Financial incentives have increasingly been proposed to remedy what is described as a situation of global ‘organs scarcity’. In this article, I draw on qualitative sociological research investigating the corporeal generosity of living directed and non-directed kidney donors in New Zealand to ask what insights they can offer regarding financial incentives to encourage organ donation. This entails examining whether compensation and reimbursement for organ donation is likely to reduce donors’ capacity to act altruistically and diminish their dignity as moral subjects. In so doing, I seek to expand the conceptual tool kit of organ transplantation as a ‘gift of life’ to consider organ transfer in sociological terms as body work. I suggest that introducing the notion of body work into discussion about recompense for living kidney donation may help to unlock the ideological impasse currently polarising the debate between altruism and commerce.
BraunVClarkeV (2006) ‘Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology’, Qualitative Research in Psychology3: 77–101.
5.
CherryMJ (2005) Kidney for Sale by Owner: Human Organs, Transplantation, and the Market. Washington DC: Georgetown University Press.
6.
CohenCB (2002) ‘Public Policy and the Sale of Human Organs’, Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal12(1): 47–67.
7.
DaarAS (1998) ‘Paid Organ Donation – the Grey Basket Concept’, Journal of Medical Ethics24(6): 365–368.
8.
DewMAJacobsCLJowseySGHantoRMillerCDelmonicoFL (2007) ‘Guidelines for the Psychosocial Evaluation of Living Unrelated Kidney Donors in the United States’, American Journal of Transplantation7: 1047–1054.
9.
ErinCAHarrisJ (2003) ‘An Ethical Market in Human Organs’, Journal of Medical Ethics29: 137–138.
10.
FinchJGrovesD (1980) ‘Community Care and the Family: A Case for Equal Opportunities’, Journal of Social Policy9(4): 487–514.
11.
FisherMS (2003) ‘Psychosocial Evaluation Interview Protocol for Living Related and Living Unrelated Kidney Donors’, Social Work in Health Care38(1): 39–61.
12.
FortinM-CDion-LabrieMHébertM-JDoucetH (2010) ‘The Enigmatic Nature of Altruism in Organ Transplantation: A Cross-cultural Study of Transplant Physicians’ Views on Altruism’, BMC Research Notes3: 216 [http://www.biomedcentral.com/1756-0500/3/216].
13.
FoxRC (1996) ‘Afterthoughts: Continuing Reflections on Organ Transplantation’, pp. 252–272 in YoungnerSJFoxRCO’ConnellLJ (eds) Organ Transplantation: Meanings and Realities. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
14.
FranklinPMCrombieAK (2003) ‘Live Related Renal Transplantation: Psychological, Social, and Cultural Issues’, Transplantation76(8): 1247–1252.
15.
GhodsAJ (2004) ‘Governed Financial Incentives as an Alternative to Altruistic Organ Donation’, Experimental and Clinical Transplantation2(2): 221–228.
16.
GillMBSadeRM (2002) ‘Paying for Kidneys: The Case against Prohibition’, Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal12(1): 17–45.
17.
GimlinD (2007) ‘What is “Body Work”? A Review of the Literature’, Sociology Compass1(1): 353–370.
18.
GoodwinM (2009) ‘Empires of the Flesh: Tissue and Organ Taboos’, Alabama Law Review60(5): 1219–1248.
19.
GordonEJ (2012) ‘Informed Consent for Living Donation: A Review of Key Empirical Studies, Ethical Challenges and Future Research’, American Journal of Transplantation12(9): 2273–2280.
20.
HealyK (2004) ‘Altruism as an Organizational Problem: The Case of Organ Procurement’, American Sociological Review69: 387–404.
21.
HughesPM (2009) ‘Constraint, Consent, and Well-being in Human Kidney Sales’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy34: 606–631.
22.
MatasAJ (2008) ‘Should We Pay Donors to Increase the Supply of Organs for Transplantation? Yes’, British Medical Journal336: 1342.
