Scale as both material and discursive: A view through China’s rescaling of urban planning system for environmental governance

Abstract

This paper elaborates on the interconnectedness of scale and discourse in environmental governance. It accentuates that the emergence and subsequent reconfiguration of a particular scalar structure of environmental governance is the outcome of the discursive contest among various political actors, whose discourses acquire persuasive power through employing scale to frame how the world should be observed. In so arguing this paper distinguishes two moments of scale, as material political–environmental relations being shaped and as device shaping political–environmental relations. The connections of these two moments are illustrated by a case study based in the Pearl River Delta region of China, where scalar-implicated discourses were constructed by various tiers of the state to influence the scaling of the urban planning system, now being an important domain to perform environmental governance. With a scalar-discursive attention, this paper seeks to move towards a more holistic treatment of the obscured operational complexities of politics of scale.

Keywords

Scale material discursive environment China

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agnew

(1997) The dramaturgy of horizons: Geographical scale in the ‘Reconstruction of Italy’ by the new Italian political parties, 1992–1995. Political Geography 16(2): 99–127.

Boyle

(2002) Cleaning up after the Celtic Tiger: Scalar ‘fixes’ in the political ecology of Tiger economies. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 27(2): 172–194.

Brenner

(1998) Between fixity and motion: accumulation, territorial organization and the historical geography of spatial scales. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 16(4): 459–481.

Brenner

(2000) The urban question as a scale question: Reflects on Henri Lefebvre, urban theory and the politics of scale. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 24(2): 361–378.

Brenner

(2001) The limits to scale? methodological reflections on scalar structuration. Progress in Human Geography 25(4): 591–614.

Brenner

(2004) Urban governance and the production of new state spaces in western Europe. Review of International Political Economy 11(3): 591–614.

Brown

Purcell

(2005) There’s nothing inherent about scale: Political ecology, the local trap, and the politics of development in the Brazilian Amazon. Geoforum 36(5): 607–624.

Bulkeley

(2005) Reconfiguring environmental governance: Towards a politics of scales and networks. Political Geography 24(8): 875–902.

Bulkeley

Betsill

(2005) Rethinking sustainable cities: Multilevel governance and the ‘urban’ politics of climate change. Environmental Politics 14(1): 42–63.

10.

Cartier

(2005) City-space: Scale relations and China’s spatial administrative hierarchy. In: Ma

LJC

(eds) Restructuring the Chinese City, Oxon, UK: Routledge, pp. 21–38.

11.

Cartier C (2011) Urban growth, rescaling, and the spatial administrative hierarchy. Provincial China 3(1): 9–33.

12.

Castree

(2008) Neoliberalising nature: The logics of deregulation and reregulation. Environment and Planning A 40(1): 131–152.

13.

Chan

RCK

Yao

(2010) New trends in urban and regional governance in the Pearl River Delta Region. Asian Geographer 27(1–2): 127–143.

14.

Chen

J-C

(2013) Sustainable territories: Rural dispossession, land enclosures and the construction of environmental resources in China. Human Geography 6(1): 102–118.

15.

Chien

(2013) Chinese eco-cities: A perspective of land-speculation-oriented entrepreneurialism. China Information 27(2): 173–196.

16.

Chou B (2006) Guanche Luoshi Kexue Fazhan Guan, Nuli Kaichuang Chengshi Lühua Gongzuo De Xin Jumian. Available at: http://www.mohurd.gov.cn/jsbfld/200611/t20061101_165317.html (accessed 1 July 2015).

17.

Chung

CKL

(2015) Upscaling in progress: The reinvention of urban planning as an apparatus of environmental governance in China. In: Wong

Han

Zhang

(eds) Population Mobility, Urban Planning and Management in China, Cham, Switzerland: Springer, pp. 171–187.

18.

Cohen

Bakker

(2014) The eco-scalar fix: Rescaling environmental governance and the politics of ecological boundaries in Alberta, Canada. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 32(1): 128–146.

19.

Cowell

(2003) Substitution and scalar politics: Negotiating environmental compensation in Cardiff Bay. Geoforum 34(3): 343–358.

20.

Cowell

Owens

(2006) Governing space: Planning reform and the politics of sustainability. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 24(3): 403–421.

21.

Feindt

Oels

(2005) Does discourse matter? Discourse analysis in environmental policy making. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 7(3): 161–173.

22.

Guangdong Provincial Government (GG) (2005) Pearl River Delta Urban Cluster Coordinated Development Plan. Unpublished government document.

