From self-government to government of the self: Fiscal subjectivity,Indigenous governance and the politics of transparency

Abstract

In 2013 the Canadian Parliament passed the First Nations Financial Transparency Act (FNFTA). Subject to immediate controversy, the law generated legal and political resistance from Indigenous leaders and scholars. The law requires First Nations governments to post audited consolidated financial statements and the salaries of chiefs and councillors online for public consumption. The article traces the use of transparency as a technology of government to examine how disclosure acts as an organizing mechanism of commensuration and moral scrutiny. The article then shows how transparency and disclosure was directed to rescale critique of the state away from the Canadian government, and toward First Nations governments. The article concludes by examining how bureaucrats envisioned how Indigenous peoples would use transparency and disclosure to reform their political conducts into that of a calculating taxpayer citizenship.

Keywords

audit settler colonialism First Nations governmentality indigeneity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abele

Prince

(2006) Four pathways to Aboriginal self-government in Canada. American Review of Canadian Studies 36(4): 568–595.

Alfred

(2006) ‘Sovereignty’ – an inappropriate concept. In: Maaka

RCA

Andersen

(eds) The Indigenous Experience: Global Perspectives. Toronto: Canadian Scholars Press, pp. 322–336

Alfred

(2008) Peace, Power, Righteousness: An Indigenous Manifesto. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Alfred

(2009) First Nation perspectives on political identity. Assembly of First Nations. Available at: https://taiaiake.files.wordpress.com/2015/01/fn-political-identity-taiaiake-alfred-final.pdf.

Alloa

(2018) Transparency: A magic concept of modernity. In: Alloa

Thomä

(eds) Transparency, Society and Subjectivity: Critical Perspectives. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 21–55.

Altamirano-Jiménez

(2004) North American First Peoples: Slipping up into market citizenship? Citizenship Studies 8(4): 349–365.

Andersen

(2013) Underdeveloped identities: The misrecognition of Aboriginality in the Canadian census. Economy and Society 42(4): 626–650

Birchall

(2011) Introduction to secrecy and transparency: The politics of opacity and openness. Theory, Culture & Society 28(7–8): 7–25.

Bielefeld

(2018) Government mythology on income management, alcohol, addiction and Indigenous communities. Critical Social Policy 38(4): 749–770.

10.

Björklund Larsen

(2018) A Fair Share of Tax: A Fiscal Anthropology of Contemporary Sweden. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

11.

Borrows

(1992) A genealogy of law: Inherent sovereignty and First Nations self-government. Osgoode Hall Law Journal 30(2): 291–353.

12.

Borrows

(1996) With or without you: First Nation law (in Canada). McGill Law Review 41: 629–665.

13.

Britton

(1999) Edouard Glissant and Postcolonial Theory: Strategies of Language and Resistance. Charlottesville VA: University of Virginia Press.

14.

Brownlie

(2003) A Fatherly Eye: Indian Agents, Government Power and Aboriginal Resistance in Ontario, 1918–1939. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

15.

Christensen

Cornelissen

(2015) Organizational transparency as myth and metaphor. European Journal of Social Theory 18(2): 132–149.

16.

Coulthard

(2007) Subjects of empire: Indigenous peoples and the ‘politics of recognition’ in Canada. Contemporary Political Theory 6(4): 437–460.

17.

Coulthard

(2014) Red Skin White Masks: Rejecting the Colonial Politics of Recognition. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

18.

Dafnos

(2018) The enduring settler–colonial emergency: Indian affairs and contemporary emergency management in Canada. Settler-Colonial Studies. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/2201473X.2018.1491157.

19.

Dean

(2002) Liberal government and authoritarianism. Economy & Society 31(1): 37–61.

20.

Dean

(2010) Governmentality: Power and Rule in Modern Society. London: Sage

21.

Denis

(2015) Contact theory in a small town settler–colonial context: The reproduction of laissez faire racism in Indigenous–white Canadian relations. American Sociological Review 80(1): 218–242.

22.

