Alternatives to the Draize rabbit eye irritation test are currently being investigated. Because of morphological and biochemical differences between the rabbit and the human eye, continuous human cell lines have been proposed for use in ocular toxicology studies. Single cell-type monolayer cultures in culture medium have been used extensively in ocular toxicology. In the present study, an SV40-immortalised human corneal epithelial (HCE) cell line was characterised immunohistochemically, by using 13 different monoclonal antibodies to cytokeratins (CKs), ranging from CK3 to CK20. The results from the monolayer HCE cell cultures were compared with those from the corneal epithelium of human corneal cryostat sections. Previous studies have shown that the morphology of the HCE cell is similar to that of primary cultured human corneal epithelial cells, and that the cells express the cornea-specific CK3. In the study reported here, we show that the cell line also expresses CKs 7, 8, 18 and 19. These CKs are typically expressed by simple epithelial cells, and are not found in the human cornea in vivo. Therefore, the monolayer HCE cell line grown in culture medium does not express the CK pattern that is typical of human corneal epithelium. This should be taken into consideration when using HCE cell cultures in similar single cell-type experiments for ocular toxicology.
DraizeJ.H., WoodardG., & CalveryH.O. (1944). Methods for the study of irritation and toxicity of substances applied topically to the skin and mucous membranes. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics82, 377–390.
2.
WeilC.S., & ScalaR.A. (1971). Study of intra- and interlaboratory variability in the results of rabbit eye and skin irritation tests. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology19, 276–360.
3.
SharpeR. (1985). The Draize test – motivations for change. Food and Chemical Toxicology23, 139–143.
4.
SwanstonD.W. (1985). Assessment of the validity of animal techniques in eye-irritation testing. Food and Chemical Toxicology23, 169–173.
5.
FrazierJ.M., GadS.C., GoldbergA.M., & McCulleyJ.P. (1987). A Critical Evaluation of Alternatives to Acute Ocular Irritation Testing, Vol. 4, 136 pp. New York, NY, USA: Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
6.
EarlL.K., DickensA.D., & RowsonM.J. (1997). A critical analysis of the rabbit eye irritation test variability and its impact on validation of alternative methods. Toxicology in Vitro11, 295–304.
7.
YorkM., & SteilingW. (1998). A critical review of the assessment of eye irritation potential using the Draize rabbit eye test. Journal of Applied Toxicology18, 233–240.
8.
WilhelmusK.R. (2001). The Draize eye test. Survey of Ophthalmology45, 493–515.
9.
DoughmanD.J. (1980). Prolonged donor cornea preservation in organ culture: long-term clinical evaluation. Transactions of the American Ophthalmological Society78, 567–628.
10.
RichardN.R., AnderssonJ.A., WeissJ.L., & BinderP.S. (1991). Air/liquid corneal organ culture: a light microscopic study. Current Eye Research10, 739–749.
11.
SunT.T., & GreenH. (1978). Immunofluorescent staining of keratin fibers in cultured cells. Cell14, 469–476.
12.
EbatoB., FriendJ., & ThoftR.A. (1987). Comparison of central and peripheral human corneal epithelium in tissue culture. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science28, 1450–1456.
13.
NiederkomJ.Y., MeyerD.R., UbelakerJ.E., & MartinJ.H. (1990). Ultrastructural and immunohistological characterisation of the SIRC corneal cell line. In Vitro Cellular and Developmental Biology26, 923–930.
14.
ArakiA., OhashiY., SasabeT., KinoshitaS., HayashiK., YangX.Z., HosakaY., AizawaS., & HandaH. (1993). Immortalization of rabbit corneal epithelial cells by a recombinant SV40 adenovirus vector. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science34, 2665–2671.
15.
Castro-MunozledoF. (1994). Development of a spontaneous permanent cell line of rabbit corneal epithelial cells that undergoes sequential stages of differentiation in cell culture. Journal of Cell Science107, 2343–2351.
16.
OkamotoS., OhjiM., KosakuK., SundarrajN., HassellJ.R., ThoftR.A., & PipasJ.M. (1995). Characterization of immortalized rabbit corneal epithelial cells with SV40 large T antigen. Japanese Journal of Ophthalmology39, 323–333.
