The politics of government ‘support’ in Aotearoa/New Zealand: Reinforcing and reproducing the poor citizenship of young Māori parents

Abstract

Despite the poor outcomes of early childbearing increasingly found to be equivocal, there remains a persistent pathologising of teen parenting, which structures government response. By applying a Foucauldian analysis to the recently introduced Young Parent Payment, this article examines the political rationalities that shape government responses and welfare assistance for young parents in Aotearoa/New Zealand. A biopolitical concern for the good economic citizen and right parent is found to inform the social investment approach, and exclude those who do not conform. Discourses about being Māori, young, a parent and needing financial assistance frame young Māori parents as at risk of long-term welfare-dependency and a threat to their own children. Welfare assistance is demonstrated to be a disciplinary practice to punish young Māori mother beneficiaries for deviating from the preferred normative life-course trajectory.

Keywords

discourse Foucauldian analysis governmentality neoliberalism welfare reform young parent payment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alter-Shaw

(2001) Shaping the bureau or maximising the budget? Rational choice, historical institutionalism and bureaucratic reform in New Zealand. PhD thesis, Massey University, Palmerston North.

Arai

(2009) What a difference a decade makes: Rethinking teenage pregnancy as a problem. Social Policy & Society 8: 171.

Barcelos

(2014) Producing (potentially) pregnant teen bodies: Biopower and adolescent pregnancy in the USA. Critical Public Health 24: 476–488.

Bell

Green

(2016) On the perils of invoking neoliberalism in public health critique. Critical Public Health 26(3): 239–243.

Breheny

Stephens

(2007a) Individual responsibility and social constraint: The construction of adolescent motherhood in social scientific research. Culture, Health & Sexuality 9(4): 333–346.

Breheny

Stephens

(2007b) Irreconcilable differences: Health professionals’ constructions of adolescence and motherhood. Social Science & Medicine 64: 112–124.

Breheny

Stephens

(2008) ‘Breaking the cycle’: Constructing intergenerational explanations for disadvantage. Journal of Health Psychology 13: 754–763.

Breheny

Stephens

(2010) Youth or disadvantage? The construction of teenage mothers in medical journals. Culture, Health & Sexuality 12: 307–322.

Brown

(2011) Antenatal education for adolescents: A qualitative study from a Foucauldian perspective. Master’s thesis, Massey University, Albany, New Zealand.

10.

Cherrington

Breheny

(2005) Politicizing dominant discursive constructions about teenage pregnancy: Re-locating the subject as social. Health 9: 89–111.

11.

Collins

(2010) Resilience in Teenage Mothers: A Follow-up Study. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development.

12.

Fergusson

Woodward

(2000) Teenage pregnancy and female educational underachievement: a prospective study of a New Zealand birth cohort. Journal of Marriage and Family 62: 147–161.

13.

Foucault

(1978/1990) The history of sexuality: Volume 1: An introduction, translated by Hurley

. New York: Vintage Books.

14.

Foucault

(1980) Truth and power. In: Gordon

(ed.) Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972/1977. New York: Random House, 109–133.

15.

Foucault

(1991) Governmentality. In: Burchell

Gordon

Miller

(eds) The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality. Chicago: University of Chigaco Press, 87–104.

16.

Foucault

(2008) The Birth of Biopolitics: Lectures at the College de France, 1978–1979. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

17.

Furstenberg

(2007) Destinies of the Disadvantaged: The Politics of Teenage Childbearing. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.

18.

Garwood

(2014) Regulating motherhood: A Foucauldian analysis of the social construction of the mother. The New Birmingham Review 1(1): 19–28.

19.

Geronimus

(2003) Damned if you do: Culture, identity, privilege, and teenage childbearing in the United States. Social Science & Medicine 57: 881–893.

20.

Goodwin

DWT

(1996) ‘He tapu te whare tangata’: Support for young Maori mothers during pregnancy, birth and motherhood. Master’s thesis, Massey University, New Zealand.

21.

Graham

McDermott

(2006) Qualitative research and the evidence base of policy: Insights from studies of teenage mothers in the UK. Journal of Social Policy 35: 21–37.

22.

Green

(2011) A discursive analysis of Maori in sexual and reproductive health policy. Master’s thesis, University of Waikato, New Zealand.

23.

Henman

Marston

(2008) The social division of welfare surveillance. Journal of Social Policy 37: 187–205.

24.

Humpage

(2006) An ‘inclusive’ society: A ‘leap forward’ for Māori in New Zealand? Critical Social Policy 26: 220–242.

25.

Humpage

(2016) Income management in New Zealand and Australia: Differently framed but similarly problematic for Indigenous peoples. Critical Social Policy. Epub ahead of print 29 March 2016. doi: 10.1177/0261018316638459.

26.

Kidger

(2004) Including young mothers: limitations to New Labour’s strategy for supporting teenage parents. Critical Social Policy 24: 291–311.

27.

MacLeod

(2001) Teenage motherhood and the regulation of mothering in the scientific literature: The South African example. Feminism & Psychology 11: 493–510.

28.

MacLeod

(2002) Economic security and the social science literature on teenage pregnancy in South Africa. Gender & Society 16: 647–664.

29.

MacLeod

Durrheim

(2002) Foucauldian feminism: The implications of governmentality. Journal for the theory of social behaviour 32(1): 41–60.

30.

Marie

Fergusson

Boden

(2011) Cultural identity and pregnancy/parenting by age 20: Evidence from a New Zealand birth cohort. Social Policy Journal of New Zealand (January): 19–36.

31.

