Protecting difference: A discussion on transphobic and homophobic hate crime in the Irish context

Abstract

Ireland has been applauded internationally for its legislative progress in supporting the rights of (lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender) LGBT+ citizens. Yet much of the positive change within the social and political context of sexuality and gender expression has been achieved by campaign groups, operating outside government boundaries. Notwithstanding these advances, LGBT+ people continue to face discrimination, abuse and violence. Concerns surrounding acts of aggression towards transgender and gay people call for an ongoing dialogue between legislators, policymakers, and practitioners to explore ways in which safety can be ensured. This article draws from an emerging body of scholarship and research to question the effectiveness of current social policy and legislation in Ireland. It offers a discourse on hate crime related to transphobia and homophobia, while challenging the existing political thinking. Multi-agency collaborative working is suggested as key to fostering solutions together with changes in legal paradigms, and the continued formation of policy aimed at safeguarding the LGBT+ community.

Keywords

Hate homophobia political processes transphobia

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Carr

Haynes

Schweppe

(2017) Hate crime: An overview of significant and relevance to Irish sociology. Irish Journal of Sociology 25(1): 73–83.

Chakraborti

(2010) Crimes against the “other”: Conceptual, operational, and empirical challenges for hate studies. Journal of Hate Studies 8(1): 9–28.

Chakraborti

(2015) Re-Thinking hate crime: Fresh challenges for policy and practice. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 30(10): 1738–1754.

Chakraborti

Garland

(2012) Reconceptualising hate crime victimization through the lens of vulnerability and difference. Theoretical Criminology 16(4): 499–514.

Chakraborti

Garland

(2014) Responding to Hate Crime: The Case for Connecting Policy and Research. Bristol, UK: Policy Press.

Concannon

(2008) Citizenship, sexual identity and social exclusion: Exploring issues in British and American social policy. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 28(9): 326–339.

Coulter

Reynolds

(2020) Good times for a change? Ireland since the general election. Surroundings 75(194): 66–81.

Dane

Short

Healy

(2016) “Swimming with sharks”: the negative social and psychological impacts of Ireland’s marriage referendum ‘NO’ campaign. Available at: http://vuir.vu.edu.au/view/people/Healy=3AG=3A=3A.default.html (accessed 12 August 2020).

Dononhoe

(2019) Following an attack in which a gang attacked Danilo Matt upon seeing him kiss his boyfriend, Danilo is now calling on the Government to implement hate crime legislation. Available at: https://gcn.ie/victim-homophobic-attack-hate-crime-legislation-feel-safer-dublin/ (accessed 11 July 2020).

10.

Dunne

(2020) Irish gay couple stabbed and beaten in vicious homophobic attack in Newbridge. GCN.ie. 3 February 20. Available at: https://gcn.ie/irish-gay-couple-homophobic-attack-newbridge/ (23 September 2020).

11.

eISB (2020) Government of Ireland (1993) Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1993, Houses of Oireachtas: Dublin. Available at: http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/1993/act/20/enacted/en/html (accessed 22 April 2020).

12.

European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) (2012) Making Hate Crime Visible in the European Union: Acknowledging Victims’ Rights, Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. Available at: https://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra-2012_hate-crime.pdf (accessed 19 June 2020).

13.

European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) (2014) Being Trans in the European Union. Comparative Analysis for EU LGBT Survey Data. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. Available at: https://fra.europa.eu/en/publication/2014/being-trans-eu-comparative-analysis-eu-lgbt-survey-data (accessed 28 August 2020).

14.

European Union for Fundamental Rights (FRA) (2013) European Union Lesbian, Gay Bisexual and Transgender Survey, Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. Available at: https://fra.europa.eu/en/publication/2013/eu-lgbt-survey-european-union-lesbian-gay-bisexual-and-transgender-survey-results (accessed 4 July 2020).

15.

Gadd

(2009) Aggravating racism and elusive motivation. British Journal of Criminology 49(6): 755–771.

16.

Gallagher

(2020a) The far right rises: Its growth as a political force in Ireland. The Irish Times 19, September, 2020.

17.

Gallagher

(2020b) Planned hate speech laws will contain higher bar for prosecution. The Irish Times 17, December, 2020.

18.

Godzisz

Pudzianowska

(2016) Do some identities deserve more protection than others? The case of anti-LGB hate crime laws in Poland. In: Schweppe

Walters

(eds) The Globalisation of Hate: Internationalising Hate Crime? Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 74–189.

19.

Green

McFalls

Smith

(2003) Hate crime: An emergent research agenda. In: Perry

(ed) Hate and Bias Crime: A Reader. London: Routledge, pp. 27–49.

20.

Habarth J

(2015) Development of the heteronormative attitudes and belief scale. Journal of Psychology & Sexuality 6(2): 166–188.

21.

Hall

(2013) Hate Crime, 2nd edn London: Routledge.

22.

