EU peacebuilding’s new khaki: Exceptionalist militarism in the trading of good governed for military-capable states

Abstract

This article explores how European Union (EU) peacebuilding is being reconfigured. Whereas the EU was once a bulwark of liberal peacebuilding, promoting a rule of law–based international order, it is now downplaying the goal of good governance and placing military capacity as central for international peace and security. Several works have analysed these changes but have not theorised militarism, despite war-waging and war-preparation have marked EU peacebuilding’s direction. The article argues that EU peacebuilding continues to expose elements of liberal militarism since its origins but is now changing from what Mabee and Vucetic call a nation-statist to an exceptionalist militarism. This shift implies that peace has ceased to be served by the intervention of sovereignty with a discourse based on the link between order, good governance, and human rights and is now premised on the upholding of sovereignty, even if that means the suspension of rights. The research draws on thematic analysis of EU documents and interviews undertaken with EU and G5 Sahel officials and managers of EU-funded peacebuilding programmes. It also briefly analyses the case of the Sahel as an example of how the build-up of states’ military capacity is strengthening states’ capacity to override human rights and repressing dissent.

Keywords

European Union liberal peace militarism peacebuilding

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrahamsen

(2019) Defensive development, combative contradictions: Towards an international political sociology of global militarism in Africa. Conflict, Security & Development 19(6): 543–562.

Akkerman

(2018) Militarization of European border security. In: Karampekios

Oikonomou

Carayannis

(eds) The Emergence of EU Defense Research Policy (Innovation, Technology, and Knowledge Management). New York: Springer, pp.337–355.

Barbé

Kienzle

(2007) Security provider or security consumer? The European union and conflict management. European Foreign Affairs Review 12(4): 517–536.

Bargués

(2020) Peacebuilding without peace? On how pragmatism complicates the practice of international intervention. Review of International Studies 46(2): 237–255.

Basham

(2018) Liberal militarism as insecurity, desire and ambivalence: Gender, race and the everyday geopolitics of war. Security Dialogue 49(1–2): 32–43.

Campbell

Chandler

Sabaratnam

(2011) Introduction: The politics of liberal peace. In: Campbell

Chandler

Sabaratnam

(eds) A Liberal Peace? The Problems and Practices of State Building. London: Zed Books, pp.1–9.

Chandler

(2017) Peacebuilding: The Twenty Years’ Crisis, 1997-2017. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Committee on Foreign Affairs (2017) Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European parliament and of the council amending regulation establishing an instrument contributing to stability and peace. A8-0261/2017, 17 July. Brussels: EU Parliament.

Davitti

Ursu

A-E

(2018) Why Securitising the Sahel Will Not Stop Migration. Human Rights Law Centre, University of Nottingham.

10.

De Coning

(2017) Peace enforcement in Africa: Doctrinal distinctions between the African Union and United Nations. Contemporary Security Policy 38(1): 145–160.

11.

Duffield

(2001) Global Governance and the New Wars: The Merging of Development and Security. London: Zed Books.

12.

Edmunds

Juncos

(2020) Constructing the capable state: Contested discourses and practices in EU capacity building. Cooperation and Conflict 55(1): 3–21.

13.

EEAS (2011) Strategy for security and development in the Sahel. Available at: http://www.eeas.europa.eu/archives/docs/africa/docs/sahel_strategy_en.pdf (accessed 29 February 2020).

14.

EEAS (2016) Shaping of a common security and defence policy. Available at: https://eeas.europa.eu/topics/common-security-and-defence-policy-csdp/5388/shaping-common-security-and-defence-policy_en (accessed 8 March 2020).

15.

Ejdus

(2018) Local ownership as international governmentality: Evidence from the EU mission in the Horn of Africa. Contemporary Security Policy 39(1): 28–50.

16.

Ejdus

Juncos

(2018) Reclaiming the local in EU peacebuilding: Effectiveness, ownership, and resistance. Contemporary Security Policy 39(1): 4–27.

17.

EPRS (2017) Briefing – The EU’s New Approach to Funding Peace and Security. Brussels: EPRS.

18.

EU (2019) Annual Report CSDP Missions and Operations. Luxemburg: EEAS.

19.

EU Commission (2015) Joint Communication to the European Parliament and the Council. Capacity building in support of security and development - Enabling partners to prevent and manage crises. JOIN(2015) 17 final, 28 April.

20.

