John Rawls’s distinction between a comprehensive liberalism and his political version remains unclear to even his sympathetic critics. They stress his over-reliance on intuitive ideas of a liberal political culture in formulating the original position and its principles of justice. In this article, I argue that Rawls defends his liberal intuitions in a way philosophers might least expect. He conveys the sense of justice that motivates political liberalism through his metaphors. Rawls draws his concept of a well-ordered society – a social union of social unions – from Wilhelm von Humboldt, a seldom-noticed source. Paralleling von Humboldt’s use of musical metaphors, Rawls characterizes liberal democracy as a symphony orchestra. Analyzing this metaphor, I argue, reveals the cultural limitations of Rawls’s overlapping consensus and the political project which undergirds his theory of justice.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adorno, Theodor (1976) The Sociology of Music. New York: Seabury Press .
2.
Bekker, Paul (1936) The Story of the Orchestra. New York: W.W. Norton and Co.
3.
Berkeley, George (1990) Alciphron: or the Minute Philosopher. On Locke, Berkeley, and Hume, CD-ROM. Pittsboro, NC: Intelex Corporation .
4.
Bickford, Susan (1996) The Dissonance of Democracy, Listening, Conflict, and Citizenship. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
5.
Braithwaite, R.B. (1955) A Theory of Games as a Tool for the Moral Philosopher, An Inaugural Lecture Delivered in Cambridge On 2 December 1954. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
6.
Burke, Kenneth (1969) A Grammar of Motives. Berkeley: University of California Press .
7.
Collins, Patricia Hill (1998) Fighting Words, Black Women and the Search for Justice. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press .
8.
Connolly, William E. (1999) Why I Am Not a Secularist. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press .
9.
Dryzek, John S. (2000) Deliberative Democracy and Beyond, Liberals, Critics, Contestations. New York: Oxford University Press .
10.
Dunn, Leslie C. and Nancy A. Jones (1993) Embodied Voices, Representing Female Vocality in Western Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
11.
Flammang, Janet (1997) Women’s Political Voice, How Women Are Transforming the Practice and Study of Politics. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press .
12.
Foucault, Michel (1980) Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972–1977, Colin Gordon (ed.). New York: Pantheon Books .
13.
Gal, Susan (1991) ‘Between Speech and Silence: The Problematics of Research on Language and Gender’, pp. 175–203 in Micaela di Leonardo (ed.) Gender at the Crossroads of Knowledge: Feminist Anthropology in the Postmodern Era. Berkeley: University of California Press .
14.
Gutmann, Amy and Dennis Thompson (1996) Democracy and Disagreement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
15.
Harrell, Jean Gabbert (1992) Profundity: A Universal Value. University Park, PA: Penn State Press .
16.
Hume, David (1990) An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals. On Locke, Berkeley, and Hume, CD-ROM. Pittsboro, NC: Intelex Corporation .
17.
Jones, Bart (1999) ‘Street Kids Discover New Life in Music’, Los Angeles Times 31 October: 8-8.
18.
Kateb, George (2000) ‘Aestheticism and Morality: Their Cooperation and Hostility’ , Political Theory28(1): 5–33 .
19.
Kelly, George Armstrong (1996) ‘Veils: The Poetics of John Rawls’ , Journal of the History of Ideas57: 343–364 .
20.
Klosko, George (1997) ‘Political Constructivism in Rawls’s Political Liberalism’ , American Political Science Review91(3): 535–646 .
21.
Lakoff, George and Mark Johnson (1999) Philosophy in the Flesh: The Embodied Mind and Its Challenge to Western Thought. New York: Basic Books .
22.
Locke, John (1990) Treatise of Civil Government. On Locke, Berkeley, and Hume, CD-ROM. Pittsboro, NC: Intelex Corporation .
23.
Love, Nancy S. (2002) ‘“ Singing For Our Lives”: Women’s Music and Democratic Politics’ , Hypatia, A Journal of Feminist Philosophy17(4): 71–94 .
24.
McCarthy, Thomas (1994) ‘Kantian Constructivism and Reconstructivism: Rawls and Habermas in Dialogue’ , Ethics, an International Journal of Social, Political, and Legal Philosophy105: 44–63 .
25.
Mercosur Youth Orchestra, Retrieved 10 January 2003 from the World Wide Web.
