Seeking refuge in a productivist welfare regime: Well-being of African asylum seekers/refugees in Hong Kong

Abstract

Chinese

Consistent with its productivist welfare model, Hong Kong offers limited welfare support to asylum seekers and refugees (ASR). This study examines the living conditions, experiences, support systems and well-being of African ASRs in Hong Kong in the context of the city's productivist welfare regime. Semi-structured interviews with 53 African ASRs revealed that they faced economic precarity, social stigma, and social isolation, which culminated in distress and unhappiness. Due to challenges in meeting their basic needs, the ASRs turned to voluntary institutions (e.g., non-governmental organisations and religious groups) and informal welfare (e.g., private residents and families) for social, economic, cultural and symbolic capital. These capitals offered them tangible (food and clothing) and intangible (information, emotional support, prestige, and belief systems) resources to navigate harsh circumstances. The study argues that the well-being of African ASRs in Hong Kong hinges on the interplay between public and private welfare services. Such complementary support reflects the principles of the productivist welfare regime in Hong Kong and it is partly why the government is able to maintain low decommodification among ASRs. Therefore, protecting the well-being of ASRs within this framework requires a more integrated welfare programme that enables stronger cross-sectoral collaboration.

Keywords

asylum seekers Hong Kong productivist welfare refugees well-being

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Amoah

Ameyaw

Fordjour

(2024) Interplay of sociocultural factors, health literacy and well-being among African asylum seekers and refugees in Asia: A systematic review. Journal of Migration and Health 10: 100262.

Amoah

Koduah

Anaduaka

, et al. (2020) Psychological wellbeing in diaspora space: A study of African economic migrants in Hong Kong. Asian Ethnicity 21(4): 542–559.

Arat

Eryigit-Madzwamuse

Hart

(2023) Cultivating resilience among Hong Kong's underprivileged ethnic minority groups in the face of a pandemic through a social justice lens. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal 42(7): 829–847.

Aspalter

(2006) The East Asian welfare model. International Journal of Social Welfare 15(4): 290–301.

Aspalter

(2011) The development of ideal-typical welfare regime theory. International Social Work 54(6): 735–750.

Bhowmik

Chan

AH-T

Halse

(2022) Multiculturalism and the cultural politics of racism in Hong Kong. Multicultural Education Review 14(1): 13–27.

Birger

(2024) Permanent Temporariness’ as a critical Lens: A framework for social work with forced migrants. The British Journal of Social Work 54(2): 780–796.

Bourdieu

(1986) The forms of capital. In: Richardson

(ed) Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. New York: Greenwood Press, 241–258.

Braun

Clarke

(2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3(2): 77–101.

10.

Bryman

(2012) Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

11.

Census and Statistics Department (2021) Hong Kong Poverty Situation Report 2020. Available at: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/en/scode461.html.

12.

Census and Statistics Department (2022) 2021 Population Census - Thematic Report: Ethnic Minorities. Hong Kong: Census and Statistics Department (CSD).

13.

Choi

(2012) End of the era of productivist welfare capitalism? Diverging welfare regimes in East Asia. Asian Journal of Social Science 40(3): 275–294.

14.

Choy

(2022) The securitization of refugees in Hong Kong: Government, members of the legislative council and Chinese newspapers (2005 to June 2019). Social Transformations in Chinese Societies 18(1): 19–45.

15.

Diener

Chan

(2011) Happy people live longer: Subjective well-being contributes to health and longevity. Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being 3(1): 1–43.

16.

Esping-Andersen

(1997) Hybrid or unique? The Japanese welfare state between Europe and America. Journal of European Social Policy 7(3): 179–189.

17.

Faran

Zanbar

Slonim-Nevo

(2023) Does social capital reduce the psychological distress and improve the wellbeing of asylum seekers? Evidence from Israel. International Journal of Intercultural Relations 93: 101777.

18.

Fereday

Muir-Cochrane

(2006) Demonstrating rigor using thematic analysis: A hybrid approach of inductive and deductive coding and theme development. International Journal of Qualitative Methods 5(1): 80–92.

19.

Holliday

(2000) Productivist welfare capitalism: Social policy in east Asia. Political Studies 48(4): 706–723.

20.

Humanitarian Action (2022) After 20 years, rising displacement shows no sign of slowing. Available at: https://humanitarianaction.info/article/after-20-years-rising-displacement-shows-no-sign-slowing (accessed 22 Novemeber).

21.

George

(2022) Impacts of COVID-19 on refugee service provision and community support: A rapid assessment during the pandemic. Social Work in Public Health 37(1): 84–103.

22.

Immigration Department (2024) Facts and Statistics: Torture/Non-refoulement Claim Cases. Available at: https://www.immd.gov.hk/eng/facts/enforcement.html (accessed 11 December).

23.

Izuhara

(2016) Social policy in east Asia. In: Alcock

Haux

May

(eds) The Students’ Campanion to Social Policy. Chichester, UK: Wiley Blackwell, 481–487.

24.

Kennedy

Wong

H-Y

(2019) Being asylum seekers in Hong Kong institutions, action and power. Asian Journal of Social Science 47(4/5): 534–565.

25.

Lau

PYF

(2019) Empowerment in the asylum-seeker regime? The roles of policies, the non-profit sector and refugee community organizations in Hong Kong. Journal of Refugee Studies 34(1): 305–327.

26.

