This article examines some of the links between the phenomena of urban migration and squatter settlements in the Third World city. This will be done by demonstrating that both are outcomes of fundamental social and political forces that have operated on these societies. Migration and squatting are placed in a context of the historical processes that led to the uneven development of Malaysia1. The article offers some explanation for the origin of the inequalities observed in spatial structures — in this case urban housing—by focusing on one of the contributory factors, namely migration.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AminS.1974“Modern Migrations in Western Africa”. In Modern Migration in West Africa. Edited by AminS.London: Oxford University Press.
2.
AnthonyJ. A.1971“Urban Politics in Malaysia: A Study of Kuala Lumpur”. Unpublished Ph. D. thesis, The Australian National University, Canberra.
3.
BachR. L.1976“Historical Patterns of Capitalist Penetration in Malaysia”, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 64: 458–476.
4.
BalanJ.1969“Migrant-Native Socioeconomic Differences in Latin American Cities: A Structural Analysis”, Latin American Research Review, 4(1): 3–29.
5.
BarakbahS. M.1971“The Problems of Illegal Settlers in Urban Areas of Kedah State, Malaysia”, Journal of Administration Overseas, 10: 201–209.
6.
BauerP. T.1948The Rubber Industry: A Study in Competition and Monopoly.London: Longmans.
7.
BedfordR.1980“Overview of Recent Research on the Variety and Forms of Population Mobility in Relation to Development Goals: the Case of Circulation”. Paper presented in the 1980 Development Studies Centre Seminar Series onPopulation Mobility and Development. February 27, Australian National University, Canberra.
8.
BernidaE.1968“Squatter and Slum Dwellings in Metropolitan Manila”, Philippine Sociological Review, 16(1): 92–105.
9.
CaldwellJ. C.1963“Urban Growth in Malaya: Trends and Implications”, Population Review, 7: 39–50.
10.
CaldwellM.1977a “The British Forward Movement, 1874–1914”.The Making of a Neo-colony. Edited by AminMohamed, and Caldwell. Pp. 13–37. Nottingham: Spokesman Books.
11.
CaldwellM.1977b “War, Boom and Depression”. In op. cit. Pp. 38–63.
12.
CaldwellM.1977c “From ‘Emergency’ to ‘Independence’, 1948–57”.Op. cit. pp. 216–265.
13.
ChingChang Yong1970“The Squatter Population of Singapore”.Berita Peranchang, 1(1): 5–10.
14.
ConcannonT. A. L.1955“A New Town in Malaya: Petaling Jaya, Kuala Lumpur”, The Malayan Journal of Tropical Geography, 5(March): 39–43.
15.
CorneliusW. A.1976“The Impact of Cityward Migration and Urban Land and Housing Markets: Problems and Policy Alternatives in Mexico City”. In The City in Comparative Perspective. Edited by WaltonJ., and MasottiL. M. Pp. 193–248. New York: Sage Publications.
16.
CorneliusW. A.1971“The Political Sociology of Cityward Migration in Latin America”. In Latin American Urban Research, Vol. I. Edited by Rabinovitz and Rabinovitz. Pp. 95–147. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
17.
CurtainR.1980“Migration in Papua New Guinea: The Role of the Peasant Household in Migration as a Strategy of Survival”. Paper presented in the 1980 Development Studies Centre Seminar Series onPopulation Mobility and Development, March 26. Australian National University, Canberra.
18.
DrabbleJ. H.1973Rubber in Malaya 1876–1922: The Genesis of the Industry.London: Oxford University Press.
19.
EmersonR.1964Malaysia: A Study in Direct and Indirect Rule.New York: University of Malaya Press.
20.
FMS: Federated Malay States1938–1945 Annual Reports on Social and Economic Progress of the People of Pahang, Selangor, Perak, Kuala Lumpur: Government Printer.
21.
FeldmanK.1975“Squatter Migration Dynamics in Davao City, Philippines”, Urban Anthropology, 4(2): 123–144.
22.
FlinnW.1971“Rural and Intra-Urban Migration in Colombia: Two Case Studies in Bogota”. In Latin American Urban Research. Edited by RabinovitzR., and TruebloodF. F. Pp. 83–94. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
23.
