This study examines the relationship between claiming unemployment insurance in Canada and the immigrant class in which immigrants were admitted using a new data base that combines tax and immigration records. Immigrants who entered Canada in 1980, 1985 or 1989, and who filed a personal income tax return, are followed from their year of landing until 1995 when the data end. There are large differences among the immigrant classes in the claims made against Canada's unemployment insurance scheme. Claim rates rise rapidly in the few years after arrival no matter in which class a person happened to be admitted in or which year she or he landed, but those rates decline thereafter for all classes or landing cohorts. Claim rates for Canada as a whole, as well as for the provinces of Ontario, Quebec, Alberta, and British Columbia, for both males and females, are examined and the patterns described above are repeated.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BeachC. and KaliskiS. F.1983“The Impact of the 1979 Unemployment Insurance Amendments,”Canadian Public Policy, 9(2):164–173.
2.
BakerM. and BenjaminD.1995a “The Receipt of Transfer Payments by Immigrants to Canada,”Journal of Human Resources, 30(4):650–676.
3.
BakerM. and BenjaminD.1995b “Labor Market Outcomes and the Participaiton of Immigrant Women in Canadian Transfer Programs.” In Diminishing Returns: The Economics of Canada's Recent Immigration Policy. Ed. DeVoretzD.Toronto: CD. Howe Institute. Pp. 209–242.
4.
BlauF.1984“The Use of Transfer Payments by Immigrants,”Industrial Labor Relations Review, 37:222–239. January.
5.
BorjasG. and HiltonL.1996“Immigration and the Welfare State: Immigrant Participation in Means-Tested Entitlement Programs,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 11:575–604. May.
6.
BorjasG. and TrejoS.1991“Immigrant Participation in the Welfare System,”Industrial Labor Relations Review, 44:195–211. January.
7.
CardD. and RiddellC.1993“A Comparative Analysis of Unemployment in Canada and the United States.” In Small Differences That Matter: Labor Markets and Income Maintenance in Canada and the United States. Ed. CardD. and FreemanR.Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Pp. 149–189.
8.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada1997“Preliminary Profile of Immigrants Landed in Canada over the 1980 to 1994 Period.” Prepared for distribution at the CERF-CIC Conference on Immigration, Employment, and the Economy.
9.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada1995a A Broader Vision: 1996 Immigration Plan.Ottawa: Citizenship and Immigration Canada.
10.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada1995b “Disentangling Effects–A Glimpse of the Power of the IMDB, October 1997.” Prepared for distribution at the CERF-CIC Conference on Immigration, Employment and the Economy.
11.
CousineauJ. M.1985“Unemployment Insurance and Labour Market Adjustment.” In Income Distribution and Economic Security in Canada. Ed. VaillancourtF.Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Pp. 187–213.
12.
Department of Finance1995Economic Reference Tables.Ottawa: Department of Finance Canada. August.
13.
DumasJ. and BelangerA.1996Report on the Demographic Situation in Canada 1995.Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
14.
Economic Council of Canada1991Economic and Social Impacts of Immigration.Ottawa: Supply and Services Canada.
15.
FootD. and MilneW.1994“Population-Output Linkages: A National and Regional Perspective,”Canadian Journal of Regional Science, 17:395–412. Autumn.
16.
GreenD. and GreenA.1995“Canadian Immigration Policy: The Effectiveness of the Point System and Other Instruments,”Canadian Journal of Economics, 28(4b):1006—1041.
17.
GreenD. and RiddellC.1993“The Economic Effects of Unemployment Insurance in Canada: An Empirical Analysis of UI Disentitlement,”Journal of Labor Economics, 11(1):S96–S147.
18.
KesselmanJ.1983Financing Canadian Unemployment Insurance.Canadian Tax Foundation.
19.
LangloisC. and DoughertyC.1997The Longitudinal Immigration Database (IMDB).Ottawa: Citizenship and Immigration Canada.
20.
MarrW.1988SOPEMI 1988.Wilfrid Laurier University.
21.
MyattA.1992“Provincial Unemployment Rate Disparities: A Case of No Concern?”Canadian Journal of Regional Science, 15:101–119. Spring.
22.
Revenue Canada Various Taxation Statistics.Ottawa: Revenue Canada. Years
23.
RiddellC.1985“Work and Pay: The Canadian Labour Market: An Overview.” In Work and Pay: The Canadian Labour Market. Ed. RiddellC.Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Pp. 1–75.
24.
RobertsonM.1986“A Longitudinal Perspective on the Unemployment Experience of Principal Applicant Immigrants to Canada: 1977–1981,”Canadian Studies in Population, 13(1):37—56.
25.
SamuelT. J.1984“Economic Adaptation of Refugees in Canada: Experience of a Quarter Century,”International Migration, 22(1):45–55.
26.
SamuelT. J. and WoloskiB.1985“The Labour Market Experience of Canadian Immigrants,”International Migration, 23(2):225–250.
27.
SiklosP. and MarrW.1998a “The Unemployment Insurance Compensation Usage of Canada's Immigrants Resident in Selected Provinces, 1981–1988,”International Migration, 36(3):337–356.
28.
SiklosP. and MarrW.1998b “The Unemployment Insurance Compensation Experience of Immigrants in Canada, 1980–1988,”Journal of Population Economics, 11(1): 127–147.
29.
Statistics Canada1984b Unemployment Insurance 1984.Ottawa: Supply and Services Canada.
30.
WrightR. E. and MaximP. S.1991“Changes in the ‘Cohort Quality’ of Canadian Immigrants.” Paper presented at the Canadian Economics Association meetings, Kingston, Ontario.
