The Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006 claims to devolve ownership to local forest dwellers in India, to provide local communities with better tenurial security and allow increased rights over forest resources. One argument for this is the redressal of historical injustices, particularly to tribal people. Offering a reality check, this article scrutinises the interface of informal and formal institutions with respect to livelihood of forest-dependent communities and forest conservation to identify ongoing implementation challenges. Empirical data from two villages of Mayurbhanj district in Odisha use oral history, focus group discussions and in-depth interviews with different actors in FRA implementation as evidence. Asymmetric information flow, deficient coordination, undemocratic participation, dearth of transparency and lack of accountability at various levels hinder FRA implementation, which claims to safeguard the basic rights of disempowered local people, but does not appear to deliver ‘complete justice’.
ActionAid (2013) Our Forest Our Rights. Implementation Status of Forest Rights Act—2006. Natural Resources—Knowledge Activist Hub. New Delhi: ActionAid.
Appiah-OpokuS.MulamoottilG. (1997) ‘Indigenous Institutions and Environmental Assessment: The Case of Ghana’, Environmental Management, 21(2): 159–71.
4.
BagchiS.MishraC.BhatnagarY.V. (2004) ‘Conflicts between Traditional Pastoralism and Conservation of Himalayan Ibex (Capra sibirica) in the Trans-Himalayan Mountains’, Animal Conservation, 7(2): 121–8.
5.
BardhanP.MookherjeeD. (2006) ‘Decentralisation and Accountability in Infrastructure Delivery in Developing Countries’, The Economic Journal, 116(508): 101–27.
6.
BaviskarA. (1994) ‘Fate of the Forest. Conservation and Tribal Rights’, Economic and Political Weekly, 29(38): 2493–501.
7.
BlairH. (2000) ‘Participation and Accountability at the Periphery: Democratic Local Governance in Six Countries’, World Development, 28(1): 21–39.
8.
ConroyC.MishraA.RaiA. (2002) ‘Learning from Self-initiated Community Forest Management in Orissa, India’, Forest Policy and Economics, 4(3): 227–37.
9.
DemsetzH. (1967) ‘Toward a Theory of Property Rights’, The American Economic Review, 57(2): 347–59.
10.
Forest Survey of India (2013) State of Forest Report 2011. Dehradun: Ministry of Environment and Forests.
11.
GadgilM.BerkesF.FolkeC. (1993) ‘Indigenous Knowledge for Biodiversity Conservation’, Ambio, 22(2–3): 151–6.
12.
GadgilM.ChandranM.D.S. (1992) ‘Sacred Groves’, India International Centre Quarterly, 19(1–2):183–7.
13.
GadgilM.VartakV.D. (1975) ‘Sacred Groves in India—A Plea for Continued Conservation’, Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society, 72(2): 314–20.
14.
GordonH.S. (1954) ‘The Economic Theory of a Common-Property Resource: The Fishery’, The Journal of Political Economy, 62(2): 124–42.
15.
Government of India (2010) Manthan: Report of National Committee on Forest Rights Act. A Joint Committee of Ministry of Environment and Forests, and Ministry of Tribal Affairs. New Delhi: GoI.
16.
Government of Odisha (2014) Highlights of Odisha Forestry Sector. Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Bhubaneswar, Odisha: GoO.
17.
HumanJ.PattanaikM. (2000) Community Forest Management: A Casebook from India. London: Oxfam.
18.
JodhaN.S. (1986) ‘Common Property Resources and Rural Poor in Dry Regions of India’, Economic and Political Weekly, 21(27): 1169–81.
19.
KaranthK.K.CurranL.M.Reuning-SchererJ.D. (2006) ‘Village Size and Forest Disturbance in Bhadra Wildlife Sanctuary, Western Ghats, India’, Biological Conservation, 128(2): 147–57.
20.
KhanM.L.KhumbongmayunA.D.TripathiR.S. (2008) ‘The Sacred Groves and Their Significance in Conserving Biodiversity: An Overview’, International Journal of Ecology and Environmental Sciences, 34(3): 277–91.
KumarR.ShahabuddinG. (2005) ‘Effects of Biomass Extraction on Vegetation Structure, Diversity and Composition of an Indian Tropical Dry Forest’, Environmental Conservation, 32(3): 1–12.
23.
MalhotraK.C.GokhaleY.ChatterjeeS.SrivastavaS. (2007) Sacred Groves in India. An Overview. Bhopal: Indira Gandhi Rasthriya Manav Sangrahalaya.
24.
MathurK. (2008) From Government to Governance. A Brief Survey of Indian Experience. New Delhi: National Book Trust.
25.
MerokaP.HallerT. (2008) ‘Government Wildlife, Unfulfilled Promises and Business: Lessons from Participatory Conservation in the Selous Game Reserve, Tanzania’. In GalvinM.HallerT. (Eds), People, Protected Areas and Global Change. Participatory Conservation in Latin America, Africa, Asia and Europe (pp. 177–219). Bern: Geographica Bernesia.
MuraliK.S.ShankerU.ShankarR.U.GaneshaiahK.N.BawaK.S. (1996) ‘Extraction of Non-timber Forest Produce in the Forests of Biligiri Rangan Hills, India. 2. Impact of NTFP Extraction on Regeneration, Population Structure and Species Composition’, Economic Botany, 50(2): 252–69.
28.
NicholsonJ.W. (1938) Annual Progress Report on Forest Administration in the Province of Orissa for the Year 1936–37. Cuttack: Press Officer, Government Press.
29.
OlsonM. (1965) The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. Harvard: Harvard University Press.
30.
