Abstract
In his controversial new book Dogs and Demons: The Fall of Modern Japan, Alex Kerr (2001) maintains that modern Japan represents ‘a case of failed modernization’ due to a deep-seated ‘cultural malaise’ that arises ‘because of a severe mismatch between Japan’s bureaucratic systems and the realities of modern life’. Kerr argues this thesis by means of examples drawn from the arts, culture, economics, politics and other aspects of contemporary Japan. This review note attempts to provide a critical examination of Kerr’s economic arguments. We contend that he has radically overstated his case, ignored much existing critical literature on Nippon, and ‘exoticised’ Japanese society unnecessarily.
Keywords
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Befu H.
(2001 ). Hegemony of Homogeneity , Trans Pacific Press , Melbourne .
2.
Dale P.
(1986 ). The Myth of Japanese Uniqueness , Croom Helm , London .
3.
Emmerson. J.K.
(1978 ). A Japanese Thread: A Life in the US Foreign Service , Holt , Rinehart and Winston, New York .
4.
Friedman C.
(ed.) (2001 ). Economic Reform in Japan: Can the Japanese Change? , Edward Elgar , Cheltenham .
5.
Gibney F.
(ed.) (1998 ). Unlocking the Bureaucrat’s Kingdom: Deregulation and the JapaneseEconomy , Brookings Institute , Washington .
6.
Gibney F.
(1979 ). Japan: The Fragile Superpower , Sharpe , New York .
7.
Kerr A.
(2001 ). Dogs and Demons: The Fall of Modern Japan , Penguin Books , London .
8.
Hall I.P.
(2002 ). Bamboozled! How America Loses the Intellectual Game With Japan and ItsImplications , Sharpe , New York .
9.
Ito T
(1992 ). The Japanese Economy (Eighth edition), MIT Press , London .
10.
Lomborg B.
(2001 ). The Skeptical Environmentalist , Cambridge University Press , Cambridge .
11.
McCormack G.
(1996 ). The Emptiness of Japanese Affluence , Sharpe , New York .
12.
Miller R.A.
(1982 ). Japan’s Modern Myth: The Language and Beyond , Weatherhill , New York .
13.
Mouer R.
Sugimoto Y.
(1986 ). Images of Japanese Society , Keegan Paul International , London .
14.
Shoppa L.J.
(2001 ). ‘Japan, the Reluctant Reformer’ , Foreign Affairs , September/October , 76 –90 .
15.
Woodhall B.
(1996 ). Japan Under Construction , University of California Press , Berkeley .
16.
Yoshino K.
(1997 ). Bunka Nashonarizumu no Shakaigaku [The Sociology of Cultural Nationalism] , Nagoya Daigaku Shuppankai , Nagoya .
17.
Yoshino K.
(1992 ). Cultural Nationalism in Contemporary Japan , Routledge , London .