Introduction: Neoliberal housing policy – time for a critical re-appraisal

Abstract

This paper introduces the themed section of Critical Social Policy on social housing, privatization and neoliberalism. In tracing the key elements in the development of privatization and residualization since 1979, it argues that these can only be fully understood as part of a wider neoliberalizing agenda, an agenda that is driven by a particular class project. The paper also seeks to re-assert the importance of a critical approach to successive decades of social housing policies in the devolved UK, arguing that the classed basis of housing privatization policies has been largely overlooked by academics in favour of an evolutionary and ‘modernizing’ framework which isolates developments in social housing provision from other wider shifts in social welfare and in labour markets. Understanding such processes, it is claimed, is a necessary step in the development of a more socially just and sustainable form of housing provision.

Keywords

class housing neoliberalism privatization stock transfer

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

(2008) Housing Market Renewal and Social Class. Abingdon: Routledge.

Allen

Imrie

(2010) The Knowledge Business: The Commodification of Urban and Housing Research. Farnham: Ashgate.

Annetts

Law

McNeish

Mooney

(2009) Understanding Social Welfare Movements. Bristol: Policy Press.

Ball

(1982) ‘Housing Provision and the Economic Crisis’, Capital and Class 6(2): 60–77.

Bank of England (2011) Financial Stability Report, June 2011. Issue No. 29. London: Bank of England. [http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Pages/fsr/2011/fsr29.aspx]

Brenner

(2009) ‘What is Critical Urban Theory?’, City 13(2–3): 198–207.

Clark

(2010) ‘Housing Benefit Changes Will Push the Poor Out of Town’, The Guardian, 29 June.

Cole

Furbey

(1994) The Eclipse of Council Housing. London: Routledge.

Collinson

(2012) ‘The East End Tenants Facing Eviction during the Olympics’, The Guardian, 19 May.

10.

Conservative Research Department (1976) ‘Public Housing Sector Policy Group – Report’, June [http://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/110148].

11.

Critical Social Policy (2012) ‘Social Policy in an Age of Austerity’ [Themed Issue], Critical Social Policy 32(3): 297–478.

12.

Crook

(1986) ‘Privatisation of Housing and the Impact of the Conservative Government’s Initiatives on Low-Cost Homeownership and Private Renting between 1979 and 1984 in England and Wales: 1. The Privatisation Policies’, Environment and Planning A 18: 639–659.

13.

Cumbers

Helms

Swanson

(2010) ‘Class, Agency and Resistance in the Old Industrial City’, Antipode 42(1): 46–73.

14.

Davison

Dovey

Woodcock

(2012) ‘Keeping Dalston Different: Defending Place-Identity in East London’, Planning Theory & Practice 13(1): 47–69.

15.

DCH (Defend Council Housing) (2006) The Case for Council Housing in 21st Century Britain. London: Defend Council Housing.

16.

DCLG (Department for Communities and Local Government) (2010) Local Decisions: A Fairer Future for Social Housing – Consultation. London: DCLG.

17.

DCLG (2012) ‘Table 241 House Building: Permanent Dwellings Completed by Tenure, United Kingdom Historical Calendar Year Series’ [http://www.communities.gov.uk/documents/housing/xls/2145750.xls], accessed 2 June 2012.

18.

Fenton

(2010) ‘How Will Changes to Local Housing Allowance Affect Low-Income Tenants in Private Rented Housing?’, Working Paper, September. Cambridge: Cambridge Centre for Housing and Planning Research, University of Cambridge.

19.

Forrest

Murie

(1988) Selling the Welfare State: The Privatisation of Public Housing. London: Routledge.

20.

Foucault

(1991) ‘Governmentality’, pp. 87–104 in Burchell

Gordon

Miller

(eds) The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

21.

Fuller

Geddes

(2008) ‘Urban Governance under Neoliberalism: New Labour and the Restructuring of State-space’, Antipode 40(2): 252–282.

22.

Ginsburg

(1981) ‘Rejoinder to Sidney Jacobs’, Critical Social Policy 1(2): 48–53.

23.

Ginsburg

(1989) ‘The Housing Act, 1988 and its Policy Context: A Critical Commentary’, Critical Social Policy 9: 56–81.

24.

Ginsburg

(2005) ‘The Privatization of Council Housing’, Critical Social Policy 25(1): 115–135.

25.

Glynn

(ed.) (2009) Where the Other Half Lives: Lower Income Housing in a Neoliberal World. London: Pluto Press.

26.

Hamnett

(2010) ‘Moving the Poor Out of Central London? The Implications of the Coalition Government 2010 Cuts to Housing Benefits’, Environment and Planning A 42(12): 2809–2819.

27.

Harloe

(1982) ‘Towards the Decommodification of Housing? A Comment on Council House Sales’, Critical Social Policy 2(4): 39–42.

28.

Harvey

(2005) A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

29.

Harvey

(2012) Rebel Cities: From the Right to the City to the Urban Revolution. London: Verso.

30.

Hodkinson

(2009) ‘From Popular Capitalism to Third-Way Modernisation: The Case of Leeds, England’, pp. 99–123 in Glynn

(ed.) Where the Other Half Lives: Lower Income Housing in a Neoliberal World. London: Pluto Press.

31.

