U.K. Statistics on Immigration: Development and Limitations 1

Abstract

This article discusses the data on international migration to the United Kingdom, their limitations and their origins. No one source gives a demographically satisfactory account of net migration, and different sources of data are not compatible with each other. Their present form can only be understood in the context of a reluctant acceptance, in the face of domestic political pressure, of the need to impose the same controls on the entry of Commonwealth citizens from 1962 through to 1971 as had been imposed on the entry of aliens since 1920. An attempt is made to relate these attitudes to a broader historical context.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baines

1985 “Migration in a Mature Economy”. Emigration and Internal Migration in England and Wales 1861-1900. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Barnett

C.D.

1972 The Collapse of British Power. London.

Betts

1971 “The Allusion to Rome in British Imperial Thought of the Late 19th and Early 20th Centuries”. Victorian Studies 15, 156.

Board of Trade 1894 Reports on the Volume and Effects of Recent Immigration from Eastern Europe into the United Kingdom. c.7406. London, HMSO.

Bohning

W.R.

1972 The Migration of Workers in the United Kingdom and the European Community. London, Oxford University Press.

Brown

1985 Black and White Britain. London, Heinemann.

Bryce

Visc. 1901 “The Roman Empire and the British Empire in India”. In Studies in History and Jurisprudence, Vol. 1. Oxford, Clarendon Press.

Bryce

1914 The Ancient Roman Empire and the British Empire in India. “The Diffusion of Roman and English Law Throughout the World”. Two historical studies … London.

Coleman

D.A.

, ed. 1982 The Demography of Immigrants and Minority Groups in the United Kingdom. London, Academic Press.

10.

Coleman

D.A.

1985 “Inter-Ethnic Marriage in Great Britain”. Population Trends, 40, 4-10.

11.

Coleman

D.A.

1983 “Some Problems of Data for the Demographic Study of Immigration and of Immigrant and Minority Populations in Britain”. Ethnic and Racial Studies 6, 1, 103-110.

12.

Council of Europe 1981 “European Migration in the 1980s: Trends and Policies”. Conference of European ministers responsible for migration affairs, Strasbourg, Council of Europe.

13.

Cramb

J.A.

1915 Origins and Destiny of Imperial Britain. London, Letchworth.

14.

Devis

1985 “International Migration – Return Migrants and Re-Migrants Flows”. Population Trends, 41, 13-20.

15.

Dicey

A.V.

1897 “A Common Citizenship for the English Race”. Contemporary Review 71, 467. (See also, 19th Century 56, Dec. 1903).

16.

Garvey

1985 “The History of Migration Flows in the Republic of Ireland”. Population Trends, 39, 22-30.

17.

General Household Survey 1971 Introductory Report. Pp. 75–83. London, HMSO 1973.

18.

Gilley

1978 “English Attitudes to the Irish in England, 1789-1900”. In Immigrants and Minorities in British Society. Edited by Holmes

London, George Allen and Unwin.

19.

Hobson

J.A.

1902 Imperialism. (Reprinted 1961, London, George Allen and Unwin).

20.

Hollis

1982 “New Commonwealth Ethnic Groups. Populations in Greater London”. In The Demography of Immigrant and Minority Groups in the United Kingdom. Edited by Coleman

D.A.

London, Academic Press.

21.

Holmes

, ed. 1978 Immigrants and Minorities in British Society. London, George Allen and Unwin.

22.

House of Commons Select Committee on Emigration and Immigration 1888, 1889 Report, etc. London, HMSO.

23.

Home Affairs Committee 1986 Second Report: Immigration from the Indian Sub-Continent. Vol. 1. Session 1985/86. HC. London, HMSO

24.

Home Affairs Committee 1983 Second Report: Ethnic and Racial Questions in the Census. 83 HC33-1. London, HMSO.

25.

Home Affairs Committee 1982 Fifth Report: Immigration from the Indian Sub-Continent. Vol. 1. session 1981/1982. London, HMSO.

26.

Home Affairs Committee 1981 Fifth Report: Racial Disadvantage. Session 1980/1981. HC424. London, HMSO.

27.

Home Office 1986 “Immigration and Nationality Department Report”. London, Home Office.

28.

Home Office 1986 “Bulletin on Immigration Statistics”. London, Statistical Department, Home Office (Quarterly).

29.

Home Office 1986 “Control of Immigration: Statistics United Kingdom, 1985”. Cmnd. 9863. London, HMSO. (Annual from 1973)

30.

Home Office 1985 “Immigration from the Indian Sub-Continent”. London, HMSO.

31.

