Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This paper explores the perspectives which postmodernism and post- structuralism bring to an understanding of care, particularly in the writings of Jacques Derrida, Michel Foucault, Hélène Cixous and Stephen White.

It is suggested that care is paradoxical. On one hand it is a tech nology of surveillance which, as a consequence of the professionalisa tion of caring, constitutes the vigil.

But although this technology is one of control and supplies the authority for profession care, it is also possible to recognise an alternative caring, which is about love, generosity, and a celebration of otherness. This gift of care seeks to enable the cared-for person, and resists the discourses of the vigil.

The paper examines the issues raised for practitioners by this dual character of care.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aiken, L

and

Fagm, C

(1992) (eds) Charting Nursing's Future, Philadelphia. JB Lippincott

Anderson, B.M.

(1991) 'Mapping the terrain of the discipline' in

Gray, G

and

Pratt, R.

(eds) Towards a Discipline of Nursing, Melbourne: Churchill Livingstone.

Armstrong, D.

(1983) The Pohtical Anatomy of the Body, Cambridge: Cambndge University Press.

Armstrong, D.

(1983b) 'The fabrication of nurse-patient relationships' , Social Science & Medicine, 17, 457-60

Armstrong, D.

(1987) 'Theoretical tensions in biopsychosocial medicine' , Social Science & Medicine, 25, 1213-8.

Barthes, R.

(1977) Image-Music-Text, Glasgow, Colhns-Fontana

Bauman, Z.

(1989) Modernity and the Holocaust, Cambridge: Polity.

Bauman, Z.

(1993) Postmodern Ethics, Oxford. Blackwell.

Bevis, E.M.

(1982) Curriculum Building in Nursing - a process, St Louis. Mosby

10.

Bloor, M.

and

McIntosh, J.

(1990) 'Surveillance and concealment' in

Cunningham-Burley, S

and

McKeganey, N

(eds) Readings in Medical Sociology, London. Routledge

11.

Bond, J.

(1991) 'The politics of care-giving. the professionalization of informal care', Paper presented to the Bntish Sociological Association Conference, Manchester

12.

Bowman, R.

(1992) 'Nursing returns to the home health frontier. markets and trends in home health care' m

Aiken, L.

and

Fagm, C

(eds) Charting Nursing's Future, Philadelphia. JB Lippincott

13.

Brownlea, A.

(1987) 'Participation, myth, realities and prognosis' , Social Science & Medicine, 25, 605-14

14.

Brykczynska, G.

(1992) 'Caring. a dying art?' m

Jolley, M

and

Brykczynska, G

(eds) Nursing Care The Challenge to Change, London : Edward Arnold

15.

Bunting, S.

(1993) Rosemarie Parse Theory of Health as Human Becoming , Newbury Park, California. Sage

16.

Butler, J.

(1990) Gender Trouble, London

Routledge

17.

Cameron-Traub, E.

(1991) 'An evolving discipline', in

Gray, G

and

Pratt, R.

(eds) Towards a Discipline of Nursing, Melbourne : Churchill Livingstone

18.

Caputo, J.D.

(1993) Against Ethics, Bloomington . Indiana University Press.

19.

Cixous, H.

(1986) 'Sorties' in

Cixous, H.

and

Clement, C

The Newly Born Woman, Manchester- Manchester University Press

20.

Clark, J.

(1993) 'Into the community', in

Dolan, B

(ed) Project 2000 Reflection and Celebration, London. Scutan

21.

Cooper, R.

and

Burrell, G.

(1988) 'Modernism, postmodernism and organisational analysis: an introduction', Organisation Studies, 9, 99-112

22.

Deleuze, G.

and

Guattan, F.

(1984) Anti-Oedipus Capitalism and Schizophrenia,

London Athlone Deleuze, G

and

Guattan, F

(1988) A Thousand Plateaux, London: Athlone

23.

Dernda, J.

