Orwellian Rectification

Abstract

What Churchill's biographers have written about his life matter because he continues to be deployed by ideological conservatives in the Anglo-Saxon countries as the ideal leader exemplifying decisiveness and moral courage. This content analysis of seventeen popular biographies of Britain's emblematic prime minister show that they consistently ignore material about a decision taken by his government during the Second World War that had disastrous consequences for the Indians. While nearly all of the biographies treat the controversial area bombing of Germany by the Royal Air Force, which resulted in approximately 900,000 deaths of non-combatants, none treat the failure to respond to the 1943 Bengal Famine, which resulted in more deaths than the number of non-combatant deaths. This discrepancy may be explained by unconscious or conscious racist Eurocentrism that places greater value on the lives of Europeans than those of Asians. That was certainly true of their subject, and their choice of subject may reflect shared identity of values.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Addison, P. (2005), Churchill: The Unexpected Hero, Oxford .

Bayly, C. and T. Harper (2005), Forgotten Armies: The Fall of British Asia, 1941–1945, Cambridge .

Best, G. (2001), Churchill: A Study in Greatness, London .

Bose, S. (1990), ‘ Starvation among Plenty: The Making of Famine in Bengal, Honan and Tonkin, 1942–45 ’, Modern Asian Studies, Vol. 24: 4, pp. 699–727 .

Broad, L. (1963), Winston Churchill: The Years of Achievement, New York .

Callahan, R. (1984), Churchill: Retreat From Empire, Wilmington .

Cowles, V. (1953), Winston Churchill: The Era And The Man, New York .

Friedrich, J. (2006), The Fire: The Bombing of Germany, 1940–1945, Allison Brown, trans., New York .

Gilbert, M. (1988), Winston S. Churchill, 1874–1965. Volume VIII, ‘Never Despair,’ 1945–1965, Boston .

10.

Gilbert, M. (1991), Churchill: A Life, New York .

11.

Grayling, A. (2006), Among the Dead Cities: The History and Moral Legacy of the WWII Bombing of Civilians in Germany and Japan, New York .

12.

Greenough, P. (1982), Prosperity and Misery in Modern Bengal: The Famine of 1943–1944, New York .

13.

Grosscup, B. (2006), Strategic Terror: The Politics and Ethics of Aerial Bombardment, London .

14.

Holmes, R. (2005), In the Footsteps of Churchill: A Study in Character, New York .

15.

Jenkins, R. (2001), Churchill: A Biography, New York .

16.

Loconte, J. (2006), ‘ Churchillian Courage: Moral Leadership and the War on Terror ’, National Review, 21 June.

17.

Lukacs, J. (2002), Churchill: Visionary. Statesman. Historian, New Haven .

18.

Moran, Lord (1966), Churchill: Taken From the Diaries of Lord Moran, Boston .

19.

Moore, H. , (1944), ‘ India and Us ’, Far Eastern Survey, Vol. 13: 1, pp. 1–2 .

20.

Norton, A. (2004), Leo Strauss and the Politics of American Empire, New Haven .

21.

Orwell, G. (1949), Nineteen Eighty-Four, London .

22.

Payne, R. (1974), The Great Man: A Portrait of Winston Churchill, New York .

23.

Roberts, A. (2005), ‘ Blood, Toil, Tears, Etc.; Is There Anything New to be Said About Winston Churchill? ’, The Weekly Standard, 26 September.

24.

Rose, N. (1995), Churchill: The Unruly Giant, New York .

25.

Rubin, G. (2003), Forty Ways to Look at Winston Churchill, New York .

26.

Taylor, F. (2004), Dresden: Tuesday, 13 February 1945, New York .

27.

Thompson. K. (1983), Winston Churchill's World View: Statesmanship and Power, Baton Rouge .

28.

Thompson, W. (1955), Assignment: Churchill, New York .

29.

Venkataramani, M. (1973), Bengal Famine of 1943: The American Response, Delhi .

30.

Weintraub, P. (1945), ‘ UNRRA: An Experiment in International Welfare Planning ’, The Journal of Politics, Vol. 7: 1, pp. 1–24 .