ForbesD.1980“Mobility and Uneven Development in Indonesia”. Paper presented in the 1980 Development Studies Centre Seminar Series onPopulation Mobility and Development, March 12. Australian National University, Canberra.
24.
Friel-SimonV., and KimKhoo Kay1976“The Squatter as a Problem to Urban Development: A Historical Perspective”. Unpublished paper presented to Third Convention of the Malaysian Economic Association, August 21–24. Penang.
25.
Gerold-ScheepersT., and van BinsbergenW. M. J.1978“Marxist and Non-Marxist Approaches to Migration in Tropical Africa”.African Perspectives, 1: 21–36.
26.
GregoryJ. W., and PicheV.1978“African Migration and Peripheral Capitalism”.Africa Perspectives, 1: 37–50.
27.
GullickJ. M.1969Malaysia.London: Ernest Benn Limited.
28.
GullickJ. M.1958Indigenous Political Systems of Western Malaya.London.
29.
SendutHamzah1962“Patterns of Urbanization in Malaya”.The Journal of Tropical Geography, 16 (Oct.), pp. 114–130.
30.
HirschmanC.1976“Recent Urbanization Trends in Peninsular Malaysia”.Demography, 13(4): 445–461.
31.
HollnsteinerM. R.1972“Becoming an Urbanite: The Neighborhood as a Learning Environment”. In The City as a Centre of Change in Asia. Edited by DwyerD. J. Pp. 29–41. Hong Kong: University of Hong Kong Press.
32.
ITB: Ipoh Town Board1954“Annual Report”. Unpublished report (No. N. A. BK/A/MBI). Ipoh.
33.
JacksonJ. C.1968Planters and Speculators: Chinese and European Agricultural Enterprise in Malaya 1786–1921.OUP: Kuala Lumpur and Singapore.
34.
JohnstonM. A. (Forthcoming) Housing Policy and the Urban Poor in Peninsular Malaysia. Third World Planning Review, 5(3).
35.
JohnstonM. A.1981“Conventional Housing Provision in Peninsular Malaysia”.Habitat International, 5(3/4): 337–359.
36.
JohnstonM. A.1979a “Access to Urban Housing in Peninsular Malaysia: Social and Spatial Distortions in a Peripheral Economy”. Unpublished Ph. D. thesis, Department of Human Geography, Research School of Pacific Studies, Australian National University.
37.
JohnstonM. A.1979b “Urban Squatters and Unconventional Housing in Peninsular Malaysia”.Journal of Tropical Geography, 49(Dec.): 19–33.
38.
KLTB: Kuala Lumpur Town Board1931“Report of the Health Officer”. Unpublished report, Kuala, Lumpur.
39.
LaquianA. A.1969“The ‘Urban’ Slum as a Zone of Tradition”.Journal of Comparative Local Government, 3(1): 17–27.
40.
FoongLee Tong1977“The MPAJA and the Revolutionary Struggle 1939–45”.Op. cit. Edited by AminMohamed, and CaldwellM. Pp. 95–119.
41.
LeedsA.1969“The Significant Variables Determining the Character of Squatter Settlement”.America Latina, 12(3): 44–86.
42.
LomnitzL.1977“Mechanisms of Articulation Between Shantytown Settlers and the Urban System”. Unpublished paper presented at Burg Wartenstein Symposium No. 73, on ‘Shanty-towns in Developing Nations’, Wenner-Gren Foundation.
43.
McGeeT. G.1971“Catalysts or Cancers: The Role of Cities in Asian Societies”.Urbanization and National Development in South and Southeast Asia. Edited by JakobsenI., and PrakashV. (Urban Affairs Annuals Vol. 1)pp. 157–181. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
44.
McGeeT. G.1968“Malays in Kuala Lumpur: A Geographical Study in the Process of Urbanization”. Unpublished Ph. D. thesis, Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand.
45.
McGeeT. G.1965“An Aspect of the Urban Geography of Malaysia: The Movement of Malays to Kuala Lumpur City”.New Zealand Geographical Society Record, 39: 7–9.
46.
MU: Malayan Union1946“Grow More Food Campaign”, unpublished records. File 607/46, Kuala Lumpur.
47.
Malayan Union1948Proceedings of the Advisory Council.Kuala Lumpur: Malayan Union Government Press.
48.
