We study whether the acquisition of host country human capital, such as obtaining equivalent qualifications, good language skills, or naturalization, explains differences in labor market integration between migrants depending on their initial motivation. We use cross-national European data from the 2008 ad hoc module of the Labour Force Survey to analyze migrant gaps in labor market participation, employment, occupational status, and precarious employment. We find that different rates of and returns to host country human capital explain a substantial part of the improvements in labor market outcomes with years of residence, particularly for noneconomic migrants who experience faster growth on average.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AiyarS.BarkbuB.BatiniN.BergerH.DetragiacheE.DizioliA.EbekeC.LinH.KaltaniL.SosaS.SpilimbergoA.TopalovaP.. 2016. The Refugee Surge in Europe: Economic Challenges. Washington, DC: IMF.
2.
AlganY.DustmannC.GlitzA.ManningA.. 2010. “The Economic Situation of First and Second-generation Immigrants in France, Germany and the United Kingdom.” The Economic Journal120:F4–30.
3.
AydemirA. 2009. “Immigrant Selection and Short-Term Labor Market Outcomes by Visa Category.” Journal of Population Economics24:451–75.
4.
BarryB. 2001. Culture and Equality: An Egalitarian Critique of Multiculturalism. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
5.
BarslundM.BusseM.LenaertsK.LudolphL.RenmanV.. 2016. Labour Market Integration of Refugees: A Comparative Survey of Bosnians in Five EU Countries. Brussels, Belgium: CEPS.
6.
BevelanderP. 2011. “The Employment Integration of Resettled Refugees, Asylum Claimants, and Family Reunion Migrants in Sweden.” Refugee Survey Quarterly30:22–43.
7.
BevelanderP.PendakurR.. 2014. “The Labour Market Integration of Refugee and Family Reunion Immigrants: A Comparison of Outcomes in Canada and Sweden.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies40:689–709.
8.
BoeriT.De PhilippisM.PatacchiniE.PellizzariM.. 2015. “Immigration, Housing Discrimination and Employment.” The Economic Journal125:F82–114.
9.
BratsbergB.RaaumO.RøedK.. 2017. Immigrant Labor Market Integration across Admission Classes. Bonn, Germany: IZA Institute of Labor Economics.
10.
BuchholzS.Hof äckerD.MillsM.BlossfeldH.-P.KurzK.HofmeisterH.. 2009. “Life Courses in the Globalization Process: The Development of Social Inequalities in Modern Societies.” European Sociological Review25:53–71.
11.
CampbellS. 2014. Does It Matter Why Immigrants Came Here? Original Motives, the Labour Market, and National Identity in the UK. London, UK: Department of Quantitative Social Science - UCL. DQSS Working paper No. 65.
CebullaA.DanielM.ZurawanA.BrownV.TippingS.TomaszewskiW.. 2010. Spotlight on Refugee Integration: Findings from the Survey of New Refugees in the United Kingdom. London, UK: Home Office and UK Visas and Immigration.
14.
CheungS. Y. 2013. “Ethno-religious Minorities and Labour Market Integration: Generational Advancement or Decline?” Ethnic and Racial Studies37:140–60.
15.
CheungS. Y.PhillimoreJ.. 2014. “Refugees, Social Capital, and Labour Market Integration in the UK.” Sociology48:518–36.
16.
ChiswickC. U. 2009. “The Economic Determinants of Ethnic Assimilation.” Journal of Population Economics22:859–80.
17.
ChiswickB. R.MillerP. W.. 2008. “Why Is the Payoff to Schooling Smaller for Immigrants?” Labour Economics15:1317–40.
18.
ConnorP. 2010. “Explaining the Refugee Gap: Economic Outcomes of Refugees Versus Other Immigrants.” Journal of Refugee Studies23:377–97.
19.
CorluyV.MarxI.VerbistG.. 2011. “Employment Chances and Changes of Immigrants in Belgium: The Impact of Citizenship.” International Journal of Comparative Sociology52:350–68.
20.
CortesK. E. 2004. “Are Refugees Different from Economic Immigrants? Some Empirical Evidence on the Heterogeneity of Immigrant Groups in the United States.” Review of Economics and Statistics86:465–80.
21.
Damas de MatosA.LiebigT.. 2014. “The Qualifications of Immigrants and Their Value in the Labour Market: A Comparison of Europe and the United States.” In Matching Economic Migration with Labour Market Needs, edited by OECD/EU, 187–228. Paris, France: OECD Publishing.
22.
De VroomeT.van TubergenF.. 2010. “The Employment Experience of Refugees in the Netherlands.” International Migration Review44:376–403.
23.
DuleepH. O.LiuX.RegetsM.. 2014. Country of Origin and Immigrant Earnings, 1960–2000: A Human Capital Investment Perspective. Bonn, Germany: IZA Institute of Labor Economics.