23.
McCuneTR (2008) ‘Social Issues’, pp. 64–69 in GruessnerRWGBenedettiE (eds) Living Donor Organ Transplantation. New York: McGraw-Hill.
PidgeonG (2012) ‘New Zealand Dialysis and Transplantation Audit: 2010’. National Renal Advisory Board [http://www.moh.govt.nz/nrab], accessed 27 November 2012.
26.
Radcliffe-RichardsJ (1998) ‘The Case for Allowing Kidney Sales: International Forum for Transplant Ethics’, Lancet351: 1950–1952.
27.
SatelS (2008) When Altruism Isn’t Enough: The Case for Compensating Organ Donors. Washington DC: AEI Press.
28.
SaundersB (2012) ‘Altruism or Solidarity? The Motives for Organ Donation and Two Proposals’, Bioethics26(7): 376–381.
29.
SavulescuJ (2003) ‘Is the Sale of Body Parts Wrong?’, Journal of Medical Ethics29: 138–139.
30.
Scheper-HughesN (2004) ‘Parts Unknown: Undercover Ethnography of the Organs-Trafficking Underworld’, Ethnography5(1): 29–73.
31.
Scheper-HughesN (2007) ‘The Tyranny of the Gift: Sacrificial Violence in Living Donor Transplants’, American Journal of Transplantation7: 507–511.
32.
SegevDLMuzaaleADCaffoBSMehtaSHSingerALTarantoSEMcBrideMAMontgomeryRA (2010) ‘Perioperative Mortality and Long-term Survival Following Live Kidney Donation’, JAMA303(10): 959–966.
33.
ShildrickMMcKeeverPAbbeySPooleJRossH (2009) ‘Troubling Dimensions of Heart Transplantation’, Medical Humanities35: 35–38.
34.
ShillingC (2005) The Body in Culture, Technology & Society. London: SAGE.
35.
SothernMDickinsonJ (2011) ‘Repaying the Gift of Life: Self-help, Organ Transfer and the Debt of Care’, Social & Cultural Geography12(8): 889–903.
36.
SteinmanJL (2006) ‘Gender Disparity in Organ Donation’, Gender Medicine3(4): 246–252.
37.
StrathernMWrightK (2011) ‘Donating Bodily Material: The Nuffield Council Report’, Clinical Ethics6: 191–194.
38.
TitmussRA (1997) The Gift Relationship: From Human Blood to Social Policy, ed. A Oakley and J Ashton. New York: The New Press.
39.
TongAChapmanJRWongGKanellisJMcCarthyGCraigJC (2012a) ‘The Motivations and Experiences of Living Kidney Donors: A Thematic Synthesis’, American Journal of Kidney Disease60(1): 15–26.
40.
TongACraigJCWongGArmstrongSSchollumJCrossN (2012b) ‘“It Was Just an Unconditional Gift”: Self Reflections of Non-directed Living Kidney Donors’, Clinical Transplantation26(4): 589–599.
41.
TrotterG (2008) ‘Preferred Allocation for Registered Organ Donors’, Transplantation Reviews22: 158–162.
42.
TwiggJ (2000) ‘Carework as a Form of Bodywork’, Ageing and Society20(4): 389–411.
43.
TwiggJWolkowitzCCohenRLNettletonS (eds) (2011) Body Work in Health and Social Care: Critical Themes, New Agendas. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.
44.
ValapourM (2008) ‘The Live Organ Donor’s Consent: Is It Informed and Voluntary?’, Transplantation Reviews22(3): 196–199.
45.
WolkowitzC (2002) ‘The Social Relations of Body Work’, Work, Employment & Society16(3): 497–510.
46.
WolkowitzC (2006) Bodies at Work. London: SAGE.
47.
ZeilerK (2009) ‘Just Love in Live Organ Donation’, Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy12: 323–331.
