Details of the major pathways of metabolism have been elucidated, in large measure through work on experimental animals. It is unlikely that they differ qualitatively between mammalian species. The more important challenge facing researchers today is that of metabolic regulation, and of the integrated control of metabolic pathways in the whole organism. These aspects may well differ quantitatively or even qualitatively between species. In this review, methods for studying metabolism and metabolic regulation in humans are described. There are both scientific and practical advantages to performing studies of metabolic regulation in humans. The scientific advantages are clear from some fundamental differences in metabolic regulation between rats and humans, such as the importance of de novo lipogenesis to the deposition of body fat, and the metabolism of atherogenic triacylglycerol-rich lipoproteins. The practical advantages result mainly from the size of a human compared with that of most laboratory animals, enabling large blood samples to be obtained, and several measurement techniques to be applied at one time. Reasons for the persistence of animal experimentation as the norm, rather than the exception, among life science researchers are discussed.
KleiberM. (1961). The Fire of Life: An Introduction to Animal Energetics.Davis: John Wiley & Sons.
2.
HolmesF.L. (1974). Claud Bernard and Animal Chemistry: The Emergence of a Scientist.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
3.
LuskG. (1928). The Elements of the Science of Nutrition, 4th edn.Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders.
4.
FraynK.N. (1983). Calculation of substrate oxidation rates in vivo from gaseous exchange.Journal of Applied Physiology55, 628–634.
5.
FarranniniE. (1988). The theoretical bases of indirect calorimetry: a review.Metabolism37, 287–301.
6.
SimonsonD.C., & DeFronzoR.A. (1990). Indirect calorimetry: methodological and interpretative problems.American Journal of Physiology258, E399–E412.
7.
DeFronzoR.A., TobinJ., & AndresR. (1979). Glucose clamp technique: a method for quantifying insulin secretion and resistance.American Journal of Physiology237, E214–E223.
8.
WhiteR.H., FraynK.N., LittleR.A., ThrelfallC.J., StonerH.B., & IrvingM.H. (1987). Hormonal and metabolic responses to glucose infusion in sepsis studied by the hyperglycemic glucose clamp technique.Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition11, 345–353.
9.
RizzaR.A., MandarinoL.J., & GerichJ.E. (1981). Dose-response characteristics for effects of insulin on production and utilization of glucose in man.American Journal of Physiology240, E630–E639.
10.
ShipleyR.A., & ClarkR.E. (1972). Tracer Methods for In Vivo Kinetics: Theory and Applications.New York: Academic Press.
11.
WolfeR.R. (1984). Tracers in Metabolic Research: Radioisotope and Stable Isotope/Mass Spectrometry Methods.New York: Alan R. Liss, Inc.
12.
UmplebyA.M.S., & SönksenP.H. (1987). Measurement of the turnover of substrates of carbohydrate and protein metabolism using radioactive isotopes.Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism1, 773–796.
13.
BierD.M. (1987). The use of stable isotopes in metabolic investigation.Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism1, 817–836.
14.
ZierlerK.L. (1976). Fatty acids as substrates for heart and skeletal muscle.Circulation Research38, 459–463.
15.
AndresR., CaderG., & ZierlerK.L. (1956). The quantitatively minor role of carbohydrate in oxidative metabolism by skeletal muscle in intact man in the basal state. Measurements of oxygen and glucose uptake and carbon dioxide and lactate production in the forearm.Journal of Clinical Investigation35, 671–682.
16.
BaltzanM.A., AndresR., CaderG., & ZierlerK.L. (1962). Heterogeneity of forearm metabolism with special reference to free fatty acids.Journal of Clinical Investigation41, 116–125.
17.
GreenfieldA.D.M., WhitneyR.J., & MowbrayJ.F. (1963). Methods for the investigation of peripheral blood flow.British Medical Bulletin19, 101–109.
18.
ButlerP.C., & HomeP.D. (1987). The measurement of metabolite exchange across muscle beds.Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism1, 863–878.
19.
DeFronzoR.A. (1987). Use of the splanchnic/ hepatic balance technique in the study of glucose metabolism.Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism1, 837–862.
20.
WhiteJ.J., & DupréJ. (1968). Regulation of insulin secretion by the intestinal hormone, secretin: studies in man via transumbilical portal vein catheterization.Surgery64, 204–213.
21.
