The historic burial ground (1722–1859) of the First Baptist Church of Philadelphia was excavated in 2016/17 as part of a development project. All human remains were reinterred in Mount Moriah Cemetery in 2024. The excavations recovered skeletal remains representing several hundred individuals (MNI = 354), Many of these individuals were recovered in coffins which were still in suitable condition to be documented. However, because the headstones were historically removed, dates are limited leaving artifacts and historical records to provide a time range of the sample's burial dates. Nails and screws collected from 206 of the coffins provide a unique opportunity to analyze a large sample of fasteners from a historic burial ground. This paper presents the results from a novel method of empirically driven analysis of the nails and screws in which we attempt to extract supplemental data to assist placing the coffin sample in a time range within the burial ground usage.
AdamsWH (2002) Machine cut nails and wire nails: American production and use for dating 19th-century and early-20th-century sites. Historical Archaeology4(36): 66–88.
2.
BinningAC (1938) Pennsylvania Iron Manufacture in the Eighteenth Century. Harrisburg: Pennsylvania Historical Commission.
3.
BjornerudO (2022) Assessment of historic coffin. Unpublished graduate paper. Winterthur Museum. University of Delaware Conservation Program. Available by request.
4.
BonneauN (2022) Accounting for the Dead: A History of the First Baptist Church of Philadelphia Cemetery (The Arch Street Project). Unpublished lecture 4 April, Online Public Lecture.
5.
BrooksR (1988) Standard screw threads for scientific instruments. Part I: Production techniques and the Filière Suisse. History and Technology: An International Journal5: 59–76. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/07341518808581726
6.
BrooksRC (1991) Origins, usage and production of screws: An historical perspective. History and Technology: An International Journal8: 51–76. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/07341519108581789
7.
CarsonCLounsburyCR (2013) The Chesapeake House: Architectural Investigation by Colonial Williamsburg. North Carolina: The University of North Carolina Press.
FriedmanDJ (2023) Historical research on the production of Nails Research Citations & details of age of nails to indicate building age. Research Citations History of Production of Nails Indicate Building Age. https://inspectapedia.com/interiors/Nails-Hardware-Age-Research.php.
KeenWW (1899) Bi-centennial Celebration of the Founding of the First Baptists Church of the City of Philadelphia, 1898. Miami: Hard Press Publishing.
14.
LauferB (1915) The Eskimo screw as a culture-historical problem. American Anthropologist17(2): 396–406.
15.
LeachAE (2000) Nail identification at Old Fort Niagara. Journal of the New York State Archaeological Association116: 35–49.
16.
LeaderGM (2024) Artifacts of Mourning: Archaeology of the Historic Burial Ground of the First Baptist Church of Philadelphia. Oxford, UK: Oxbow Books.
17.
LeaderGMDe PaolaPMinaL, et al. (2021a) B threads of evidence: Polarized light microscopy for funerary textile identification from an 18th and 19th century Philadelphia burial ground. International Journal of Historical Archaeology26(1): 1–23.
18.
LeaderGMMoranKSBeatriceJ, et al. (2021b) Eighteenth- and nineteenth-century funerary hardware and material culture from the historic cemetery (ca. 1702–1859) of the first baptist church of Philadelphia. Historical Archaeology56: 72–90.
19.
LenikEJ (1977) A study of cast iron nails. Historical Archaeology11: 45–47.
20.
ManbyK (2024) How do you solve a problem like nails? A new, multi-period metholodogy and typology for recording iron nails. Oxford Journal of Archaeology2(43): 173–194.
21.
MorrellK (2017) 218 Arch Street/First Baptist Church of Philadelphia Cemetery Relocation Project. Report to PMC Property Group, Philadelphia, PA, from AECOM, Burlington, NJ.
22.
MytumHBurgessL (2018) Death Across Oceans. Washington D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Scholarly Press.
Noël HumeI (1969) A Guide to Artifacts of Colonial America. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
25.
PhillipsMK (1993) “Mechanic geniuses and duckies,” a revision of New England’s cut nail chronology before 1820. APT Bulletin: The Journal of Preservation Technology25(3/4): 4–16.
26.
ReevesMSchweickartE (2019) Identifying and analyzing agricultural landscapes using metal-detector survey and nail-batch analysis. Historical Archaeology53(2): 412–431.
27.
RiordanTB (2009) “Carry me to you kirk yard”: An investigation of changing burial practices in the seventeenth-century cemetery at St. Mary’s City, Maryland. Historical Archaeology43(1): 81–92.
28.
SpragueR (2018) The need for greater precision in mortuary hardware terminology. In: MytumHBurgessL (eds) Death Across Oceans. Washington D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Scholarly Press, 123–127.
29.
SpringateME (2015) Coffin Hardware in Nineteenth-century America. Walnut Creek, California: Left Coast Press.
30.
TharpBW (1996) Preserving their form and features: The role of coffins in the American understanding of death, 1607–1870. Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis. College of William and Mary. Available at: https://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21220/s2-mene-k112 (accessed May 2024).
WarnashS (2021) TITLE Archaeological Society of New Jersey Bulletin 76: xx-xx.
33.
WellsT (1998) Nail chronology: The use of technologically derived features. Historical Archaeology32(2): 78–99.
34.
YoungA (1991) Nailing down the patter in Historical Archaeology. Unpublished Masters Thesis, University of Tennessee, Knoxville. Available at: https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_gradthes/1240/.
35.
YoungA (1994) Spatial pattering on nineteeth century Appalachian Houselot: Evidence from nail analysis. Southeastern Archaeology1(13): 53–63.
36.
ZunigaL (2024) Forging identity: Learning about craft production and identity through the analysis of handmade nails. Poster presented at the 54th Meeting of the Middle Atlantic Archaeological Conference, Ocean City, MD.
