The results of two studies support the contention that teaching metacognitive strategies with the aid of software packages enhances positive transfer of reading comprehension and writing skills. The first study investigated reading comprehension. 140 5th graders, very able learners, were divided into 4 groups which received, respectively, 15 hours of: (a) metacognitive instruction + clozes; (b) traditional instruction of clozes; (c) metacognitive instruction of complete texts and (d) traditional instruction of complete texts. The second study focused on teaching writing skills. 136 7th graders, very able learners, were divided into 4 groups which received, respectively, 48 hours of (a) metacognitive instruction plus Nvo, a writing-skills software package; (b) metacognitive instruction plus Qtext, a word processor; (c) traditional instruction plus Nvo and (d) traditional instruction plus Qtext. Results showed a greater improvement in learning and positive transfer in the group which received metacognitive instruction and used Nvo. The results of both studies show the efficiency of teaching reading and writing processes metacognitively, in integrating computerized environments.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdeyP.ShayerM. (1993). An exploration of long-term far transfer effects following an extended intervention program in the high school science curriculum. Cognition & Instruction, 11, 1–29.
2.
AndersonJ.C., (1980). Native and nonnative speaker performance on cloze texts. Language Learning, 30, 59–76.
3.
ArmbrusterB. B.EcholsC. H.BrownA. L., (1982). Role of metacognition in reading: A development perspective. Volta Review, 84, 45–56.
4.
BaddeleyA.D. (1986). Working memory. Oxford: Clarendon.
5.
BakerL.BrownA.L. (1984a). Metacognitive skills and reading. In PearsonP., (Ed.). Handbook of reading research (pp. 145–170). N.Y.: Longman.
6.
BakerL.BrownA.L., (1984b). Cognitive monitoring reading. In FloodJ., (Ed.) Understanding reading comprehension, (pp. 37–49). Newark: Delaware Publishing: International Reading Association.
7.
BakerL. (1989). Metacognition, comprehension monitoring, and the adult reader. Educational Psychology Review, 1, 3–37.
8.
BelmontJ.M.ButterfieldE.C.FerrettiR.P., (1982). To secure transfer of training instruct self-management skills. In DettermanD.K.SternbergR.J., (Eds.). How and how much can intelligence be increased? (pp. 147–154). Norwood, N.J.: Albex.
9.
BereiterC.BirdM. (1985). Use of thinking aloud identification and teaching of reading comprehension strategies. Cognition and Instruction, 2, 131–156.
10.
BereiterC.ScardamaliaM., (1987). The Psychology of written composition. London: Lawrence Erelbaum Assoc.
11.
BensousanM. (1988), Diagnosing errors in English as a foreign language through the cloze procedure. English Teachers' Journal, 37, 21–26.
12.
BerningerV.W.WhitakerD.P. (1992). Developmental and individual ditlerences in planning translating and revising. Riverside: University of California.
13.
BracewellR. J. (1983). Investigating the control of writing skills. In MosenthalP.WamsleyS.TamorL. (Eds.). Research on writing, principals and methods, (pp. 177–203). N.Y.: Longman..
14.
BridwellL.SircG.BrookeR. (1985). Revising and computing, case studies of student writer. In FreedmanS., (Ed.), The Acquisition of writting language, revision and response, (pp. 155–170). Norwood, NJ: Albex Publishing Company.
15.
BroshS. (1993). From writer to reader to teacher: The new literacy (Hebrew). Tel Aviv: Center for Educational Technology.
16.
BrownJ. S. (1985). Process Versus Product: A perspective tools for communal and informal electronic learning. In CohenM.HalsleyW., (Eds.). Children and microcomputers, (pp. 195–218). Hillsdale, N.J.: Erlbaum.
17.
BrownA.L.CampioneJ.C. (1982). Modifying intelligence or modifying cognitive skills: more than a semantic quibble? In DettermanD.K.SternbergR.J. (Eds.). How and how much can intelligence be increased? (pp. 215–230). Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
18.
