Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2018-9
When Increasing the Strength of the Argument Becomes Counterproductive: The Role of Argumentative Markers in the Arousal of the Psychological Reactance
The rationale of this study is that by stressing the argumentative force of the message, and thus orientating its processing, scalar adverbs are likely to be processed as an attempt to influence the decision making as regards the message advocacy and consequently trigger some aversive reactions in the recipients. To support this claim, an experiment is conducted in a context of a (campus) health promotion program dealing with HIV infection. It shows that the introduction of such adverbs in an epidemiological information report increases the cognitive and affective outcomes dealing with psychological reactance, and decreases the message acceptability and the behavioral intentions. It also shows that for the affective component of psychological reactance and message acceptability, these effects occur especially when the source of the message is perceived as authoritative. The persuasiveness of such linguistic items in the context of health communication is addressed in the conclusion of the study.
AhnH.PaekH. J.TinkhamS. (2009). The persuasive effects of anti-binge drinking public service advertising on college students’ binge drinking: The effectiveness of message sources, message appeals and their interactions. Paper presented at the 2009 annual convention of American Academy of Advertising, Cincinnati, OH.
2.
AllenL. (2011). Young people and sexuality education. Rethinking key debates. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
3.
AnscombreJ. C.DucrotO. (1976). L’argumentation dans la langue. Langages, 42, 5-27.
4.
AnscombreJ. C.DucrotO. (1983). L’argumentation dans la langue. Brussells, Belgium: Mardaga.
5.
ApothelozD.NowakowskaM. (2011). Déjà en emploi justificatif. In CorminboeufG.BéguelinM. J. (Eds.), Du système linguistique aux actions langagières (pp. 249-261). Brussells, Belgium: De Boeck-Duculot.
6.
BaekT. H.YoonS.KimS. (2015). When environmental messages should be assertive: Examining the moderating role of effort investment. International Journal of Advertising, 34, 135-157.
7.
BassanoD. (1991). Opérateurs et connecteurs argumentatifs: Une approche psycholinguistique. Intellectica, 11, 149-191.
8.
BassanoD.ChampaudC. (1987). La fonction argumentative des marques de la langue. Argumentation, 1, 175-199.
9.
BenoitW. L. (1998). Forewarning and persuasion. In MillerM.PreissR. W. (Eds.), Persuasion: Advances through meta-analysis (pp. 139-154). Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
10.
BrehmJ. W. (1966). A theory of psychological reactance. New York, NY: Academic Press.
11.
BrehmJ. W.MannM. F. (1975). Effect of importance of freedom and attraction to group members on influence produced by group pressure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 31, 816-824.
12.
BrehmS. S.BrehmJ. W. (1981). Psychological reactance: A theory of freedom and control. New York, NY: Academic Press.
13.
BrinõlP.PettyR. E. (2005). Individual differences in attitude change. In AlbarracínD.JohnsonB. T.ZannaM. P. (Eds.), The handbook of attitudes and attitude change (pp. 575-615). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
14.
BrinõlP.PettyR. E. (2009). Source factors in persuasion: A self-validation approach. European Review of Social Psychology, 20, 49-96.
15.
BullerD. B.BorlandR.BurgoonM. (1998). Impact of behavioral intention on effectiveness of message features. Evidence from the family sun safety project. Human Communication Research, 24, 433-453.
16.
BurgoonM.AlvaroE. M.GrandpreJ. R.VoloudakisM. (2002). Revisiting the theory of psychological reactance: Communicating threats to attitudinal freedom. In DillardJ. P.PfauM. (Eds.), The persuasion handbook: Developments in theory and practice (pp. 213-232). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
17.
BurgoonM.KingL. B. (1974). The mediation of resistance to persuasion strategies by language variables. Human Communication Research, 1, 30-41.
18.
BushmanB. J. (1998). Effects of warning and information labels on consumption of full-fat, reduced-fat, and no-fat products. Journal of Applied Psychology, 83, 97-101.
19.
BushmanB. J.StackA. D. (1996). Forbidden fruit versus tainted fruit: Effects of warning labels on attraction to television violence. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2, 207-226.
20.
ChampaudC.BassanoD. (1987). Argumentative and informative functions of French intensity modifiers “presque,” “à peine” and “à peu près”: An experimental study on children and adults. Cahiers de Psychologie Cognitive, 7, 605-631.
21.
CranoW. D.SiegelJ. T.AlvaroE. M.PatelN. M. (2007). Overcoming adolescents’ resistance to anti-inhalant appeals. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 21, 516-524.
22.
CrossleyM. L. (2001). “Resistance” and health promotion. Health Education Journal, 60, 197-204.
23.
CrossleyM. L. (2002). Resistance to health promotion: A preliminary comparative investigation of British and Australian students. Health Education, 102, 289-299.