23.

Gibbs

Jonas

AEG

(2001) Rescaling and regional governance: The English Regional Development Agencies and the environment. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 19(2): 269–288.

24.

Guangzhou Urban Planning Bureau (GZUPB) (1994) Guangzhou Master Plan (Outline). Unpublished government document.

25.

Hall

Hubbard

(1996) The entrepreneurial city: New urban politics, new urban geographies? Progress in Human Geography 20(2): 153–174.

26.

Herod

Wright

(2002) Introduction: Rhetorics of scale. In: Herod

Wright

(eds) Geographies of Power: Placing Scale, Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishers, pp. 147–153.

27.

Huber

Emel

(2009) Fixed minerals, scalar politics: The weight of scale in conflicts over the ‘1872 Mining Law’ in the United States. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 41(2): 371–388.

28.

Jonas

AEG

(1994) The scale politics of spatiality. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 12(3): 257–264.

29.

Jonas

AEG

While

Gibbs

(2004) State modernization and local strategic selectivity after Local Agenda 21: Evidence from three northern English localities. Policy & Politics 32(2): 151–168.

30.

Jones

(1998) Scale as epistemology. Political Geography 17(1): 25–28.

31.

Kaup

(2008) Negotiating through nature: The resistant materiality and materiality of resistance in Bolivia’s natural gas sector. Geoforum 39(5): 1734–1742.

32.

Keil

Debbané

A-M

(2005) Scaling discourse analysis: Experiences from Hermanus, South Africa and Walvis Bay, Namibia. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 7(3): 257–276.

33.

Kurtz

(2003) Scale frames and counter-scale frames: Constructing the problem of environmental injustice. Political Geography 22(8): 887–916.

34.

Kythreotis

Jonas

AEG

(2012) Scaling sustainable development? How voluntary groups negotiate spaces of sustainability governance in the United Kingdom. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 30(3): 381–399.

35.

Lemos

Agrawal

(2006) Environmental governance. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 31: 297–325.

36.

Li H (1987) Mayor Li Hao’s speech at the founding of Shenzhen Municipal Urban Planning Committee. China City Planning Review 3(1/2): 2–9.

37.

Yuan

Lai

(2001) To develop Guangzhou a city of mountain and water. City Planning Review 25(3): 28–31.

38.

Yeh

AG-O

(2004) Analyzing spatial restructuring of land use patterns in a fast growing region using remote sensing and GIS. Landscape and Urban Planning 69: 335–354.

39.

Miao

Lang

(2011) The local environmental state in China: A study of county-level cities in Suzhou. The China Quarterly 205: 115–132.

40.

Lieberthal

Lampton

(1992) Bureaucracy, Politics, and Decision Making in Post-Mao China, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

41.

Lilja

Vinthagen

(2014) Sovereign power, disciplinary power and biopower: Resisting what power with what resistence? Journal of Political Power 7(1): 107–126.

42.

Lin

GCS

(2001) Metropolitan development in a transitional socialist economy: Spatial restructuring in the Pearl River Delta, China. Urban Studies 38: 383–406.

43.

Lin

GCS

(2009) Scaling-up regional development in globalizing China: Local capital accumulation, land-centred politics, and reproduction of space. Regional Studies 43: 429–447.

44.

MacKinnon

(2011) Reconstructing scale: Towards a new scalar politics. Progress in Human Geography 35(1): 21–36.

45.

May

(2008) Ecological citizenship and a plan for sustainable development: Lessons from Huangbaiyu. City: Analysis of Urban Trends, Culture, Theory, Policy, Action 12(2): 237–244.

46.

McCann

(2003) Framing space and time in the city: Urban policy and the politics of spatial and temporal scale. Journal of Urban Affairs 25(2): 159–178.

47.

(2004) Viewpoint: The role of urban planning in China’s sustainable development. Town Planning Review 75(4): i–v.

48.

(2005) Planning cultures in two Chinese transitional cities: Hong Kong and Shenzhen. In: Sanyal

(ed.) Comparative Planning Cultures, New York, NY: Routledge, pp. 113–143.

49.

(2014) Second metamorphosis? Urban restructuring and planning responses in Guangzhou and Shenzhen in the twenty-first century. In: Altrock

Schoon

(eds) Maturing Megacities: The Pearl River Delta in Progressive Transformation, Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Springer, pp. 29–60.

50.

(1995) The role of the local state in China’s transitional economy. The China Quarterly 144: 1132–1149.

51.