Miller

(2012) Re-storying identities: Young women’s narratives of teenage parenthood and educational support. PhD thesis, University of Canterbury, Canterbury.

32.

Ministry of Youth Development (2013) Briefing to the Incoming Minister: Working with Young People for a Better Future. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development. Available at: www.myd.govt.nz/documents/resources-and-reports/publications/updated-redacted-myd-bim.pdf (accessed 14 August 2016).

33.

Moore

(2013) Governmentality and the maternal body: Infant mortality in early twentieth-century Lancashire. Journal of Historical Geography 39: 54–68.

34.

Morel

Palier

Palme

(2012) Towards a Social Investment Welfare State? Ideas, Policies and Challenges. Bristol: The Policy Press.

35.

MoSD (2012a) Departmental Report: Social Security (Youth Support and Work Focus) Amendment Bill. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development.

36.

MoSD (2012b) Regulatory Impact Statement: Youth Package. Policy Decisions on the Youth Package. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development.

37.

MoSD (2012c) Regulatory Impact Statement: Youth Package. Further Policy Decisions on the Youth Package. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development.

38.

MoSD (2015a) Departmental Report: Social Security (Extension of Young Persons Services and Remedial Matters) Amendment Bill. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development.

39.

MoSD (2015b) Regulatory Impact Statement – Extension of the Youth Service. February. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development. Available at: www.msd.govt.nz/about-msd-and-our-work/publications-resources/regulatory-impact-statements/extension-of-the-youth-service.html (accessed 14 August 2016).

40.

Neill-Weston

(2013) The politicisation of motherhood: Silencing sole mothers. Master’s thesis, Massey University, Palmerston North. Available at: hdl.handle.net/10179/7026 (accessed 14 August 2016).

41.

O’Brien

(2012) Lone parents working for welfare in New Zealand. Local Economy 27: 577–592.

42.

O’Brien

(2013) Welfare reform in Aotearoa/ New Zealand: From citizen to managed worker. Social Policy & Administration 47: 729–748.

43.

Office of the Minister for Social Development (2012) Further Policy Decisions on the Youth Package. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development.

44.

Office of the Privacy Commissioner (2012) Submission to the Social Services Committee on the Social Security (Youth Support and Work Focus) Amendment Bill. 13 April. Wellington: Office of the Privacy Commissioner. Available at: www.privacy.org.nz/news-and-publications/reports-to-parliament-and-government/submission-by-the-office-of-the-privacy-commissioner-on-the-social-security-youth-support-and-work-focus-amendment-bill/ (accessed 14 August 2016).

45.

Orr

(2015) Consistency with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990: Social Security (Extension of Young Persons Services and Remedial Matters) Amendment Bill. 10 June. Wellington: Ministry of Justice. Available at: www.justice.govt.nz/policy/constitutional-law-and-human-rights/human-rights/bill-of-rights/social-security-extension-of-young-persons-services-and-remedial-matters-amendment-bill (accessed 14 August 2016).

46.

Pihama

(1996) Policy constructions: In whose interest? A critical analysis of PAFT in relation to Maori education. Social Policy Journal of New Zealand: Te Puna Whakaaro (December): 108–123.

47.

Pulkingham

Fuller

Kershaw

(2010) Lone motherhood, welfare reform and active citizen subjectivity. Critical Social Policy 30(2): 267–291.

48.

Rawiri

(2007) Adolescent Maori mothers experiences with social support during pregnancy, birth and motherhood and their participation in education. Master’s thesis. University of Waikato, New Zealand.

49.

Rudoe

(2014) Becoming a young mother: Teenage pregnancy and parenting policy. Critical Social Policy 34: 293–311.

50.

SmithBattle

(2007) Legacies of advantage and disadvantage: The case of teen mothers. Public Health Nursing 24: 409–420.

51.

Social Services Committee (2012) Social Security (Youth Support and Work Focus) Amendment Bill 10–2 Commentary. 26 July. Wellington: New Zealand Parliament.

52.

The Treasury (2016) Social Investment. Available at: www.treasury.govt.nz/statesector/socialinvestment (last updated 18 February 2016) (accessed 14 August 2016).

53.

Tuffin

Rouch

Frewin

(2010) Constructing adolescent fatherhood: Responsibilities and intergenerational repair. Culture Health & Sexuality 12: 485–498.

54.

UK Government (1999) Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 1999. Background to the Act. The National Archives. Available at: www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1999/30/contents (accessed 06 July 2012).

55.

Ware

FJR

Walsh-Tapiata

(2010) Youth development: Māori styles. Youth Studies Australia 29(4): 18–30.

56.

Welfare Working Group (2011) Reducing Long-Term Benefit Dependency: Recommendations. Wellington: Welfare Working Group, Institute of Policy Studies, Victoria University. Available at: igps.victoria.ac.nz/WelfareWorkingGroup/Downloads/Final%20Report/WWG-Final-Recommendations-Report-22-February-2011.pdf (accessed 14 August 2016).

57.

Whitworth

Griggs

(2013) Lone parents and welfare-to-work conditionality: Necessary, just, effective? Ethics and Social Welfare 7(2): 124–140.

58.

Wilson

Huntington

(2006) Deviant (M)others: The construction of teenage motherhood in contemporary discourse. Journal of Social Policy 35(1): 59–76.

59.

Wynd

(2013) Benefit Sanctions: Creating an Invisible Underclass of Children? Child Poverty Action Group. Auckland: Child Poverty Action Group Inc. Available at: www.cpag.org.nz/assets/Backgrounders/2–0%2028509%20Benefit%20Sanctions%20Report%20Sept%202013.pdf (accessed 14 August 2016).