17.
ArakiK., SasabeT., OhashiY., YasudaM., HandaH., & TanoY. (1994). Immortalization of rat corneal epithelial cell line by SV40-adenovirus recombinant vector. Nippon Ganka Gakkai Zasshi98, 327–333.
18.
JozwiakJ., SkopinskiP., KomarA., WojcikA., & MalejczykJ. (2001). Characterization of epithelial cell line from rat cornea. Eye15, 82–88.
19.
KahnC.R., YoungE., LeeI.H., & RhimJ.S. (1993). Human corneal epithelial primary cultures and cell lines with extended life span: in vitro model for ocular studies. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science34, 3429–3441.
20.
Araki-SasakiK., OhashiY., SasabeT., HayashiK., WatanabeH., TanoY., & HandaH. (1995). An SV40-immortalized human corneal epithelial cell line and its characterization. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science36, 614–621.
21.
HalendaR.M., GrevanV.L., HookR.R., & RileyL.K. (1998). An immortalized hamster corneal epithelial cell line for studies of the pathogenesis of Acanthamoeba keratitis. Current Eye Research17, 225–230.
22.
MasonD.Y., AbdulazizZ., FaliniB., & SteinH. (1983). Double immunoenzymatic labeling. In Immunocytochemistry, Practical Applications in Pathology and Biology (ed. PolakJ.M., & van NoordenS.), pp. 113–128. Bristol, UK: John Wright and Sons.
23.
MollR., FrankeW.W., SchillerD.L., GeigerB., & KreplerR. (1982). The catalog of human cytokeratins: patterns of expression in normal epithelia, tumors and cultured cells. Cell31, 11–24.
24.
OsbornM. (1983). Intermediate filaments as histologic markers: an overview. Journal of Investigative Dermatology81, 1045–1049.
25.
TsengS.C., JarvinenM.J., NelsonW.G., HuangJ.W., Woodcock-MitchellJ., & SunT.T. (1982). Correlation of specific keratins with different types of epithelial differentiation: Monoclonal antibody studies. Cell30, 361–372.
26.
SunT.T., EichnerR., SchermerA., CooperD., NelsonW.G., & WeissR.A. (1984). Classification, expression, and possible mechanisms of evolution of mammalian keratins: a unifying model. In Cancer Cells, Vol I. The Transformed Phenotype (ed. LevineA., ToopW., Van de WoudeG., & WatsonJ.D.), pp. 169–176. Cold Spring Harbor, NY, USA: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory.
27.
CooperD., SchermerA., & SunT.T. (1985). Classification of human epithelia and their neoplasms using monoclonal antibodies to keratins: strategies, applications, and limitations. Laboratory Investigation52, 243–256.
28.
SchermerA., GalvinS., & SunT.T. (1986). Differentiation-related expression of a major 64K corneal keratin in vivo and in culture suggests limbal location of corneal epithelial stem cells. Journal of Cell Biology103, 49–62.
29.
KasperM., MollR., StosiekP., & KarstenU. (1988). Patterns of cytokeratin and vimentin expression in the human eye. Histochemistry89, 369–377.
30.
BarnardZ., ApelA.J., & HarkinD.G. (2001). Phenotypic analyses of limbal epithelial cell cultures derived from donor corneoscleral rims. Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology29, 138–142.
31.
MollR., LoweA., LauferJ., & FrankeW.W. (1992). Cytokeratin 20 in human carcinomas. A new histodiagnostic marker detected by monoclonal antibodies. American Journal of Pathology140, 427–447.
32.
ChaloindufauC., PavittI., DelormeP., & DhouaillyD. (1993). Identification of keratin 3 and keratin 12 in corneal epithelium of vertebrates. Epithelial Cell Biology2, 120–125.
33.
KurpakusM.A., StockE.L., & JonesJ.C. (1990). Expression of the 55-kD/64-kD corneal keratins in ocular surface epithelium. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science31, 448–456.
34.
KasperM., StosiekP., & LaneE.B. (1992). Cytokeratin and vimentin heterogeneity in human cornea. Acta Histochemica93, 371–381.