Padt

Arts

(2014) Concepts of scale. In: Padt

Opdam

Polman

(eds) Scale-Sensitive Governance of the Environment, Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 1–16.

52.

Qian

Weingast

(1996) China’s transition to markets: Market-preserving federalism, Chinese style. The Journal of Policy Reform 1(2): 149–185.

53.

Rydin

(2003) Conflict, Consensus, and Rationality in Environmental Planning: An Institutional Discourse Approach, Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

54.

Sayre

(2005) Ecological and geographical scale: Parallels and potential for integration. Progress in Human Geography 29(3): 21–36.

55.

Shenzhen Government (SG) (1997) Shenzhen Master Plan (1996–2010). Unpublished government document.

56.

Shenzhen Economic Daily (2010) Shenzhen hua ding guonei shou tiao shengtai kongzhi xian, Shenzhen Economic Daily, 13 September. Available at: http://www.szass.com/bbs/?id=9016 (accessed 1 September 2014).

57.

Smith

(1992) Geography, different and the politics of scale. In: Doherty

Graham

Malek

(eds) Postmodernism and the Social Sciences, London, UK: Macmillan, pp. 57–79.

58.

Shenzhen Urban Planning Bureau (SUPB) (2005) Interpretation on Shenzhen Ecological Protection Boundary Management Regulation. Available at: http://ft.szpl.gov.cn:8080/b5/www.szpl.gov.cn/main/ghdt/gzdt/2005110102018.shtml (accessed 1 September 2014).

59.

Swyngedouw

(1996) Neither global nor local: ‘Glocalization’ and the politics of scale. In: Cox

(ed.) Spaces of Globalization: Reasserting the Power of the Local, New York, NY: Guilford, pp. 137–166.

60.

Swyngedouw

(2000) Authoritarian governance, power, and the politics of rescaling. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 18(1): 63–76.

61.

Swyngedouw

(2004) Scaled geographies: Nature, place and the politics of scale. In: Sheppard

McMaster

(eds) Scale and Geographic Inquiry, Oxford, UK: Blackwell, pp. 129–153.

62.

While

Jonas

AEG

Gibbs

(2010) From sustainable development to carbon control: Eco-state restructuring and the politics of urban and regional development. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 35(1): 76–93.

63.

Wong

Qian

Zhou

(2008) In search of regional planning in China: The case of Jiangsu and the Yangtze Delta. Town Planning Review 79(2–3): 295–329.

64.

Yeh

AGO

(2007) Urban Development in Post-reform China: State, Market, and Space, Oxon, UK: Routledge.

65.

Wu F (2015) Planning for Growth: Urban and Regional Planning in China. New York, NY: Routledge.

66.

Wu W (2006) Shenzhen shiwei shuji: Shede touru, shede shijian, shede shengyu, 10 March. Available at: http://finance.people.com.cn/BIG5/1037/4184429.html (accessed 14 March 2015).

67.

Xin Kuai Bao (2004) Shenzhen yinggai xiang Guangdong shengji caizheng shangjiao dishui, 13 February. Available at: http://www.southcn.com/news/gdnews/lh/2004lh/yt/200402130299.htm (accessed 14 March 2015).

68.

(2008) Governing city-regions in China: Theoretical issues and perspectives for regional strategic planning. Town Planning Review 79(2–3): 157–186.

69.

Xu J (2015) Environmental discourses in China’s urban planning system: A scaled discourse-analytical perspective. Urban Studies. Epub ahead of print 10 February 2015. DOI: 10.1177/0042098015571054.

70.

Chung

CKL

(2014) ‘Environment’ as an evolving concept in China’s urban planning system. International Development Planning Review 36(4): 391–412.

71.

Yeh

AGO

(2003) Guangzhou. Cities 20(5): 361–374.

72.

Xu J and Yeh A (2009) Decoding urban land governance: State reconstruction in contemporary Chinese cities. Urban Studies 46(3): 559–581.

73.

Xu Z and Yeh A (2014) Spatio-temporal development of foreign direct investment in Guangdong, China from 1980 to 2011. Asian Geographer 31(1): 31–57.

74.

Zhao

(2011) Towards Sustainable Cities in China: Analysis and Assessment of Some Chinese Cities in 2008, New York, NY: Springer.

75.

Zhu

(2006) Two great challenges of China’s urban planning. Urban Planning Forum 6: 27–31.

76.

Zhu

(2004) Local developmental state and order in China’s urban development during transition. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 28(2): 424–447.