This article studies whether migration policy is a suitable tool to improve the inefficient use of immigrants’ human capital. This line of investigation complements the traditional analysis of migration policy as a tool to manage labor supply. The effect of migration policy is studied, using a policy change that occurred in Australia in the late 1990s that tightened the selection applied to certain economic immigrants. The empirical analysis, based on data collected by the Longitudinal Survey of Migrants to Australia, confirms that the policy change raised, on average, the human capital of the affected group. It also, however, consistently reveals that the change had no detectable impact on indicators measuring immigrants’ skill utilization. This result suggests that migration policy, by itself, may not be best suited to address issues related to the efficient use of foreign talent in the labor market. Better coordination with employment policy may alleviate this problem. Additional research on migration policy’s effect on efficiency-related issues is also called for.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AkbariA. H.MacDonaldM.. 2014. “Immigration Policy in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United States: An Overview of Recent Trends.” International Migration Review48(3):801–22.
2.
AkreshI. R.2006. “Occupational Mobility among Legal Immigrants to the United States.” International Migration Review40(4):854–84.
3.
AleksynskaM.TritahA.. 2013. “Occupation–Education Mismatch of Immigrant Workers in Europe: Context and Policies.” Economics of Education Review36:229–44.
4.
AmbrosiniJ. W.PeriG.. 2012. “The Determinants and the Selection of Mexico–US Migrants.” World Economy35(2):111–51.
5.
AntecolH.Cobb-ClarkD. A.TrejoS. J.. 2003. “Immigration Policy and the Skills of Immigrants to Australia, Canada, and the United States.” Journal of Human Resources38(1):192–218.
6.
AtheyS.ImbensG.. 2017. “The State of Applied Econometrics. Causality and Policy Evaluation.” Journal of Economic Perspectives31(2):3–32.
AydemirA.2011. “Immigrant Selection and Short-Term Labor Market Outcomes by Visa Category.” Journal of Population Economics24(2):451–75.
9.
BarrettA.DuffyD.. 2008. “Are Ireland’s Immigrants Integrating into Its Labor Markets?” International Migration Review42(3):597–619.
10.
BarroR. J.Sala-i-MartinX.. 1995. Economic Growth. New York: McGraw-Hill.
11.
BeckerS. O.HvideH. K.. 2017. “Do Entrepreneurs Matter?” IZA Discussion Paper 7146. Geneva: International Organization for Migration.
12.
BeckerS. O.IchinoA.. 2002. “Estimation of Average Treatment Effects Based on Propensity Scores.” Stata Journal2(4):358–77.
13.
BeineM.BoucherA.BurgoonB.CrockM.GestJ.HiscoxM.McGovernP.RapoportH.SchaperJ.ThielemannE.. 2016. “Comparing Immigration Policies: An Overview from the IMPALA Database.” International Migration Review50(4):827–63.
14.
BeineM.DocquierF.Oden-DefoortC.. 2011. “A Panel Data Analysis of the Brain Gain.” World Development39(4):523–32.
15.
BelotM.HattonT. J.. 2012. “Immigrant Selection in the OECD.” Scandinavian Journal of Economics114(4):1105–28.
16.
BertoliS.BrückerH.. 2011. “Selective Immigration Policies, Migrants’ Education and Welfare at Origin.” Economics Letters113(1):19–22.
17.
BertoliS.DequiedtV.ZenouY.. 2016. “Can Selective Immigration Policies Reduce Migrants’ Quality?” Journal of Development Economics119:100–109.
18.
BertoliS.RapoportH.. 2015. “Heaven’s Swing Door: Endogenous Skills, Migration Networks, and the Effectiveness of Quality-Selective Immigration Policies.” Scandinavian Journal of Economics117(2):565–91.
19.
BorjasG. J.1987. “Self-Selection and the Earnings of Immigrants.” American Economic Review77(4):531–53.
20.
BorjasG. J.. 1989. “Economic Theory and International Migration.” International Migration Review23(3):457–85.
21.
BorjasG. J.. 1991. “Immigration Policy, National Origin, and Immigrant Skills: A Comparison of Canada and the United States.” No. w3691. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
22.
BorjasG. J.. 1995. “The Economic Benefits from Immigration.” Journal of Economic Perspectives9(2):3–22.