24.
DefriseC.NirenburgS. (1990). Meaning representation and text planning. In COLING-90:Proceedings of the 13th conference on computational linguistics (Vol. 3, pp. 219-224). Helsinki, Finland: Association for Computational Linguistics.
25.
DillardJ. P. (2014). Language, style, and persuasion. In HoltgravesT. M. (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of language and social psychology (pp. 177-187). Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
26.
DillardJ. P.ShenL. (2005). On the nature of reactance and its role in persuasive health communication. Communication Monographs, 72, 144-168.
27.
DucrotO. (1988). Topoi et formes topiques [Topoi and topic forms] . Bulletin d’Etudes de Linguistique Française, 22, 1-14.
28.
DurantiniM. R.AlbarracínD.MitchellA. L.EarlA.GilletteJ. C. (2006). Influential agents of behavior change for different genders, ethnicities, ages, and behaviorally-defined groups: A meta-analysis of HIV-prevention interventions. Psychological Bulletin, 132, 212-248.
29.
Dutta-BergmanM. J. (2005). Psychographic profiling of fruit and vegetable consumption: The role of health orientation. Social Marketing Quarterly, 11, 19-35.
30.
Erceg-HurnD. M.SteedL. G. (2011). Does exposure to cigarette health warnings elicit psychological reactance in smokers?Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 41, 219-237.
31.
FahnestockJ. (1998). Accommodating science: The rhetorical life of scientific facts. Written Communication, 15, 330-350.
32.
FoolenA. (1996). Pragmatic particles. In VerschuerenJ.OstmanJ. O.BlommaertJ.UlcaenC. (Eds.), Handbook of pragmatics (pp. 1-24). Philadelphia, PA: John Benjamins.
33.
FraserB. (1998). What are discourse markers?Journal of Pragmatics, 31, 931-952.
34.
FruchterJ. (2002, June4). Colorado looks for new way to educate, avoid “Safer sex burnout”. Colorado Daily. Available from CDC National Prevention Information Network: News Record No. 35254.
35.
GansR. (2014). The politics of HPV vaccination advocacy: Effects of source expertise on effectiveness of a pro-vaccine message. Proceedings of the New York State Communication Association, 2013, Article 3. Retrieved from http://docs.rwu.edu/nyscaproceedings/vol2013/iss2013/3
36.
GodinhoJ.VeenJ. (2006). Illicit drug policies and their impact on the HIV epidemic in Europe. In MaticS.LazarusJ. V.DonoghoeM. C. (Eds.), HIV/AIDS in Europe. Moving from death sentence to chronic disease management (pp. 27-42). Copenhagen, Denmark: WHO Regional Office for Europe.
37.
GoldfarbE.ConstantineN. A. (2011). Sexuality education. In BrownB. B.PrinsteinM. J. (Eds.), Encyclopedia of adolescence (Vol. 2, pp. 322-331). London, England: Elsevier/Academic Press.
38.
HaynesM. D. (2015). Reversing the boomerang effect in persuasive health communication: Reducing psychological reactance to self-persuasion using inoculation and restoration treatments (Unpublished master’s thesis). Texas Christian University, Fort Worth. Retrieved from https://repository.tcu.edu/handle/116099117/8324
39.
HellerJ.PallackM.PicekJ. (1973). The interactive effects of intent and threat on boomerang attitude change. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 26, 273-279.
40.
HoltgravesT. (2008). Automatic intention recognition in conversation processing. Journal of Memory and Language, 58, 627-645.
41.
HongS. M. (1992). Hong’s psychological reactance scale: A further factor analytic validation. Psychological Reports, 70, 512-514.
42.
HongS. M.FaeddaS. (1996). Refinement of the Hong psychological reactance scale. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 56, 173-182.
43.
HongS. M.GiannakopoulosE.LaingD.WilliamsN. A. (1993). Psychological reactance: Effects of age and gender. Journal of Social Psychology, 134, 223-228.
44.
HosmanL. (1989). The evaluative consequences of hedges, hesitations, and intensifiers. Powerful and powerless speech styles. Human Communication Research, 15, 383-406.
45.
JarvellaR. J.LundquistR. (1994). Scales in the interpretation of words, sentences, and texts. Journal of Semantics, 11, 171-198.
46.
JarvellaR. J.MathieuS. (2000). On judging quantities in text without expert knowledge. In LundquistR.JarvellaR. J. (Eds.), Language, text and knowledge (pp. 261-284). New York, NY: Mouton De Gruyter.
47.
JayezJ.TovenaL. M. (2008). Presque and almost: How argumentation derives from comparative meanings. In BonamiO.Cabredo HofherrP. (Eds.), Empirical issues in syntax and semantics (Vol. 7, pp. 217-239). Paris, France: CNRS.
48.
