This article proceeds from the assumption that the transition to socialism must take account of individuals as they are, not as they might be. The emphasis on the individual appears to be inconsistent with the marxian basis of socialist thought. Attempts to resolve this inconsistency have led marxists to concentrate on cultural and psychological explanations of people within capitalist society. We criticise these attempts, and argue for a view of the individual in society which recognises personal autonomy yet acknowledges the role of structural forces in social change. Given this model, we then ask if there is any indication of individual changes within contemporary capitalism which promote the transition to socialism. In contrast to the pessimistic interpretations which dominate the literature, we argue that the present psychological and cultural states of individuals within capitalism can engender socialist change.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adorno T (1967/8), Sociology and Psychology, New Left Review, 46-47
2.
Althusser L (1977), For Marx, London: New Left Books
3.
Arendt H (1968), The Origins of Totalitarianism, New York: Harcourt Brace
4.
Aronowitz S (1982), Towards a Critique of Political Economy, in Giddens A and Held D, Class, Power and Conflict, London: MacMillan
5.
Bahro R (1982), Socialism and Survival, London: Heretic
6.
Balbus I (1982), Marxism and Domination, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
7.
Barrett M (1980), Women's Oppression Today, London: NLB/Verso
8.
Beiner R (1983), Political Judgment, London: Methuen
9.
Bell D (1976), The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism, New York: Basic Books
10.
Berki R (1975), Socialism, London: Dent
11.
Bleicher J & Featherstone M (1982), Historical Materialism Today: An Interview with Anthony Giddens, Theory, Culture and Society, 1, 2, pp 63-77
12.
Clecak P (1982), America's Quest for the Ideal Self, Times Higher Educational Supplement, 14th May, pp 12-13
13.
Connolly W E (1981), Appearance and Reality in Politics, Cambridge: CUP
Habermas J (1979), Communication and the Evolution of Society, London: Heinemann
34.
Habermas J (1981), New Social Movements, Telos, 49, Fall, pp 33-37
35.
Hall S (1984), The State-Socialism's Old Caretaker, Marxism Today, 28, 11, pp 24-31
36.
Held D (1980), Introduction to Critical Theory, London: Hutchinson
37.
Hirsch F (1978), The Social Limits to Growth, London: RKP
38.
Hobsbawm Ret al (1981), The Forward March of Labour Halted?London: NLB/Verso
39.
Honneth Aet al (1981), The Dialectics of Rationalisation: An Interview with Jurgen Habermas, Telos, 49, Fall, pp 5-32
40.
Kellner D (1983), Critical Theory, Commodities and the Consumer Society, Theory, Culture and Society, 1, 3, pp 66-84
41.
Kitching G (1984), Rethinking Socialism, London: Methuen
42.
Lane R E (1978), Waiting for Lefty: The Capitalist Genesis of Socialist Man, Theory and Society, 4, 1
43.
Lasch C (1979), The Culture of Narcissism, New York: Norton
44.
Leiss W (1983), The Icons of the Marketplace, Theory, Culture and Society, 1, 3, pp 10-21
45.
Lukes S (1977), Socialism and Equality in Kolakowski L and Hampshire S (eds), The Socialist Idea, London: Quartet
46.
MacIntyre A (1970), Marcuse, London: Fontana
47.
MacIntyre A (1982), After Virtue, London: Duckworth
48.
Marcuse H (1966), Eros and Civilisation, Boston: Beacon Press
49.
Marcuse H (1968), One-Dimensional Man, London: Sphere
50.
Marcuse H (1969), An Essay on Liberation, Harmondsworth: Penguin
51.
Marcuse H (1972), Counterrevolution and Revolt, Boston: Beacon Press
52.
Marcuse H (1978/9), Theory and Practice: A Discussion with Herbert Marcuse, Jurgen Habermas, Heinz Lubasz and Telman Spengler, Telos, 38, pp 124-153
53.
Markovic M (1974), The Contemporary Marx, Nottingham: Spokesman
54.
Marx K (1888), The Communist Manifesto, ed A J P Taylor (1967), London: Penguin
55.
Marx K (1845), The German Ideology, ed C J Arthur (1970), London: Lawrence and Wishart
56.
Marx K (1865), Wages, Price and Profit, London: Lawrence and Wishart
57.
Marx K (1869), The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte in Surveys from Exile (1973) London: Penguin
58.
Marx K (1891), Critique of the Gotha Programme, London: Lawrence and Wishart
59.
Marx K (1894), Capital, Vol III, London: Lawrence and Wishart
60.
Mullan R (1984), The Mating Trade, London: RKP
61.
Norman R (1982), Does Equality destroy Liberty, in Graham, K (ed) Contemporary Political Philosophy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
62.
Piaget J and Inhelder B (1969), The Psychology of the Child, New York: Basic Books
63.
Plant R (1984), Equality, Markets and the State, London: Fabian Society
64.
Rowbotham Set al (1979), Beyond the Fragments, London: Macmillan
65.
Sandel M (1982), Liberation and the Limits of Justice, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
66.
Savage J (1979), Androgyny: Confused Chromosomes and Camp Followers, The Face, 38, June, pp 20-23
67.
Schwartz B and Mercer C (1981), Popular Politics and Marxist Theory in Britain in Bridges G and Brunt R (eds) Silver Linings, London: Lawrence and Wishart
68.
Sennett R (1977), The Fall of Public Man, Cambridge: CUP
69.
Seve L (1975), Marxism and the Theory of Human Personality, London: Lawrence and Wishart
70.
Taylor M (1982), Community, Anarchy, and Liberty, Cambridge: CUP
71.
Thompson E P (1967), The Making of the English Working Class, London: Penguin
72.
Thompson E P (1979), The Poverty of Theory, London: Merlin
73.
Williams R (1983), Marx: The First Hundred Years, London: Fontana
74.
Wilson E (1983), All the Rage, New Socialist, 14, Nov/Dec, pp 22-26
75.
Wolfe T (1977), Mauve Gloves and Madmen, Clutter and Vine, London: Corgi