Home Office 1983 Control of Immigration Statistics, 1982. Cmnd. 8944, London, HMSO.

32.

Home Office 1965 Immigration from the Commonwealth. Cmnd. 2739, London, HMSO.

33.

Home Office 1964 Control of Immigration Statistics, July 1, 1962 - December 31, 1963. Cmnd. 2379, London, HMSO.

34.

Home Office 1955 Statistics of Foreigners Entering and Leaving the U.K. 1954. Cmnd. 9560, London HMSO (and annually up to 1971).

35.

Home Office 1939 Statistics in Regard to Alien Passengers who Entered and Left the U.K. in 1938. Cmnd. 6036, London, HMSO (and annually back to 1920).

36.

Immigrant Statistics Unit 1977 “New Commonwealth and Pakistani Population Estimates”. In Population Trends, 9, 4-7.

37.

Jeffery

and Carrier

N.H.

1953 External Migration: A Study of the Available Statistics, 1815; 1950. GRO Studies on medical and population subjects, No. 6. London, HMSO.

38.

Jenkyns

1980 The Victorians and Ancient Greece. Oxford, Basil Blackwell.

39.

Jones

1977 “Immigration and Social Policy in Britain”. London, Tavistock.

40.

Jones

and Smith

A.D.

1970 The Economic Impact of Commonwealth Immigration. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

41.

Jones

1982 “Ethnic Intermarriage in Britain”. Ethnic and Racial Studies 5.

42.

Jones

1981a “British Unemployment and Immigration: Two Case Studies”. New Community 9, 1, Pp. 112–117.

43.

Jones

1981b “Ins and Outs of Home Office and IPS Immigration Data: A Reply”. New Community 9, Pp. 283–4.

44.

Kirwin

F.X.

1981 “Recent Irish Migration: A Note on a Neglected Data Source”. European Demographic Information Bulletin XII, 2, 56-62. The Hague, European Center for Population Studies.

45.

Kubat

1983 The Politics of Return: International Return Migration in Europe. New York, Center for Migration Studies.

46.

Kubat

1979 The Politics of Migration Policies. New York, Center for Migration Studies.

47.

Lucas

C.P.

1912 Greater Rome and Greater Britain. London, Clarendon Press.

48.

MacDonald

J.S.

and MacDonald

L.D.

1972 The Invisible Immigrants. London, Runnymede Industrial Unit.

49.

Moser

1976a A report by Sir Claus Moser of errors into the statistics relating to embarkations of Commonwealth citizens from Heathrow Airport, Jan. 1973 -July 1974. Home Office, unpublished, available at Home Office and OPCS libraries.

50.

Moser

1976b Report by Sir Claus Moser on the general significance of statistics of admissions and embarkations. Home Office, unpublished, available at Home Office and OPCS libraries.

51.

O'Grada

1985 “On Two Aspects of Post War Irish Immigration” Center for Economic Policy Research Discussion Paper No. 52 London, Center for Economic Policy Research.

52.

OPCS 1986a Labour Force Survey Ethnic Group and Country of Birth. OPCS Monitor LFS 86/2. London, OPCS

53.

OPCS 1986b International Migration mid 1984 to mid 1985. Monitor MN 86 1 London, OPCS.

54.

OPCS 1986c International Migration 1984. Series MN No. 11. London, HMSO.

55.

OPCS 1986d “Estimating the Size of the Ethnic Minority Population in the 1980s” Population Trends, 44, 23-27.

56.

OPCS 1983a GB Census 1981. Country of Birth. London, HMSO

57.

OPCS 1983b The Labour Force Survey 1981 OPCS Monitor LFS 83 1 PP1 83 1 London, OPCS.

58.

OPCS 1983c Births by Birthplace of Parent 1981 OPCS Monitor FMI 83/2. London, OPCS.

59.

OPCS 1983d International Migration. OPCS Monitor Series MN 83/2. OPCS, London.

60.

OPCS 1983e International Migration. OPCS Monitor Series MN 83/3. OPCS, London.

61.

OPCS 1983f International Migration. OPCS Monitor Series MN 83/5. OPCS, London.

62.

OPCS 1982 Sources of Statistics on Ethnic Minorities. OPCS Monitor PP1 82/1, also Population Trends 28. London, OPCS

63.

OPCS 1981a International Migration 1978. Series MN No. 5. London, HMSO

64.

OPCS 1981b Mid 1980 Estimates of the Population of New Commonwealth and Pakistani Ethnic Origin. Monitor PP1 81/6. London, OPCS.

65.

OPCS 1979 International Migration 1976. Series MN No. 3. Pp. 8–10. London, HMSO.

66.