KayJ. (1990). Even. Linguistics and Philosophy, 13, 59-111.
49.
KronrodA.GrinsteinA.WathieuL. (2012). Go green! Should environmental messages be so assertive?Journal of Marketing, 76, 95-102.
50.
KruglanskiA. W. (1990). Motivations for judging and knowing: Implication for causal attribution. In HigginsE. T.SorrentinoR. M. (Eds.), Handbook of motivation and cognition (Vol. 2, pp. 333-368). New York, NY: Guilford Press.
51.
LotF.SmatiJ.MontlahucC.CazeinF.BarinF.Le StratY.. . . DollfusC. (2015). Découvertes de séropositivité VIH chez les jeunes en France, 2003-2013 [HIV seropositivity discoveries in young peoples in France, 2003-2013] . Bulletin Epidémiologique Hebdomadaire, 40-41, 744-751.
52.
McCroskeyJ. C. (1966). Scales for the measurement of ethos. Speech Monographs, 31, 65-72.
53.
McKenzieA.HedgeN.EnslinP. (2016). Sex education: Challenges and choices. British Journal of Educational Studies. doi:10.1080/00071005.2016.1232363
54.
MichaelisL. A. (1992). Aspect and the semantics-pragmatics interface: The case ofalready. Lingua, 87, 321-339.
55.
MichaelisL. A. (1996). On the use and meaning of already. Linguistics and Philosophy, 19, 477-502.
56.
MillerC. H. (2015). Persuasion and psychological reactance: The effects of explicit, high-controlling language. In ShulzeR.PishwaH. (Eds.), The exercise of power in communication: Devices, reception and reaction (pp. 269-286). London, England: Palgrave Macmillan.
57.
MillerC. H.LaneL. T.DeatrickL. M.YoungA. M.PottsK. A. (2007). Psychological reactance and promotional health messages: The effects of controlling language, lexical concreteness, and the restoration of freedom. Human Communication Research, 33, 219-240.
58.
MoeschlerJ. (2015). Argumentation and connectives. How do discourse connectives constrain argumentation and utterance interpretations? In CaponeA.MeyJ. (Eds.), Interdisciplinary studies in pragmatics, culture and society (pp. 653-676). New York, NY: Springer.
59.
Moyer-GuséE. (2008). Toward a theory of entertainment persuasion: Explaining the persuasive effects of entertainment-education messages. Communication Theory, 18, 407-425.
60.
PaekH. J.HoveT.JeongH. J.KimM. (2011). Peer or expert? The persuasive impact of You Tube public service announcement producers. International Journal of Advertising, 30, 161-188.
61.
PaveyL.SparksP. (2009). Reactance, autonomy and paths to persuasion: Examining perceptions of threats to freedom and informational value. Motivation and Emotion, 33, 277-290.
62.
PennebakerJ. W.SandersD. Y. (1976). American graffiti: Effects of authority and reactance arousal. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2, 264-267.
63.
PettyR. E.CacioppoJ. T. (1977). Forewarning, cognitive responding, and resistance to persuasion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35, 645-655.
64.
PlantinC. (2002). Argumentation studies and discourse analysis: The French situation and global perspectives. Discourse Studies, 4, 343-368.
65.
PlattnerE. (2015). HIV and AIDS “fatigue” and sexual risk behavior among university students in Botswana. Paper presented at the 12th International AIDS Impact Conference, Amsterdam, Netherlands. Retrieved from http://www.aidsimpact.com/2015/Academics/Programme/abstract/?id=2272
66.
PornpitakpanC. (2004). The persuasiveness of source credibility: A critical review of five decades’ evidence. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 34, 243-281.
67.
PhuaJ. (2016). The effects of similarity, parasocial identification, and source credibility in obesity public service announcement (PSAs) on diet and exercise self-efficacy. Journal of Health Psychology, 21, 699-708.
68.
QuickB. L.BatesB. R. (2010). The use of gain- or loss- frame messages and efficacy appeals to dissuade excessive alcohol consumption among college students: A test of psychological reactance theory. Journal of Health Communication, 15, 603-628.
69.
QuickB. L.ConsidineJ. R. (2008). Examining the use of forceful language when designing exercise persuasive messages for adults: A test of conceptualizing reactance arousal as a two-step process. Health Communication, 23, 483-491.
70.
QuickB. L.ShenL.DillardJ. P. (2013). Reactance theory and persuasion. In DillardJ. P.ShenL. (Eds.), The Sage handbook of persuasion: Advances in theory and research (2nd ed., pp. 167-183). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
71.
QuickB. L.StephensonM. T. (2007a). The reactance restoration scale (RRS): A measure of direct and indirect restoration. Communication Research Report, 24, 131-138.
72.