BrownA. L.CampioneJ.C.DayJ.D., (1982). Learning to learn: On training students to learn from texts. Educational Researcher, 10, 14–21.
19.
BrownA.L.PalinscarA.S. (1987). Reciprocal teaching of comprehension strategies: A natural history of one program for enhancing learning. In DayJ.D.BorkowskiJ.G., (Eds), Intelligence and exceptionality, (pp. 81–132). Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
20.
ButterfieldE.C.NelsonG.D., (1989). Theory and practice of teaching for transfer. Educational Technological Research and Development, 37, 5–38.
21.
GathercoleS.E.BaddeleyA.D. (1993). Working memory and language. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale
22.
CampioneJ.C.BrownA.L. (1990). Guided learning and transfer: Implications for approaches to assessment. In FrederiksenN.GlaserR.LesgoldA.ShaftoM.G. (Eds.),. Diagnostic monitoring of skill and knowledge acquisition (pp. 141–172). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
23.
DillonR.F. (1986). Issues in cognitive psychology and instruction. In DillonR. F.SternbergR. J., (Eds.). Cognition and instruction, (pp. 1–11). N.Y.: Academic Press.
24.
De BeaugrandeR., (1984). The linearity of reading: Fact, fiction, or frontier? In FloodJ. (Ed.), Understanding and comprehension, (pp. 45–74). Newark: DE, International Reading Association.
25.
DominowskiR.L. (1990). Problem solving and metacognition. In GilhoolyK.J.KeaneM.T.G.LogieR.H.ErdosG. (Eds.) Lines of Thinking Vol 2, N.Y.: John Wiley & Sons.
26.
EmigJ. (1983). Literacy and freedom. New Jersey: Baynton-Cook.
27.
EstesW. K. (1991). Cognitive architectures from the standpoint of an experimental psychologist. Annual Review of Psychology, 42, 1–28.
28.
FatalS.KanielS. (1992). The influence of metamemory on acquisition, transfer and maintenance of memory tasks. Individual Differences, 4, 91–102
29.
FerrettiR.P.ButterfieldE.C. (1992). Intelligence-related differences in the learning, maintenance and transfer of problem-solving strategies. Intelligence, 16, 207–223.
30.
FitzgeraldJ. (1993). Teachers' knowing about knowledge: Its significance for classroom writing instruction. Language Arts, 70, 282–289.
31.
FlavellJ.H. (1976). Metacognitive aspects of problem solving. In ResnickL., (Ed.), The nature of intelligence (pp. 17–35). NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
32.
FlavellJ.H. (1979). Metacognition and cognitive monitoring: A new area of cognitive developmental inquiry. American Psychologist, 34, 906–911.
33.
FlavellJ.H. (1993). Young childrens' understanding of thinking and consciousness. Current Directions in Psychological Science2, 40–43.
34.
FlowerL.A.HayesJ.R. (1984). The representation of meaning in writing. Written Communication, 1, 120–160.
35.
GelzheiserL.M.ShepherdM.J.WozniakR.H. (1986). The development of instruction to induce skill transfer. Exceptional Children, 53, 125–129.
GickM.L.HolyoakK.J. (1987). The cognitive basis of knowledge transfer. In CormierS.M.HagmanJ.D. (Eds.), Transfer of learning: Contemporary research and applications, (pp 59–85). San Diego: Academic Press.
38.
GutermanA. (1987). Fostering the ability to learn from texts (Hebrew). Unpublished masteros thesis, Israel, Tel Aviv University.
39.
HulmeC.MakenzyS. (1990). Working memory and severe learning difficulties, Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associate.
40.
JongsmaE., (1980). Cloze instruction research: A second look, Newark DE, International Reading Association.
41.
KanielS.AraziS. (1996). Components of attention: Choice, concentration and effort - an integrative and practical model (Hebrew). Megamot, 38, 92–111.
42.
KurtzB.E.BorkovskyJ.G. (1987). Development of strategic skills in impulsive and reflective children: A longitudinal study of metacognition. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 43, 129–148.