(1976) Of Grammatology, Baltimore

John Hopkms

24.

Dernda, J.

(1978) Writing and Difference, London : Routledge and Kegan Paul

25.

Derrida, J.

(1992) Given Time I Counterfeit Money. (Trans P Kamuf), Chicago. University of Chicago Press.

26.

de Swaan, A.

(1990) The Management of Normality, London: Routledge

27.

Dolan, B.

(1993) 'Reflection and celebration' in

Dolan, B

(ed) Project 2000 Reflection and Celebration, London: Scutan

28.

Dolan, J.

(1985) Nursing in Society, an Historical Perspective, Philadelphia

WB Saunders

29.

Dunlop, M.J.

(1986) 'Is a science of canng possible?' Journal of Advanced Nursing, 11, 661-70

Forrester, J.

(1990) The Seductions of Psychoanalysis, Cambridge. Cambndge University Press.

30.

Foucault, M.

(1967) Madness and Civilisation, London : Tavistock

31.

Foucault, M.

(1976) Birth of the Clinic, London . Tavistock

32.

Foucault, M.

(1979) Discipline and Punish, Harmondsworth : Penguin

33.

Foucault, M.

(1980) 'The eye of power' in

Gordon, C

(ed) Power/Knowledge, Bnghton Harvester Foucault, M (1984) The History of Sexuality Part 1, Harmondsworth. Penguin.

34.

Foucault, M.

(1986) The Care of the Self, New York . Random House

35.

Fox, N.J.

(1993) Postmodernism, Sociology and Health, Buckingham: Open University Press

36.

Fox, N.J.

(1994) 'Anaesthetists, the discourse on patient fitness and the organisation of surgery', Sociology of Health and Illness, 16, 1-18.

37.

Game, A.

(1991) Undoing the Social, Buckingham : Open University Press.

38.

Gardner, K.

(1992) 'The historical conflict between caring and professionalization, a dilemma for nursing', in

Gaut, D.A.

(ed) The Presence of Caring, New York: National League for Nursing Press.

39.

Goffman, E.

(1968) Asylums, Harmondsworth: Penguin

40.

Goffman, E.

(1970) Stigma, Harmondsworth: Penguin.

41.

Graham, H.

(1983) 'Caring: a labour of love' in

Finch, J

and

Groves, D

(eds) A Labour of Love: Women, Work and Caring, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul

42.

Graham, H.

(1991) 'The concept of caring m feminist research', Sociology, 25, 61-78

43.

Gray, G

and

Pratt, R

(1991) (eds) Towards a Discipline of Nursing, Melbourne: Churchill Livingstone

Hochschild, A.R.

(1983) A Managed Heart, Berkeley: University of California Press.

44.

Hugman, R.

(1991) Power in Caring Professions, Basingstoke. Macmillan

45.

Hunt, M.

(1991) 'The identification and provision of care for the terminally ill at home by "family" members', Sociology of Health & Illness, 13, 375-95

46.

Inglesby, E.

(1992) 'Values and philosophy of nursing. the dynamic of change' in

Jolley, M

and

Brykczynska, G.

(eds) Nursing Care The Challenge to Change, LondonEdward Arnold .

47.

James, N.

(1989) 'Emotional labour. skill and work in the social regulation of feelings', Sociological Review, 37, 15-42.

48.

Kershaw, B.

(1992) 'Nursing models' m

Jolley, M.

and

Brykczynska, G.

(eds) Nursing Care The Challenge to Change, London : Edward Arnold

49.

Knowles, J.

(1977) Doing Better and Feeling Worse, New YorkNorton.

50.

Lash, S.

(1991) 'Genealogy and the body. Foucault/Neitzsche/Deleuze' m

Featherstone, M.

Hepworth, M.

and

Turner, B S

(eds) The Body, London: Sage

51.

Lynaugh, J.

and

Fagm, C.