Haynes

Schweppe

(2017) Lifecycle of a Hate Crime: Country Report for Ireland. Dublin. Irish Council for Civil Liberties. Available at: https://www.iccl.ie/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/Life-Cycle-of-a-Hate-Crime-Country-Report-for-Ireland.pdf (accessed 21 April 2020).

23.

Haynes

Schweppe

(2019) Call it Out. Ireland and our LGBT Community. Hate and Hostility Research Group. Republic of Ireland: University of Limerick. Available at: https://ulir.ul.ie/bitstream/handle/10344/8065/CallitOut-Research.pdf?sequence=2 (accessed 28 October 2020).

24.

Herz

Johansson

(2015) The normativity of the concept of heteronormativity. Journal of Homosexuality 62(8): 1009–1020.

25.

Higgins

Doyle

Downes

, et al. (2016) The LGBT Ireland report: national study of the mental health and wellbeing of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex people in Ireland (Rep.). GLEN and BeLonG To. Available at: https://www.tcd.ie/equality/assets/docs/LGBTIrelandReport_KeyFindings.pdf (accessed 03 November 2020).

26.

Hugendubel

(2019) IGLA-Europe Welcome European Parliament Resolution Tackling the Rise in Hate Against the LGBTI Community. Belgium: IGLA-Europe. 18 December 2019. Available at: https://www.ilga-europe.org/resources/news/latest-news/ilga-europe-welcome-european-parliament-decision-tackling-rise-hate (accessed 08 May 2020).

27.

ICCL, Irish Council for Civil Liberties (2018) Ireland has among Highest Rates of Hate Crime Against People of African Background and Transgender People in the EU, but no Laws to Address it. Dublin, 4 July 2018. Available at: https://www.iccl.ie/news/ireland-high-hate-crime-no-laws-to-address (accessed 18 May 2021).

28.

ICCL, Irish Council for Civil Liberties (2020) Welcomes Proposal of Outlaw Hate Crime, Sounds Note of Caution re Free Speech. Dublin, 17 December, 20. https://www.iccl.ie/news/iccl-welcomes-proposal-to-outlaw-hate-crime-sounds-note-of-caution-re-free-speech/ (accessed 3 May 2021).

29.

Iganski

(2008) “Hate Crime” and the City. Bristol, UK: Polity Press. University of Bristol.

30.

ILGA Europe (2021) Annual Report of the Human Rights of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex People in Europe and Central Asia. Available at: https://www.ilga-europe.org/sites/default/files/2021/full_annual_review.pdf (accessed 20 May 2021).

31.

Jackson

(2006) Gender, sexuality and heterosexuality: The complexity (and limits) of heteronormativity. Feminist Theology 7(1): 105–121.

32.

Javaid

(2017) The penis is a weapon of power: A feminist and hate crime interpretation of male sexual victimisation. NORMA: International Journal for Masculinity Studies 13(1): 23–40.

33.

Javaid

(2018) Out of place: Sexualities, sexual violence, and heteronormativity. Aggression and Violent Behaviour 39: 83–89.

34.

Johnny (2006) LGBT hate crime report: Stop hate crime in Ireland campaign. Available at: http://gayhealthnetwork.ie/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/2006-Hate-Crime-Report-Johnny-Peer-Action-Group.pdf (accessed 13 May 2020).

35.

Kavanagh

(2015) An end to “civil war politics”? The radically reshaped political landscape of post-crash Ireland. Electoral Studies 38: 71–81.

36.

Keogh

(2000) The prohibition of incitement to hatred Act 1989 – A paper tiger? Bar Review, Dublin 6(3): 178–181. Available at: https://www.lawlibrary.ie/rss/barreview/3-2000.pdf (accessed 22 November 2020).

37.

Lally

(2021) New hate crime law to cover gender expression and identity. The Irish Times 16 April, Dublin 9, 2021.

38.

Law Society Gazette Ireland (2021) Not all Hate Speech Merits a Criminal law Response. 15 March, 2021.

39.

Lentin

McVeigh

(2006) After optimism? Ireland racism and globalisation. Metro Eireann, 72: 3, Available at: http://www.tara.tcd.ie/handle/2262/25156 (accessed 6 September 2020).

40.

Marchia

Sommer

(2019) (Re)defining heteronormativity. Sexualities 22(3): 267–295.

41.

Mason-Bish

(2010) Future challenges for hate crime policy: Lessons from the past In: Chakraborti

(ed) Hate Crime: Concepts, Policy, Future Directions. Cullompton, UK: Willan, pp.58–77.

42.

McCabe

(2015) The radical left in Ireland. Socialism and Democracy 29(3): 158–165.

43.

McCrave

(2019) Government looking at hate crime legislation as LGBT group says assaults are on the rise. 18 October 20. Journal.ie. Available at: https://www.thejournal.ie/government-hate-crime-lgbt-assaults-4855842-Oct2019/ (accessed 13 November 2020).

44.

