In Vitro Assessment of Cytotoxicity and Carcinogenic Potential of Chemicals: Evaluation of the Cytotoxicity Induced by 58 Metal Compounds in the Balb/3T3 Cell Line
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online September, 2001
In Vitro Assessment of Cytotoxicity and Carcinogenic Potential of Chemicals: Evaluation of the Cytotoxicity Induced by 58 Metal Compounds in the Balb/3T3 Cell Line
A new, mechanistically based, in vitro strategy involving Balb/c 3T3 clone A31-1-1 mouse embryo fibroblasts has been proposed for the determination of the carcinogenic potential of inorganic chemicals, in order to establish priority of metal compounds to be tested and, whenever possible, to compare the in vitro results with the corresponding in vivo data. As a first step in this research, this study reports on the cytotoxic effects of 58 metal compounds in the Balb/3T3 cell line. After harmonisation and standardisation of the Balb/3T3 protocol, cells were exposed for 72 hours to a fixed dose (100μM) of 58 individual compounds. The cytotoxicity induced by some metal compounds was found to be related to their chemical form (for example, Cr(NO3)3 and Na2CrO4), suggesting that the Balb/3T3 cell line is a valuable cellular model in relation to this aspect of metal speciation. The results of the systematic study on the metal-induced cytotoxic effects in the Balb/3T3 cell line could be arbitrarily classified into three groups according to the degree of cytotoxicity. Group I includes 26 species that induced no observable effect or only a slight cytotoxic effect; Group II includes 13 metal compounds that exhibited an obvious degree of cytotoxicity; and Group III includes 19 metal species that displayed a strong cytotoxic response. Metal compounds of Groups II and III are considered to be of the highest priority for setting of dose–effect relationships for a subsequent in vitro study on metal-induced concurrent cytotoxicity and morphological transformation in the Balb/3T3 cell line.
LeonardA., GerberG.B., JacquetP., & LauwerysR.R. (1984). Carcinogenicity, mutagenicity and teratogenicity of industrially used metals. In Mutagenicity, Carcinogenicity and Teratogenicity of Industrial Pollutants (ed. Kirsh-VoldersM.), pp. 59–126. New York, NY, USA: Plenum Press.
2.
SundermanF.W.Jr. (1978). Carcinogenic effects of metals. Federation Proceedings64, 40–46.
3.
IARC (2001). IARC monographs on the evaluation of carcinogenic risks to humans and their supplements: a complete list. In Programme on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans. Al: (1987) suppl. 7, p. 89; As: (1987) suppl. 7, p. 100; Be: (1993) vol. 58, p. 41; Cd: (1993) vol. 58, p. 119; Cr(VI): (1990) vol. 49, p. 49; Ni: (1990) vol. 49, p. 257; cis-Pt: (1987) suppl. 7, p. 170; Co: (1991) vol. 52, p. 363; Pb: (1987) suppl. 7, p. 230; Methyl-Hg: (1993) vol. 58, p. 239; Sb: (1989) vol. 47, p. 291; metallic Ni: (1990) vol. 49. http://193.51.164.
4.
YamasakiH., MesnilM., & NakazawaH. (1992). Interaction and distinction of genotoxic and non-genotoxic events in carcinogenesis. Toxicology Letters64/65, 597–604.
5.
CombesR., BallsM., CurrenR., FischbachM., FusenigN., KirklandD., LasneC., LandolphJ., Le BoeufR., MarquardtH., McCormickJ., MüllerL., RivedalE., SabbioniE., TanakaN., VasseurP., & YamasakiH. (1999). Cell transformation assays as predictors of human carcinogenicity. The conclusions and recommendations of ECVAM Workshop 39. ATLA27, 745–767.
6.
MatthewsE.J., SpaldingJ.W., & TennantR.W. (1993). Transformation of Balb/c 3T3 cells. I V. Rank-ordered potency of 24 chemical responses detected in a sensitive new assay procedure. Environmental Health Perspectives101, Suppl. 2, 319–345.
7.
DiPaoloJ.A., & CastoB.C. (1979). Quantitative studies of in vitro morphological transformation of Syrian hamster cells by inorganic metal salts. Cancer Research39, 1008–1013.
8.
BertoleroF., PozziG., SabbioniE., & SaffiottiU. (1987). Cellular uptake and metabolic reduction of pentavalent to trivalent arsenic as determinants of cytotoxicity and morphological transformation. Carcinogenesis8, 803–807.
9.
SabbioniE., PozziG., PintarA., CasellaL., & GarattiniS. (1991). Cellular retention, cytotoxicity and morphological transformation by vanadium(IV) in Balb/3T3 cell lines. Carcinogenesis12, 47–52.
10.
Le BoeufR.A., KerckaertG.A., AardemaM.J., GibsonD.P., BrauningerR., & IsfortR.J. (1996). The pH 6.7 Syrian hamster embryo cell transformation assay for assessing the carcinogenic potential of chemicals. Mutation Research356, 85–127.
11.
LandolphJ.R. (1994). Molecular mechanisms of transformation of C3H/10T½ C1 8 mouse embryo cells and diploid human fibroblasts by carcinogenic metal compounds. Environmental Health Perspectives102, Suppl. 3, 119–125.