EU Commission (2016) Shared Vision, Common Action: A Stronger Europe – A Global Strategy for the European Union’s Foreign and Security Policy. Brussels: EU Commission.

21.

EU Commission (2018) Action document for ‘Support to the G5 Sahel Joint Force’. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/transparency/regdoc/rep/3/2018/EN/C-2018-6822-F1-EN-ANNEX-2-PART-1.PDF (accessed 15 February 2019).

22.

EU Parliament (2006) The European Security and Defence Policy: From the Helsinki Headline Goal to the EU Battlegroups, Directorate B. September, 12. DGExPo/B/PolDep/Note/2006_ 146.

23.

EU Parliament (2014) Regulation (EU) No 230/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 March 2014 establishing an instrument contributing to stability and peace.

24.

EU Parliament (2019) EU-Turkey statement and action plan. Available at: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train (accessed 10 March 2020).

25.

Fisher

Anderson

(2015) Authoritarianism and the securitization of development in Africa. International Affairs 91(1): 131–151.

26.

Frowd

Sandor

(2018) Militarism and its limits: Sociological insights on security assemblages in the Sahel. Security Dialogue 49(1–2): 70–82.

27.

Gelot

Hansen

(2019) They are from within us: CVE brokerage in South-central Somalia. Conflict, Security & Development 19(6): 563–582.

28.

Guterres USGA (2019) Conflict-related sexual violence. S/2019/280, 29 March. New York: United Nations.

29.

Human Rights Watch (2018) ‘By Day We Fear the Army, By Night the Jihadists’: Abuses by Armed Islamists and Security Forces in Burkina Faso, 21 May. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/report/2018/05/21/day-we-fear-army-night-jihadists/abuses-armed-islamists-and-security-forces (accessed 20 May 2020).

30.

Human Rights Watch (2019) World report 2019: Rights trends in Mali. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2019/country-chapters/mali (accessed 11 March 2020).

31.

ICC (2019) Situation en Republique du Mali. ICC-01/12-01/18, 11 May. The Hague: ICC. Available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/mali (accessed 11 March 2020).

32.

Ikenberry

(2018) The end of liberal international order? International Affairs 94(1): 7–23.

33.

Iñiguez de Heredia

(2020a) Military capacity building as EU’s new security and development strategy: The new rules for peace promotion? In: Johansson-Nogués

Vlaskamp

Barbé

(eds) European Union Contested: Foreign Policy in a New Global Context. Cham: Springer, pp.173–190.

34.

Iñiguez de Heredia

(2020b) Dataset collection on CSDP missions and IcSP projects. Available at: https://zenodo.org/deposit/3939068 (accessed 10 July 2020).

35.

Iñiguez de Heredia

Ndiaye

(2019) Empoderamiento de las mujeres en zonas de conflicto: enfoque en el Sahel. Opex: Fundación Alternativas.

36.

IPI (2019) Strengthening the human rights compliance framework for the G5 Sahel joint force. International Peace Institute. Available at: https://www.ipinst.org/2019/05/human-rights-compliance-framework-g5-sahel-joint-force (accessed 11 March 2020).

37.

Johansson-Nogués

Vlaskamp

Barbé

(eds) (2020) European Union Contested: Foreign Policy in a New Global Context. Cham: Springer.

38.

Joseph

Juncos

(2020) A promise not fulfilled: The (non) implementation of the resilience turn in EU peacebuilding. Contemporary Security Policy 41(2): 287–310.

39.

Juncos

(2017) Resilience as the new EU foreign policy paradigm: A pragmatist turn? European Security 26(1): 1–18.

40.

Karlsrud

(2015) The UN at war: Examining the consequences of peace-enforcement mandates for the UN peacekeeping operations in the CAR, the DRC and Mali. Third World Quarterly 36(1): 40–54.

41.

Kolek

(2018) EU multi-annual financial framework in the perspective of 2021-2027: Assumptions and area of changes. International Journal of Contemporary Management 17(4): 253–263.

42.

Kronsell

(2012) Gender, Sex, and the Postnational Defense: Militarism and Peacekeeping. Oxford: OUP.

43.

Mabee

(2016) From ‘liberal war’ to ‘liberal militarism’: United States security policy as the promotion of military modernity. Critical Military Studies 2(3): 242–261.

44.

Mabee

Vucetic

(2018) Varieties of militarism: Towards a typology. Security Dialogue 49(1–2): 96–108.

45.

