

Abstract

Host cities have increasingly sought to combine the staging of a multi-sports event with the regeneration of run-down areas. Like London 2012, Glasgow has sought to use the Commonwealth Games 2014 as a catalyst for the physical, social and economic renewal of its East End. This paper presents a novel approach to the assessment of legacy for a host community which recognises the complexity of potential impacts, without assuming a trickle-down effect to the local area. This comprises a holistic approach to evaluation, encompassing consideration of plausibility, the specifics of people and place, and legacy programmes. Three requirements for sustained economic legacy impacts for the host community are identified: continued and extended partnership working at a strategic level; extending the scope and duration of legacy programmes beyond that required for the event itself; resolving inherent tensions between delivering legacy at different spatial scales, and ensuring the equitable treatment of disadvantaged areas.

Keywords

Mega-sports events regeneration economic impacts Glasgow 2014

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agha

Fairley Gibson

(2012) Considering legacy as a mega-dimensional construct: The legacy of the Olympic Games. Sport Management Review 15: 125–139.

Ahlfeldt

Kavetsos

(2014) Form or function?: The effect of new sports stadia on property prices in London. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society) 177(1): 169–190.

Andersson

Armbrecht

Lundberg

(2008) Impact of mega-events on the economy. Asian Business and Management 7(2): 163–179.

Andreff

(2012) The winner’s curse: Why is the cost of mega-sporting events so often underestimated? In: Maennig

Zimbalist

(eds) International Handbook on the Economics of Mega Sporting Events, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 37–69.

Anholt

(2007) Competitive Identity: A new model for the brand management of nations, cities and regions. Policy and Practice: A Development Education Review 4(Spring): 3–13.

Audit Scotland (2013) Commonwealth Games 2014 Progress report 2: Planning for the delivery of the XXth Games Impact report and update on progress. Available at: http://www.auditscotland.gov.uk/docs/central/2013/ir_131031_commonwealth_games.pdf (accessed 25 August 2014).

Audit Scotland (2015) Commonwealth Games 2014, Third Report. Available at: http://www.audit-scotland.gov.uk/docs/central/2015/nr_150312_commonwealth_games_third.pdf (accessed 11 June 2015).

Baade

Matheson

(2002) Bidding for the Olympics: Fool’s gold? In: Barros

Ibrahimo

Szymanski

(eds) Transatlantic Sport: The Comparative Economics of North American and European Sports, Massachusetts: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 127–151.

Barnes

Matka

Sullivan

(2003) Evidence, understanding and complexity: Evaluation in non-linear systems. Evaluation 9: 265–284.

10.

BBC SPORT (3 April 2014) “Glasgow 2014: Commonwealth’s hailed best in 84-year history.” Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/commonwealth-games/28631639 (accessed 30 June 2014).

11.

Berman

Brooks

Davidson

(2000) The Sydney Olympic Games announcement and Australia stock market reaction. Applied Economic Letters 7: 781–784.

12.

Blamey

Mackenzie

(2007) Theories of change and realistic evaluation: Peas in a pod or apples and oranges? Evaluation 13(4): 439–455.

13.

Bond

Egan

Kearns

(2013) GoWell: The challenges of evaluating regeneration as a population health intervention. Preventive Medicine 57: 941–947.

14.

Broudehoux

A-M

(2004) The Making and Selling of Post-Mao Beijing 2nd Revised Edition, Planning History and Environment Series, London: Routledge.

15.

Brown

Szymanski

(2012) The employment effects of London 2012: An assessment in mid-2011. In: Maennig

Zimbalist

(eds) International Handbook on the Economics of Mega Sporting Events, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 546–570.

16.

Brückner M and Pappa E (2011) For an olive wreath? Olympic Games and anticipation effects in macroeconomics. School of Economics Working Papers 2011–18. University of Adelaide, School of Economics.

17.

Burbank

Avdranovich

Heying

(2012) Mega events and local politics. In: Maennig

Zimbalist

(eds) International Handbook on the Economics of Mega Sporting Events, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 162–178.

18.

Cashman

(2002) What is ‘Olympic Legacy’? In: Kennett

Puig

(eds) The Legacy of the Olympic Games 1984–2000, Lausanne: IOC, pp. 31–42.

19.

Cashman

(2006) The Bitter-Sweet Awakening, Petersham, NSW: Walla Walla Press.

