The two main techniques used in biomedical research for the production of transgenic animals have several implications for animal welfare in terms of the Three Rs of Russell & Burch. Some are intrinsic to the transgenic objectives, while others relate to the effects of mutations, transgene expression, associated methodologies, and husbandry or production systems. All of these actual and potential implications for animal welfare demand serious consideration within a broad ethical analysis of the technology. In the light, of the Three Rs, this may require a fundamental reappraisal of the processes by which such scientific procedures are approved.
RussellW.M.S., and BurchR.L. (1959). The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique, 238 pp. London: Methuen. Facsimile edition (1992). Potters Bar, Herts., UK: UFAW.
2.
BroomD.M., and JohnsonK.G. (1993). Stress and Animal Welfare, 211 pp. London: Chapman & Hall.
3.
DawkinsM.S. (1988). Animal Suffering: The Science of Animal Welfare, 149 pp. London: Chapman & Hall,
4.
HurnikJ.F., and LehmanH. (1988). Ethics and farm animal welfare.Journal of Agricultural Ethics1, 305–318.
5.
SmithJ.A., and BoydJ.A. (1991). Lives in the Balance: The Ethics of Using Animals in Biomedical Research, 352 pp. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
6.
RowanA.N., and AndrutisK.A. (1990). Alternatives: a socio-political commentary from the USA.ATLA18, 3–10.
7.
GordonJ.W., ScangosG.A., PlotkinD.J., BarbosaJ.A., and RuddleF.H. (1980). Genetic transformation of mouse embryos by microinjection of purified DNA.Proceedings of The National Academy of Sciences of The United States of America77, 7380–7384.
8.
MurphyD., and HansonJ. (1987). The production of transgenic mice by the microinjection of cloned DNA into fertilized one-cell eggs. In DNA Cloning, Vol. III, A Practical Approach (ed. GloverD.M.), pp. 213–248. Oxford: IRL Press.
9.
PolitesH.G., and PinkertC.A. (1994). DNA microinjection and transgenic animal production. In Transgenic Animal Technology: A Laboratory Handbook (ed. PinkertC.A.), pp. 15–68. San Diego, CA, USA: Academic Press.
10.
NancarrowC.D., MarshallJ.T.A., and WardK.A. (1993). Production of transgenic sheep. In Methods in Molecular Biology, Vol. 18, Transgenesis Techniques: Principles and Protocols (ed. MurphyD., CarterD.A.), pp. 273–304. Totowa, NJ, USA: Humana Press.
11.
HammerR.E., PurselV.G., RexroadC.E., WallR.J., BoltD.J., EbertK.M., PalmiterR.D., and BrinsterR.L. (1985). Production of transgenic rabbits, sheep and pigs by microinjection.Nature315, 680–683.
12.
VizeP.D., MichalskaA.E., AshmanR., LloydB., StoneB.A., QuinnP., WellsJ.R.E., and SeamarkR.F. (1988). Introduction of a porcine growth hormone fusion gene into transgenic pigs promotes growth.Journal of Cell Science90, 295–300.
13.
SugieT. (1965). Successful transfer of fertilised bovine eggs by non-surgical techniques.Journal of Reproduction and Fertility10, 197–201.
14.
KrimpenfortP., RademakersA., EyestoneW., van der SchansA., van der BroekS., KooimanP., KootwijkE., PlatenburgG., PieperF., SrtijkerR., & de BoerH. (1991). Generation of transgenic dairy cattle using in vitro embryo production.Biotechnology9, 844–847.
15.
HyttinenJ.M., PeuraT., TolvanenM., AaltoJ., AlhonenL., SinervirtaR., HalmekytoM., MyohanenS., & JänneJ. (1994). Generation of transgenic dairy cattle from transgene-analysed and sexed embryos produced in vitro.BioTechnology12, 606–608.
16.
OverbeekP. (1994). Factors affecting transgenic animal production. In Transgenic Animal Technology: A Laboratory Handbook (ed. PinkertC.A.), pp. 69–114. San Diego, CA, USA: Academic Press.
17.
BishopJ.O., and SmithP. (1989). Mechanism of chromosomal integration of microinjected DNA.Molecular Biology and Medicine6, 283–298.
18.
GalvinJ.M., KillianD.B., and StewartA.N.V. (1994). A procedure for successful non-surgical embryo transfer in swine.Theriogenology41, 1279–1289.
19.