43.
KletzienS.B. (1991), Strategy use by good and poor comprehenders reading expository text of differing levels. Reading Research Quartetly, 26, 67–86.
44.
KurtzB.E.BorkovskyJ.G. (1987). Development of strategic skills in impulsive and reflective children: A longitudinal study of metacognition. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 43, 129–148.
45.
LevenstonE.A.NirR.Blum-KulkaS., (1984). Danalysis and the testing of reading comprehension by cloze technique. In PughA.K.UlijaJ.M. (Eds.), Reading for Professional Purposes, (pp. 202–212). London: Heinemann, 202–212.
46.
LichtP. (1995). The influence of exposure to óNvoô, a writing-generating software package, on writing levels, internalization and transfer of metacognition, in learners using the óFrom Reader to Writerô program (Hebrew). Unpublished masteros thesis, Ramat Gan, Israel, Bar Ilan University.
47.
McCarthyS.J. (1994). Authors, texts and talk: The internalization of dialogue from social interaction during writing. Reading Research Quarterly29, 200–231.
48.
NastasiB.K.ClementsD.H.BattistaM.T. (1990). Social cognitive interaction, motivation and growth in Logo programming and CAI problem solving environments. Journal of Educational Psychology, 82, 150–158.
49.
NeisserU. (1976). Cognition and reality, San Francisco: Freeman.
50.
NelsonT.A. (1994). Metacognition, London, Allyn and Bacon.
51.
PalinscarA.S.BrownA.L., (1984). Reciprocal teaching of comprehension fostering and comprehension-monitoring activities, Cognition and Instruction, 1, 117–175.
52.
PeaR. D. (1985). Beyond amplification: Using the computer to recognize mental functioning. Education Psychologist, 20, 167–182.
53.
PeledB. (1995). The influence of teaching strategies for eliciting meaning from a paragraph. using rational clozes and complete texts, on learning and internalization of these strategies in elementary school pupils. (Hebrew). Unpublished masteròs thesis, Ramat Gan, Israel, Bar Ilan University.
54.
PughA.K. (1978). Silent reading: An introduction to its study and teaching. Heinemann Educational Books.
55.
RauenbuschF.BereiterC., (1991). Making reading more difficult: A degraded text microworld for teaching reading comprehension strategies, Cognition and Instruction, 8, 181–206.
56.
RyeJ., (1982). Cloze procedure and the teaching of reading, London, Heinemann Educational Books Ltd.
57.
SalomonG., (1986). Information technologies: what you see is not (always) what you get. Educational Psychologist, 20, 207–216.
58.
SalomonG.PerkinsD.N. (1989). Rocky roads to transfer: Rethinking mechanisms of a neglected phenomenon. Educational Psychologist, 24, 113–143.
59.
ScardamaliaM.BerieterC. (1985). Research on written composition. In WittrockM. (Ed.). Handbook of Research on Teaching, (pp. 87–130). N.Y.: Macmillan Education Ltd.
60.
ScardamaliaM.BerieterC. (1986). Writing. In DillonR. F.SternbergR. J., (Eds.). Cognition and Instruction. (pp. 59–77). N.Y.: Academic Press.
61.
ScardamaliaM.BerieterC. (1987). The psychology of witing composition. Hillsdale, New Jersey: Erlbaum.
62.
SchneiderW.FiskA.D. (1982). Concurrent automatic and controlled visual search: Can processing occur without resource cost. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition, 8, 261–278.
63.
SchmittM.C. (1988). The effects of an elaborated directed reading activity on the Metacomprehension skills of third graders. Dialogues in literacy research. The 37th Yearbook of the National Reading Conference, pp. 167–181.
64.
SmithC.DahlK. (1984). Teaching, reading and writing together. Teachers College Press.
65.
VygotskyL.S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
66.
WertschV. (1985). (Ed.). Culture communication and cognition: Vygotskian perspectives. Cambridge University Press.