12.
SabbioniE., BallsM., PietraR., & FortanerS. (1999). The IMETOX project (In Vitro MEtal TOXicology). ATLA27, Special Issue, 107.
13.
FentemJ.H., & BallsM. (1997). Application of the Three Rs in toxicology. Comments on Toxicology6, 5–20.
14.
BallsM., BlaauboerB.J., FentemJ.H., BrunerL., CombesR.D., EkwallB., FielderR.J., GuillouzoA., LewisR.W., LovellD.P., ReinhardtC.A., RepettoG., S·ladowskiD., SpielmannH., & ZuccoF. (1995). Practical aspects of the validation of toxicity test procedures. The conclusions and recommendations of ECVAM Workshop 5, ATLA23, 129–147.
15.
DiPaoloJ.A., TakanoK., & PopescuN.C. (1972). Quantitation of chemically induced neoplastic transformation of Balb/3T3 cloned cell lines. Cancer Research32, 2686–2695.
16.
MazzottiF. (1999). Cellular Cultures as Alternative Methods to the Use of Animal Experiments for the Study of Transformation and Cytotoxicity of Trace Metals. Degree Thesis. S.P.I. (Special Publication Ispra) No. I.99.71, 110 pp. Ispra, Italy: European Commission Joint Research Centre.
17.
SpielmannH., & LiebschM. (2000). INVITTOX Protocol Number 46. The cytotoxicity effect of chemicals upon Balb/c 3T3 cells in culture is measured by cell viability (neutral red uptake) and total cell protein (kenacid blue R dye binding method).ECVAM SIS databank.http://ecvam.sis.jrc.it.
18.
MatthewsE.J. (1990). Chemical-induced transformation in Balb/c-3T3 cells: relationship between in vitro transformation and cytotoxicity, carcinogenesis, and genotoxicity. Progress in Clinical and Biological Research340D, 229–238.
19.
TsuchiyaT., UmedaM., NishiyamaH., YoshimuraI., AjimiS., AsakuraM., BabaH., DewaY., EbeY., FushiwakiY., HamadaS., HamamuraM., IwaseY., KajiwaraY., KasaharaY., KawabataM., KitadaE., KuboK., MashikoK., MiuraD., MizuhashiF., MizunoF., NakajimaM., NakamuraY., NobeN., OishiH., OtaE., SakaiA., SatoM., ShimadaS., SugiyamaT., TakahashiC., TakedaY., TanakaN., ToyoizumiC., TsutsuiT., WakuriS., YajimaS., & YajimaN. (1999). An interlaboratory validation study of the improved transformation assay employing Balb/c 3T3 cells: results of a collaborative study on the two-stage cell transformation assay by the Nongenotoxic Carcinogen Study Group. ATLA27, 685–702.
20.
SabbioniE., PozziG., DevosS., PintarA., CasellaL., & FischbachM. (1993). The intensity of vanadium(V)-induced cytotoxicity and morphological transformation in Balb/3T3 cells is dependent on glutathione-mediated bioreduction to vanadium(IV). Carcinogenesis14, 2565–2568.
21.
BertoleroF., SabbioniE., EdelJ., & PietraR. (1987). Quantitative studies on cytotoxicity and neoplastic transformation of Balb/3T3 cells by trace metals. In Occupational & Environmental Chemical Hazards (ed. ColombiA., EnnetE.A., FoàV., & MaroniM.), pp. 478–483. Chichester, UK: Elliss Horwood.
22.
DiPaoloJ.A., & CastoB.C. (1979). Quantitative studies of in vitro morphological transformation of Syrian hamster cells by inorganic metal salts. Cancer Research39, 1008–1013.
23.
RivedalE., & SannerT. (1981). Metal salts as promoters of in vitro morphological transformation of hamster embryo cells initiated by benzo(a)pyrene. Cancer Research41, 2950–2953.
24.
EliasZ., PoirotO., PezeratH., SuquetH., SchneiderO., DanierM.C., TerzettiF., BaruthioF., FournierM., & CavelierC. (1989). Cytotoxic and neoplastic transforming effects of industrial hexavalent chromium pigments in Syrian hamster embryo cells. Carcinogenesis10, 2043–2052.
25.
RivedalE., RosengL.E., & SannerT. (1990). Vanadium compounds promote the induction of morphological transformation of hamster embryo cells with no effect on gap junctional cell communication. Cellular Biology and Toxicology6, 303–314.
26.
HulmeL.M., ReevesH.L., ClothierR.H., SmithM., & BallsM. (1987). Assessment of two alternative methods for predicting the in vivo toxicities of metallic compounds. Molecular Toxicology1, 589–596.
27.
SabbioniE., EndelJ., & GoetzL. (1985). Trace metal speciation in environmental toxicology research. Nutrition Research Suppl. 1, 32–43.
28.
HornerS.A., & ShahM.K. (1984). Effects of fungizone on the in vitro cytotoxicity of other chemicals. ATLA11, 147–153.
29.
IARC/NCI/EPA Working Group (1985). Cellular and molecular mechanisms of cell transformation and standardisation of transformation assays of established cell lines for the prediction of carcinogenic chemicals: overview and recommended protocols. Cancer Research45, 2395–2399.