EvansM.J., NotarianniE., LaurieS., and MoorR.M. (1990). Derivation and characterisation of pluripotent cell lines from porcine and bovine embryos.Theriogenology33, 125–128.
20.
PiedrahitaJ.A., AndersonG.B., and BonDurantR.H. (1990). On the isolation of embryonic stem cells: comparative behaviour of murine, porcine and ovine embryos.Theriogenology34, 879–901.
21.
EvansM.J., and KaufmanM.H. (1981). Establishment in culture of pluripotent cells from mouse embryos.Nature292, 154–156.
22.
MartinG.R. (1981). Isolation of a pluripotent cell line from early mouse embryos cultured in medium conditioned by teratocarcinoma stem cells.Proceedings of The National Academy of Sciences of The United States of America78, 7634–7638.
23.
ChuG., HayakanaH., and BergP. (1987). Electro-poration for the efficient transfection of mammalian cells with DNA.Nucleic Acids Research15, 1311–1326.
24.
SmithiesO., GreggR.G., BoggsS.S., KoralewskiM.A., and KucherlapatiR.S. (1985). Insertion of DNA sequences into the human chromosomal β-globin locus by homologous recombination.Nature317, 230–234.
25.
ThomasK.R., and CapecchiM.R. (1987). Site directed mutagenesis by gene targeting in mouse embryo-derived stem cells.Cell51, 503–512.
26.
WilmutI., HooperM.L., and SimonsJ.P. (1991). Genetic manipulation of mammals and its application in reproductive biology.Journal of Reproduction & Fertility92, 245–279.
27.
PurselV.G., & RexroadC.E.Jr. (1993). Status of research with transgenic farm animals.Journal of Animal Science71, Suppl. 3, 10–19.
28.
NicolasJ.F., and DelouisC. (1993). Transgenic animals: genetic manipulation of the germ line. In Reproduction in Mammals and Man (ed. ThibaultC., LevasseurM.C., HunterR.H.F.), pp. 757–778. Paris: Ellipses.
29.
BradleyA., HastyP., DavisA., & Ramirez-SolisR. (1992). Modifying the mouse: design and desire.BioTechnology10, 534–539.
30.
RobertsonE.J., and BradleyA. (1986). Permanent cell lines from early embryos. In Experimental Approaches to Mammalian Embryonic Development (ed. RossandJ., PedersenR.A.), pp. 475–508. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
31.
WellsD. (1993). Production of chimeras derived from murine embryonic stem cells. In Methods in Molecular Biology, Vol. 18, Transgenesis Techniques: Principles and Protocols (ed. MurphyD., CarterD.A.), pp. 217–238. Totowa, NJ, USA: Humana Press.
GordonJ.W. (1989). Transgenic animals.International Review of Cytology115, 171–229.
34.
CamperS.A., and TilghmanS.M. (1989). Postnatal repression of the α-fetoprotein gene is enhancer independent.Genes and Development3, 537–546.
35.
McMahonA.P., and BradleyA. (1990). The Wnt-1 (int-1) proto-oncogene is required for development of a large region of the mouse brain.Cell62, 1073–1085.
36.
PetersD.K. (1992). Animal experimentation and the future of medicine. In Animal Experimentation and the Future of Medical Research (ed. BottingJ.H.), pp. 5–12. London: Portland Press.
37.
SnouwaertJ.N., BrigmanK.K., LatourA.M., MaloufN.N., BoucherR.C., SmithiesO., and RollerB.H. (1992). An animal model for cystic fibrosis made by gene targeting.Science257, 1083–1088.
38.
ClarkeL.L., GrubB.R., GabrielS.E., SmithiesO., RollerB.H., and BoucherR.C. (1992). Defective epithelial chloride transport in a gene-targeted model of cystic fibrosis.Science257, 1125–1128.
39.
ColledgeW.H., RatcliffR., FosterD., WilliamsonR., and EvansM.J. (1992). Cystic fibrosis mouse with intestinal obstruction.The Lancet340, 680.
40.
DorinJ.R., DickinsonP., AltonE., SmithS.N., GeddesD.M., StevensonB.J., KimberW.L., FlemingS., ClarkeA.R., HooperM.L., AndersonL., BeddingtonR., and PorteusD.J. (1992). Cystic fibrosis in the mouse by targeted insertional mutagenesis.Nature359, 211–215.
41.
HydeS.C., GillD.R., HigginsC.F., TreziseA.E.O., MacVinishL.J., CuthbertA.W., RatcliffR., EvansM.J., and ColledgeW.H. (1993). Correction of the ion transport defect in cystic fibrosis transgenic mice by gene therapy.Nature362, 250–255.