OrmsbyA.BhagwatS.A. (2010) ‘Sacred Forests of India: A Strong Tradition of Community-based Natural Resource Management’, Environmental Conservation, 37(3): 320–6.
31.
OstromE. (1990) Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32.
PankajA.K. (Ed.) (2012) Right to Work and Rural India. Working of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS). New Delhi: SAGE Publications.
33.
PathakN. (Ed.) (2009) Community Conserved Areas. A Directory. Pune & Delhi: Kalpavriksh Environmental Action Group.
34.
PearceD.MoranD. (1994) The Economic Value of Biodiversity. London: Earthscan.
35.
PershaL.AnderssonK. (2014) ‘Elite Capture Risk and Mitigation in Decentralised Forest Governance Regimes’, Global Environmental Change, 24: 265–76.
36.
PlatteauJ. (2004) ‘Monitoring Elite Capture in Community-driven Development’, Development and Change, 35(2): 223–46.
37.
PoteeteA.R.OstromE. (2004) ‘Heterogeneity, Group Size and Collective Action: The Role of Institutions in Forest Management’, Development and Change, 35(3): 435–61.
38.
Press Information Bureau (2016) ‘Supreme Court Vacates the Interim Order of Madras High Court on the Issue of Patta to Forest Dwellers’. Government of India. PIB. URL (consulted 27June2017), from http://pib.nic.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=135998
ReddyG.M.KumarK.A.RaoP.T.Springate-BaginskiO. (2011) ‘Issues Related to Implementation of the Forest Rights Act in Andhra Pradesh’, Economic & Political Weekly, 46(18): 73–81.
43.
RoutS. (2003) Joint Forest Management in Orissa: Challenges and Opportunities. Working Paper No. 117. Bangalore: Institute for Social and Economic Change.
44.
RRI (2015) Potential for Recognition of Community Forest Resource Rights Under India’s Forest Rights Act. A Preliminary Assessment. Washington, DC: Rights and Resources Initiative.
45.
SahuN.C.RathB. (2011) ‘Impact of Joint Forest Management (JFM) on Environmental Stress Migration Evidence from Orissa’, International Journal of Rural Management, 6(1): 63–78.
46.
SampatP. (2013) ‘Limits to Absolute Power. Eminent Domain and the Right to Land in India’, Economic and Political Weekly, 48(19): 40–52.
47.
SarapK. (2007) ‘Forest and Livelihoods in Orissa’. In Springate-BaginskiO.BlaikieP. (Eds), Forests, People and Power. The Political Ecology of Reform in South Asia (pp. 261–99). London: Earthscan.
48.
SarapK.SarangiT.K.NaikJ. (2013) ‘Implementation of Forest Rights Act 2006 in Odisha: Process, Constraints and Outcome’, Economic and Political Weekly, 48(36): 61–7.
49.
SathyapalanJ. (2010) ‘Implementation of the Forest Rights Act in the Western Ghats Region of Kerala’, Economic and Political Weekly, 45(30): 65–72.
50.
SatoT.ImaiK.S. (2010) Decentralisation, Democracy and Allocation of Poverty Alleviation Programmes in Rural India. BWPI Working Paper No. 136. Manchester: Brooks World Poverty Institute.
51.
SatpathyB. (2015) ‘Where Are Tribals in Their Development? A Century of Indian Forest Legislations’, International Journal of Rural Management, 11(1): 60–74.
52.
SenA. (2009) The Idea of Justice. London: Penguin.
53.
SenapatiN.SahuN.K. (1967) Orissa District Gazetteers: Mayurbhanj. Cuttack: Orissa Government Press, Department of Revenue, Gazetteers Unit.
54.
ShankarU.MuraliK.S.ShankerR.U.GaneshaiahK.N.BawaK.S. (1998) ‘Extraction of Non-timber Forest Products in the Forests of Biligiri Rangan Hills, India. 4. Impact on Floristic Diversity and Population Structure in the Thorn Scrub Forest’, Economic Botany, 52(3): 302–15.
55.
SiebertS.F. (2004) ‘Demographic Effects of Collecting Rattan Cane and Their Implications for Sustainable Harvesting’, Conservation Biology, 18(2): 424–31.
56.
SinnH. (1984) ‘Common Property Resources, Storage Facilities and Ownership Structures: A Cournot Model of the Oil Market’, Economica, 51(203): 235–52.
57.
SiripurapuK.K. (2010) The Semantic of CFM–People’s Narration. Case Studies from Odisha. Bhubaneswar: Vasundhara.
58.
SmithR.J. (1981) ‘Resolving the Tragedy of the Commons by Creating Private Property Rights in Wildlife’, Cato Journal, 1(2): 439–68.
UNDP (2012) Recognition of Community Rights under Forest Rights Act in Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh: Challenges and Way Forward. Final Report—July2011. Prepared by Samarthan. New Delhi: Centre for Development Support.
61.
VartakV.D.GadgilM. (1981) ‘Sacred Groves of Maharastra: An Inventory’. In JainS.K. (Ed.), Glimpses of Indian Ethnobotany (pp. 279–94). Bombay: Oxford University Press.
62.
WadeR. (1987) ‘The Management of Common Property Resources: Collective Action as an Alternative to Privatisation or State Regulation’, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 11(2): 95–106.
63.
WainrightC.WehrmeyerW. (1998) ‘Success in Integrating Conservation Development? A Study from Zombia’, World Development, 26(6): 933–44.
64.
WeitzmanM.L. (1974) ‘Free Access vs. Private Ownership as Alternative Systems for Managing Common Property’, Journal of Economic Theory, 8(2): 225–34.
