This article evaluates the concept of migration channels, identifying the strengths and weaknesses that have emerged from use of a migration channels framework in international migration research. Using professional migration to and from Hong Kong in the 1990s as an empirical lens, it is argued that the meso-scale understanding offered by examining the effect of migration channels is valuable. This is illustrated in terms of the contrasting channels used by different professions, as well by migrants motivated to move by citizenship as opposed to career reasons. Survey research of migrant engineers and doctors, however, points to the need to recast the channels migration framework in at least three ways, giving stronger recognition to 1) the strategic behavior of migrants themselves, 2) the need for a theorization of the hierarchically ordered economic “space” within which migration channels operate and, 3) the sociocultural context within which constructions of the meaning of migration and place occur.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AppleyardR.1989“International Migration and Developing Countries.” In The Impact of International Development on Developing Countries. Ed. AppleyardR.Paris: OECD. Pp. 19–36.
2.
Asian Migrant Center1994Nowhere To Turn To.Hong Kong: Asian Migrant Center.
3.
BeaverstockJ.1994“Rethinking Skilled International Labour Migration – World Cities and Banking Organizations,”Geoforum, 25:323–338.
4.
BeaverstockJ.1991“Skilled International Labour Migration: An Analysis of the Geography of International Secondments within Large Accountancy Firms,”Environment and Planning A, 23:1133–1146.
5.
BoyleM., FindlayA., LelievreE. and PaddisonR.1996“World Cities and the Limits to Global Control: A Case Study of Executive Search Firms in Europe's Leading Cities,”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 20:498–517.
6.
ChampionA.1994“International Migration and Demographic Change in the Developed World,”Urban Studies, 31:653–677.
7.
CormodeL.1994“Japanese Foreign Direct Investment and the Circulation of Personnel from Japan to Canada.” In Population Migration and the Changing World Order. Ed. GouldW.T.S. and FindlayA.M.Chichester: Wiley. Pp. 67–90.
8.
EelensF. and SpeckmannJ. D.1990“Recruitment of Labor Migrants for the Middle East,”International Migration Review, 24:297–322.
9.
FindlayA. and GarrickL.1990“Scottish Emigration in the 1990s,”Transactions, Institute of British Geographers, 15:177–192.
10.
FindlayA., LiF. L. N., JowettA. J. and SkeldonR.1996“Skilled International Migration and the Global City,”Transactions, Institute of British Geographers, 21:54–65.
11.
FindlayA. M.1994“Doctors Diagnose Their Destinations,”Environment and Planning A, 26:1605–1624.
12.
FordR.1992Migration and Stress among Corporate Employees. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of London.
13.
FriedmannJ.1986“The World City Hypothesis,”Development and Change, 17:69–83.
14.
GarrickL.1991A Channels Framework for the Study of Skilled International Migration. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Glasgow.
15.
GossJ. and LindquistB.1995“Conceptualizing International Migration: A Structuration Perspective,”International Migration Review, 29:317–351.
16.
GouldW.S.T.1990“Occupational Continuity and International Migration of Skilled Workers,”International Migration, 27:3–14.
17.
HardieE. T.1994“Recruitment and Release: Migrant Advisers and the Creation of Exile.” In Reluctant Exiles? Ed. SkeldonR.Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press. Pp. 52–67.
18.
Hong Kong Government Industry Department (HKID)19921992 Survey of Overseas Investment in Hong Kong's Manufacturing Industries.Hong Kong:Data and Services Division Industry Department.
19.
KanjanapanW.1995“The Immigration of Asian Professionals to the United States: 1988–1990,”International Migration Review, 29(1):7–32.
20.
KnoxP.1996“Globalization and the World City Hypothesis,”Scottish Geographical Magazine, 112:124–126.
21.
LiF. L. N. and FindlayA.1996“Placing Identity: Interviews with Hong Kong Chinese Immigrants in Britain and Canada, International Journal of Population Geography, 2:361–378.
22.
LiF. L. N., JowettA. J., FindlayA. and SkeldonR.1995“Discourse on Migration and Ethnic Identity: Interviews with Professionals in Hong Kong,”Transactions, Institute of British Geographers, 20:342–356.
23.
LiF. L. N., FindlayA., JowettA. J. and SkeldonR.1996“Migrating to Learn and Learning to Migrate,”International Journal of Population Geography, 2:51–69.
24.
ProtheroM.1990“Labor Recruiting Organizations in the Developing World,”International Migration Review, 24:221–228.
25.
RadcliffeS.1990“Between Hearth and Labor Market,”International Migration Review, 24:229–249.
26.
SaltJ.1992“Migration Processes amongst the Highly Skilled in Europe,”International Migration Review, 26:484–505.
27.
SassenS.1991The Global City.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
28.
SkeldonR., ed. 1994Reluctant Exiles?Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.
29.
SkeldonR.1996Labour Market Developments and Foreign Worker Policy in Hong Kong.” In Migration and the Labour Market in Asia.Paris: OECD.
30.
SkeldonR., JowettA. J., FindlayA. M. and LiF. L. N.1995“An Assessment of the Available Data Sources for the Analysis of Trends in Migration.” In Emigration from Hong Kong. Ed. SkeldonR.Hong Kong: Chinese University Press. Pp. 79–110.
31.
TaylorJ.1990“The Reorganization of Mine Labor Recruitment in Southern Africa,”International Migration Review, 24:250–272.
32.
TzengR.1995“International Migration through Multinational Enterprises,”International Migration Review, 29:139–154.
33.
YuW.1983“The Fading Pearl of the Orient under the Confidence Crisis,”The Nineties, 166:30–33. November. (Chinese)