24.
DuleepH. O.RegetsM. C.. 1999. “Immigrants and Human-capital Investment.” American Economic Review89:186–91.
25.
DumontJ.-C.LiebigT.PreschnerJ.TanayF.XenogianiT.. 2016. How Are Refugees Faring on the Labour Market in Europe?Brussels, Belgium: European Commission and OECD.
26.
DustmannC.FabbriF.. 2003. “Language Proficiency and Labour Market Performance of Immigrants in the UK.” The Economic Journal113:695–717.
27.
DustmannC.FasaniF.FrattiniT.MinaleL.SchonbergU.. 2016. On the Economics and Politics of Refugee Migration. London, UK: Centre for Economic Policy Research.
28.
Eurostat. 2015. The Labour Market Situation of Migrants and Their Immediate Descendants: Evaluation of the 2014 Labour Force Survey. Luxembourg: Eurostat.
29.
FleischmannF.DronkersJ.. 2010. “Unemployment among Immigrants in European Labour Markets: An Analysis of Origin and Destination Effects.” Work Employment Society24:337–54.
30.
GanzeboomH. B. G.TreimanD. J.. 1996. “Internationally Comparable Measures of Occupational Status for the 1988 International Standard Classification of Occupations.” Social Science Research25:201–39.
31.
HainmuellerJ.HangartnerD.LawrenceD.. 2016. “When Lives Are Put on Hold: Lengthy Asylum Processes Decrease Employment among Refugees.” Science Advances2:e1600432.
32.
HelgertzJ.BevelanderP.TegunimatakaA.. 2014. “Naturalization and Earnings: A Denmark–Sweden Comparison.” European Journal of Population/Revue Europeenne de Demographie30:337–59.
33.
HuddlestonT.TanczosJ.WolffhardtA.. 2016. Strategic Developments on Migrant Integration Policies in Europe. Oxford, UK: Centre on Migration, Policy and Society (COMPAS).
34.
IacusS. M.KingG.PorroG.. 2012. “Causal Inference without Balance Checking: Coarsened Exact Matching.” Political Analysis20:1–24.
35.
JarreauJ. 2015. The Impact of Naturalizations on Job Mobility and Wages: Evidence from France. Aix-Marseille, France: Aix Marseille School of Economics.
36.
KausarR.DrinkwaterS.. 2010. Who Performs Better? A Comparison of Earnings and Occupational Attainment of Refugees and Asylum Seekers and Economic Immigrants in the UK. Guildford, UK: University of Surrey - School of Economics.
37.
Konle-SeidlR.BolitsG.. 2016. Labour Market Integration of Refugees: Strategies and Good Practices. Brussels, Belgium: European Parliament.
38.
LewisJ. B.LinzerD. A.. 2005. “Estimating Regression Models in Which the Dependent Variable Is Based on Estimates.” Political Analysis13:345–64.
39.
LuikM.-A.EmilssonH.BevelanderP.. 2016. Explaining the Male Native-immigrant Employment Gap in Sweden: The Role of Human Capital and Migrant Categories. Bonn, Germany: IZA Institute of Labor Economics.
40.
LundborgP. 2013. “Refugees’ Employment Integration in Sweden: Cultural Distance and Labor Market Performance.” Review of International Economics21:219–32.
41.
LuthraR.PlattL.SalamońskaJ.. 2016. “Types of Migration: The Motivations, Composition, and Early Integration Patterns of ‘New Migrants’ in Europe.” International Migration Review, pp. 1–36.
MaozZ.HendersonE. A.. 2013. “The World Religion Dataset, 1945–2010: Logic, Estimates, and Trends.” International Interactions39:265–91.
44.
MartíM.RódenasC.. 2007. “Migration Estimation Based on the Labour Force Survey: An EU-15 Perspective.” The International Migration Review41:101–26.
45.
ReyneriE.FullinG.. 2011. “Labour Market Penalties of New Immigrants in New and Old Receiving West European Countries.” International Migration49:31–57.
46.
RuizI.Vargas-SilvaC.. 2017. “Are Refugees’ Labour Market Outcomes Different from Those of Other Migrants? Evidence from the United Kingdom in the 2005–2007 Period.” Population, Space and Place23:e2049.
47.
SarvimakiM. 2017. Labor Market Integration of Refugees in Finland. Helsinki, Finland: VATT Institute for Economic Research.
48.
van TubergenF.MaasI.FlapH.. 2004. “The Economic Incorporation of Immigrants in 18 Western Societies: Origin, Destination, and Community Effects.” American Sociological Review69:704–27.
49.
VinkM. P.Prokic-BreuerT.DronkersJ.. 2013. “Immigrant Naturalization in the Context of Institutional Diversity: Policy Matters, but to Whom?” International Migration51:1–20.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