(1988) 'Nursing comes of age', Image, 20(4), 184-90

52.

Lynch, K.

(1989) 'Solidary labour its nature and marginalisation' , Sociological Review, 37, 1-14

53.

Maseide, P.

(1991) 'Possibly abusive, often benign and always necessary. On power and domination m medical practice', Sociology of Health and Illness, 13, 545-61.

54.

Marsden, D.

and

Abrams, S.

(1987) "Allies", "Liberators", "Intruders" and "Cuckoos m the Nest": a sociology of caring relationships over the hfe cycle' in

Allatt, P.

et al (eds) Women and the Life Cycle, London. Macmillan

55.

Mauss, M.

(1990) The Gift, the Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies, London: Routledge

Mayall, B.

and

Foster, M-C.

(1989) Child Health Care, Oxford: Hememann

56.

Miles, A.

(1988) Women, Health and Medicine, Buckingham. Open University Press

57.

Moi, T.

( 1985) Sexual Textual Politics, London: Methuen

58.

Nettleton, S.

(1992) Power, Pain and Dentistry, Buckingham: Open University Press.

59.

Ostrander, G.

(1988) 'Foucault's disappearing body' m

Kroker, A

and

Kroker, M

Body Invaders, Basingstoke. Macmillan

60.

Parse, R.

Coyne, A.B.

and

Smith, M.J.

(1985) Nursing Research Qualitative Methods, Bowie, Maryland: Brady

61.

Parse, R.

(1987) Nursing Science, Major Paradigms, Theories and Critiques, Philadelphia. WB Saunders

Parsons, T.

and

Fox, R.

(1952) 'Illness, therapy and the modern American family', Journal of Social Issues , 8, 31-44.

62.

Riehl, J.P

and

Roy, C

(1980) (eds) Conceptual Models for Nursing Practice, New York: Appleton Century Crofts

63.

Roberts, H.

(1985) The Patient Patients, London . Routledge and Kegan Paul

64.

Rose, N.

(1989) Governing the Soul, London. Routledge

65.

Rosenau, P.

M (1992) Postmodernism and the Social Sciences, Princeton: Princeton University Press

Salvage, J.

(1989) 'Selling ourselves', Nursing Times , 85, 24

66.

Shrock, R.A.

(1982) 'Is health visiting a profession?', Health Visitor, 55(3), 104-6

67.

Sims, S.E R

(1991) 'The nature and relevance of theory for practice ' in

Gray, G

and

Pratt, R

(eds) Towards a Discipline of Nursing, Melbourne: Churchill Livingstone

68.

Stacey, M.

(1988) The Sociology of Health and Healing, London

Unwm Hyman

69.

Strumpf, N.E.

and

Stevenson, C.

M (1992) 'Breaking new ground in elder care practice, research and education' in

Aiken, L.

and

Fagm, C

(eds) Charting Nursing's Future, Philadelphia: JB Lippincott.

70.

Summers, A.

(1979) 'Home from home women's philanthropic work in the nineteenth century' in

Burman, S

(ed) Fit Work for Women, London: Croom Helm

71.

Thomas, C.

(1993) 'Deconstructing concepts of care', Sociology, 27, 649-70

72.

Thomas, J.

and

Dolan, B.

(1993) 'The changing face of nursing 2000 and beyond' , in

Dolan, B

(ed) Project 2000: Reflection and Celebration, London: Scutari

73.

Twinn, S.F.

(1991) 'Conflicting paradigms of health visiting: a continuing debate for professional practice', Journal of Advanced Nursing , 16, 966-73

74.

Ungerson, C.

(1987) Policy is Personal: Sex, Gender and Informal Care , London: Tavlstock.

75.

White, S.

(1991) Political Theory and Postmodernism, Cambridge. Cambridge University Press

76.

Who

(1985) Targets for Health for All, Geneva: World Health Organisation

Postmodern perspectives on care: the vigil and the gift

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References