Sustainable social exclusion: the case of land-use planning and 'newer' travellers

Abstract

The last Conservative administration privatized the provision of sites for travellers by introducing the 1994 Criminal Justice and Public Order Act and the associated Circular 1/94, 'Gipsy Sites and Planning'. This article reproduces the results of a study of local planning authorities' responses to the needs of 'newer' travellers—those who apparently contradict preconceived ideas about 'gypsies'—and critically examines the results in the light of these travellers' experiences of the land-use planning system thus far. It finds that there is a distinct blindness to these travellers' requirements and suggests that this may have indeed been anticipated.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beale, A. and Geary, R. (1994) 'New Age Gypsies?', Solicitors Journal, 138(5): 112-13.

Bestic, L. (1994) 'Out of the b&b on to the Road', The Guardian, 22 March 1994.

Clements, L. (1994) 'The Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994' , Proceedings of the One Day Course on Gypsies and Sites: A Hard Road Ahead. . Oxford Brookes University, 15 March 1994

Clements, L. (1995) 'The Legal Implications'. Proceedings of Seminar on Gypsy Policy after the Criminal Justice and Public Order .Act. School for Advanced Urban Studies, Bristol University, 21-22 February 1995

Davis, J. , Grant, R. and Locke, A. (1994) Out of Site, Out of Mind: New Age Travellers and the Criminal Justice and Public Order Bill. The Children's Society.

Doe (1991) Gypsy Site Provision and Policy: Research Report London: HMSO.

Doe (1992) Reform of the Caravan Sites Act 1968. Consultation Paper. London: HMSO.

Doe (1993) Crackdown on Illegal Camping and Raves. News Release 237. London: HMSO.

Doe (1994) Gipsy Sites and Planning. Circular 1/94. London: HMSO.

10.

Doe (1995) 'The National Dimension: The Role of the DoE'. Proceedings of Seminar on Gypsy Policy after the Criminal Justice and Public Order .Act. School for Advanced Urban Studies, Bristol University, 21-22 February 1995

11.

Earle, F. , Dearling, A. , Whittle, H. , Glasse, R. and Gubby (1994) A Time to Travel? An Introduction to Britain's Newer Travellers. Lyme Regis: Enabler Publications.

12.

Fraser, A. (1993) The Gypsies. London: Blackwell.

13.

Friends, Families and Travellers (1996) Confined, Constrained and Condemned: Civil Rights and Travellers. Glastonbury : Friends, Families and Travellers.

14.

Gypsies and Traveller Organisations (1994) Alternative Proposals for the Constructive Reform of the 1968 Caravan Sites Act. London: Gypsies and Traveller Organisations.

15.

Hawes, D. and Perez, B. (1995) The Gypsy and the State: the Ethnic Cleansing of British Society. Bristol: SAUS.

16.

Home, R. (1993) 'Planning aspects of the Government Consultation Paper on Gypsies', Journal of Planning and Environment Law, 13-18.

17.

Home, R. (1994) 'Planning for Private Sites Post Circular 1/94'. Proceedings of One Day Course on Gypsies and Sites: a Hard Road Ahead . Oxford Brookes University, 15 March 1994.

18.

Home Office (1993) News Release 68/93: Government Action on New Age Travellers and Ravers—Statement by Home Office Minister Lord Ferrers. London: HMSO.

19.

Home Office (1994) Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994: Introductory Guide. London : HMSO.

20.

Lowe, S. (1986) Urban Social Movements: the City after Castells . London: Macmillan.

21.

Lowe, R. and Shaw, W. (1993) Travellers: Voices of the New Age Nomads . London: Fourth Estate.

22.

R v South Hams District Council ex parte Gibb 1993.

23.

Sedley, J. (1995) R v Lincolnshire County Council, R v Wealden District Council, R v Wealden District Council, unrevisedjudgement.

24.

Thomas, H. and Krishnarayan, V., eds. (1994) Race Equality and Planning: Policies and Procedures. Aldershot: Avebury.

25.

Thomson, T. (undated) Draft Planning Policy: Sites for Nomadic People .

26.

Wake, J. (1994) An examination of the Reasons for, and Policy Response to, New Age Travelling, BA dissertation, University of Central England.

27.

Wilkin, K. (1996) Marginal Grounds for Negotiation, an Examination of the Experiences of Newer Travellers of a 'Fair and Impartial' Planning System, BA dissertation, University of the West of England .