42.
BørresenA-L., & LotheR.A. (1994). Cancer genes: from mouse to man.Animal Biotechnology5, 135–146.
DickmanS. (1989). Oncomouse seeks European protection.Nature340, 85.
45.
StewartT.A., PattengaleP.R., and LederP. (1984). Spontaneous mammary adenocarcinomas in transgene mice that carry and express MTV/myc fusion genes.Cell38, 627–637.
46.
FoxJ.L. (1993). Transgenic mice fall far short.BioTechnology11, 663.
47.
JamesA. (1993). Transplants with transgenic pig organs?The Lancet342, 45.
48.
ConcarD. (1994). The organ factory of the future?New Scientist142(1930), 24–29.
SimonsJ.P., WilmutI., ClarkA.J., ArchibaldA.L., BishopJ.O., and LatheR. (1988). Gene transfer into sheep.BioTechnology6, 179–183.
51.
ClarkA.J., BessosH., BishopJ.O., BrownP., HarrisS., LatheR., McClenaghanM., ProwseC., SimonsJ.P., WhitelawC.B.A., and WilmutI. (1989). Expression of human anti-hemophilic factor IX in the milk of transgenic sheep.BioTechnology7, 487–492.
52.
WrightG., CarverA., CottomD., ReevesD., ScottA., SimonsJ.P., WilmutI., GarnerI., and ColmanA. (1991). High level expression of active human α-1-antitrypsin in the milk of transgenic sheep.BioTechnology9, 830–834.
53.
ArchibaldA.A., McClenaghanM., HornseyV., SimonsJ.P., and ClarkA.J. (1990). High level expression of biologically active human α-l-anti-trypsin in the milk of transgenic mice.Proceedings of The National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America87, 5178–5182.
54.
CarverA.S., DalrympleM.A., WrightG., CottomD.S., ReevesD.B., GibsonY.H., KeenanJ.L., BarrassJ.D., ScottA.R., ColmanA., and GarnerI. (1993). Transgenic livestock as bio-reactors: stable expression of human α-l-anti-trypsin by a flock of sheep.BioTechnology11, 1263–1270.
55.
HallJ., AliS., SuraniM.A., HazlewoodG.P., ClarkA.J., SimonsJ.P., HirstB.H., and GilbertH.J. (1993). Manipulation of the repertoire of digestive enzymes secreted into the gastrointestinal tract of transgenic mice.BioTechnology11, 376–379.
56.
WardK.A., and NancarrowCD. (1991). The genetic engineering of production traits in domestic animals.Experientia47, 913–922.
57.
PalmiterR.D., BrinsterR.L., HammerR.E., TrumbauerM.E., RosenfeldM.G., BirnbergN.C., and EvansR.M. (1982). Dramatic growth of mice that develop from eggs microinjected with met-allothionein-growth hormone fusion genes.Nature300, 611–615.
58.
HammerR.E., PurselV.G., RexroadC.E.Jr., WallR.J., BoltD.J., EbertK.M., PalmiterR.D., and BrinsterR.L. (1985). Production of transgenic rabbits, sheep and pigs by microinjection.Nature315, 680–683.
59.
PurselV.G., PinkertC.A., MillerK.F., BoltD.J., CampbellR.G., PalmiterR.D., BrinsterR.L., and HammerR.E. (1989). Genetic engineering of livestock.Science244, 1281–1288.
60.
MurrayJ.D., NancarrowC.D., MarshallJ.T., HazeltonI.G., and WardK.A. (1989). Production of transgenic Merino sheep by microinjection of ovine metallothionein-ovine growth hormone fusion genes.Reproduction, Fertility & Development1, 147–155.
61.
MephamT.B. (1994). Transgenesis in farm animals: ethical implications for public policy.Politics and the Life Sciences13, 195–203.
62.
MüllerM., and BremG. (1991). Disease resistance in farm animals.Experientia47, 923–934.
63.
VerhogH. (1992). The concept of intrinsic value and transgenic animals.Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics5, 147–160.
64.
RollinB.E. (1986). The Frankenstein thing: the moral impact of genetic engineering of agricultural animals on society and future science. In Genetic Engineering of Animals: An Agricultural Perspective (ed. EvansJ.W., HollaenderA.), pp. 285–297. New York: Plenum Press.
65.