MarJ. M.1961“Migration and Urbanization—The Barriadas of Lima: An Example of Integration Into Urban Life”. In Urbanization in Latin America. Edited by HauserP. M. Pp. 170–190. New York: Columbia University Press.
49.
BuyongMohamed Rosli bin1975“Housing Development and Urban Sprawl”. In op. cit. Edited by HaiTan Soo, and SendutHamzah. Pp. 270–298.
50.
MokhzaniB. A. R.1974“Gombak: A Malay Village East of Kuala Lumpur”.Discussion paper 77, Center for Southeast Asian Studies, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan.
51.
MorganM.1977“The Rise and Fall of Malayan Trade Unionism, 1945–1950. Op. cit. Edited by AminMohamed, and CaldwellM. Pp. 150–198.
52.
NarayananS.1975“Urban In- Migration and Urban Labor Absorption: A Study of Metropolitan Urban Selanger”. Unpublished M. Econ. thesis, University of Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur.
53.
KiangNg Lee1976“The Squatter Problem in Chan Sow Lin (with special emphasis on their education). A Case Study of Squatters in Kuala Lumpur”. Unpublished B. A. graduation exercise, Faculty of Economics and Administration, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur.
54.
OoiKin Bee1975“Urbanization and the Urban Population in Peninsular Malaysia, 1970”.Journal of Tropical Geography, 40(June), pp. 40–48.
55.
OoiKin Bee1963Land, People and Economy in Malaya.London: Longman.
56.
OoiKin Bee1955“The Mining Landscapes of Kinta”.The Malayan Journal of Tropical Geography”.4 (Jan.), pp. 1–55.
57.
PryorR.J. (ed.) 1979Migration and Development in Southeast Asia: A Demographic Perspective.Kuala Lumpur: OUP.
58.
PryorR.J. (ed.) 1972“Malaysians on the Move: A Study of Internal Migration in West Malaysia”. Unpublished Ph. D. thesis, University of Malaya.
59.
PurcellV.1948The Chinese in Malaysia.London: Oxford University Press.
60.
RimmerP. J., and ChoG. C. M.1978“Urbanization of the Malays Since Independence: Evidence from West Malaysia, 1957–1970”. Unpublished paper presented to the Second National Conference, Asian Studies Association of Australia. May 14–18. Sydney.
61.
RobertsB. R.1973Organizing Strangers: Poor Families in Guatemala City.Austin: University of Texas Press.
62.
SandhuK. S.1964a “Emergency Resettlement in Malaya”.Journal of Tropical Geography.18 (Aug.), pp. 157–183.
63.
SandhuK. S.1964b “The Saga of the Malayan Squatter”.Journal of Southeast Asian History.5: 143–177.
64.
HockSaw Swee1972“Patterns of Urbanization in West Malaysia, 1911–1970”.Malayan Economic Review.17: 114–120.
65.
AhmatSharom1970“The Structure of the Economy of Kedah 1879–1905”.Journal of Malaysian Branch, Royal Asiatic Society, XLIII, pp. 1–24.
66.
AliSyed Husin1972“Land Concentration and Poverty Among Rural Malaya”.Nusantara.1 (Jan.): 100–113.
67.
BaharuddinShamsul Amri1979“The Development of the Underdevelopment of the Malaysian Peasantry”.Journal of Contemporary Asia.9(3): 434–453.
68.
TurnerJ. F. C.1968“Housing Priorities, Settlement Patterns and Urban Development in Modernizing Countries”.Journal of the American Institute Planners.34(Nov.): 354–355.
69.
van BinsbergenW. M. J., and MeilinkH. A.1978“Migration and the Transformation of Modern African Society: An Introduction”.African Perspectives.1: 7–20.
70.
WebsterD.1978“Migrant Labor, Social Formations and the Proletarianization of the Chopi of Southern Mozambique”.African Perspectives.1: 257–174.
71.
WilliamsE. T.1940Annual Report on the Social and Economic Progress of the People of Kelantan 1939.Kuala Lumpur: Caxton Press.
72.
HoongYip Hat1969The Development of the Tin Mining Industry of Malaya.Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press.
73.
YoungM. L.1978“Migration and Employment: A Case Study of a Rural Settlement Within a Development Scheme in Peninsular Malaysia”. Unpublished paper presented to the Second National Conference of Asian Studies Association of Australia. May 14–18, University of New South Wales, Sydney.