35.
NishidaK., AdachiW., Shimizu-MatsumotoA., KinoshitaS., MizunoK., MatsubaraK., & OkuboK. (1996). A gene expression profile of corneal epithelium and the isolation of human keratin 12 cDNA. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science37, 1800–1809.
36.
WileyL., SundarRajN., SunT.T., & ThoftR.A. (1991). Regional heterogeneity in human corneal and limbal epithelia: an immunohistochemical evaluation. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science32, 594–602.
37.
RamaekersF., van NiekerkC., PoelsL., SchaafsmaE., HuijsmansA., RobbenH., SchaartG., & VooijsP. (1990). Use of monoclonal antibodies to keratin 7 in the differential diagnosis of adenocarcinomas. American Journal of Pathology136, 641–655.
38.
WuY.J., ParkerL.M., BinderN.E., BeckettM.A., SinardJ.H., GriffithsC.T., & RheinwaldJ.G. (1982). The mesothelial keratins: a new family of cytoskeletal proteins identified in cultured mesothelial cells and nonkeratinising epithelia. Cell31, 693–703.
39.
van der VeldenL.A., SchaafsmaH.E., ManniJ.J., RamaekersF.C.S., & KuijpersW. (1993). Cytokeratin expression in normal and (pre)malignant head and neck epithelia: an overview. Head and Neck15, 133–146.
40.
FrankeW.W., SchillerD.L., MollR., WinterS., SchmidE., EngelbrechtI., DenkH., KreplerR., & PlatzerB. (1981). Diversity of cytokeratins. Differentiation specific expression of cytokeratin polypeptides in epithelial cells and tissues. Journal of Molecular Biology153, 933–959.
41.
FrankeW.W., DenkH., KaltR., & SchmidE. (1981). Biochemical and immunological identification of cytokeratin proteins present in hepatocytes of mammalian liver tissue. Experimental Cell Research131, 299–318.
42.
FrankeW.W., MayerD., SchmidE., DenkH., & BorenfreundE. (1981). Differences of expression of cytoskeletal proteins in cultured rat hepatocytes and hepatoma cells. Experimental Cell Research134, 345–365.
43.
SuR.T., & ChangY.C. (1989). Transformation of human epidermal cells by transfection with plasmid containing simian virus 40 DNA linked to a neomycin gene in a defined medium. Experimental Cell Research180, 117–133.
44.
Banks-SchlegelS.P., & HowleyP.M. (1983). Differentiation of human epidermal cells transformed by SV40. Journal of Cell Biology96, 330–337.
45.
BernardB.A., RobinsonS.M., SematA., & DarmonM. (1985). Re-expression of fetal characters in simian virus 40-transformed human keratinocytes. Cancer Research45, 1707–1716.
46.
BrownK.W., & GallimoreP.H. (1987). Malignant progression of an SV40-transformed human epidermal keratinocyte cell line. British Journal of Cancer56, 545–554.
47.
KamalatiT., McIvorZ., HowardM., GreenM.R., & BrooksR.F. (1989). Expression of markers of differentiation in a transformed human keratinocyte line induced by coculture with a fibroblast line. Experimental Cell Research185, 453–463.
48.
CukiermanE., PankovR., & YamanaK.M. (2002). Cell interactions with three-dimensional matrices. Current Opinion in Cell Biology14, 633–639.
49.
WardS.L., WalkerT.L., & DimitrijevichS.D. (1997). Evaluation of chemically induced toxicity using an in vitro model of human corneal epithelium. Toxicology in Vitro11, 121–139.
50.
OrwinE.J., & HubelA. (2000). In vitro culture characteristics of corneal epithelial, endothelial, and keratocyte cells in a native collagen matrix. Tissue Engineering6, 307–319.
51.
RezniczekG.A., de PeredaJ.M., ReipertS., & WicheG. (1998). Linking integrin α6β4-based cell adhesion to the intermediate filament cytoskeleton: direct interaction between the β4 subunit and plectin at multiple molecular sites. Journal of Cell Biology141, 209–225.