QuickB. L.StephensonM. T. (2007b). Further evidence that psychological reactance can be modeled as a combination of anger and negative cognition. Communication Research, 34, 255-276.
73.
QuickB. L.StephensonM. T. (2008). Examining the role of trait reactance and sensation seeking on perceived threat, state reactance, and reactance restoration. Human Communication Research, 34, 448-476.
74.
RainsS. A. (2013). The nature of psychological reactance revisited: A meta-analytic review. Human Communication Research, 39, 47-73.
75.
RainsS. A.TurnerM. M. (2007). Psychological reactance and persuasive health communication: A test and extension of the intertwined model. Human Communication Research, 33, 241-269.
76.
RichardsA. S.BanasJ. A. (2015). Inoculating against reactance to persuasive health messages. Health Communication, 30, 451-460.
77.
RitterJ. (2000, July31). Fresh rise in HIV rate rings alarms: Prevention burnout and a return of risky sexual behavior among gay men. USA Today. Available from CDC National Prevention Information Network: News Record No. 30430.
78.
SalmonC. T.AtkinC. (2003). Using media campaigns for health promotion. In ThompsonT. LDorceyA. M.MillerK. I.ParrotR. (Eds.), The handbook of health communication (pp. 449-472). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
79.
SenseningJ.BrehmJ. W. (1968). Attitude change from an implied threat to attitudinal freedom. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 8, 324-330.
80.
ShenL. (2010). Mitigating psychological reactance: The role of message-induced empathy in persuasion. Human Communication Research, 36, 397-422.
81.
ShenL. (2014). Antecedents to psychological reactance: The impact of threat, message frame, and choice. Health Communication, 30, 975-985.
82.
Shirong LuA. (2013). An experimental test of the persuasive effect of source similarity in narrative and nonnarrative health blogs. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 15(7), e142. doi:10.2196/jmir.2386
83.
SilviaP. J. (2005). Deflecting reactance: The role of similarity in increasing compliance and reducing resistance. Basic and Applied Social Psychology, 27, 277-284.
84.
SmithM. J. (1977). The effects of threats to attitudinal freedom as a function of message quality and initial receiver attitude. Communication Monographs, 44, 196-206.
85.
Snoeck-HenkemansF. (2010). “Anyway” and “even” as indicators of complex argumentation. Cogency: Journal of Reasoning and Argumentation, 2, 81-94.
86.
SnyderL. B.BloodD. J. (1992), Caution: Alcohol advertising and the Surgeon General’s alcohol warnings may have adverse effects on young adults. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 20, 37-53.
87.
SteindlC.JonasE.SittenthalerS.Traut-MattaushE.GreenbergJ. (2015). Understanding psychological reactance. New developments and findings. Zeitschrift fur Psychologie, 223, 205-214.
88.
StockmanJ.SchwarczS.ButlerL.de JongB.ChenS.DelgadoV.McFarlandW. (2004). HIV prevention fatigue among high-risk populations in San Francisco. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 35, 432-434.
89.
Van GerrevinkR.de HoopH. (2007). On the optimal use of almost and barely in argumentation. In AloniM.DekkerP.RoelofsenF. (Eds.), Proceedings of the 16th Amsterdam Colloquium (pp. 229-235). Amsterdam, Netherlands: ILLC, University of Amsterdam.
90.
Van’t RietJ.RuiterR. A. C. (2013). Defensive reactions to health-promoting information: An overview and implications for future research. Health Psychology Review, 7, 104-136.
91.
VerhagenA. (2008). Intersubjectivity and the architecture of the language system. In ZlatevJ.RacineT. P.SinhaC.ItkonenE. (Eds.), The shared mind. Perspectives on intersubjectivity (pp. 307-331). Philadelphia, PA: John Benjamins.
92.
WagnerH. S.HowlandM.MannT. (2015). Effects of subtle and explicit health messages on food choice. Health Psychology, 34, 79-82.
93.
WebsterD. M.KruglanskiA. W. (1997). Cognitive and social consequences of the need for cognitive closure. European Review of Social Psychology, 8, 133-173.
94.
WicklundR. A. (1974). Freedom and reactance. Potomac, MD: Lawrence Erlbaum.
95.
WintersteinG.SchadenG. (2011). Relevance and utility in an argumentative framework: An application to the accommodation of discourse topics. In LecomteA.TronçonS. (Eds.), Ludics, dialogue and interactions (pp. 134-146). Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag.
96.
WollerK. M. P.BuboltzW. C.LovelandJ. M. (2007). Psychological reactance: Examination across age, ethnicity, and gender. American Journal of Psychology, 120, 15-24.
97.
WongN. C. H.HarrisonK. J.HarvellL. A. (2015). Reactance and public health messages: The unintended dangers of anti-tobacco PSAs. Studies in Media and Communication, 3, 72-83.