HollandA. (1995). Artificial lives: philosophical dimensions of farm animal biotechnology. In Issues in Agricultural Bioethics (ed. MephamT.B., TuckerG.A., & WisemanJ.). Nottingham: Nottingham University Press, in press.
66.
van ReenenC.G., and BlokhuisH.J. (1993). Investigating welfare of dairy calves involved in genetic modification: problems and perspectives.Livestock Production Science36, 81–90.
67.
GridleyT., SorianoP., and JaenischR. (1987). Insertional mutagenesis in mice.Trends in Genetics3, 162–166.
68.
WilmutI. (1995). Modification of farm animals by genetic engineering and immunomodulation. In Issues in Agricultural Bioethics (ed. MephamT.B., TuckerG.A., WisemanJ.). Nottingham: Nottingham University Press, in press.
69.
MarkW.H., SignorelliK., and LacyE. (1985). An insertional mutation in a transgenic mouse line results in developmental arrest at day 5 of gestation.Cold Spring Harbor Symposium on Quantitative BiologyL, 453–463.
70.
WoychikR.P., StewartT.A., DavisL.G., D'EustachioP., and LederP. (1985). An inherited limb deformity created by insertional mutagenesis in a transgenic mouse.Nature318, 36–40.
71.
CovarrubiasL., NishidaY., and MintzB. (1986). Early post-implantation embryo lethality due to DNA arrangements in a transgenic mouse strain.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America83, 6020–6024.
72.
BrinsterR.L., BraunR.E., LoD., AverbockM.R., and OramF. (1989). Targeted correction of a major histocompatability class II Ea gene by DNA microinjection into mouse eggs.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America86, 7087–7091.
73.
StrohmanR. (1994). Epigenesis: the missing beat in biotechnology.BioTechnology12, 156–164.
74.
KohnM. (1994). Stretched genes (interview with Dr K.A. Ward).The Observer: Life Supplement (6th March), 4–6.
75.
Al ShawiR., KinnairdJ., BurkeJ., and BishopJ.O. (1990). Expression of a foreign gene in a line of transgenic mice is modulated by chromosomal position effect.Molecular and Cellular Biology10, 1192–1198.
76.
WilmutI., and ClarkA.J. (1991). Basic techniques for transgenesis.Journal of Reproduction and Fertility43, 265–275.
77.
SeamarkR.F. (1993). Recent advances in animal biotechnology: welfare and ethical implications.Livestock Production Science36, 5–15.
78.
ShamayA., PurselV.G., WilkinsonE., WallR.J., and HennighausenL. (1992). Expression of whey acidic protein in transgenic pigs impairs mammary development.Transgenic Research1, 124–132.
79.
GrosveldF., Blom van AssendelftG., GreavesD.R., and KolliasG. (1987). Position independent high-level expression of the human β-globin gene in transgenic mice.Cell51, 975–985.
80.
GroenenM.A.M., & van der PoelJ.J. (1994). Regulation and expression of milk protein genes: a review.Livestock Production Science38, 61–78.
81.
RexroadC.E.Jr., WallR.J. (1987). Development of one-cell fertilised sheep ova following microinjection into pronuclei.Theriogenology27, 611–619.
82.
GagnéM., and SirardM. (1990). Nuclear injection of bovine oocytes after in vitro maturation.Journal of Reproduction & Fertility, Suppl. 41, 211–212.
83.
NiemannH., and ReicheltB. (1993). Manipulating early pig embryos.Journal of Reproduction & Fertility, Suppl. 48, 75–94.
84.
LemmeE., EckertJ., CarnwathJ.W., and NiemannH. (1994). Expression of 6WTK-Lac Z gene construct in in vitro produced bovine embryos following microinjection into pronuclei or cytoplasm.Theriogenology41, 236.
85.
HajduM.A., KnightJ.W., CansecoR.S., KrisherR.L., JohnsonJ.L., VelanderW.H., PearsonR.E., and GwazdauskasF.C. (1994). Effect of culture conditions, donor source and injection site on in vitro development of DNA injected porcine zygotes.Theriogenology41, 211.
86.
HillK.G., CurryJ., De MayoF.J., Jones-DillerK., SlapakJ.R., and BondioliK.R. (1992). Production of transgenic cattle by pronuclear injection.Theriogenology37, 222.
87.
BroomD.M. (1993). Assessing the welfare of modified or treated animals.Livestock Production Science36, 39–54.
88.
SeamarkR.F. (1993). Recent advances in animal biotechnology: welfare and ethical implications.Livestock Production Science36, 5–15.