Diabo

Pasternak

(2011) Canada has had First Nations under surveillance: Harper Government has prepared for First Nations ‘unrest’. First Nations Strategic Bulletin 9(1–5): 1–6.

23.

Dyck

(2013) First Nations Financial Transparency Act. Senate of Canada, March. Available at: http://sen.parl.gc.ca/ldyck/html/eng/07speeches_01_96.html.

24.

Espeland

Sauder

(2007) Rankings and reactivity: How public measures recreate social worlds. American Journal of Sociology 113(1): 1–40

25.

Espeland

Stevens

(1998) Commensuration as a social process. Annual Review of Sociology 24(1): 313–343.

26.

Fenster

(2015) Transparency in search of a theory. European Journal of Social Theory 18(2): 150–167.

27.

Foucault

(2008) The Birth of Biopolitics: Lectures at the Collège de France 1978–1979. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

28.

Flyverbom

(2015) Sunlight in cyberspace? On Transparency as a form of social ordering. European Journal of Social Theory 18(2):168–184.

29.

Hansen

Thøger Christensen

Flyverbom

(2015) Introduction: Logics of Transparency in Late Modernity: Paradoxes, Mediation and Governance. European Journal of Social Theory 18(2): 117–131.

30.

Harp

(2015) Most First Nations see right through Canada’s Transparency Act. Media Indigena, January. Available at: https://www.mediaindigena.com/most-first-nations-see-right-through-canadas-transparency-act/.

31.

Henderson

(2015) Residential schools and opinion-making in the era of traumatized subjects and taxpayer-citizens. Journal of Canadian Studies 49(1): 5–43.

32.

Hindess

(1997) Politics and governmentality. Economy and Society 26(2): 127–143.

33.

King

(2014) First Nations transparency act may do more harm than good. CBC News, 2 August. Available at: https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.2725654.

34.

Laruffa

(2018) Social investment: Diffusing ideas for redesigning citizenship after neo-liberalism? Critical Social Policy 38(4): 688–706.

35.

Lawrence

(2003) Gender, race, and the regulation of Native identity in Canada and the United States: An overview. Hypatia 18(2): 3–31.

36.

Lemke

(2001) ‘The birth of biopolitics’: Michel Foucault’s lecture at the College de France on neo-liberal governmentality. Economy and Society 30(2): 190–207.

37.

Luscombe

Walby

(2017) Theorizing freedom of information: The live archive, obfuscation, and actor–network theory. Government Information Quarterly 34(3): 379–387.

38.

Mackinnon

(forthcoming) Piecing it together, studying public private partnerships: Freedom of Information as oligoptic technologies. In: Walby

(ed.) Freedom of Information and Social Science Research Design. Routledge.

39.

Martin

Kidder

(2012) What we talk about when we talk about taxes. Symbolic Interaction 35(2): 123–145.

40.

McKeen

Porter

(2003) Politics and transformation: Welfare state restructuring in Canada. In: Clement

Vosko

(eds) Changing Canada: Political economy as transformation. Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp. 109–134.

41.

Matsunaga

(2016) Two faces of transitional justice: Theorizing the incommensurability of transitional justice and decolonization in Canada. Decolonization: Indigeneity, Education & Society 5(1): 24–44.

42.

Miller

O’Leary

(1987) Accounting and the construction of the governable person. Accounting, Organizations and Society 12(3): 235–265.

43.

Monaghan

(2013) Settler governmentality and racializing surveillance in Canada’s North-West. Canadian Journal of Sociology 38(4): 487–508.

44.

Monture-Angus

(1999) Journeying Forward: Dreaming First Nations’ Independence. Winnipeg, MB: Fernwood Publishing.

45.

Moreton-Robinson

(2015) The White Possessive: Property, Power and Indigenous Sovereignty. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

46.

Napoleon

(2001) Extinction by number: Colonialism made easy. Canadian Journal of Law and Society 16(1): 113–145.

47.

Neu

Graham

(2006) The birth of a nation: Accounting and Canada’s First Nations, 1860–1900. Accounting, Organizations and Society 31(1): 47–76.