20.

Centre for Sport Physical Education and Activity Research (2013) London Legacy Supra-Evaluation: Final Report, London: Greater London Authority (GLA).

21.

Chalkley

Essex

(1999) Urban development through hosting international events: A history of the Olympic Games. Planning Perspectives 14(4): 369–394.

22.

Chen

H-T

(2005) Practical Program Evaluation, Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

23.

Chen

H-T

Rossi

(1983) Evaluating with sense – the theory-driven approach. Evaluation Review 7(3): 283–302.

24.

Clyde Gateway URC (2013) Economic Benefits Review: Interim Report, Glasgow: Clyde Gateway URC.

25.

Coates

(2012) Not-so-mega events. In: Maennig

Zimbalist

(eds) International Handbook on the Economics of Mega Sporting Events, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 401–433.

26.

Department for Culture Media and Sport (2013) 2012 Games Meta Evaluation: Report 5 Post-Games Evaluation Summary Report, London: DCMS.

27.

Evans

(2011) London 2012. In: Gold

Gold

(eds) Olympic Cities 1896–2016, 2nd ed. London: Routledge, pp. 359–389.

28.

Giesecke

Madden

(2007) The Sydney Olympics Seven Years On: An Ex-Post Dynamic CGE Assessment – General Paper G168, Melbourne: Monash University, Centre of Policies Studies.

29.

Giesecke

Madden

(2011) Modelling the economic impacts of the Sydney Olympics in retrospect – Game over for the bonanza story? Economic Papers 30(2): 218–232.

30.

Girginov

(2012) Governance of the London 2012 Olympic Games legacy. International Review for the Sociology of Sport Vol 47(5): 543–558.

31.

Glasgow Centre for Population Health (2014) Headline findings: Volunteering for the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games. Note to Glasgow Evaluation Group, June 2014, Glasgow: Glasgow City Council.

32.

Glasgow City Council (2007) People, Place, Passion: Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games Candidate City File, Glasgow: Glasgow City Council.

33.

Glasgow City Council (2008) Changing Places, Changing Lives: East End Local Development Strategy, Glasgow: Glasgow City Council.

34.

GCC (2009) A Games Legacy for Glasgow: Towards 2014. Glasgow: Glasgow City Council.

35.

Glasgow City Council (2014) Glasgow Business Portal Legacy Executive Committee Report, 26/06/2014. Glasgow: Glasgow City Council. Available at: http://www.glasgow.gov.uk/councillorsandcommittees/viewSelectedDocument.asp?c=e%97%9Dj%8Fk∼%8F (accessed 6 July 2015).

36.

Gold

(2009) Future indefinite? London 2012, the spectre of retrenchment and the challenge of Olympic sports legacy. The London Journal 34(2): 179–196.

37.

Gold

(2011) From a to b: The summer Olympics 1896–2008. In: Gold

Gold

(eds) Olympic Cities 1896–2016, 2nd ed. London: Routledge, pp. 17–54.

38.

Grant Thornton, Ecorys, Loughborough University, Oxford Economics, Future Inclusion (2013) Meta-Evaluation of the Impacts and Legacy of the London 2012 Olympic Games and Paralympic Games. Report 5: Post-Games Evaluation –Economic Evidence Base, London: DCMS.

39.

Gratton

Shilbi

Coleman

(2006) The economic impact of major sports events: A review of ten events in the UK. Sociological Review 54: 41–58.

40.

Gray

Mooney

(2011) Glasgow’s new urban frontier: ‘Civilising’ the population of ‘Glasgow East’.”. City 15(1): 4–24.

41.

Hall CM (1992) Hallmark Tourist Events: Impacts, Management and Planning. London: Belhaven.

42.

Hall

(2006) Urban Entrepreneurship, corporate interests and sports mega-events. In: Horne

Manzenreiter

(eds) Sports Mega-Events: Social Scientific Analyses of a Global Phenomenon, Oxford: Blackwell Publishing Ltd, pp. 59–70.

43.

Herstein

Beger

(2013) Hosting the Olympics: A city’s make or break impression. Journal of Business Strategy 34(5): 54–59.

44.

Horne

Manzenreiter

(2006) An introduction to the sociology of sports mega-events. In: Horne

Manzenreiter

(eds) Sports Mega Events: Social Scientific Analyses, Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, pp. 1–24.

