Philosophy against and in Praise of Violence: Kant,Thoreau and the Revolutionary Spectator

Abstract

In this article, the author argues that the works of Immanuel Kant and Henry David Thoreau can help reframe current political discussions about violence and nonviolence within revolutionary movements. For both of them, the means and ends of political change must coincide. Since they seek a nonviolent state of affairs, each argues against violent political change. However, they are also concerned to articulate a relationship between armed and unarmed struggle. After all, Kant and Thoreau worked to find what was positive in violent acts: the French Revolution and John Brown’s raid on Harpers Ferry, respectively. They suggest that one of the ethical acts of revolutionary nonviolence is the sympathetic spectatorship of comrades in struggle who have chosen violent means. This opens up a theory of revolutionary nonviolence as a dual injunction to remain resolutely opposed to violence, but also to be capable of finding within violent acts a deeper desire for the end of violence.

Keywords

Kant nonviolence peace political philosophy revolutionary movement Thoreau violence

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

al-Gharbi M (2015) There is no social change without coercion: Race, Baltimore, and how violence makes nonviolence possible. Salon. Available at: http://www.salon.com/2015/05/02/there_is_no_social_change_without_coercion_race_baltimore_and_how_violence_makes_nonviolence_possible/ (accessed July 2015).

Arendt

(1972) Crises of the Republic, New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.

Arendt

(1992) Lectures on Kant’s Political Philosophy, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Beck JK (2009) Creating the John Brown Legend: Emerson, Thoreau, Douglass, Child and Higginson in Defense of the Raid on Harpers Ferry. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland.

Beck

(1971) Kant and the right of revolution. Journal of the History of Ideas 32(3): 411–422.

Butler

(2009) Frames of War, New York: Verso.

Calhoun

(2012) The Roots of Radicalism: Tradition, the Public Sphere, and Early Nineteenth-Century Social Movements, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Cavell

(1990) Conditions Handsome and Unhandsome, Chicago: Open Court Press.

Cavell

(1992) The Senses of Walden, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

10.

Chenoweth

Stephan

(2012) Why Civil Resistance Works: The Strategic Logic of Nonviolent Conflict, New York: Columbia University Press.

11.

Churchill W (1998) Pacifism as Pathology: Reflections on the Role of Armed Struggle in North America. Winnipeg, Manitoba: Arbeiter Ring.

12.

Clastres

(1987) Society against the State: Essays in Political Anthropology, Cambridge: Zone Books.

13.

Coates T-N (2014) Barack Obama, Ferguson, and the evidence of things unsaid. The Atlantic. Available at: http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/11/barack-obama-ferguson-and-the-evidence-of-things-unsaid/383212/ (accessed November 2014).

14.

Cobb

Jr (2014) This Nonviolent Stuff’ll Get You Killed: How Guns Made the Civil Rights Movement Possible, New York: Basic Books.

15.

Cooney

(1995) Neither resistance nor violence: Thoreau’s consistent response to social evils. The Concord Saunterer 3: 134–139.

16.

Dalton

(1993) Mahatma Gandhi: Nonviolent Power in Action, New York: Columbia University Press.

17.

Du Bois

WEB

(2014) Dusk of Dawn: An Essay Toward an Autobiography of a Race Concept, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

18.

Emerson

(1904) War. In: Emerson

(ed.) The Complete Works of Ralph Waldo Emerson Vol. 11, Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin, pp. 150–176.

19.

Fanon

(1968) The Wretched of the Earth, New York: Grove Press.

20.

Fanon

(2008) Black Skin, White Masks, New York: Grove Press.

21.

Foucault

(2011) The Government of Self and Others: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1982–1983, New York: Picador.

22.

Gandhi

(1969) Ahimsa or the way of non-violence. In: Kripalani

(ed.) All Men Are Brothers: Life and Thoughts of Mahatma Gandhi as Told in His Own Words, Paris: UNESCO.

23.

Gandhi

(2008a) Non-violence and truth. In: Brown

(ed.) Mahatma Gandhi: The Essential Writings, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

24.

Gandhi M (2008b) Non-violence and individual transformation. In: Brown J (ed.) Mahatma Gandhi: The Essential Writings. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

25.

Gelderloos

(2007) How Nonviolence Protects the State, Boston, MA: South End Press.

26.

Goodman A, Sekou O and Cobb J (2014) Riot as the language of the unheard: Ferguson protests set to continue in fight for racial justice [Interview]. Democracy Now. Available at: http://www.democracynow.org/2014/11/25/riot_as_the_language_of_the_unheard (accessed December 2014).

27.

Gordon

(1996) Fanon’s tragic revolutionary violence. In: Gordon

(eds) Fanon: A Critical Reader, Cambridge: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 297–308.

