This article examines social science research into the socioeconomic and cultural factors associated with immigrants who naturalize. Few of the studies in this review use statistical methodologies and many of the findings are highly impressionistic. Yet, several of the studies find common factors to explain the decision to naturalize. These include: length of residence in the United States, varied potentials for acculturation among different national origin groups, motivation for immigration and formal education and language skills. However, no single study is found that examines all of the variables influencing the naturalization decision.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlvarezR.1985“A Profile of the Citizenship Process Among Hispanics in the United States: An Anthropological Perspective”, The NALEO Education Fund, Washington.
2.
BarkanE.R.1983“Whom Shall We Integrate? A Comparative Analysis of the Immigration and Naturalization Trends of Asians Before and After the 1965 Immigration Act (1951–1978)”. In The Journal of American Ethnic History. Vol. 3 #1, Fall: 29–57.
3.
BarkanE.R., and KhokhlovN.1980“Socioeconomic Data as Indices of Naturalization Patterns in the United States: A Theory Revisted”, Ethnicity, Vol. 7.
4.
BeijbomU.1971Swedes in Chicago: A Demographic and Social Study of the 1846–1880 Immigration, The Chicago Historical Society.
5.
BernardW.S.1936“Cultural Determinants of Naturalization”. In American Sociological Review. Vol.1 #6, December: 943–953.
6.
BernardW.S.1937“Naturalization Adjusts to the Changing Status of Women”. In Studies in the Science of Society. Edited by MurdockG.P.Yale University Press, New Haven: 43–65.
7.
CarpenterN.1927Immigrants and Their Children 1920, Arno Press, New York (Originally published 1927).
8.
CarterH., and DosterB.1950a “Social Characteristics of Naturalized Americans from Mexico: Age and Marital Status”. In IMS. Monthly Review. Vol. 8 # 3, September: 35–39.
9.
CarterH.1950b “Residence and Occupation of Naturalized Americans from Mexico”. In I.N.S. Monthly Review. Vol. 8 #4, October: 47–53.
10.
CorneliusW.A.1981“The Future of Mexican Immigrants in California: A New Perspective for Public Policy”, Working Papers in U.S. Public Policy. #6, University of California at San Diego.
11.
EckersonH.F.1946“Outstanding Facts About Citizens Naturalized in 1945”. In I.N.S. Monthly Review. Vol. 3 #10, April: 293–297.
12.
FernandezC.1984“The Causes of Naturalization and Non-naturalization for Mexican Immigrants: An Empirical Study Based on Case Histories”.Final Report to Project Participar, unpublished.
13.
FernandezC., and FriasM.L.1984“Factors Affecting the Rate of Naturalization Among Mexican Immigrants: Research Findings and Field Observations”, Project Participar, Research Publication Series.
14.
FranklinF.G.1969The Legislative History of Naturalization in the United States, Arno Press and The New York Times, New York.
15.
GarciaJ.A.1986“A Look at Political Integration of Mexican Immigrants: Factors Affecting Naturalization”.The NALEO Education Fund, Washington, D.C.
16.
GarciaJ.A.1981“Political Integration of Mexican Immigrants: Explorations into the Naturalization Process”. In International Migration Review, 15(4): 608–625.
17.
GavitJ. P.1922Americans by Choice. Patterson Smith Reprint Series in Criminology, Law Enforcement and Social Problems. Patterson Smith Publishers, Montclair, NJ.
18.
GreblerL.1966“The Naturalization of the Mexican Immigrant in the U.S.”. In The International Migration Review, 1(3): 17–32.
19.
GuestA.M.1980“The Old-New Distinction and Naturalization: 1900”. In The International Migration Review, 14(4).
20.
HunterJ.E., SchmidtF.L., and JacksonG.B.1982Meta-Analysis: Cumulating Research Findings Across Studies, Sage Publications, Beverly Hills.
21.
Immigration Commission1911Report of the U.S. Immigration Commission, Washington.
22.