Hodkinson

(2011) ‘The Private Finance Initiative in English Council Housing Regeneration: A Privatisation too Far?’, Housing Studies 26(6): 911–932.

32.

Hughes

Lowe

(1995) Social Housing Law and Policy. London: Butterworths.

33.

Immergluck

(2009) Foreclosed: High-Risk Lending, Deregulation and the Undermining of America’s Mortgage Market. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

34.

Jacobs

(1981a) ‘The Sale of Council Houses: Does it Matter?’, Critical Social Policy 1(2): 35–48.

35.

Jacobs

(1981b) ‘Socialist Housing Strategy and Council House Sales: A Reply to Ginsburg and Karnavou’, Critical Social Policy 1(3): 40–45.

36.

Jones

Murie

(2006) The Right to Buy: Analysis and Evaluation of a Housing Policy. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.

37.

Karnavou

(1981) ‘Rejoinder to Sidney Jacobs’, Critical Social Policy 1(2): 48–53.

38.

Lees

(2011) ‘The Urban Injustices of New Labour’s New Urban Renewal: The Case of the Aylesbury Estate in London’, Paper presented at the 23rd ENHR Conference, Toulouse, 5–8 July.

39.

Leitner

Peck

Sheppard

(2007) Contesting Neoliberalism. New York: Guilford Press.

40.

Malpass

(1990) Reshaping Housing Policy: Subsidies, Rents and Residualisation. London: Routledge.

41.

Malpass

(2005) Housing and the Welfare State: The Development of Housing Policy in England. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

42.

Malpass

Mullins

(2002) ‘Policy Review. Local Authority Housing Stock Transfer in the UK: From Local Initiative to National Policy’, Housing Studies 17(4): 673–686.

43.

Malpass

Victory

(2010) ‘The Modernisation of Social Housing in England’, International Journal of Housing Policy 10(1): 3–18.

44.

Marcuse

(2009) ‘A Critical Approach to the Subprime Mortgage Crisis in the United States: Rethinking the Public Sector in Housing’, City and Community 8(3): 351–356.

45.

McKee

Phillips

(2012) ‘Social Housing and Homelessness Policies: Reconciling Social Justice and Social Mix’, pp. 223–238 in Mooney

Scott

(eds) Social Justice and Social Policy in Scotland. Bristol: Policy Press.

46.

Merrett

(1979) State Housing in Britain. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

47.

Ministry of Justice (2012) Statistics on Mortgage and Landlord Possession Actions in the County Courts in England and Wales – First Quarter 2012. London: Ministry of Justice.

48.

Mooney

Law

(2007) New Labour/Hard Labour? Bristol: Policy Press.

49.

Mooney

Poole

(2005) ‘Marginalised Voices: Resisting the Privatisation of Council Housing in Glasgow’, Local Economy 20(1): 27–39.

50.

O’Malley

(2004) Risk, Uncertainty and Government. London: Glasshouse Press.

51.

Pawson

(2006) ‘Restructuring England’s Social Housing Sector since 1989: Undermining or Underpinning the Fundamentals of Public Housing?’, Housing Studies 21(5): 767–783.

52.

Pawson

Mullins

(2010) After Council Housing: Britain’s New Social Landlords. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

53.

Schmuecker

(2011) The Good, the Bad and the Ugly: Housing Demand 2025. London: Institute for Public Policy Research. [http://www.ippr.org.uk/publicationsandreports/publication.asp?id=807]

54.

Shelter (2012) London Rent Watch: Rent Inflation and Affordability in London’s Private Rental Market. London: Shelter.

55.

Smith

Stenning

Willis

(2008) Social Justice and Neoliberalism: Global Perspectives. London: Zed Books.

56.

Smith

(2002) ‘New Globalism, New Urbanism: Gentrification as Global Urban Strategy’, Antipode 34(3): 427–450.

57.

Urban Studies (2008) ‘Special Issue on Gentrification and Public Policy’, Urban Studies 45(12): 2379–2642.

58.

Walker

(2001) ‘How to Abolish Public Housing: Implications and Lessons from Public Management Reform’, Housing Studies 16(5): 675–696.

59.

Wallace

(2010) Remaking Community? New Labour and the Governance of Poor Neighbourhoods. Farnham: Ashgate.

60.

Watt

(2008) ‘“Underclass” and “Ordinary People” Discourses: Representing/ Re-presenting Council Tenants in a Housing Campaign’, Critical Discourse Studies 5(3): 345–357.

61.

Watt

(2009) ‘Housing Stock Transfers, Regeneration and State-led Gentrification in London’, Urban Policy and Research 27(3): 229–242.

62.

Watt

(2011) ‘Whatever Happened to Class in Housing Studies?’, Paper presented at ‘Housing in Hard Times: Class, Poverty and Social Exclusion’, Housing Studies Association Conference, University of York, 13–15 April.

63.

Wilks-Heeg

(2009) ‘New Labour and the Reform of English Local Government, 1997–2007: Privatizing the Parts that Conservative Governments Could Not Reach’, Planning, Practice & Research 24(1): 23–39.

64.

Woodward

(1991) ‘Mobilising Opposition: The Campaign against Housing Action Trusts in Tower Hamlets’, Housing Studies 6(1): 44–56.