26.
Miller, Eugene F. (1979) ‘Metaphor and Political Knowledge’ , American Political Science Review73: 155–170 .
27.
Nelson, John S. (1998) Tropes of Politics: Science, Theory, Rhetoric, Action. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press .
28.
Odedoyin, Remi (2000) ‘Overlapping Consensus: Objectivising a Subjective Standpoint’ , Journal of Philosophical Research25: 323–343 .
29.
Osborne, William (1994) ‘Performers Place. Art is Just and Excuse: Gender Bias in International Orchestras’ , IAWM Journal2(3): 6–14 .
30.
Osborne, William (1999) ‘Symphony Orchestras and Artist-Prophets: Cultural Isomorphism and the Allocation of Power in Music’ , Leonardo Music Journal9: 69–76 .
31.
Rawls, John (1955) ‘Two Concepts of Rules’, pp. 20–46 in Samuel Freeman (ed.) John Rawls: Collected Papers. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1999 .
32.
Rawls, John (1958) ‘Justice as Fairness’, pp. 47–72 in Samuel Freeman (ed.) John Rawls: Collected Papers. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1999 .
33.
Rawls, John (1971) ‘Justice as Reciprocity’, pp. 190–224 in Samuel Freeman (ed.) John Rawls: Collected Papers. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1999 .
34.
Rawls, John (1996) Political Liberalism. New York: Columbia University Press .
35.
Rawls, John (1999a) A Theory of Justice, revised edn. New York: Columbia University Press .
36.
Rawls, John (1999b) The Law of Peoples: with, ‘The Idea of Public Reason Revisited’. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
37.
Rawls, John (1999c) Collected Papers, ed. Samuel Freeman. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
38.
Rosen, Charles (1997) The Classical Style, Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven. New York: W.W. Norton and Co.
39.
Rothstein, Edward (1986) ‘The New Amateur Player and Listener’, pp. 529–544 in Joan Peyser (ed.) The Orchestra: Origins and Transformations. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons .
40.
Scheffler, Samuel (1994) ‘The Appeal of Political Liberalism’ , Ethics, an International Journal of Social, Political, and Legal Philosophy105(1): 4–22 .
41.
Shepherd, John (1993) ‘Difference and Power in Music’, pp. 46–65 in Ruth Solie (ed.) Musicology and Difference: Gender and Sexuality in Music Scholarship. Berkeley: University of California Press .
42.
Sheridan, Molly (2000) ‘American Sound Redefined, Composer Brent Michael Davids Brings a Native American Powwow into the Concert Hall’, Symphony Magazine May–June. Retrieved 30 Jan. 2003 from the World Wide Web, http://www.brentmichaeldavids.com/writings_rev_amersound.htm
43.
Shore, Bernard (1938) Orchestra Speaks. Freeport, NY: Books for Libraries Press .
44.
Silverman, Kaja (1988) The Acoustic Mirror: The Female Voice in Psychoanalysis. Bloomington: Indiana University Press .
45.
Stevens, Dennis (1986) ‘Why Conductors? Their Role and the Idea of Fidelity’ pp. 229–254 in Joan Peyser (ed.) The Orchestra: Its Origin and Transformation. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons .
46.
Verba, Sidney, Kay Lehman Schlozman and Henry E. Brady (1995) Voice and Equality, Civic Voluntarism in American Politics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
47.
Von Humboldt, Wilhelm (1969) The Limits of State Action, ed. J.W. Burrow. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
48.
Walzer, Michael (1994) ‘Comment’, pp. 99–103 in Amy Gutmann (ed.) Multiculturalism, Examining the Politics of Recognition. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
49.
Weiss, Michael D. (1993) ‘A Jurisprudence of Blindness: Rawls’ Justice and Legal Theory’ , Drake Law Review42: 565–589 .
50.
Wenar, Leif (1995) ‘Political Liberalism: An Internal Critique’ , Ethics, an International Journal of Social, Political, and Legal Philosophy106(1): 32–62 .
51.
Young, Iris Marion (1997) Intersecting Voices: Dilemmas of Gender, Political Philosophy, and Policy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
52.
Young, Iris Marion (2000) Inclusion and Democracy. New York: Oxford University Press .