Mac Ginty

Richmond

(2013) The local turn in peace building: A critical agenda for peace. Third World Quarterly 34(5): 763–783.

46.

Mann

(1993) The Sources of Social Power: The Rise of Classes and Nation-States, 1760–1914, vol. II. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

47.

Mann

(1996) Authoritarian and liberal militarism: A contribution from comparative and historical sociology. In: Smith

Booth

Zalewski

(eds) International Theory: Positivism and Beyond. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.221–239.

48.

Manners

(2006) Normative power Europe reconsidered: Beyond the crossroads. Journal of European Public Policy 13(2): 182–199.

49.

Moe

(2018) Counter-insurgency in the Somali territories: The ‘grey zone’ between peace and pacification. International Affairs 94(2): 319–341.

50.

Müller

Zahda

(2018) Local perceptions of the EU’s role in peacebuilding: The case of security sector reform in Palestine. Contemporary Security Policy 39(1): 119–141.

51.

Natorski

(2011) The European Union Peacebuilding Approach: Governance and Practices of the Instrument for Stability. Frankfurt: PRIF.

52.

Nozawa

Lefas

(2018) When the Dust Settles: Judicial Responses to Terrorism in the Sahel. Washington, DC: Global Centre on Cooperative Security.

53.

Palm

Crum

(2019) Military operations and the EU’s identity as an international security actor. European Security 28(4): 513–534.

54.

Parry

Sapala

(2018) 2021-2027 Multiannual financial framework and new own resources: analysis of the commission’s proposal. EPRS PE 625.148. Brussels: EU Parliament.

55.

Reuters (2019) Burkina Faso extends state of emergency in north by six months after attack, 12 January. Available at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-burkina-security/burkina-faso-extends-state-of-emergency-in-north-by-six-months-after-attack-idUSKCN1P526H (accessed 22 March 2020).

56.

Richmond

Björkdahl

Kappler

(2011) The emerging EU peacebuilding framework: Confirming or transcending liberal peacebuilding? Cambridge Review of International Affairs 24(3): 449–469.

57.

Rieker

(2006) From common defence to comprehensive security: Towards the Europeanisation of French defence and security policy? Security Dialogue 37(4): 509–525.

58.

Sabaratnam

(2011) The liberal peace? An intellectual history of international conflict management, 1990-2010. In: Campbell

Chandler

Sabaratnam

(eds) A Liberal Peace? The Problems and Practices of Statebuilding. London: Zed Books, pp.13–30.

59.

Shaw

(2013) Twenty-first century militarism: A historical-sociological framework. In: Starvrianakis

Selby

(eds) Militarism and International Relations, Electronic edn. Abingdon: Routledge.

60.

SIPRI (2018) Military Expenditure by Country 1988-2018. Stockholm: SIPRI.

61.

Sjoberg

Via

(2010) Gender, War, and Militarism : Feminist Perspectives (Praeger Security International). Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.

62.

Sloan

(2011) The Militarisation of Peacekeeping in the Twenty-First Century. London: Bloomsbury.

63.

Solana

(2003) A Secure Europe in a Better World. Brussels: EEAS.

64.

Speier

(1936) Militarism in the eighteen century. Social Research 3(3): 304–336.

65.

Stamnes

(2016) The European union and peacebuilding. Policy Brief Series, 3 March. Oslo: NUPI.

66.

Stavrianakis

(2018) Controlling weapons circulation in a postcolonial militarised world. Review of International Studies 45(1): 1–20.

67.

Stavrianakis

Selby

(2013) Militarism and international relations in the twenty-first century. In: Stavrianakis

Selby

(eds) Militarism and International Relations, Electronic edn. Abingdon: Routledge.

68.

Venturi

(2017) The EU and the Sahel: A laboratory of experimentation for the security–migration–development nexus. IAI Working Paper 17/17, December.

69.

Verweijen

(2015) The ambiguity of militarization: The complex interaction between the Congolese armed forces and civilians in the Kivu Provinces, Eastern DR Congo. PhD Dissertation, Faculty of Humanities, Utrecht University.

70.

Wagner

Anholt

(2016) Resilience as the EU Global strategy’s new leitmotif: Pragmatic, problematic or promising? Contemporary Security Policy 37(3): 414–430.

71.

Zyck

Muggah

(2013) Conflicts colliding in Mali and the Sahel. Stability: International Journal of Security & Development 2(2): 1–6.