OwenO.E., MorganA.P., KempH.G., SullivanJ.M., HererraM.G., & CahillG.F. (1967). Brain metabolism during fasting.Journal of Clinical Investigation46, 1589–1595.
22.
AulickL.H., GoodwinC.W., BeckerR.A., & WilmoreD.W. (1981). Visceral blood flow following thermal injury.Annals of Surgery193, 112–116.
23.
FraynK.N., CoppackS.W., HumphreysS.M., & WhyteP.L. (1989). Metabolic characteristics of human adipose tissue in vivo.Clinical Science76, 509–516.
24.
HendersonA.A., FraynK.N., GalaskoC.S.B., & LittleR.A. (1991). Dose-response relationships for the effects of insulin on glucose and fat metabolism in injured patients and control subjects.Clinical Science80, 25–32.
25.
EdwardsR.H.T., RoundJ.M., & JonesD.A. (1983). Needle biopsy of skeletal muscle: a review of 10 years experience.Muscle and Nerve6, 676–683.
26.
HirschJ., & GoldrickR.B. (1964). Serial studies on the metabolism of human adipose tissue. I. Lipogenesis and free fatty acid uptake and release in small aspirated samples of subcutaneous fat.Journal of Clinical Investigation43, 1776–1792.
27.
TaylorR. (1987). Use of adipose tissue for metabolic studies.Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism1, 1023–1035.
28.
BearnA.G., BillingB.H., & SherlockS. (1951). Hepatic glucose output and hepatic insulin sensitivity in diabetes mellitus.Lancet2, 698–701.
29.
NilssonL.H., & HultmanE. (1973). Liver glycogen in man: the effect of total starvation or a carbohydrate-poor diet followed by carbohydrate refeeding.Scandinavian Journal of Clinical and Laboratory Investigation32, 325–330.
30.
IlesR.A., & CohenR.D. (1987). NMR as a metabolic tool.Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism1, 937–966.
31.
ShulmanG.I., RothmanD.L., JueT., SteinP., DeFronzoR.A., & ShulmanR.G. (1990). Quantitation of muscle glycogen synthesis in normal subjects and subjects with non-insulin-dependent diabetes by [13C]-nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy.New England Journal of Medicine322, 223–228.
32.
KingR.F.G.J., AlmondD.J., OxbyC.B., HolmfieldJ.H.M., & McMahonM.J. (1984). Calculation of short-term changes in body fat from measurement of respiratory gas exchange.Metabolism33, 826–832.
33.
AchesonK.J., FlattJ.P., & JéquierE. (1982). Glycogen synthesis versus lipogenesis after a 500g carbohydrate meal in man.Metabolism31, 1234–1240.
34.
AchesonK.J., SchutzY., BessardT., RavussinE.J., JéquierE., & FlattJ.P. (1984). Nutritional influences on lipogenesis and thermogenesis after a carbohydrate meal.American Journal of Physiology246, E62–E70.
35.
SoutarA.K. (1989). Second receptor verified?Nature341, 106–107.
36.
FerreriL.F. (1984). Fractionation of plasma lipoproteins: evaluation of preparative methods. In Lipid Research Methodology (ed. StoryJ.A.), pp. 133–156. New York: Alan R. Liss, Inc.
37.
GibbonsG.F. (1990). Assembly and secretion of hepatic very-low-density lipoprotein.Biochemical Journal268, 1–13.
38.
PottsJ.L., FisherR.M., CoppackS.W., GibbonsG.F., & FraynK.N. (1990). Lipoprotein interconversions during passage through subcutaneous adipose tissue in humans in vivo.Biochemical Society Trasactions18, 1196–1197.
39.
CoppackS.W., FisherR.M., GibbonsG.F., HumphreysS.M., McDonoughM.J., PottsJ.L., & FraynK.N. (1990). Postpradial substrate deposition in human forearm and adipose tissues in vivo.Clinical Science79, 339–348.
40.
Medical Research Council (1964). Responsibility in investigations on human subjects.British Medical Journalii, 178–180.
41.
WarnockM. (1988). A national ethics committee.British Medical Journal297, 1626–1627.
42.
FraynK.N. (1991). Insulin resistance in obesity and in wasting disorders. In Obesity and Cachexia: Physiological Mechanisms and New Approaches to Pharmacological Control (ed. StockM.J., and RothwellN.J.), Chichester: John Wiley & Sons Limited (in press).