48.

Neu

Therrien

(2003) Accounting for Genocide: Canada’s Bureaucratic Assault on Aboriginal People. Halifax: Fernwood.

49.

Palmater

(2011) Stretched beyond human limits: Death by poverty in First Nations. Canadian Review of Social Policy 65/66: 112–127.

50.

Palmater

(2014a) Genocide, Indian policy, and legislated elimination of Indians in Canada. aboriginal policy studies 3(3): 27–54.

51.

Palmater

(2014b) Stephen Harper and the myth of the crooked Indian. Rabble.ca, November. Available at: http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/pamela-palmater/2014/11/stephen-harper-and-myth-crooked-indian.

52.

Pasternak

(2015) How capitalism will save colonialism: The privatization of reserve lands in Canada. Antipode 47(1): 179–196.

53.

Pasternak

(2016) The fiscal body of sovereignty: To ‘make live’ in Indian country. Settler Colonial Studies 6(4): 317–338. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/2201473X.2015.1090525.

54.

Porter

(1995) Trust in Numbers: The Pursuit of Objectivity in Science and Public Life. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

55.

Power

(2003) Auditing and the production of legitimacy. Accounting, Organizations and Society 28(4): 379–394. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0361-3682(01)00047-2.

56.

Pulkingham

Ternowetsky

(1997) The changing landscape of social policy and the Canadian welfare state. In: Pulkingham

Ternowetsky

(eds) Remaking Canadian Social Policy: Social Security in the Late 1990s. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing, pp. 2–29.

57.

Rose

(1991) Governing by numbers: Figuring out democracy. Accounting, Organizations and Society 16(7): 673–692. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/0361-3682(91)90019-B.

58.

Rose

(1999) Powers of Freedom: Reframing Political Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

59.

Rose

(2000) Government and control. British Journal of Criminology 40(2): 321–339.

60.

Shewell

(2004) ‘Enough to Keep them Alive’: Indian Welfare in Canada, 1873–1965. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

61.

Shore

Wright

(2015) Governing by numbers: Audit culture, rankings and the new world order. Social Anthropology 23(1): 22–28. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1111/1469-8676.12098.

62.

Sieciechowicz

(2012) Effective politics: Band elections and decision making in a Northern Ontario Anishnaabek community. In Gardiner Barber

Leach

Lem

(eds) Confronting Capital: Critique and Engagement in Anthropology. New York and London: Routledge, pp 53–76.

63.

Simpson

(2014) Mohawk Interruptus: Political Life Across the Borders of Settler States. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

64.

Simpson

(2017) The ruse of consent and the anatomy of ‘refusal’: Cases from indigenous North America and Australia. Postcolonial Studies 20(1): 18–33.

65.

Smith

(2009) Liberalism, Surveillance, and Resistance: Indigenous communities in Western Canada, 1877–1927. Athabasca, AB: Athabasca University Press.

66.

Stanley

(2016) Legitimacy gaps, taxpayer conflict, and the politics of austerity in the UK. British Journal of Politics and International Relations 18(2): 389–406.

67.

Tillotson

(2017) Give and Take: The Citizen-Taxpayer and the Rise of Canadian Democracy. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.

68.

Todd

(2016) From a Fishy Place: Examining Canadian State Law applied in the Daniels Decision from the perspective of Métis Legal Orders. TOPIA: Canadian Journal of Cultural Studies 36: 43–57.

69.

Tuhiwai Smith

(2012) Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples. London: Zed Books.

70.

Walsh

(2018) Racial Taxation: Schools, Segregation and Taxpayer Citizenship, 1869–1973. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.

71.

Walters

(2002) Deportation, expulsion, and the international police of aliens. Citizenship Studies 6(3): 265–292.

72.

Williamson

(2017) Read My Lips: Why Americans Are Proud to Pay Taxes. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

73.

Willmott

(2017) Taxpayer governmentality: Governing government in Metro Vancouver’s Transit Tax Debate. Economy and Society 46(2): 255–274.