OPCS 1978 International Migration 1975. Series MN No. 2. London, HMSO.

67.

OPCS/Home Office 1979 Immigration Statistics: Sources and Definitions. London, OPCS.

68.

Parliamentary Reports (Hansard) 1986 Written answer to Sir Patrick Wall by David Waddington. July 25, 1986.

69.

Parliamentary Reports (Hansard) 1961 Commonwealth Immigrants Bill. Second Reading 1961-62, Vol. 649, 688-824, Committee Vol. 650, Col. 1163-1330, 1399-1500. 1961-62 Vol. 651, 233-356, 357-408. 1961-62 Vol. 653, 236-386, 430-572, 1125-1270. London HMSO

70.

Parliamentary Reports (Hansard) 1905 Vol. 143 Col. 956 (Parliamentary Question, March 23, 1905).

71.

Parliamentary Reports (Hansard) 1905 Aliens Bill Vol. 145 4th series. Introduction Col. 464-473. First Reading Col. 473, Second Reading Col. 687-808, C'tee. Vol. 148, 268-326, 345-352, 390-474, 7960-8761. C'tee. Vol. 169, 110, 289, 903, 1137, 211; 3375, 906-1162.

72.

Peach

G.C.K.

1981a “Ins and Outs of Home Office and IPS Migration Data”. New Community 9, 1. Pp. 117–119.

73.

Peach

G.C.K.

1981b “Straining at Gnats and Swallowing Camels”. New Community 9. Pp. 284–286.

74.

Peach

G.C.K.

1968 West Indian Immigration to Britain: A Social Geography. London, OUP.

75.

Peach

G.C.K.

1966 “Under Enumeration of West Indians in the 1961 Census”. Sociological Review, 14. Pp. 73–80.

76.

Peach

G.C.K.

and Winchester

S.W.C.

1974 “Birthplace, Ethnicity and the Under-Enumeration of West Indians, Indians and Pakistanis in the Census of 1966 and 1971”. New Community, 3. 386.

77.

Population Statistics Division 1986 “Ethnic Minority Populations in Great Britain”. Population Trends 46. 18-21.

78.

Radical Race Statistics Group/Runnymede Trust 1980 Britain's Black Population. London, Heinemann.

79.

Registrar-General 1970 Registrar-General's Statistical Review for 1966. Vol. III. Commentary, Pp. 10–19. London, HMSO.

80.

Registrar-General 1966 Registrar-General's Statistical Review for 1963. Vol. III. Commentary, Pp. 28–38. London, HMSO.

81.

Registrar-General 1965 Registrar-General's Statistical Review for 1963. Vol. II. Population. Table S. (See also, previous years and up to 1973). London, HMSO.

82.

Registrar-General 1905 Census of Great Britain 1901. General Report. London, HMSO.

83.

Rich

P.B.

1986 Race and Empire in British Politics. Cambridge University Press.

84.

Robertson

J.M.

1902 Duties of Empire. London.

85.

Robertson

J.M.

1899 Patriotism and Empire. London.

86.

Roche

T.W.E.

1969 The Key in the Lock. Immigration Control in England from 1066 to the Present Day. London, John Murray.

87.

Rose

E.J.B.

and Associates 1969 Colour and Citizenship: A Report on British Race Relations. London, Oxford University Press.

88.

Roth

1964 A History of the Jews in England. Oxford, Clarendon Press.

89.

Royal Commission on Alien Immigration 1903 1906 Vol. 1. Report Vol. II Minutes of Evidence, Vol III Appendix to Minutes of Evidence, Vol. IV Index and Analysis to Minutes of Evidence. Cmnd. 1741, 1742, 1743. London, HMSO.

90.

Salt

and Clout

1976 Migration in Post-War Europe. London, Oxford University Press.

91.

Seeley

J.R.

1883 The Expansion of England. London.

92.

Smith

T.E.

1981 Commonwealth Migration. Flows and Policies. London, Macmillan.

93.

Studlar

D.T.

1980 “Elite Responsiveness or Elite Autonomy: British Immigration Policy Reconsidered”. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 3, 2, 207-223.

94.

Taylor

A.J.P.

1965 English History 1914-1945. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

95.

Van Annersfoort

and Surie

1985 “An Unwilling Immigration Country The Netherlands 1970-1985”. Paper presented at the Institute of British Geographies Population Study Group, Oxford Conference 1986.

96.

United Nations 1979 “Trends and Characteristics of International Migration Since 1950”. Demographic Studies No. 64. New York, United Nations.

97.

Zimmern

1911 The Greek Commonwealth. Oxford, Clarendon Press.