45.

IOC (2012) Olympic Legacy, Lausanne, Switzerland: International Olympic Committee.

46.

Kasimati

(2003) Economic aspects and the summer Olympics: A review of related research. International Journal of Tourism Research 5(6): 433–444.

47.

Kazi M (2003) Realist Evaluation in Practice: Health and Social Work. London: Sage.

48.

Kernick

(2006) Wanted–new methodologies for health service research. Is complexity theory the answer? Family Practice 23: 385–390.

49.

Kernick

Mannion

(2005) Developing an evidence base for intermediate care delivered by GPs with a special interest. British Journal of Medical Practice 55(521): 908–910.

50.

Kornblatt T (2006) Setting the bar: Preparing for London’s Olympic legacy. Discussion Paper No. 8. Centreforcities. London: IPPR, pp.1–16.

51.

KPMG (2006) Economic Impact Study of the Melbourne 2006 Commonwealth Games Post-event Analysis, Melbourne: Office of the Commonwealth Games Co-ordination.

52.

Latouche

(2011) Montreal 1976. In: Gold

Gold

(eds) Olympic Cities 1896–2016, 2nd ed. London: Routledge, pp. 247–267.

53.

Leeuw FL (2012) Linking theory-based evaluation and contribution analysis: Three problems and a few solutions. Evaluation 18(3): 348–363.

54.

McCartney

Thomas

Thomson

(2010) The health and socioeconomic impacts of major mega-sport events: Systematic review (1978–2008). British Medical Journal 340: c2369.

55.

McTier

McGregor

(2014) Review of the Clyde Gateway Approach to Linking Opportunity and Need, Glasgow: TERU, University of Glasgow.

56.

Maennig

Zimbalist

(2012a) Introduction: The economics of major sporting events. In: Maennig

Zimbalist

(eds) International Handbook on the Economics of Mega Sporting Events, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 3–8.

57.

Maennig

Zimbalist

(2012b) Future challenges: Maximising the benefits and minimizing the costs. In: Maennig

Zimbalist

(eds) International Handbook on the Economics of Mega Sporting Events, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 571–586.

58.

Marchal

van Belle

van Olmen

(2012) Is realist evaluation keeping its promise? A review of published empirical studies in the field of health systems. Evaluation 18(2): 192–212.

59.

Matheson

(2010) Legacy planning, regeneration and events: The Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games. Local Economy 25(10): 10–23.

60.

Minnaert

(2012) An Olympic legacy for all: The non-infrastructural outcomes of the Olympic Games for socially excluded groups (Atlanta 1996–Beijing 2008). Tourism Management 33(2): 361–370.

61.

Monclús

F-J

(2011) Barcelona 1992. In: Gold

Gold

(eds) Olympic Cities 1896–2016, 2nd ed. London: Routledge, pp. 268–286.

62.

Mules T and Faulkner B (1996) An economic perspective on major events. Tourism Economics 12(2): 107–117.

63.

Newby L (2003) To what extent has the commonwealth games accelerated the physical, social, and economic regeneration of east Manchester? Dissertation. LEDQ.

64.

O’Brien

(2005) Strategic Business Leveraging of a Mega Sport Event: The Sydney 2000 Olympic Games Experience, Gold Coast, Queensland: CRC for Sustainable Tourism.

65.

O’Brien

Gardiner

(2006) Creating sustainable mega event impacts: Networking and relationship development through pre-event training. Sport Management Review 9: 25–47.

66.

OECD (2010) Local Development Benefits from Staging Global Events: Achieving the Local Development Legacy from 2012 – A Peer Review of the Olympic and Paralympic Legacy for East London Proposed by the Department of Communities and Local Government, Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.

67.

Oxford Economics (2012) The Economic Impact of the London 2012 Olympic & Paralympic Games, Oxford: Oxford Economics.

68.

Owen

(2005) Estimating the cost and benefit of hosting Olympic Games: What can Beijing expect from its 2002 Games? The Industrial Geographer 1: 1–18.

69.

Parker

(2004) Strategy and environmental analysis in sport. In: Beech

Chadwick

(eds) Business of Sport Management, Essex: Pearson Education Limited, pp. 213–239.

70.

Paton

Mooney

McKee

(2012) Class, citizenship and regeneration: Glasgow and the commonwealth games 2014. Antipode 44(4): 1470–1489.

