Fictional Scotland: A “Realm of the Imagination” in Film Drama and Literature

Abstract

This article examines the issues of media representation and cultural distinctiveness within Scotland, one of many national entities currently denied political and cultural expression at the sub-nation state level. Current output of Scotland's television and film industries is compared with traditional and modern Scottish literature to see which themes and subjects have been preserved, how representative these themes are of Scotland, and whether they remain distinct from dominant English and American trends. The author argues that Scottish media output remains culturally and nationally distinctive in terms of recurring patterns in the selection of various themes and discourses. However, in the absence of a modern Scottish polity that could give political and cultural expression to the country, these themes, discourses, and patterns of use remain inherently regressive and mythic, placing Scottish cultural identity squarely in Scotland's past rather than its present or its expectations of the future.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson, Benedict R. 1991. Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism. London, New York: Verso.

Bold, Alan . 1983. Modern Scottish literature. London: Longman.

Brown, George Mackay . 1989. Celia. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

Brown, John . 1988. Love and death in the Scottish cinema. In Image and identity: Theatre and cinema in Scotland and Quebec, edited by I. Lockerbie (S.1). John Grierson Archive, University of Stirling.

Calder, Angus . 1994. Revolving culture: Notes from the Scottish Republic. London, New York: I. B. Tauris.

Caughie, John . 1982. Scottish television: What would it look like? In Scotch reels: Scotland in cinema and television, edited by C. McArthur . London: BFI.

Craig, Cairns . 1982. Myths against history: Tartanry and kailyard in 19th-century Scottish literature. In Scotch reels: Scotland in cinema and television, edited by C. McArthur . London: BFI.

Craig, Cairns . 1990. The haunted heart. New Statesman and Society, 5 October, 26-28.

Dickson, K. 1989. Scotland is different, OK? In The making of Scotland: Nation, culture and social change, edited by D. McCrone and S. Kendrick . Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

10.

Gaitens, Edward . 1989. A wee nip. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

11.

Gibbon, Lewis Grassic . 1950. A Scots quair: A trilogy of novels. London, New York: Jarrolds.

12.

Gibbon, Lewis Grassic . 1983. Smeddum. In The new Penguin book of Scottish short stories, edited by I. Murray . Harmondsworth, New York: Penguin.

13.

Herdman, John . 1989. Clapperton. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

14.

Hobsbawm, Eric J. 1990. Nations and nationalism since 1780. Cambridge, New York: Cambridge University Press.

15.

Hoggs, James . 1983. The brownie of the black haggs. In The new Penguin book of Scottish short stories, edited by I. Murray . Harmondsworth, New York: Penguin.

16.

Hoggs, James . 1989. Seeking the houdy. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

17.

Kelman, James . 1989. Not not while the giro. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

18.

Leonard, Tom . 1989. Honest. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

19.

MacDonald, George . 1989. The golden key. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

20.

Macdonald, Gus . 1990. Fiction friction. In From limelight to satellite, edited by Eddie Dicks . London: Scottish Film Council/British Film Institute.

21.

Macnicol, Eona . 1989. The small herdsman. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

22.

McIlvanney, William . 1986. The big man. London: Sceptre.

23.

Meech, Peter , and Richard Kilborn . 1992. Media and identity in a stateless nation: The case of Scotland. Media, Culture and Society 14:245-259.

24.

Mitchison, Naomi . 1989. A matter of behaviour. In The devil and the giro, edited by Carl MacDougall . Edinburgh: Canongate.

25.

Murray, Iain . 1983. Introduction. In The new Penguin book of Scottish short stories. Harmondsworth, New York: Penguin.

26.

O'Hagan, Andrew . 1996. The boys are back in town. Sight and Sound, February, 6-8.

27.

Pattison, Ian . 1992. More Rab C. Nesbitt scripts. London: BBC Books.

28.

Scullion, Adrienne Claire . 1990. Screening the heyday: Scottish cinema in the 1930s. In From limelight to satellite, edited by Eddie Dicks . Scottish Film Council/British Film Institute.

29.

Smith, A. D. 1996. Ethnic origins of nations. Oxford and New York: Blackwell.

30.

Watt, Julie . 1987. Beam me up Scotty. In Image and identity: Theatre and cinema in Quebec and Scotland, edited by I. Lockerbie . University of Stirling.

31.

Welsh, Irvine . 1996. Trainspotting. London: Heinemann.