Immigration and Naturalization Service1986Statistical Yearbook of the Immigration and Naturalization Service: 1985, Washington.
23.
I.N.S. Monthly Review1945“Median Age of Persons Naturalized in the Fiscal Year 1944”. Vol.2 #7, January: 88–90.
24.
JacobsJ.B., and HayesL.A.1981“Aliens in the U.S. Armed Forces: An Historico-Legal Analysis”. In Armed Forces and Society, Vol. 7 #2, Winter: 187–208.
25.
JassoG., and RosenzweigM.R.1984“U.S. Immigration Law and Immigrant Behavior: Preliminary Findings from a Longitudinal Analysis”. Unpublished paper, The University of Minnesota.
26.
JassoG.1985a “What's in a Name? Country of Origin Influences on the Earnings of Immigrants in the United States”. Economic Development Center, University of Minnesota. Bulletin Number 85–4, June.
27.
JassoG.1985b “Family Reunification and the Immigration Multiplier: U.S. Immigration Law, Origin-Country Conditions, and the Reproduction of Immigrants”. Unpublished paper, The University of Minnesota, September.
28.
JohnstonR.1965Immigrant Assimilation: A Study of Polish People in Western Australia.Paterson Brokensha Pty. Ltd., Perth.
29.
KrichefskyG.D.1963“Naturalization Rates of Immigrants”. In I & N Reporter. Vol. 11 #4, April: 43–50.
30.
KrichefskyG.D.1957“A Half Century of Naturalization”. In I & N Reporter. Vol. 4 #3: 35–38.
31.
LegendreC., and ShaffirW.1984“Altering Citizenship Status: Some Preliminary Thoughts”. In Canadian Review of Studies in Nationalism. Vol. 11 #2: 257–270.
32.
LiebersonS.1963Ethnic Patterns in American Cities, The Free Press of Glencoe.
33.
NorthD.S.1985The Long Grey Welcome: A Study of the American Naturalization Program, The NALEO Education Fund, Washington.
34.
PachonH., and DeSipioL.1986“The Attitudes of Citizenship Service Providers Toward the Naturalization Process”. Paper prepared for Presentation at the meetings of the Western Political Science Association, Eugene, OR: March.
35.
PolenbergR.1980One Nation Divisible: Class, Race and Ethnicity in the United States Since 1938.The Viking Press, New York.
36.
PortesA., and BachR. L.1985Latin Journey: Cuban and Mexican Immigrants in the United States, University of California Press, Berkeley.
37.
PortesA., and MozoR.1985“The Political Adaptation Process of Cubans and Other Ethnic Minorities in the United States: A Preliminary Analysis”. In The International Migration Review, 16(1): 35–63.
38.
PortesA., and CurtisJ.1986“Changing Flags: Naturalization and its Determinants Among Mexican Immigrants”, The NALEO Education Fund, Washington.
39.
PortesA., and TrueloveC.1986“Making Sense of Diversity: Recent Research on Hispanic Minorities in the United States”. Paper prepared for the American Journal of Sociology. Vol. 13 (1987).
40.
RamirezD.M.1979“Legal Residents and Naturalization: A Pilot Study”, Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund, October.
41.
ReislerM.1976By the Sweat of their Brow: Mexican Immigrant Labor in the United States, 1900–1940, Greenwood Press, Westport, CT.
42.
RichmondA.H.1967Post-War Immigrants in Canada, University of Toronto Press.
43.
RoggE.M.1974The Assimilation of Cuban Exiles: The Role of Community and Class, Aberdeen Press, New York.
44.
SchibsbyM.1937“Naturalization in the United States”. In Our Racial and National Minorities. Edited by BrownF.J.Prentice Hall, New York.
45.
SmithL.1973“Naturalization Rates of Immigrants”, The Immigration and Naturalization Service, Winter: 29–35.
46.
WalkerH.W.1929“Mexican Immigrants and American Citizenship”. In Sociology and Social Research. Vol. 13: 5, May/June: 465–471.