28.

Hallward

Norman

(2015) Understanding Nonviolence: Contours and Contexts, Malden, MA: Polity.

29.

Hill P (2003) Mix My Blood with the Blood of the Unborn. Available at: http://www.armyofgod.com/PHillBookForward.html (accessed December 2015).

30.

Hobsbawm

(1965) Primitive Rebels: Studies in Archaic Forms of Social Movement in the 19th and 20th Centuries, New York: Norton.

31.

Hobson

(2012) The Eurocentric Conception of World Politics: Western International Theory, 1760–2010, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

32.

Kant

(1970) The contest of faculties. In: Reiss

(ed.) Kant: Political Writings, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

33.

Kant

(1996a) On the common saying, that may be correct in theory, but it is of no use in practice. In: Gregor

(ed.) Practical Philosophy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

34.

Kant I (1996b) The metaphysics of morals. In: Gregor M (ed.) Practical Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

35.

Kant I (1996c) Toward perpetual peace. In: Gregor M (ed.) Practical Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

36.

Kant I (1996d) Critique of practical reason. In: Gregor M (ed.) Practical Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

37.

Kant

(1998) Religion within the boundaries of mere reason. In: Wood

(ed.) Religion within the Boundaries of Mere Reason and Other Writings, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

38.

Kant

(2000) Critique of the Power of Judgment, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

39.

Kateb

(1995) Emerson and Self-Reliance, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

40.

King ML (1967) Beyond Vietnam. Available at: http://mlk-kpp01.stanford.edu/index.php/encyclopedia/documentsentry/doc_beyond_vietnam/ (accessed December 2014).

41.

King ML (1968) The other America. Available at: http://www.gphistorical.org/mlk/mlkspeech/index.htm (accessed December 2014).

42.

Korsgaard

(1997) Taking the law into our own hands: Kant on the right to revolution. In: Reath

(eds) Reclaiming the History of Ethics: Essays for John Rawls, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 297–328.

43.

Lakey G (2001) Nonviolent action as the sword that heals. Training for Change. Available at: http://new.trainingforchange.org/nonviolent_action_sword_that_heals (accessed April 2014).

44.

Losurdo

(2015) Non-Violence: A History Beyond the Myth, Lexington, KY: Lexington Books.

45.

May

(2015) Nonviolent Resistance: A Philosophical Introduction, Cambridge: Polity.

46.

Muthu

(2003) Enlightenment against Empire, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

47.

Obama B (2014) Remarks by the President after announcement of the decision by the Grand Jury in Ferguson, Missouri. Available at: http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/11/24/remarks-president-after-announcement-decision-grand-jury-ferguson-missouri (accessed December 2014).

48.

Pape

(2003) The strategic logic of suicide terrorism. American Political Science Review 97(3): 343–361.

49.

Rancière

(2011) The Emancipated Spectator, London: Verso.

50.

Rawls

(1969) The justification of civil disobedience. In: Bedau

(ed.) Civil Disobedience: Theory and Practice, New York: Pegasus Books, pp. 240–255.

51.

Reiss

(1970) Kant: Political Writings, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

52.

Resnikoff N (2014) Think riots have never caused change in America? Think again. Al Jazeera. Available at: http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2014/11/26/american-social-movementshavealwaysincludedriots.html (accessed July 2015).

53.

Scott

(1985) Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

54.

Shabi R (2015) Baltimore and the media tyranny of nonviolence. Al Jazeera. Available at: http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2015/04/baltimore-media-tyranny-violence-150430070102282.html (accessed July 2015).

55.

Sharp

(1973) The Politics of Nonviolent Action, Boston, MA: Sargent.

56.

Smith

(2014) Weird John Brown: Divine Violence and the Limits of Ethics, Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.

57.

Stout

(2004) Democracy and Tradition, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

58.

Stout

(2010) Blessed Are the Organized: Grassroots Democracy in America, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

59.

Sutherland

Meyer

(2000) Guns and Gandhi in Africa: Pan African Insights on Nonviolence, Armed Struggle and Liberation in Africa, Trenton, NJ: Africa World Press.

60.

Thoreau

(1950) A plea for Captain John Brown. In: Atkinson

(eds) Walden and Other Writings, New York: Modern Library.

61.

Thoreau

(1992) Resistance to civil government. In: Rossi

(ed.) Walden and Resistance to Civil Government, New York: Norton.

62.

Tilly

(2004) Social Movements, 1768–2004, Boulder, CO: Paradigm.

63.

Turner

(2005) Performing conscience: Thoreau, political action, and the plea for John Brown. Political Theory 33(4): 448–471.

64.

Weber

(1958) Politics as vocation. In: Mills

(ed.) From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, Oxford: Oxford University Press.