Evaluation of a Rule Base for Identifying Contact Allergens by using a Regulatory Database: Comparison of Data on Chemicals Notified in the European Union with “Structural Alerts” Used in the DEREK Expert System

Abstract

To assess the suitability of the use of structural alerts to identify the skin-sensitising properties of chemicals, the 40 originally published structural alerts for the prediction of skin-sensitisation properties used by the DEREK system (which now contains 59 structural alerts), have been evaluated against a database developed in the German Federal Institute for Health Protection of Consumers and Veterinary Medicine (BgVV), which contains data submitted under the procedure for notifying new chemicals within the European Union. The evaluation of the 40 structural alerts used in DEREK revealed that eight of the 40 structural alerts for the prediction of skin-sensitising potential could be used without any further refinement. Ten structural alerts may need further specifications or refinements in order avoid false-positive predictions — proposals for refinement are discussed. Not enough substances were found within the BgVV database (containing data for more than 1000 substances) to evaluate ten of the DEREK substructures; hence, for these structural alerts, a judgement on their suitability for prediction of skin-sensitisation properties in expert systems is not possible. For 12 structural alerts, no comparative result could be obtained, because these rules did not “fire” for any of the examined chemicals. As a general result of the evaluation process, the approach of using structural alerts for the prediction of skin-sensitising properties of chemicals proved to be reliable. Proposals are given for a refinement of the structural alerts for prediction of contact allergy used in the DEREK system. In addition, advice and several preconditions are given, that apply when trying to teach a computer system to use structural alerts to predict toxicological properties.

Keywords

computer analysis of molecular formulae regulatory database prediction rules for expert systems skin sensitisation structure–property relationships

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Gerner

, Graetschel

, Kahl

, & Schlede

(2000). Development of a decision support system for the introduction of alternative methods into local irritation/corrosion testing strategies: development of a relational data base. ATLA 28, 11–28.

EEC (1992). Commission Directive 92/32/EEC of 30 April 1992 amending for the seventh time Directive 67/548/EEC on the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions relating to the classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances. Official Journal of the European Communities L154, 1–28.

Zinke

, Gerner

, Graetschel

, & Schlede

(2000). Local irritation/corrosion testing strategies: development of a decision support system for the introduction of alternative methods. ATLA 28, 29–40.

Barratt

M.D.

, Castell

J.V.

, Chamberlain

, Combes

R.D.

, Dearden

J.C.

, Fentem

J.H.

, Gerner

, Giuliani

, Gray

T.J.B.

, Livingstone

D.J.

, Provan

W.M.

, Rutten

F.A.J.J.L.

, Verhaar

H.J.M.

, & Zbinden

(1995). The integrated use of alternative approaches for predicting toxic hazard. The report and recommendations of ECVAM workshop 8. ATLA 23, 410–429.

OECD (1996). Final Report of the OECD Workshop on Harmonization of Validation and Acceptance Criteria for Alternative Toxicological Test Methods, ENV/MC/CHEM/TG(96)9, 60 pp. Paris, France: OECD.

de Silva

, Cottin

, Dami

, Roguet

, Catroux

, Toufic

, Sicard

, Dossou

K.G.

, Gerner

, Schlede

, Spielmann

, Gupta

K.C.

, & Hill

R.N.

(1997). Evaluation of eye irritation potential: statistical analysis and tier testing strategies. Food and Chemical Toxicology 35, 159–164.

Gerner

, & Schlede

(2002). Introduction of in vitro data into local irritation/corrosion testing strategies by means of SAR considerations: assessment of chemicals. Toxicology Letters 127, 169–175.

Commission of the European Communities (2000). Commission Directive 2000/33/EC of 25 April 2000 adapting to technical progress for the 27th time Council Directive 67/548/EEC on the approximation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions relating to the classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances. Annex I. B.40. Skin corrosion. Official Journal of the European Communities L136, 90–97.

National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS) (2001). Report of the international workshop on in vitro methods for assessing acute systemic toxicity, guidance document on using in vitro data to estimate in vivo starting doses for acute toxicity, notice of availability and request for public comment. Web site: http://ntp-server.niehs.nih.gov/htdocs/Liason/NICEATMIVWkspRpt_FR.html (Accessed 28.9.2001).

10.

Gospos

, Dreikhausen

, Dartsch

D.C.

, Szamel

, & Hockertz

(2001). Development of an allergy test model: activation of human mast cells with potentially allergenic substances. Toxicology 166, 91–96.

11.

Barratt

M.D.

, Basketter

D.A.

, Chamberlain

, Admans

G.D.

, & Langowski

J.J.

(1994). An expert system rulebase for identifying contact allergens. Toxicology in Vitro 8, 1053–1060.

12.

Sanderson

D.M.

, & Earnshaw

C.G.

(1991). Computer prediction of possible toxic action from chemical structure: the DEREK system. Human and Experimental Toxicology 10, 261–273.

13.

Magnusson

, & Kligman

A. M.

(1970). Allergic Contact Dermatitis in the Guinea-pig: Identification of Contact Allergens, 141 pp. Springfield, IL, USA: Charles C. Thomas Publisher.

14.

Barratt

M.D.

, & Langowski

J.J.

(1999). Validation and subsequent development of the DEREK skin sensitization rulebase by analysis of the BgVV list of contact allergens. Journal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences 39, 294–298.

15.

Barratt

M.D.

, & Langowski

J.J.

(2000). Validation and development of the DEREK skin sensitisation rulebase by analysis of the BgVV list of contact allergens. In Progress in the Reduction, Refinement and Replacement of Animal Experimentation (ed. Balls

, van Zeller

A-M.

, & Halder

M.E.

), pp. 493–512. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier Science,.

16.

Kayser

, & Schlede

eds (1997). Chemikalien und Kontaktallergie — Eine bewertende Zusammenstellung. Munich, Germany: MMV Medizin Verlag. The final update was published at the end of 2001 — Munich, Germany: Urban & Vogel Medien und Medizin Verlagsgesellschaft (ISBN 3–86094-163).

17.

Zinke

, & Gerner

(2000). A computer-based structure–activity relationship method for predicting the toxic effects of organic chemicals from one-dimensional representations of their molecular structures. ATLA 28, 609–620.

18.

Gerner

, Zinke

, Graetschel

, & Schlede

(2000). Development of a decision support system for the introduction of alternative methods into local irritancy/corrosivity testing strategies: creation of fundamental rules for a decision support system. ATLA 28, 665–698.

19.

EEC (1983). Commission Directive of 29 July 1983 adapting to technical progress for the fifth time Directive 67/548/EEC on the approximation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions relating to the classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances. Annex V. Official Journal of the European Communities L257, 1–33.

20.

Zinke

, & Gerner

(2000). Local irritation/corrosion testing strategies: extending a decision support system by applying self-learning classifiers. ATLA 28, 651–663.