Lau

PYF

Gheorghiu

(2017) Vanishing selves under Hong Kong’s unified screening mechanism. Cultural Diversity in China 3(1): 21–35.

27.

Hamer

(2024) As more illegal immigrants enter Hong Kong, spotlight shines again on asylum seekers: do they have valid refugee claims? Available at: https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/law-and-crime/article/3255275/more-illegal-immigrants-enter-hong-kong-spotlight-shines-again-asylum-seekers-do-they-have-valid?campaign=3255275&module=perpetual_scroll_0&pgtype=article (accessed 14 March).

28.

Marquez

(2024) Lives in limbo: struggles of asylum seekers in Hong Kong. Available at: https://multimedia.scmp.com/infographics/news/hong-kong/article/3267178/asylum-seekers/#:∼:text=However%2C%20it%20offers%20non%2Drefoulement,eventually%20relocating%20to%20other%20countries (accessed 24 June).

29.

Melwani

(2022) Driven by desperation: Without the right to work, refugees in Hong Kong face impossible choices. Available at: https://hongkongfp.com/2022/02/20/driven-by-desperation-without-the-right-to-work-refugees-in-hong-kong-face-impossible-choices/ (accessed 10 July).

30.

Midgley

Tang

(2009) Social Policy and Poverty in East Asia: The Role of Social Security. New York: Taylor & Francis.

31.

Mok

Kühner

Huang

(2017a) The productivist construction of selective welfare pragmatism in China. Social Policy & Administration 51(6): 876–897.

32.

Mok

Kühner

Yeates

(2017b) Introduction – managing welfare expectations and social change: Policy responses in Asia. Social Policy & Administration 51(6): 845–856.

33.

H-Y

Kennedy

Hue

M-T

(2019a) What contributes to ethnic minorities’ identification with Hong Kong? The cases of south Asian and Filipino youth. Asian Ethnicity 20(2): 228–249.

34.

(2020) Criminalizing the innocents: Social exclusion of asylum-seekers and refugees in Hong Kong. Journal of Asian Public Policy 13(3): 319–332.

35.

Choi

Chan

(2019b) Framing the issue of asylum seekers and refugees for tougher refugee policy—a study of the media’s portrayal in post-colonial Hong Kong. Journal of International Migration and Integration 20(2): 593–617.

36.

Chung

JWY

Choi

SFY

, et al. (2023) Self-perceived mental health and factors associated with the mental health of Hong Kong's asylum-seekers and refugees: A mixed methods study. Heliyon 9(2): 1–12.

37.

Niemi

Manhica

Gunnarsson

, et al. (2019) A scoping review and conceptual model of social participation and mental health among refugees and asylum seekers. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 16(20): 4027.

38.

Oren-Schwartz

Aizik-Reebs

Yuval

, et al. (2023) Effect of mindfulness-based trauma recovery for refugees on shame and guilt in trauma recovery among African asylum-seekers. Emotion 23(3): 622–632.

39.

Posselt

Eaton

Ferguson

, et al. (2019) Enablers of psychological well-being for refugees and asylum seekers living in transitional countries: A systematic review. Health and Social Care in the Community 27(4): 808–823.

40.

Schoeb

(2016) Healthcare service in Hong Kong and its challenges: The role of health professionals within a social model of health. China Perspectives 2016(4): 51–58.

41.

Song

(2020) Refugee law and policy in Hong Kong. In: Song

(eds) Chinese Refugee Law and Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 131–154.

42.

Toole

(2013) Forced migrants: Refugees and internally displaced persons. In: Levy

Sidel

(eds) Social Injustice and Public Health. New York: Oxford University Press, 187–202.

43.

Toomey

(2011) Empowerment and disempowerment in community development practice: Eight roles practitioners play. Community Development Journal 46(2): 181–195.

44.

Ungar

(2012) Researching and theorizing resilience across cultures and contexts. Preventive Medicine 55(5): 387–389.

45.

UNHCR (2022) Global trends: Forced displacement in 2022. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).

46.

UNHCR (2023) Mid-year trends, 2023. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).

47.

UNHCR (2024) Unified Screening Mechanism Procedures. Available at: https://www.unhcr.org/hk/en/usm-procedures-2#:∼:text=The%20Unified%20Screening%20Mechanism%20(USM,by%20the%20Government%2C%20not%20UNHCR (accessed 13 March 2024).

48.

Vecchio

(2016) The economy of seeking asylum in the global city. International Migration 54(1): 19–31.

49.

Wong

Woo

(2017a) Effects of perceived neighbourhood environments on self-rated health among community-dwelling older Chinese. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 14(6): 614.

50.

Wong

WCW

Cheung

Miu

HYH

, et al. (2017b) Mental health of African asylum-seekers and refugees in Hong Kong: using the social determinants of health framework. BMC Public Health 17(153): –9.

51.

Yau

(2021) Hong Kong is eighth safest city in world overall, but ranks badly when it comes to personal and environmental security. Available at: https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/society/article/3146874/hong-kong-eighth-safest-city-world-overall-ranks-badly-when (accessed 5 June).

52.

Yuda

(2023) Beyond path dependency: Analysing Indonesia's social policy responses to two crises. Social Policy and Administration 57(5): 727–743.

53.

Ziersch

Walsh

Due

(2023) ‘Having a good friend, a good neighbour, can help you find yourself’: Social capital and integration for people from refugee and asylum-seeking backgrounds in Australia. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 49(15): 3877–3899.