23.
BorjasG. J.. 1999. “The Economic Analysis of Immigration.” In Handbook of Labor Economics, vol. 3, 1697–1760. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
24.
BorlandJ.GregoryB.SheehanP., eds. 2001. Work Rich, Work Poor: Inequality and Economic Change in Australia. Melbourne: Centre for Strategic Economic Studies, Victoria University.
25.
CaliendoM.KopeinigS.. 2008. “Some Practical Guidance for the Implementation of Propensity Score Matching.” Journal of Economic Surveys22(1):31–72.
26.
CastlesS.De HaasH.MillerM. J.. 2013. The Age of Migration: International Population Movements in the Modern World. London: Macmillan International Higher Education.
27.
ChamberlainG.1980. “Analysis of Covariance with Qualitative Data.” Review of Economic Studies47(1):225–38.
28.
ChiquiarD.HansonG. H.. 2005. “International Migration, Self-Selection, and the Distribution of Wages: Evidence from Mexico and the United States.” Journal of Political Economy113(2):239–81.
29.
ChiswickB. R.MillerP. W.. 2006. “Immigration to Australia during the 1990s: Institutional and Labour Market Influences.” In Public Policy and Immigrant Settlement, edited by Cobb-ClarkD. A.KhooS., 121–48. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.
30.
ChiswickB. R.MillerP. W.. 2008. “Occupational Attainment and Immigrant Economic Progress in Australia.” Economic Record84:S45–S56.
31.
ClemensM. A.PritchettL.. 2016. “The New Economic Case for Migration Restrictions: An Assessment.” IZA Discussion Paper 9730. Geneva: International Organization for Migration.
32.
Cobb-ClarkD.2001. “The Longitudinal Survey of Immigrants to Australia.” Australian Economic Review34(4):467–77.
33.
Cobb-ClarkD.. 2003. “Public Policy and the Labor Market Adjustment of New Immigrants to Australia.” Journal of Population Economics16:655–81.
34.
ConstantA. F.ZimmermannK. F., eds. 2013. International Handbook on the Economics of Migration. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.
DequiedtV.ZenouY.. 2013. “International Migration, Imperfect Information, and Brain Drain.” Journal of Development Economics102:62–78.
37.
DocquierF.LohestO.MarfoukA.. 2007. “Brain Drain in Developing Countries.” World Bank Economic Review21(2):193–218.
38.
DocquierF.RapoportH.. 2012. “Globalization, Brain Drain, and Development.” Journal of Economic Literature50(3):681–730.
39.
FrankK.2013. “Immigrant Employment Success in Canada: Examining the Rate of Obtaining a Job Match.” International Migration Review47(1):76–105.
40.
FreemanR. B.2010. “Globalization of Scientific and Engineering Talent: International Mobility of Students, Workers, and Ideas and the World Economy.” Economics of Innovation and New Technology19(5):393–406.
41.
FriedH. O.LovellC. K.SchmidtS. S., eds. 2008. The Measurement of Productive Efficiency and Productivity Growth. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
42.
GhatakS.LevineP.PriceS. W.. 1996. “Migration Theories and Evidence: An Assessment.” Journal of Economic Surveys10(2):159–98.
43.
GreenC.KlerP.LeevesG.. 2007. “Immigrant Overeducation: Evidence from Recent Arrivals to Australia.” Economics of Education Review26(4):420–32.
44.
HawthorneL.2005. “Picking Winners: The Recent Transformation of Australia’s Skill Migration Policy.” International Migration Review39(3):663–96.
45.
HuntJ.Gauthier-LoiselleM.. 2010. “How Much Does Immigration Boost Innovation?” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics2(2):31–56.
46.
IchinoA.SchwerdtG.Winter-EbmerR.ZweimüllerJ.. 2017. “Too Old to Work, Too Young to Retire?” Journal of the Economics of Ageing9:14–29.
JassoG.RosenzweigM. R.. 2009. “Selection Criteria and the Skill Composition of Immigrants: A Comparative Analysis of Australian and US Employment Immigration.” In Skilled Migration Today: Prospects, Problems, and Policies, edited by BhagwatiJ.HansonG. H., 153–83. New York: Oxford University Press.
49.