71.

Pawson

Tilley

(1997) Realistic Evaluation, London: SAGE.

72.

Preuss

(2004) The Economics of Staging the Olympics: A Comparison of the Games 1972–2008, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

73.

Preuss

(2007) The conceptualisation and measurement of mega sport event legacies. Journal of Sport and Tourism 12(3–4): 207–228.

74.

Raco

Tunney

(2010) Visibilities and invisibilities in urban development: Small business communities and the London Olympics 2012. Urban Studies 47(10): 2069–2091.

75.

Rose

Spiegel

(2011) The Olympic effect. Economic Journal 121: 652–677.

76.

Scottish Government (2012) Scottish Index of Megaple Deprivation. Local Authority Summary SIMD 2012: Glasgow City, Edinburgh: Scottish Government.

77.

Scottish Government (2014) Legacy Programmes Activity Return: Scotland as a Major Events Destination, Mimeo. Edinburgh: Scottish Government.

78.

Scottish Government (2015) An Evaluation of Legacy from the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games: Post-Games Report, Edinburgh: Scottish Government.

79.

SG (2012) An Evaluation of the Commonwealth Games 2014 Legacy for Scotland, Edinburgh: Scottish Government.

80.

Smith

(2009) Theorising the relationship between major sport events and social sustainability. Journal of Sport and Tourism 14(2–3): 109–120.

81.

Smith

(2010) The development of ‘sports-city’ zones and their potential value as tourism resources for urban areas. European Planning Studies 18(3): 385–410.

82.

Smith

(2012) Events and Urban Regeneration: The Strategic Use of Events to Revitalise Cities, London: Routledge.

83.

Smith

Fox

(2007) From ‘event-led’ to ‘event-themed’ regeneration: The 2002 Commonwealth Games legacy programme. Urban Studies 44(5/6): 1125–1143.

84.

Song

(2010) Impacts of Olympics on exports and tourism. Journal of Economic Development 35(4): 93–110.

85.

Spilling

(1996) Mega-event as a strategy for regional development: The case of the 1994 Lillehammer Winter Olympics. Entrepreneurship and Regional Development 8: 321–343.

86.

SQW (2013) Olympic Jobs Evaluation, London: Greater London Authority (GLA).

87.

Stame

(2004) Theory-based evaluation and varieties of complexity. Evaluation 10(1): 58–76.

88.

Sturmburg

Martin

(2009) Complexity and health – yesterday’s traditions, tomorrow’s future. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 15: 543–548.

89.

Swyngedow

Moulaert

Rodriguez

(2002) Neoliberal urbanization in Europe: Large-scale urban development projects and the new urban policy. Antipode 34: 547–582.

90.

UKTI (2013) London 2012: Delivering the Economic Legacy – Progress Report from UK Trade and Investment, London: UK Trade and Investment.

91.

Vanwynsberghe

Surborg

Wyly

(2012) When the games come to town: Neoliberalism, mega-events and social inclusion in the Vancouver winter Olympic games. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37(6): 1468–2427.

92.

Vigor

(2006) Olympics legacy must focus on jobs. Regeneration and Renewal 24: 14.

93.

Weed

(2008) Olympic Tourism, Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann.

94.

Weed

Coren

Fiore

(2009) A Systematic Review of the Evidence Base for Developing a Physical Activity and Health Legacy from the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games, Canterbury: SPEAR, Canterbury Christ Church University.

95.

Weiss

(1997) Theory-based evaluation: Past, present, and future. New Directions for Program Evaluation 76: 41–55.

96.

Weiss

(1995) Nothing as practical as good theory: Exploring theory-based evaluation for comprehensive community-based initiatives for children and families. In: Connell

Kubisch

Schorr

(eds) New Approaches to Evaluating Community Initiatives vol. 1: Concepts, Methods and Contexts, Washington, DC: Aspen Institute, pp. 65–92.

97.

Westerbeek

Lindey

(2012) Building brands through sport events: Theoretical and empirical perspectives. Journal of Brand Strategy 1(2): 193–205.

98.

Wingfield-Hayes R (2014) Tokyo Olympic stadium: Sports cathedral or white elephant? BBC News, Tokyo. Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-29828973 (accessed 30 June 2015).

99.

Zimbalist

(2010) Is it worth it? Finance and Development 47: 1.