Can Cytotoxic Effects Induced by Industrial Chemicals be Time-dependent?

Abstract

Short-term and delayed cytotoxic effects of selected water-soluble and water-insoluble industrial chemicals (dimethyl sulphoxide, ethyl alcohol, methyl alcohol, ammonium nitrate, benzalkonium chloride, butoxyethanol and propylene glycol) were tested on confluent 3T3-L1 mouse fibroblasts by using the neutral red uptake (NRU) assay and the MTT assay. The NRU and MTT assays were performed after exposure to a chemical for 10 minutes and 3 hours and then again 7 days later. The results indicate that the system of testing used permits the assessment of both early and delayed cytotoxic effects of different classes of chemicals. Our experiments revealed that three out of the seven substances tested (butoxyethanol, dimethyl sulphoxide and propylene glycol) exhibited similar cytotoxic effects when assessed after exposure for 10 minutes and 7 days later. The results for ammonium nitrate, ethyl alcohol and methyl alcohol, tested after exposure for 10 minutes and 7 days later, did not significantly differ from each other. However, we noted that the cytotoxic effects observed 7 days after exposure were more pronounced than those found for the same concentration, after exposure for 3 hours. One chemical tested (benzalkonium chloride) had almost no cytotoxic effect after exposure for 10 minutes and 3 hours, but showed a strong cytotoxic effect 7 days after exposure. Our study indicated that the cytotoxic effect might be time-dependent in some chemicals, thus inducing a delayed effect in vitro. In our opinion, it is advisable to assess the cytotoxicity of a chemical after exposure for 3 hours (for immediate effects) and again 7 days later (for delayed effects).

Keywords

cytotoxicity NRU MTT 3T3-L1 fibroblasts immediate effects delayed effects

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Seibert

, Balls

, & Fentem

J.H.

(1996). Acute toxicity testing in vitro and the classification and labelling of chemicals. The report and recommendations of ECVAM workshop 16. ATLA 24, 499–510.

Ekwall

(1997). Alternatives: spin-off good science. In Animal Alternatives, Welfare and Ethics (ed. van Zutphen

L.F.M.

, & Balls

), pp. 531–540. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier.

Flint

O.P.

(1997). Toxicity at the cellular level. In Animal Alternatives, Welfare and Ethics (ed. van Zutphen

L.F.M.

, & Balls

), pp. 523–529. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier.

Guillot

(1992). Ocular irritation: present cell culture models and perspectives. ATLA 20, 471–475.

Fentem

, & Balls

(1995). Alternative methods in toxicological research and testing. Comments on Toxicology 5, 199–202.

Dickson

F.M.

, Lawrence

J.N.

, & Benford

D.J.

(1994). Cytotoxicity of 12 chemicals of known human and animal skin irritation potential in human keratinocyte culture. Toxicology in Vitro 8, 661–663.

Walum

, Balls

, Bianchi

, Blaauboer

, Bolcsfoldi

, Guillouzo

, Moore

G.A.

, Odland

, Reinhardt

, & Spielmann

(1992). ECITTS: an integrated approach to the application of in vitro test systems to the hazard assessment of chemicals. ATLA 20, 406–428.

Chiba

, Kawamaki

, & Tohyama

(1998). Simultaneous evaluation of cell viability by neutral red, MTT and crystal violet staining assays of the same cells. Toxicology in Vitro 12, 251–258.

Shaw

A.J.

(1994). Defining cell viability and cytotoxicity. ATLA 22, 124–126.

10.

Balls

, & Fentem

J.H.

(1992). The use of basal cytotoxicity and target organ toxicity tests in hazard identification and risk assessment. ATLA 20, 368–388.

11.

Babich

, & Borenfreund

(1990). Application of the neutral red cytotoxicity assay to in vitro toxicology. ATLA 18, 129–144.

12.

Guzzie

P.J.

(1994). Lethality testing. In In Vitro Toxicology (ed. Gad

S.C.

), pp. 57–86. New York, USA: Raven Press.

13.

Chan

P.K.

, & Hayes

A.W.

(1994). Acute toxicity and eye irritancy. In Principles and Methods in Toxicology (ed. Hayes

A.W.

), pp. 579–649. New York, USA: Raven Press.

14.

Fry

J.R.

, & Hammond

A.H.

(1993). Assessment of the functional integrity of hepatocytes: a brief review. ATLA 21, 324–329.

15.

Espersen

R.J.

, Olsen

, Nicolaisen

G.M.

, Jensen

B.L.

, & Rasmussen

E.S.

(1997). Assessment of recovery from ocular irritancy using a human tissue equivalent model. Toxicology in Vitro 11, 81–88.

16.

Smith

L.M.

, Clothier

R.H.

, Hillidge

, & Balls

(1992). Modification of the FRAME kenacid blue method for cytotoxicity tests on volatile materials. ATLA 20, 230–234.

17.

Shaw

A.J.

, Balls

, Clothier

R.H.

, & Bateman

N.D.

(1991). Predicting ocular irritation and recovery from injury using Madin-Darby canine kidney cells. Toxicology in Vitro 5, 569–571.

18.

Clothier

R.H.

, Morris

, & Lankford

W.T.

(1995). The evaluation of pesticide ingredients and formulations in vitro and correlations with in vivo data. ATLA 23, 667–675.

19.

Reader

S.J.

, Blackwell

, O'Hara

, Clothier

R.H.

, Griffin

, & Balls

(1989). A vital dye release method for assessing the short-term cytotoxic effects of chemicals and formulations. ATLA 17, 28–37.

20.

Kuchowicz

, & Rydzynski

(1997). Evaluation of cytotoxicity of 35 industrial chemicals on rat peritoneal mast cells and mouse fibroblasts 3T3-L1. Pharmacology and Toxicology 80, Suppl. 3, 66–67.

21.

Cervinka

, & Puza

(1995). Apoptosis and necrosis: dynamics of structural changes in cells cultivated in vitro after treatment with xenobiotics. Toxicology in Vitro 9, 387–396.

22.

Bursch

, Ellinger

, Török

, Parzefall

, Coulibaly

, Hochegger

, Schörkhuber

, Partik

, Marian

, Walker

, Sikorska

, & Schulte-Hermann

(1997). In vitro studies on subtypes and regulation of active cell death. Toxicology in Vitro 11, 579–588.

23.

Riddell

R.J.

, Panacer

D.S.

, Wilde

S.M.

, Clothier

R.H.

, & Balls

(1986). The importance of exposure period and cell type in in vitro cytotoxicity testing. ATLA 14, 86–92.