JunankarR.MahuteauS.. 2008. “Do Migrants Get Good Jobs in Australia? The Role of Ethnic Networks in Job Search.” Economic Record84(Issue Supplement s1):S115–30.
50.
KaestnerR.MalamudO.. 2014. “Self-Selection and International Migration: New Evidence from Mexico.” Review of Economics and Statistics96(1):78–91.
51.
KleinerM. M.2000. “Occupational Licensing.” Journal of Economic Perspectives14(4):189–202.
52.
LangeF.2007. “The Speed of Employer Learning.” Journal of Labor Economics25(1):1–35.
53.
LeeJ.KangC.. 2006. “Identification for Difference in Differences with Cross-Sections and Panel Data.” Economics Letters92:270–76.
54.
MasseyD. S.ArangoJ.HugoG.KouaouciA.PellegrinoA.TaylorJ. E.. 1993. “Theories of International Migration: A Review and Appraisal.” Population and Development Review19:431–66.
McGuinnessS.2006. “Overeducation in the Labour Market.” Journal of Economic Surveys20(3):387–418.
57.
McKenzieD.RapoportH.. 2010. “Self-Selection Patterns in Mexico-US Migration: The Role of Migration Networks.” Review of Economics and Statistics92(4):811–21.
58.
McMillanJ.BeavisA.JonesF. L.. 2009. “The AUSEI06: A New Socioeconomic Index for Australia.” Journal of Sociology45(2):123–49.
59.
MillerP. W.1999. “Immigration Policy and Immigrant Quality: The Australian Points System.” American Economic Review89(2):192–97.
60.
MoragaJ.2011. “New Evidence on Emigrant Selection.” Review of Economics and Statistics93(1):72–96.
61.
MundlakY.1978. “On the Pooling of Time Series and Cross Section Data.” Econometrica46(1):69–85.
62.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). 2001. “International Mobility of the Highly Skilled Workers.” Proceedings of the Workshop on International Mobility of the Highly Skilled Workers: From Statistical Analysis to the Formulation of Policies, Paris, June 11–12. http://www.oecd.org/sti/inno/internationalmobilityofthehighlyskilled.htm.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). 2013. “Immigration and Labour Shortages: Evaluation of Needs and Limits of Selection Policies in the Recruitment of Foreign Labour.” Paper presented at the Joint EU-OECD Conference, The Economic and Social Aspects of Migration, Brussels, January 21–23. http://www.oecd.org/migration/mig/15474016.pdf.
65.
PirachaM.TaniM.VadeanF.. 2012. “Immigrant Over- and Under-Education: The Role of Home Country Labour Market Experience.” IZA Journal of Migration1(1):3.
66.
RichardsonS.RobertsonF.IsleyD.. 2004. “The Changing Settlement Experience of New Migrants.” Report to the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs. June. Adelaide, Australia: Flinders University, National Institute of Labour Studies.
67.
RoyA. D.1951. “Some Thoughts on the Distribution of Earnings.” Oxford Economic Papers3(2):135–46.
68.
RubinD. B.1974. “Estimating Causal Effects of Treatments in Randomized and Nonrandomized Studies.” Journal of Educational Psychology66(5):688.
69.
SchusterA.DesiderioM. V.UrsoG., eds. 2013. Recognition of Qualifications and Competences of Migrants. Geneva: International Organization for Migration.
70.
SjaastadL. A.1962. “The Costs and Returns of Human Migration.” Journal of Political Economy70(5–2):80–93.
71.
TaniM.2014. Using a Point System for Selecting Immigrants. IZA World of Labor. Geneva: International Organization for Migration.
72.
TaniM.. 2017. “Local Signals and the Returns to Foreign Education.” Economics of Education Review.10.1016/j.econedurev.2017.07.006.
73.
ThapaP. J.GørgensT.. 2006. “Finding Employment after Migration: How Long Does It Take?” In Public Policy and Immigrant Settlement, edited by Cobb-ClarkD. A.KhooS. E., 219–29. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.
74.
VoitchovskyS.2014. “Occupational Downgrading and Wages of New Member States Immigrants to Ireland.” International Migration Review48(2):500–537.
75.
WilliamsL. S.1995. Understanding the Economics of Immigration. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
76.
WooldridgeJ. M.2010. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