McDonagh

(2020) Hate Crime legislation in Ireland – The journey so far and what happens next. 28 February 20. GCN.ie. Available at: https://gcn.ie/hate-crime-legislation-ireland-what-happens-next/ (accessed 28 September 2020).

45.

McIntyre

McDonald

(2012) The limitations of partial citizenship: Health care institutions underpinned with heteronormative ideals. Advances in Nursing Science 35(2): 127–134.

46.

Messerschmidt

(2016) Masculinities in the Making: From the Local to the Global. Langham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

47.

Moore

(2020) Dublin man attacked by a gang with steel bars after kissing his boyfriend. Gay times. Available at: http://www.gaytimes.co.uk/life/dublin-man-attacked-by-a-gang-with-steel-bars-after-kissing-his-boyfriend/ (accessed 11 October 2020).

48.

Moss

(2020) The anticipatory politics of homophobia: Explaining constitutional bans on same-sex marriage in post-communist Europe, East European Politics 36(3): 395–416.

49.

National LGBT Federation (2016) Burning Issue 2: What’s next for LGBT Ireland? National LGBT Community Consultation 2016. Available at: http://nxf.ie/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Burning-Issue-2-Report-by-NXF.pdf (accessed 1 June 2020).

50.

O’Brien

(2016) Fianna Fáil Hate Crime Bill “a frightening example of lazy legislation” – Jonathan O’Brien, 4 October 20. Available at: https://www.sinnfein.ie/contents/41834 (accessed 3 October 2020).

51.

Ó Broin

(2009) Sinn Féin and the Politics of Left Republicanism. London: Pluto Press.

52.

O’ Connor

(2020) Stabbing attack on gay couple in kildare being treated as hate crime. The Irish Post, 3 February 20. Available at: https://www.irishpostcom/news/stabbing-attack-gay-couple-kildare-treated-hate-crime-178556 (accessed 6 November 2020).

53.

Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (2009) Hate Crime Laws: A Practical Guide. Warsaw, Poland. Available at: http://www.at.gov.lv/files/uploads/files/7_Resursi/Rokasgramatas/36426.pdf (accessed 9 November 2020).

54.

Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (2012) Tackling Hate Crimes: An Analysis of Bias-Motivated Incidents in Bosnia and Herzegovina with Recommendations. Sarajevo: OSCE Mission to Bosnia and Herzegovina. Available at: https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/3/8/107255.pdf (accessed 12 March 2020).

55.

Perry

(2001) In the Name of Hate: Understanding Hate Crimes. London, England: Routledge.

56.

Perry

(2003) Accounting for hate crime: Doing difference. In: Perry

(ed) Hate and Bias Crime: A Reader. London: Routledge, pp.97–109.

57.

Perry

Schweppe

, et al. (2016) Introduction: Understanding hate crime: Research, policy, and practice. Criminal Justice Policy Review 27(6): 571–576.

58.

Pollark

(2019) Transphobia: You just don’t understand why someone has so much hate for who you are. Irish Times, 20 May 20. Available at: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/social-affairs/transphobia-you-just-don-t-understand-why-someone-has-so-much-hate-for-who-you-are-1.3897499 (accessed 5 July 2020).

59.

Ray

Smith

Wastell

(2004) Shame, rage and racist violence. British Journal of Criminology 44(3): 350–368.

60.

Rubin

(2011) Deviations. Durham & London: Duke University Press.

61.

Rumney

(2008) Policing male rape and sexual assault. Journal of Criminal Law 72(1): 67–86.

62.

Ryan

(2020) Sharing hate speech online to become criminal offence but there will be protections for freedom of speech. Journal.ie 17 December, 20.

63.

Seidler

(2007) Masculinities, bodies and emotional life. Men and Masculinities 10(1): 9–12.

64.

Seidman

(2009) Critique of compulsory heterosexuality. Sexuality Research & Social Research 6(1): 18–28.

65.

Smith

Lader

Hoare

, et al. (2012) Hate Crime, Cyber Security and the Experience of Crime among Children: Findings from the 2010/11 British Crime Survey: Supplementary Volume 3 to Crime in England and Wales 2010/11’, Home Office National Statistics Office: London. Available at: https://www.report-it.org.uk/files/hosb0612-2.pdf (accessed 12 October 2020).

66.

Weeks

(2017) Sex, Politics and Society: The Regulation of Sexuality Since 1800 (Themes In British Social History), 4th Edition London: Routledge.

67.

Weisburd S

Levin

(1994) On the basis of sex: Recognising gender-based bias crimes. Stanford Law & Policy Review 5(2): 21–47.

68.

Willis

(2008) Meanings in adult male victims’ experiences of hate crime and its aftermath. Issues in Mental Health Nursing 29(6): 567–584.

69.

Zulianello

(2020) Varieties of populist parties and party systems in Europe: From state-of-the-Art to the application of a novel classification scheme to 66 parties in 33 countries. Government and Opposition 55(2): 327–347.